<p dir="ltr">Directed hydrogenation, in which product geometric selectivity is dictated by the binding of an ancillary directing group on the substrate to the catalyst, is typically achieved by homogeneous Rh and Ir complexes. No heterogeneous catalyst has been able to achieve equivalently high directivity due to a lack of control over substrate binding orientation at the catalyst surface. In this work, we demonstrate through structure-activity studies that careful control of surface ensemble geometry in bimetallic nanoparticle catalysts can confer hydroxyl-directed selectivity in heterogeneous double bond hydrogenation. We postulate that the oxophilic alloy component binds hydroxyl groups to pre-orient the molecule on the surface, while proximal noble metal atoms impart facially selective addition of hydride to the olefin. We found that controlling the degree of surface alloying between oxophilic and noble metal component as well as alloy component identity is critical to maximizing reaction selectivity and starting material conversion. Our optimized catalysts exhibit good functional group tolerance on a variety of cyclohexenol and cyclopentenol scaffolds, with Pd-Cu and Pt-Ni systems being developed for the diastereoselective hydrogenation of tri- and more challenging tetra-substituted olefins, respectively. The applicability of this method is then demonstrated in a four-step synthesis of a fine fragrance compound, (1<i>R</i>,2<i>S</i>)-(+)-<i>cis</i>-methyldihydrojasmonate (Paradisone®), with high yield and enantiopurity.</p>