Over the past century, Manitoba has promoted the construction of hydroelectric dams as a means of producing energy. These projects are produced on Indigenous territory and bring these communities into direct conflict with the province and Manitoba Hydro. Recently, Manitoba Hydro has promoted partnerships with affected First Nations. These partnerships provide communities the “opportunity” to purchase shares of the dams with the goal of gaining profits. Partnerships have been established for two projects as a means of suggesting social licence. Social licence is an informal licence provided by a community to show support and consent for a project in their area. A progressive definition of social licence is when communities provide “free, prior, and informed consent.” Partnership agreements in northern Manitoba do not provide social licence, as the communities involvement in the project, and the means by which the partnership is established do not provide “free, prior, and informed consent.” / October 2015

The construction and operation of hydroelectric projects consist of multiple activities in a single watershed, which can generate significant impacts on the surrounding biophysical environment and on the health and well-being of local communities. The impacts of those activities may be insignificant individually, yet together may have an important cumulative effect. The impacts of hydroelectric development on human health and well-being have been widely documented. Current practices of cumulative effects assessment (CEA), however, as conducted under project-based environmental assessment (EA), often fail to address the deeper issues of human health and social well-being. This thesis was developed to examine how health effects, including cumulative health effects, are considered within regulatory EA practices in the hydroelectric sector in Manitoba. This was achieved by reviewing the EAs of three recent hydroelectric projects –Wuskwatim Generating Station, Bipole III Transmission Project, and Keeyask Hydroelectric Generating Station – located in the Nelson River watershed in northern Manitoba. Results indicate that the consideration of human health issues in EA has gradually improved over time; however, the assessment of health impacts was invariably limited to physical health components and often lacked due consideration of broader social health issues. The inadequacy of the practice of health impact assessment (HIA) was also evident by the lack of health-related indicators and the poor consistency in the use of indicators across projects and over time for measuring and predicting changes in the health conditions of the communities due to project development. An in-depth analysis regarding the assessment of cumulative health effects was carried out in the CEA of the most recent hydroelectric development – the Keeyask project. The findings show that cumulative health effects were not adequately considered in each of the basic components of CEA – scoping, retrospective analysis, prospective analysis, and management measures. Improving the consideration of health in EA requires paying more attention to broader range of health determinants, including both biophysical and social determinants and their interconnectedness in EA. Moreover, there is a need to improve greater consistency in the use of health indicators across projects and over time. It can be assisted by developing standardized terms of reference (ToR) for project proponents to ensure the consideration and monitoring of those indicators used for development projects built within the same geographic region and affecting the same communities and environments. Approaching cumulative health effects in a more regional and strategic framework of CEA, beyond the scale of individual projects, is likely to provide the best mechanism to understand and monitor the cumulative impacts of project development on the health and well-being of the affected communities.

Fox Lake Cree Nation (FLCN) is a First Nation community located in northern Manitoba, with approximately 1100 community members, of which approximately 500 reside in the traditional territory. FLCN has been highly affected by the development of five dams within their traditional territory, and have participated in the Clean Environment Commission hearings to share the impacts of that development. The FLCN youth have a unique perspective and experience with development. Youth are impacted by past hydroelectric development projects, and will continue to be affected in the future. In addition to looking at impacts and mitigation strategies, FLCN youth are looking to business and training opportunities that still align with their core values and Cree worldview. Knowledge transmission from Elders to youth is an important factor in moving forward for FLCN youth. Understanding how these experiences and perspectives affect and influence youth in FLCN is important to creating a future that benefits the youth of Fox Lake Cree Nation. / May 2017

Cette thèse en recherches fondamentale et appliquée a pour modèle biologique l’anguille d’eau douce qui a toujours fasciné le monde de la recherche par son cycle de vie unique et tous ses mystères non encore résolus pour certains. Dans le monde, 19 espèces d’anguilles existent dont certaines en déclins dans les zones tempérées ce qui peut justifier l’amplification des recherches sous les tropiques. En Polynésie française, cet animal mystérieux est sacré ; les légendes polynésiennes associent les anguilles à la création de la vie. Trois espèces y sont présentes : l’anguille marbrée « Anguilla marmorata », l’anguille de montagne « Anguilla megastoma » et l’anguille de vase « Anguilla obscura ». Elles n’ont pas la même distribution spatiale où la première s’adapte à n’importe quel milieu, la deuxième remonte les rivières jusqu’en haute vallée à plusieurs centaines de mètres d’altitude, tandis que la dernière reste en basse vallée préférant les eaux stagnantes. Grâce aux nombreuses rivières présentes sur Tahiti, cette île principale de Polynésie est en pleine transition énergétique et privilégie maintenant les énergies renouvelables ; particulièrement l’hydroélectricité. Cependant, les aménagements hydroélectriques connus pour provoquer des problèmes de continuité écologique de la biodiversité dulçaquicole, notamment pour les anguilles, vont nous intéresser dans ce travail de thèse en bourse Cifre. C’est dans ce contexte que s’inscrit cette thèse, dans la plus grande vallée de Tahiti, la Papenoo. Deux problématiques y sont étudiées : le recrutement des civelles et l’étude de la population adulte. Nos résultats sur les trois années de suivi de l’arrivée des juvéniles d’anguilles dans l’embouchure de la Papenoo révèlent un recrutement saisonnier des civelles de Novembre à Mars avec deux pics en Décembre et Janvier. Plus de 80% des civelles sont des Anguilla marmorata. Concernant les populations adultes, nous observons : 1/ plus de 90% de la population sont également de l’espèce Anguilla marmorata, 2/ les anguilles adultes présentent un gradient de densité de l’aval vers l’amont et 3/ le problème de continuité biologique ne vient pas des barrages ou captages en eux-mêmes, mais proviendrait des canaux de fuite en sortie de centrale où nous observons une sur-attractivité pour les anguiles. Cette étude s’est révélée très importante dans l’avancement théorique de nos connaissances biologiques et écologique sur l’anguille, dans l’appropriation par l’industriel de bonnes pratiques et par une solide communication sur la coexistence possible entre gestion et développement. / This thesis in fundamental and applied research has for biological model the freshwater eel which has always fascinated the world of the research by its unique cycle of life and all its mysteries not solved for some. Worldwide, 19 species of eels exist, some of which are declining in temperate zones, which may justify the increase in research in the tropics. In French Polynesia, this mysterious animal is sacred; the Polynesian legends associate the eels with the creation of life. Three species are present: the marbled eel "Anguilla marmorata", the mountain eel "Anguilla megastoma" and the eel "Anguilla obscura". They do not have the same spatial distribution where the former adapts to any medium, the second goes up the rivers to the upper valley at several hundred meters of altitude, while the latter remains in the lower valley preferring the stagnant waters. Thanks to the numerous rivers on Tahiti, this main island of Polynesia is in the midst of an energy transition and now favors renewable energies; particularly hydroelectricity. However, hydroelectric developments known to cause problems of ecological continuity of freshwater biodiversity, especially for eels, will interest us in this thesis work on the Cifre grant. It is in this context that this thesis, in the largest valley of Tahiti, is the Papenoo. Two problems are studied: the recruitment of glass eel and the study of the adult population. Our results over the three years following the arrival of juvenile eels in the mouth of the Papenoo reveal a seasonal recruitment of elvers from November to March with two peaks in December and January. More than 80% of elvers are Anguilla marmorata. For adult populations, we observe: 1/ more than 90% of the population is also Anguilla marmorata, 2/ adult eels have a density gradient from downstream to upstream, and 3/ biological continuity does not come from dams or water removal in themselves, but comes from the tailrace leaving the hydropower plant where we observe an over-attractiveness for the eels. This study proved to be very important in the theoretical advancement of our biological and ecological knowledge about the eel, in the appropriation by industry of good practices and in a solid communication on the possible coexistence between management and development.