第23回名古屋大学年代測定総合研究センターシンポジウム平成22(2010)年度報告

名古屋大学年代測定総合研究センターシンポジウム報告

名古屋大学年代測定総合研究センターシンポジウム報告

Located beyond the southern limit of glaciation in Britain, the upland granitic terrain of Dartmoor, south-west England, has been exposed to long intervals of intense periglacial activity during the Pleistocene. This region has been significant in debates about appropriate models of long-term landscape change, most notably two-phase versus single-phase models of landform evolution, and the development of tors. However, given the previous lack of quantitative techniques capable of constraining denudation and specific process rates, and thereby testing developmental models for these features, there remains much uncertainty in the interpretation of the classic landforms of the region. This study measures concentrations of the cosmogenic nuclide 10Be produced in-situ in quartz within the upper few metres of the Earth surface. These reflect the history of near-surface exposure to cosmic radiation of sampled material, and allow for the interpretation of exposure age and/or erosion rates of the land surface. This research utilises these cosmogenic nuclide values to evaluate geomorphological processes and investigate key aspects of landform development. These include the formation of tors in non-glaciated regions, the development of regolith and boulderfields under periglacial conditions, and the derivation of catchment-averaged denudation rates. This study provides the first quantitative measurement of erosion on tor surfaces in Dartmoor, with typical rates of 14-45 mm ka-1. These are relatively high and comparable to other components of the landscape. In addition, there is no clear relationship of cosmogenic nuclide concentration to tor dimensions. It is shown that the tors are dynamic landforms and simple, two-stage development is an inappropriate model. Catchment-averaged denudation rates are derived and these long-term rates of 20-94 mm ka-1 are significantly higher than modern, short-term values. Finally, downslope transport in a palaeo-periglacial blockslope is investigated using 10Be concentrations. This variety of landforms and scale of investigation facilitates an integrated approach to the understanding of catchment-scale erosional dynamics. In addition, the complex nature of landform development that is evident in the area provides challenges to the application of in-situ cosmogenic nuclides and highlights both the potential and limitations of the technique.

This work aims to study the behavior of the western margin of the Greenland Ice Sheet during a period of pronounced ice retreat roughly 10,000 years ago, after the end of the last glacial period. It explores the efficiency of subglacial erosion, the spatial dynamics of ice retreat, and the rates of ice retreat. To address these questions, I use the radionuclides 10Be and 26Al, which form in rocks due to the bombardment of cosmic rays, only after the rocks have been exposed from underneath retreating ice. These nuclides can be used as a geologic dating technique to explore exposure history. Before applying this dating technique to address geological questions, it was critical to first perform methodological development. My work in the University of Vermont‘s new Cosmogenic Nuclide Laboratory served to improve the precision and efficiency of the pre-existing laboratory methods. New methodological advances ensured that samples from Greenland, which contained only low concentrations of 10Be and 26Al, could be used to yield meaningful results about ice behavior. Cosmogenic nuclide dating was applied at two sites along the ice sheet margin in central-western Greenland. At both of these sites, I collected paired bedrock and boulder samples in a transect normal to and outside of the present-day ice sheet margin. Samples were collected from a variety of elevations at numerous locations along the transects, thus providing three-dimensional coverage of the field area. After isolating the mineral quartz from the rocks, and isolating the elements Be and Al from the quartz, isotopic analysis was performed using accelerator mass spectrometry to quantify the relative abundances of the radionuclides against their respective stable isotopes. The southern study site, Ilulissat, is located on the western coast of Greenland at a latitude of 69N. Much previous work has been conducted here due to the presence of one of the largest ice streams in the northern hemisphere, Jakobshavn Isbræ. My work in Ilulissat demonstrated that subglacial erosion rates were high during previous glacial periods, efficiently sculpting and eroding the landscape. Ice retreat across the land surface began around 10,300 years ago, and the ice sheet retreated behind its present-day margin about 7,600 years ago. Ice retreat occurred at a rate of about 100 meters per year. My work in this area suggests that retreat in the large ice stream set the pace and timing for retreat of the neighboring ice sheet margin. The northern site, Upernavik, is located on the western coast of Greenland at a latitude of 73N. Little research has been conducted here in the past. Unlike in Ilulissat, my work here shows that the ice sheet did not efficiently erode the landscape, especially at high elevations, during previous glacial periods. This is likely because the ice was thinner, and therefore had a colder base, than the ice in Ilulissat. My work suggests that ice cover was lost from this area very rapidly, likely at rates of about 170 meters per year, in a single episode around 11,300 years ago. Comparison between the two study sites reveals that ice characteristics can vary appreciably over relatively small distances.

This dissertation presents results from three studies that address major scientific questions in glacial geology and paleoclimatology for the late Pleistocene and Holocene using relatively new geochemical and statistical techniques. Each of the studies attempts to answer a longstanding question in the respective field using geochemical or statistical methods that have not been applied to the problem thus far. A longstanding question in glaciology is the nature and mechanism of the so- called "Heinrich events" of the last ~60 ka. These massive iceberg discharge events into the North Atlantic from the partial breakup of the Laurentide Ice Sheet are identified from distinct ice rafted debris and detrital carbonate layers in marine sediment cores. The mechanism associated with the initiation of these events is commonly thought to be related to internal ice sheet instabilities. However, Heinrich events consistently occur following a long cooling trend that culminates in an extreme cold event, thus suggesting a possible triggering mechanism by climate. Recent modeling work has proposed an oceanic mechanism associated with ocean warming, but no physical evidence has been made available to date. To test this ocean-warming hypothesis, we measured temperature sensitive trace metals and stable isotopes in benthic foraminifera from a sediment core collected in the western North Atlantic that spans the last six Heinrich events and compared our results to climate model simulations using CCSM3. Our results show subsurface warming occurred prior to or coeval with nearly all of the Heinrich events of the last ~60 ka, thus implicating subsurface ocean warming as the main trigger of these rapid breakups of the Laurentide Ice Sheet. In the field of glacial geology a longstanding question has been the timing of alpine glacial advances during the Holocene. A number of studies have interpreted several Holocene glacial advances in western North America, but age control is based largely on relative dating techniques, which have been shown to be in error by up to 10,000 yrs in some cases. Based on 124 ¹⁰Be surface exposure ages from twenty cirque moraines in ten mountain ranges across western North America, glacier were retreating from moraine positions during the latest Pleistocene or earliest Holocene and not throughout the Holocene epoch as previously assumed, thus requiring a refined interpretation of Holocene glacial activity in western North America and the associated climate forcing. In the field of paleoclimatology a question regarding how global temperature varied over the entirety of the Holocene epoch has remained to be answered for some time. While many temperature reconstructions exist for the last 2000 years, a full Holocene temperature stack does not exist, despite its potential utility of putting modern climate change into a full interglacial perspective. Based on a global composite of 73 proxy based temperature record, a Holocene temperature stack was constructed and used to demonstrate that a general cooling of ~1°C has occurred from the early to mid Holocene and that centennial and millennial scale variability is modest. We account for both temperature calibration and chronologic uncertainties using a Monte Carlo based approach. Our results are consistent with prior reconstructions of the last 2000 years and now allow for a full Holocene temperature perspective for evaluation with present and future climate change. / Graduation date: 2011 / Access restricted to the OSU Community, at author's request, from May 5, 2011 - May 5, 2012

Thesis advisor: Jeremy D. Shakun / Glaciers in the tropics have retreated over recent decades, but whether the magnitude of this retreat has exceeded the bounds of past Holocene fluctuations is unclear. In this study, we measure cosmogenic 10Be and 14C concentrations from recently exposed bedrock at the margin of five glaciers in the tropical Andes, including four small glaciers and the Quelccaya Ice Cap, the world’s largest tropical ice mass. Concentrations at the Quelccaya Ice Cap margin suggest there was extended exposure during the first half of the Holocene, but that the site was covered by ice for the last 5 kyr. In contrast, nuclide concentrations are strikingly low in all samples at the margins of the four small glaciers, equivalent to ~200 years of 14C and 50 years of 10Be accumulation at surface production rates. These data suggest that the small tropical glaciers are now smaller than they have been at any point during the Holocene, whereas the Quelccaya Ice Cap has not yet retreated to its smallest extent of the Holocene, likely due to its larger size and slower response time. / Thesis (MS) — Boston College, 2021. / Submitted to: Boston College. Graduate School of Arts and Sciences. / Discipline: Earth and Environmental Sciences.

Reconstruction of former Central Asian glaciers extents can provide valuable information about past atmospheric circulation variations. These extents, often marked by terminal moraines, need to be chronologically constrained. Cosmogenic nuclide exposure (CNE) dating is widely used to directly date moraines. In addition, there is increasing interest on using optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) techniques for dating glacial landforms. This thesis focuses on the methodological aspects of directly dating glacial landforms to perform paleoglacial reconstructions in Central Asia, with an emphasis on OSL dating. For OSL dating of sediments from glacial settings, it is important to measure the luminescence signal at the single grain scale, because the sediments are likely affected by partial bleaching due to short light exposure during glacial or glaciofluvial transport. The use of an Electron Multiplying Charges Coupled Device (EMCCD)-based imaging system for single grain OSL measurements would offer larger flexibility in light stimulation and sediment type, compared to the current Single Grain Risø reader. An automated image processing procedure has been developed to compensate for sample carrier displacement over repeated measurements and for attributing pixels to each grain for signal integration when using this imaging system. However, significant cross talk contamination, demonstrated by laboratory and simulation experiments, prohibits accurate single grain luminescence measurements. Preliminary experiments using a basic image processing algorithm show good potential for software correction solutions. Paleoglacial reconstructions conducted in the Altai Mountains, Central Asia, using both CNE and OSL dating demonstrate that luminescence measurements of glaciofluvial sediments performed at the multi-grain scale result in large age overestimates, and that single grain measurements allow for more accurate dating of glacial landforms. However, uncertainties remain that are related to the model used for extracting equivalent doses for well-bleached grains and to fading corrections when using feldspar minerals. The timing of glaciation can be inferred from scattered CNE moraine boulder ages if most of the ages are concentrated within a few thousand years, with only few ages clearly older or younger. Overall, combining CNE and OSL techniques for dating a glacial landform is a powerful approach for producing robust glacial chronologies, despite uncertainties inherent to each technique. Paleoglacial reconstructions from the Altai Mountains indicate Marine Isotope Stage (MIS) 2 and MIS 4/late MIS 5 local Last Glacial Maximums. In Central Asia, in addition to a regional MIS 2 glaciation, previous studies indicate a period of major glacial advances during MIS 3 that is out of phase with global ice volume records. However, most MIS 3 glacial chronologies from Central Asia are based on too few or too heavily scattered CNE data sets, or on OSL or Electron Spin Resonance (ESR) ages for which partial bleaching has not been properly investigated. Hence, at this stage, chronological evidence is insufficient to demonstrate a regional MIS 3 glaciation in Central Asia. Surge-related glacial features identified in the Russian Altai also highlight the importance of conducting detailed geomorphology and sedimentology studies to understand former ice dynamics, which is essential for inferring appropriate paleoclimate information from paleoglacial reconstructions. / <p>At the time of the doctoral defense, the following paper was unpublished and had a status as follows: Paper 4: Manuscript.</p>

The mountain-systems of Central Asia, act as barriers to atmospheric circulation patterns, which in turn impose striking climate gradients across the region. Glaciers are sensitive indicators of climate change and respond to changes in climate gradients over time by advancing during cold and wet periods and receding during warm and dry periods. The aim of this thesis is to investigate whether there are large-scale patterns in how past glaciers in the Tian Shan and the Altai Mountains of Central Asia responded to climate change. Multiple methods have been used, including: remote sensing, terrain analysis, field investigations, and cosmogenic nuclide (CN) dating. The glacial landform records indicate that the region experienced mainly alpine-style glaciations in the past. Large complexes of ice-marginal moraines in high elevation basins are evidence of outlet glaciers sourced from large valley glaciers, ice caps and ice-fields, and these moraine sequences, record the maximum extent of paleoglaciation. In the Ikh-Turgen Mountains, located in the continental, eastern Altai Mountains, deglaciation of these moraines occurred during marine oxygen isotope stage (MIS) 3 at ~45 ka. This is consistent with a colder and wetter climate during this time, inferred from ice core and lake level proxies. Another deglacial phase occurred during MIS 2 at ~23 ka, synchronous with the global Last Glacial Maximum. In the Russian Altai Mountains, lobate moraines in the Chuya Basin indicate deglaciation at ~19 ka, by a highly dynamic paleoglacier in the Chagan-Uzun catchment, which experienced surge-like behaviour. Furthermore, across the Tian Shan, an evaluation of new and existing CN glacial chronologies (25 dated moraines) indicates that only one regional glacial stage, between 15 and 28 ka (MIS 2), can be defined and spatially correlated across the region. These paleoglaciers were mainly restricted to valleys as a result of arid conditions during this time and variation in their extents is interpreted to reflect topographic modulation on regional climate. The ages of the oldest evidence for robust local glacial stages in the Tian Shan are not yet well constrained, however, moraines in the central Kyrgyz Tian Shan and the eastern Chinese Tian Shan have apparent minimum ages overlapping with MIS 5 and MIS 3 (with missing MIS 4 and 6 stages). However, different geological processes, such as inheritance and post-depositional shielding (e.g. deposition by surging glaciers or hummocky terrain deposition), have influenced the dating resolution, making several moraine ages inappropriate for regional comparison. Finally, to quantify regional patterns of paleoglaciation, the hypsometry (area-elevation distribution) of glacial landforms is used to estimate average paleo equilibrium line altitudes for the region. This analysis shows that while present-day ELAs mirror strong climate gradients, paleoglaciation patterns were characterised by more gentle ELA gradients. The paleo-ELA depressions across Central Asia were most prominent in the continental southern and eastern regions (500–700 m). Finally, the results from this thesis, show that Central Asia was repeatedly glaciated in the past, but underscore the importance of considering 1) catchment characteristics and styles of glaciation and 2) other non-climatic factors controlling glacier dynamics when interpreting CN chronologies to make paleoclimate inference. / <p>At the time of the doctoral defense, the following papers were unpublished and had a status as follows: Paper 2: Manuscript. Paper 4: Accepted. Paper 5: Manuscript.</p> / Central Asia Paleoglaciology Project (CAPP)

La haute montagne est un terrain particulièrement sensible aux variations climatiques. La hausse de température depuis plusieurs décennies a un fort impact sur les parois du massif du Mont Blanc : la dégradation du permafrost s’y traduit par une activité gravitaire majeure. Une augmentation du nombre d'écroulements (>100 m3) liés à des périodes chaudes a en effet été mis en évidence à plusieurs échelles de temps, lors des étés particulièrement chauds de 2003 et 2015 comme au cours des trois dernières décennies. La fréquence des écroulements dans le massif devrait continuer à s’accroitre avec l’augmentation de la température au 21e siècle.En revanche, la fréquence des écroulements dans le massif antérieurement à la fin du Petit Âge Glaciaire (PAG) est très largement inconnue. Pendant l'Holocène voire le Tardiglaciaire, les écroulements dans le massif du Mont Blanc ont-ils également été favorisés par les hausses de température ? Pour répondre à cette question, cette thèse poursuit quatre objectifs :i. Dater un grand nombre d'écroulements dans la partie centrale du massif pour comprendre leur distribution pendant l'Holocène et le Tardiglaciaire. L'âge des niches d’arrachement est obtenu par datation cosmogénique.ii. Vérifier les possibles corrélations entre périodes à forte occurrence d’écroulements et périodes climatiques post-glaciaires.iii. Quantifier le volume des écroulements par reconstruction 3D de la forme des blocs écroulés, et étudier la relation entre volumes écroulés et périodes climatiques.iv. Etudier la relation entre âge d'exposition et couleur des niches d’arrachement quantifiée avec la spectroscopie de réflectance.Un total de 70 surfaces a été échantillonné dans les parois du massif au cours de trois campagnes de terrain en 2006, 2011, et 2015-2016. Les âges d'exposition de 63 surfaces ont été obtenus, compris entre 30 ± 20 ans et 100.50 ± 8.50 ka. Trois groupes d’âges peuvent être corrélés aux périodes climatiques chaudes que sont : les Périodes Chaudes de l'Holocène moyen (7.50 – 5.70 ka), l'Optimum de l'âge de Bronze (3.35 – 2.80 ka) et le Période Chaude Romaine (2.35 – 1.75 ka) ; un quatrième groupe d'âges est daté entre 4.91 et 4.32 ka. Le groupe d'âges le plus nombreux, entre 1.09 ka et l'Actuel, aux volumes généralement réduits, est interprété comme représentatif de l'activité gravitaire annuelle du massif avec le climat actuel.Les données spectrales des échantillons datés ont permis de développer un index de la couleur du granite (GRIGRI) par combinaison des valeurs de réflectivité de deux longueurs d'onde différentes. Cet index est corrélé avec l'âge d'exposition (R=0.861) ; il a permis de proposer la datation de 10 échantillons d'âge inconnu à partir de leurs caractéristiques spectrales. / High mountain is particularly sensitive to climate variations. The raising temperature that is currently taking place due to climate change has a strong impact on the Mont Blanc massif rock walls: a higher rockfall (>100 m3) occurrence has been noticed, caused by permafrost thawing. The raising in number of rockfalls has been successfully correlated to warm periods at different timescales, e.g., during extreme warm episodes like the 2003 and 2015 heat waves, and during the last 30 years. According to the expected raising temperatures, during the 21st century rockfall occurrence should continue to rise.Rockfall frequency in the Mont Blanc massif before the Little Ice Age is still largely unknown. During Lateglacial and Holocene, high occurrence has been related to warm periods as well? In order to answer this question, this PhD thesis has four aims:i. To date several rockfalls having taken place in the central part of the Mont Blanc massif, in order to understand their frequency during Lateglacial and Holocene. Exposure age of rockfall scars is obtained using Terrestrial Cosmogenic Nuclide dating.ii. To verify possible relationships between high rockfall occurrence periods and post-glacial climate periods.iii. To quantify rockfall volumes by means of 3D reconstruction of the rockfall shapes, to explore the possible relationship between cumulate volumes and climate periods.iv. To study the relationship between exposure ages and colours of rock surfaces. Colours are quantified by reflectance spectroscopy.A total of 70 rock surfaces have been sampled during three field campaigns that took place in 2006, 2011 and 2015-2016. 63 exposure ages were obtained, ranging 30 ± 20 a to 100.50 ± 8.50 ka. Three age clusters can be correlated to warm periods, corresponding to: two Holocene Warm Periods (7.50 – 5.70 ka), the Bronze Age Optimum (3.35 – 2.80 ka) and the Roman Warm Period (2.35 – 1.75 ka). A fourth age cluster has been detected with ages ranging 4.91 – 4.32 ka. The biggest cluster, ranging 1.09 ka – recent, shows rather small volumes. This is interpreted as the normal erosion activity corresponding to the current climate.The samples reflectance spectra allowed to develop a granite colour index (GRIGRI) by combining the values of two different wavelengths. This index is correlated to the samples exposure age (R = 0.861), and has been used to date the exposure age of 10 samples where Terrestrial Cosmogenic Nuclide dating failed