Determining the genetic basis of reproductive isolation is a fundamental goal in evolutionary biology. Intrinsic reproductive isolation often arises due to epistasis between divergent interacting genes. The rapid evolution of hybrid male sterility is known to have several causes, including the exposure of recessive X-linked incompatibilities in males and the rapid evolution of male reproductive traits. Despite these insights, little is known about the genetics of reproductive isolation during the early stages of speciation. This deficiency inspired parallel studies on the molecular evolution of male reproduction in house mice and the genetic basis of hybrid male sterility between two mouse species, Mus domesticus and M. musculus. Evolutionary analysis of 946 genes showed that the intensity of positive selection varies across sperm development and acts primarily on phenotypes that develop late in spermatogenesis (Appendix A). Several reciprocal crosses between wild-derived strains of M. musculus and M. domesticus were used to examine F1 hybrid male sterility (Appendix B). These crosses revealed hybrid male sterility linked to the M. musculus X chromosome and a novel sterility polymorphism within M. musculus. A large introgression experiment was used to further dissect the genetic basis of X-linked incompatibilities between M. musculus and M. domesticus (Appendix C). Introgression of the M. musculus X chromosome into a M. domesticus genetic background produced male sterility and involved a minimum of four factors. No sterility factors were uncovered on the M. domesticus X chromosome. These data demonstrate the complex genetic basis of hybrid sterility in mice and provide numerous X-linked candidate sterility genes. The molecular evolution of five rapidly evolving candidate genes was examined using population and phylogenetic sampling in Mus (Appendix D). Four of these loci showed evidence of positive natural selection. One locus, 4933436I01Rik, showed divergent protein evolution between M. domesticus and M. musculus and was one of a handful of testis-expressed genes within a narrow interval involved in hybrid male sterility. In summary, these data demonstrate that hybrid male sterility has a complex genetic basis between two closely related species of house mice and provide a foundation for the identification of specific mutations that isolate these species.

The cactophilic Drosophila mojavensis species group living in the deserts and dry tropical forests of the Southwestern United States and Mexico provides a valuable system for studies in diversification and speciation. My dissertation addresses a variety of evolutionary genetic questions using this system.Rigorous studies of the relationships between host races of D. mojavensis and the relationships among the members of the species group (D. mojavensis, D. arizona, and D. navojoa) are lacking. I used mitochondrial CO1 sequence data to address the phylogenetics and population genetics of this species group (Appendix A). In this study I have found that the sister species D. mojavensis and D. arizonae share no mitochondrial haplotypes and thus show no evidence for recent introgression. I estimate the divergence time between D. mojavensis and D. arizonae to be between 0.66 and 0.99 million years ago. I performed additional population genetic analyses of these species to provide a basis for future hypothesis testing.In Appendix B, I report the first example of substantial intraspecific polymorphism for genetic factors contributing to hybrid male sterility. I show that the occurrence of hybrid male sterility in crosses between Drosophila mojavensis and its sister species, D. arizonae is controlled by factors present at different frequencies in different populations of D. mojavensis. In addition, I show that hybrid male sterility is a complex phenotype; some hybrid males with motile sperm still cannot sire offspring.The large degree of variation between isofemale lines in producing sterile hybrid sons suggests a complex genetic basis to hybrid male sterility warranting quantitative genetic analysis. Since the genes underlying hybrid male sterility in these species are not yet fixed, I am able to perform explicit genetic analysis of this reproductive isolating mechanism. In Appendix C, I present the results of mapping QTL for hybrid male sterility within species. The genetic architecture underlying hybrid male sterility when analyzed directly in the F1 is highly complex. Thus, hybrid male sterility arises as a complex trait in this system and we propose a drift-based model for the evolution of this phenotype.

Understanding reproductive isolation and divergence is the focus of speciation research. Recent evidence suggested that some Dendroctonus ponderosae populations produced hybrids with reproductive incompatibilities, a reproductive boundary undetected by phylogeographic analyses using molecular markers. Additionally, the unique bifurcated distribution of D. ponderosae and the proposed isolation-by-distance gene flow pattern around the Great Basin Desert provided a unique opportunity to investigate the evolution of postmating (postyzygotic) isolation while also understanding phenotypic divergence along latitudinal (climatic) gradients. First, I characterized the strength, biological pattern, and geographic pattern of postzygotic isolation in D. ponderosae by crossing increasingly divergent populations in a common garden environment. There was little evidence of hybrid inviability in these crosses, yet geographically distant crosses produced sterile males, consistent with expectations under Haldane's rule. Hybrid male sterility appeared at a threshold among increasingly divergent populations, was bidirectional (reciprocal crosses were affected), and less geographically distant crosses did not show significant gender-specific decreases in fitness. Second, a separate investigation of two critical phenotypic traits (body size and development time) was conducted on intrapopulation F2 generation offspring from a common garden experiment. Genetic differences contributing to phenotypic variance were interpreted within the context of the previously described reproductive incompatibilities, gene flow patterns, and latitudinal gradients. Genetic differences in development time were striking between faster developing and more synchronized northern populations and slower developing, less synchronized southern populations. Differences in development time were not detected between populations at similar latitudes. Body size, although more variable than developmental time, generally conformed to expectations, with northern populations being smaller than southern populations. Average adult size was found to be quite different between many populations and did vary between populations at similar latitudes, yet relative sexual size dimorphism was rather consistent. There was no evidence of correspondence between phenotypic traits (body size and development time) and either reproductive boundaries or gene flow patterns. The results suggest that latitudinally imposed climatic differences are likely driving phenotypic divergence between populations.

Malaria is a life-threatening disease caused by Plasmodium parasites that are transmitted through the bites of infected females of a few Anopheles mosquito species. Understanding the chromosome evolution and mechanisms of speciation can shed light on developing novel ecological-friendly vector control techniques. Sibling species of the An. gambiae complex provide an excellent model system for these topics. To understand the mechanisms of speciation, we investigated the cellular basis and phenotypes of hybrid male sterility in species crosses of the An. gambiae complex. By performing inter-species crosses of An. coluzzii/An. gambiae and An. merus lab strains, we found an asymmetric pattern of hybrid male sterility existed in sons from reciprocal interspecies crosses. Compared with pure species, hybrid males from crosses of ♀An. merus  ♂An. gambiae/An. coluzzii were normal in the morphology of male reproductive tracts; however, the testes of which that process the reductional meiotic division failed to produce primary spermatocytes and were accompanied with unpaired and insufficiently condensed chromosomes. As a result, primary spermatocytes undergo a mitosis-like anaphase division, producing nonmotile and malfunctional diploid sperm with two tails. However, individuals can mate with females normally and form the mating plug to induce the female monogamy. In contrast, hybrid males from the opposite crosses manifest severely underdeveloped reproductive tracts and a premeiotic arrest of germline stem cells in the testis, accompanied by a strong suppression of premeiotic and meiotic genes. In addition, hybrid males from this cross suffered from a shorter copulation time and failed to form mating plugs to induce female monogamous behaviors, albeit the expression of male accessory gland specific genes were similar between hybrids and pure species. To figure out chromosome evolution in the An. gambiae complex, we studied the molecular organization of heterochromatin and investigated the spatial organizations of autosomal regions of polytene chromosomes in soma and germline cells. We found that molecular composition of pericentrometric autosome and sex chromosome repetitive DNA differs among sibling species of An. gambiae complex with highly similarity between An. coluzzii and An. arabiensis. In addition, heterochromatin blocks of chromosomes have distinct compositions of satellite DNA sequences. Next, in order to address the relationship between inter-chromosomal (Chr-Chr) contacts and chromosome-nuclear envelope (Chr-NE) attachments during the development of the organism, we conducted microscopic analyses of the 3D organization of polytene chromosome in An. gambiae, An. coluzzii, and An. merus. Our quantitative study on chromosome territories in larval salivary gland cells and adult ovarian nurse cells showed that, compared with autosomal arms, the X chromosome has a significantly smaller volume and occupies more compact territories. The number of Chr-Chr contacts and the percentage of Chr-NE attachment were conserved among the species within the same cell type. Our data also demonstrated that there is a significantly and consistently inverse relationship between the frequencies of Chr–NE and Chr–Chr attachments on autosomes of two cell types in all tested species. / Doctor of Philosophy / Malaria is a life-threatening disease caused by Plasmodium parasites that are transmitted through the bites of infected females of a few Anopheles mosquito species. Despite being treatable and preventable, malaria is estimated to cause large numbers of deaths every year. Since 2015, the malaria elimination program has stalled largely due to increased insecticide resistance. Novel transgenic techniques have a huge potential in reducing malaria transmission more effectively. However, there are large concerns about the potential negative effects of releasing genetically modified mosquitoes, such as a possibility of accidental spread to non-target species with incomplete reproductive barriers and unpredicted ecological damage. Understanding the mechanisms of speciation about how reproductive isolation occurred and developed as well as chromosome evolution can not only empower the development of ecologically friendly vector control techniques but also improve our basic knowledge. To study mechanisms of speciation, we mated males and females from different closely related species in the Anopheles gambiae complex to investigate the fecundity of hybrid generations. Our study identified two different types of reproductive abnormalities leading to hybrid male sterility. Hybrid males from female An. merus and male An. gambiae or An. coluzzii have normal appearing testes and male accessary glands but the testes produce abnormal sperms, which cannot move and have two tails. Hybrid males from female An. gambiae or An. coluzzii and An. merus have severely underdeveloped testes and male accessary glands. The sperm producing process stops unusually very early in their tiny underdeveloped testes. We also investigated chromosome evolution in species of An. gambiae complex. We found that chromosomal parts containing repetitive DNA, the sequence in the genome not producing proteins, evolve rapidly in An. coluzzii, An. arabiensis, An. quadriannulatus, and An. merus. In contrast, chromosome territories of gene rich regions in giant polytene chromosomes from larval salivary gland cells and adult ovarian nurse cells of An. gambiae, An. coluzzii, and An. merus, were relatively conserved within the same cell type among different species. However, the chromosomal 3D distribution pattern is different among various cell types in these species.