京都大学 / 0048 / 新制・論文博士 / 博士(医学) / 乙第13163号 / 論医博第2150号 / 新制||医||1029(附属図書館) / 京都大学大学院医学研究科医学専攻 / (主査)教授 林 康紀, 教授 渡邉 大, 教授 高橋 淳 / 学位規則第4条第2項該当 / Doctor of Medical Science / Kyoto University / DFAM

La sclérose latérale amyothrophique (SLA) est une maladie neurodégénérative charactérisée par la perte des neurones moteurs menant à la paralysie et à la mort. Environ 20% des cas familiaux de la SLA sont causés par des mutations de la superoxyde dismutase 1 (SOD1), conduisant vers un mauvais repliement de la protéine SOD1, ce qui a comme conséquence un gain de fonction toxique. Plusieurs anticorps spécifiques pour la forme mal repliée de la protéine ont été générés et utilisés comme agent thérapeutique dans des modèles précliniques. Comment le mauvais repliement de SOD1 provoque la perte sélective des neurones moteurs demeure non résolu. La morphologie, le bilan énergétique et le transport mitochondrial sont tous documentés dans les modèles de la SLA basés sur SOD1, la détérioration des mitochondries joue un rôle clé dans la dégénération des neurones moteurs. De plus, la protéine SOD1 mal repliée s’associe sélectivement sur la surface des mitochondries de la moelle épinière chez les modèles de rongeurs de la SLA. Notre hypothèse est que l’accumulation de la protéine SOD1 mal repliée sur les mitochondries pourrait nuire aux fonctions mitochondriales. À cette fin, nous avons développé un nouvel essai par cytométrie de flux afin d’isoler les mitochondries immunomarquées avec des anticorps spécifiques à la forme malrepliée de SOD1 tout en évaluant des aspects de la fonction mitochondriale. Cette méthode permettra de comparer les mitochondries portant la protéine SOD1 mal repliée à celles qui ne la portent pas. Nous avons utilisé un anticorps à conformation spécifique de SOD1, B8H10, pour démontrer que la protéine mal repliée SOD1 s’associe avec les mitochondries de la moelle épinière des rat SOD1G93A d’une manière dépendante du temps. Les mitochondries avec la protéine mal repliée SOD1 B8H10 associée à leur surface (B8H10+) ont un volume et une production excessive de superoxyde significativement plus grand, mais possèdent un potentiel transmembranaire comparable aux mitochondries B8H10-. En outre, la présence de la protéine mal repliée SOD1 reconnue par B8H10 coïncide avec des niveaux plus élevés de la forme pro-apoptotique de Bcl-2. L’immunofluorescence de sections de moelle épinière du niveau lombaire avec l’anticorps spécifique à la conformation B8H10 et AMF7-63, un autre anticorps conformationnel spécifique de SOD1, démontre des motifs de localisations distincts. B8H10 a été trouvé principalement dans les neurones moteurs et dans plusieurs points lacrymaux dans tout le neuropile. Inversement, AMF7-63 a marqué les neurones moteurs ainsi qu’un réseau fibrillaire distinctif concentré dans la corne antérieure. Au niveau subcellulaire, SOD1 possèdant la conformation reconnu par AMF7-63 est aussi localisée sur la surface des mitochondries de la moelle épinière d’une manière dépendante du temps. Les mitochondries AMF7-63+ ont une augmentation du volume comparé aux mitochondries B8H10+ et à la sous-population non marquée. Cependant, elles produisent une quantité similaire de superoxyde. Ensemble, ces données suggèrent qu’il y a plusieurs types de protéines SOD1 mal repliées qui convergent vers les mitochondries et causent des dommages. De plus, différentes conformations de SOD1 apportent une toxicité variable vers les mitochondries. Les protéines SOD1 mal repliées réagissant à B8H10 et AMF7-63 sont présentes en agrégats dans les fractions mitochondriales, nous ne pouvons donc pas prendre en compte leurs différents effets sur le volume mitochondrial. Les anticorps conformationnels sont des outils précieux pour identifier et caractériser le continuum du mauvais repliement de SOD1 en ce qui concerne les caractéristiques biochimiques et la toxicité. Les informations présentes dans cette thèse seront utilisées pour déterminer le potentiel thérapeutique de ces anticorps. / Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) is a neurodegenerative disorder characterized by the loss of motor neurons resulting in paralysis and death. Approximately 20% of familial ALS cases are caused by mutations in superoxide dismutase (SOD1), which leads to misfolding of the SOD1 protein, resulting in a toxic gain of function. Several antibodies have been generated that are specific for the misfolded form of the protein, and have been used as therapeutics in pre-clinical models. How misfolded SOD1 provokes a selective loss of motor neurons remains unresolved. Mitochondrial morphology, bioenergetics and transport are all documented is SOD1-mediated ALS models, thus mitochondrial impairment plays a key role in motor neuron degeneration. Moreover, misfolded SOD1 selectively associates with the surface of spinal cord mitochondria in ALS rodent models. We hypothesize that the accumulation of misfolded SOD1 on mitochondria could impair mitochondrial function. To this end, we developed a novel flow cytometric assay to immunolabel isolated mitochondria with misfolded SOD1 antibodies while also evaluating aspects of mitochondrial function. This method will allow for a comparison of mitochondria bearing misfolded SOD1 to those without. We utilized the B8H10 conformation specific SOD1 antibody to demonstrate that misfolded SOD1 associates with SOD1G93A rat spinal cord mitochondria in a in a time dependent manner. Mitochondria with B8H10-reactive misfolded SOD1 associated with their surface (B8H10+) have a significantly larger volume and produce excessive amounts of superoxide, but have a similar transmembrane potential compared to B8H10- mitochondria. In addition, the presence of B8H10-reactive misfolded SOD1 coincides with higher levels of the pro-apoptotic form of Bcl-2. Staining of lumbar spinal cord sections with both B8H10 and another conformation specific SOD1 antibody, AMF7-63, yielded distinct localization patterns. B8H10 was found predominantly in motor neurons and numerous puncta throughout the neuropil. Conversely, AMF7-63 marked motor neurons as well as a distinctive fibrillar network that was concentrated in the anterior horn. At the subcellular level, AMF7-63-reactive misfolded SOD1 also localized to the mitochondrial surface of spinal cord mitochondria in a time-dependent manner. AMF7-63+ mitochondria have an increased volume compared to B8H10+ mitochondria and the unlabelled subpopulation. However, they produce similar amounts of superoxide. Together, these data suggest that there are multiple species of misfolded SOD1 that converge at the mitochondria to cause damage. Moreover, different SOD1 conformations may ellicit varying toxicities towards mitochondria. Both B8H10 and AMF7-63-reactive misfolded SOD1 are present in aggregates in mitochondrial fractions and can therefore not account for any different effects produced in terms of mitochondrial volume. Conformational antibodies are invaluable tools to identify and characterize the continuum of misfolded SOD1 species with regards to biochemical characteristics and toxicity. The information presented in this thesis will be used in determining the future therapeutic potential of these antibodies.

Protein misfolding and aggregation underlie several neurodegenerative proteinopathies including amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1) was the first gene found to be associated with familial ALS. Overexpression of human mutant or wild type SOD1 in transgenic mouse models induces motor neuron (MN) degeneration and an ALS-like phenotype. SOD1 mutations, leading to the destabilization of the SOD1 protein is associated with ALS pathogenesis. However, how misfolded SOD1 toxicity specifically affects human MNs is not clear. The aim of this thesis was to develop patient-derived, cellular models of ALS to help understand the pathogenic mechanisms underlying SOD1. To understand which cellular pathways impact on the level of misfolded SOD1 in human cells, we established a model using patient-derived fibroblasts and quantified misfolded SOD1 in relation to disturbances in several ALS-related cellular pathways. Misfolded SOD1 levels did not change following reduction in autophagy, inhibition of the mitochondrial respiratory chain, or induction of endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-stress. However, inhibition of the ubiquitin-proteasome system (UPS) lead to a dramatic increase in misfolded SOD1 levels. Hence, an age-related decline in proteasome activity might underlie the late-life onset that is typically seen in SOD1 ALS. To address whether or not SOD1 misfolding is enhanced in human MNs, we used mixed MN/astrocyte cultures (MNCs) generated in vitro from patient-specific induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs). Levels of soluble misfolded SOD1 were increased in MNCs as well as in pure iPSC-derived astrocytes compared to other cell types, including sensory neuron cultures. Interestingly, this was the case for both mutant and wild type human SOD1, although the increase was enhanced in SOD1 FALS MNCs. Misfolded SOD1 was also found to exist in the same form as in mouse SOD1 overexpression models and was identified as a substrate for 20S proteasome degradation. Hence, the vulnerability of motor areas to ALS could be explained by increased SOD1 misfolding, specifically in MNs and astrocytes. To investigate factors that might promote SOD1 misfolding, we focussed on the stability of SOD1 mediated by a crucial, stabilizing C57-C146 disulphide bond and its redox status. Formation of disulphide bond is dependent on oxidation by O2 and catalysed by CCS. To investigate whether low O2 tension affects the stability of SOD1 in vitro we cultured fibroblasts and iPSC-derived MNCs under different oxygen tensions. Low oxygen tension promoted disulphide-reduction, SOD1 misfolding and aggregation. This response was much greater in MNCs compared to fibroblasts, suggesting that MNs may be especially sensitive to low oxygen tension and areas with low oxygen supply could serve as foci for ALS initiation. SOD1 truncation mutations often lack C146, and cannot adopt a native fold and are rapidly degraded. We characterized soluble misfolded and aggregated SOD1 in patient-derived cells carrying a novel SOD1 D96Mfs*8 mutation as well as in cells fom an unaffected mutation carrier. The truncated protein has a C-terminal fusion of seven non-native amino acids and was found to be extremely prone to aggregation in vitro. Since not all mutation carriers develop ALS, our results suggested this novel mutation is associated with reduced penetrance. In summary, patient derived cells are useful models to study factors affecting SOD1 misfolded and aggregation. We show for the first time that misfolding of a disordered and disease associated protein is enhanced in disease-related cell types. Showing that misfolded SOD1 exists in human cells in the same form as in transgenic mouse models strengthens the translatability of results obtained in the two species. Our results demonstrate disulphide-reduction and misfolding/aggregation of SOD1 and suggest that 20S proteasome could be an important therapeutic target for early stages of disease. This model provides a great opportunity to study pathogenic mechanisms of both familial and sporadic ALS in patient-derived models of ALS. / Varje år insjuknar omkring 5300 personer i världen i motorneuronsjukdomen Amyotrofisk lateralskleros (ALS). Sjukdomen kännetecknas av degeneration av motorneuron i hjärnan och ryggmärgen, de nervceller som styr kroppens muskler, vilket leder till musklerförtvining och gradvis förlamning. ALS-patienter avlider oftast till följd av andningssvikt när sjukdomen når andningsmuskulaturen. I de allra flesta fall uppkommer ALS sporadiskt (SALS), det vill säga utan känd genetisk orsak, medan ärftliga fall (FALS) drabbar omkring 10 % och beror på mutationer i ett antal kända gener. Upp till 6 % av alla ALS fall kan härledas till mutationer i genen superoxid dismutas 1 (SOD1). SOD1 är ett enzym som ansvarar för att omvandla och oskadliggöra fria syreradikaler som bildas vid normal ämnesomsättning. 206 olika SOD1 mutationer har identifierats, alla orsakar inte ALS men många leder till att den tredimensionella proteinstrukturen förändras, vilket ökar proteinets benägenhet att felveckas. Initialt trodde man att SOD1 mutationer förhindrade proteinets normalfunktion och följaktligen orsakade ALS. Studier har emellertid visat att den enzymatiska funktionen ofta bevaras, även hos muterade proteiner. Däremot kan små mängder felveckat SOD1 störa andra viktiga cellulära funktioner. Felveckat SOD1 har en benägenhet att klumpa ihop sig och bilda aggregat i det centrala nervsystemet (CNS). Dessa aggregat återfinns hos patienter med såväl FALS som SALS vilket tyder på att även vildtyps-SOD1 kan felveckas och vara involverat i sjukdomsutvecklingen. De flesta studier är baserade på transgena musmodeller som uttrycker extremt stora mängder av muterat humant SOD1. Det är dock oklart hur väl studier i möss överensstämmer med sjukdomsutvecklingen hos ALS-patienter, där mängden SOD1 är betydligt lägre. En central fråga som fortfarande står obesvarad är varför just motorneuron degenererar i ALS, trots att SOD1 uttrycks i alla kroppens celler. Det övergripande syftet med den här avhandlingen har varit att karakterisera felveckat SOD1 i patientceller för att studera dess roll i ALSrelaterade sjukdomsmekanismer med fysiologiskt relevanta nivåer av SOD1. Samtliga studier är gjorda in vitro med celler från friska donatorer med vildtyps-SOD1, celler från patienter med SOD1-FALS, FALS som bär andra ALS-associerade gener, samt SALS. I de allra flesta fallen har vi analyserat både lösligt felveckat SOD1 samt aggregerade former av SOD1 proteinet.