Thesis (Ph. D.)--University of Canterbury, 2006. / Typescript (photocopy). Includes bibliographical references (leaves 99-118). Also available via the World Wide Web.

Thesis (Ph. D.) -- Lincoln University, 2010. / Also available via the World Wide Web.

Ineffective biological control of the Eucalyptus pest Paropsis charybdis Stål (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae: Paropsini) in cold areas of New Zealand was believed to be caused a climatic mismatch of the egg parasitoid Enoggera nassaui Girault (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae). Two Tasmanian strains of the parasitoid were introduced to test climate-matching theory in 2000, with approximately 7000 wasps released. Establishment of the Florentine Valley strain was detected in 2002 using the Mitochondrial (mtDNA) gene Cytochrome Oxidase I (COI) as a strain specific marker. The hyperparasitoid Baeoanusia albifunicle Girault (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae) and primary parasitoid Neopolycystus insectifurax Girault (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae) were detected for the first time in New Zealand.
As paropsines have proven highly invasive internationally, a risk assessment of the paropsine threat to New Zealand was undertaken by evaluating the host range of E. nassaui and a reproductive assessment of 23 paropsine species in the genera Dicranosterna Motschulsky, Chrysophtharta Weise, Paropsis Olivier, Paropsisterna Motschulsky and Trachymela Weise. Enoggera nassaui proved polyphagous, but bioassay results proved that Paropsis species were significantly more susceptible to the egg parasitoid than Chrysophtharta species. Resistance within Chrysophtharta was attributed to spine-like chorion modifications. A COI derived Chrysophtharta phylogeny divided the genus into two distinct groupings, which was supported by chorion morphology.
Paropsine reproductive output was tested for key parameters indicating pest potential. Pest species displayed fecundity exceeding 600 eggs at an oviposition rate above 10 eggs per day⁻¹. Several non-pest species were identified as potential pests based on these parameters. The Chrysophtharta phylogeny suggested a moderate relationship between genetic relatedness and reproductive output. The Acacia defoliating paropsine Dicranosterna semipunctata (Chapuis) was evaluated for its susceptibility to E. nassaui and reproductive output. Egg parasitism occurring in bioassay did not translate into biological suppression following a specifically targeted release of E. nassaui, and the fecundity and oviposition rates fell below the thresholds predicted for a pest paropsine species.
Despite establishment of Tasmanian E. nassaui, hyperparasitism has now rendered this control agent ineffective in New Zealand. Neopolycystus insectifurax offers the best hope for future biological control of paropsine species in New Zealand.

Paropsis atomaria Olivier (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae: Paropsini), is a major pest of commercially grown eucalypts in South-East Queensland. Current management of paropsine beetles involves regular inspection and the application of chemical sprays if defoliation is severe. However, non-chemical control of plantation pests is highly desirable given the requirement to certify forest practices for sustainability, and community concerns over the use of pesticides. One way of reducing pesticide use is through conservation biological control, which requires detailed knowledge of the life history of the pest and its natural enemies. This thesis documents aspects of P. atomaria phenology, including life tables, sex ratios and damage estimates; identifies the predators, parasites, and egg and larval parasitoids of P. atomaria; and examines the ecology of the most promising natural enemy, Neopolycystus Girault sp. (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae) in South-East Queensland. P. atomaria adults are active from September until April and can complete up to four generations in a season. Field mortality between egg and fourth instar larvae is approximately 94%. A large proportion of this mortality can be attributed to natural enemies. The most abundant predators in eucalypt plantations were spiders, comprising 88% of all predators encountered. Egg parasitoids exerted the greatest influence on P. atomaria populations, emerging from around 50% of all egg batches, and were responsible for mortality of almost one third of all eggs in the field. Only about one percent of larvae were parasitised in the field, in contrast to paropsine pests in temperate Australia, where egg parasitism rates are low and larval parasitism rates high. Neopolycystus sp. was the only primary parasitoid reared from P. atomaria eggs, along with three hyperparasitoid species; Baeoanusia albifunicle Girault (Encyrtidae), Neblatticida sp. (Encyrtidae) and Aphaneromella sp. (Platygasteridae). This is the first record of B. albifunicle hyperparasitising Neopolycystus spp. B. albifunicle emerged from one-third of all parasitised egg batches and could pose a potential problem to the efficacy of Neopolycystus sp. as a biological control agent. However, within egg batches, hyperparasitoids rarely killed all Neopolycystus sp. with only 9% of hyperparasitised egg batches failing to produce any primary parasitoids. Total field mortality of P. atomaria through direct and indirect effects of parasitism by Neopolycystus sp. was 28%. The proportion of egg batches parasitised increased with exposure time in the field, but within-batch parasitism rate did not. In general, there was no significant correlation between parasitism rates and distance from landscape features (viz. water sources and native forest).

An established host-parasitoid-hyperparasitoid system was used to investigate how the physiological and behavioural characteristics of parasitoids influence the outcomes of laboratory-based host specificity tests. The characteristics of the two pteromalid egg parasitoids, Enoggera nassaui (Girault) and Neopolycystus insectifurax Girault, were assessed and interpreted in regard to the particular host specificity testing methods used and the control of the eucalypt defoliating beetle Paropsis charybdis Stål (Chrysomelidae) in New Zealand. The physiology of N. insectifurax was examined to determine how to increase production of female parasitoids that were physiologically capable and motivated to parasitise P. charybdis eggs in laboratory trials. Neopolycystus insectifurax were found to be more synovigenic than E. nassaui. Provisioning them with honey and host stimuli for three days, and allowing females to parasitise hosts in isolation (i.e. in the absence of competition) was an effective means of achieving these goals. No-choice tests were conducted in Petri dish arenas with the four paropsine beetles established in New Zealand. All four were found to be within the physiological host ranges of E. nassaui and N. insectifurax, but their quality as hosts, as indicated by the percent parasitised and offspring sex ratios, varied. The results of paired choice tests between three of the four species agreed with those of no-choice tests in most instances. However, the host Trachymela catenata (Chapuis), which was parasitised at very low levels by E. nassaui in no-choice tests, was not accepted by that species in paired choice tests. A much stronger preference by N. insectifurax for P. charybdis over T. catenata was recorded in the paired choice test than expected considering the latter was parasitised at a high level in the no-choice test. The presence of the target host in paired choice tests reduced acceptance of lower ranked hosts. Both no-choice and choice tests failed to predict that eggs of the acacia feeding beetle Dicranosterna semipunctata (Chapuis) would not be within the ecological host range of E. nassaui and N. insectifurax. Behavioural observations were made of interspecific competition between E. nassaui and N. insectifurax for access to P. charybdis eggs. Two very different oviposition strategies were identified. Neopolycystus insectifurax were characterised by taking possession of, and aggressively guarding host eggs during and after oviposition. They also appeared to selectively oviposit into host eggs already parasitised by E. nassaui, but did not emerge from significantly more multi-parasitised hosts than E. nassaui. Enoggera nassaui did not engage in contests and fled when approached by N. insectifurax. Although often prohibited from ovipositing by N. insectifurax, E. nassaui were able to locate and begin ovipositing more quickly, and did not remain to guard eggs after oviposition. It is hypothesised that although N. insectifurax have a competitive advantage in a Petri dish arena, E. nassaui may be able to locate and parasitise more host eggs in the field in New Zealand, where competition for hosts in is relatively low. The biology of the newly established encyrtid Baeoanusia albifunicle Girault was assessed. It was confirmed to be a direct obligate hyperparasitoid able to exploit E. nassaui but not N. insectifurax. Field and database surveys found that all three parasitoids have become established in many climatically different parts of New Zealand. Physiological characteristics were identified that may allow B. albifunicle to reduced effective parasitism of P. charybdis by E. nassaui to below 10%. However, the fact that hyperparasitism still prevents P. charybdis larvae from emerging, and that B. albifunicle does not attack N. insectifurax, may preclude any significant impact on the biological control of P. charybdis. Overall, parasitoid ovigeny and behavioural interactions with other parasitoids were recognised as key characteristics having the potential to influence host acceptance in the laboratory and the successful biological control of P. charybdis in the field. It is recommended that such characteristics be considered in the design and implementation of host specificity tests and might best be assessed by conducting behavioural observations during parasitoid colony maintenance and the earliest stages of host specificity testing.