University, Diss., 2005--Würzburg.

Die Gattung Pogonomyrmex ist besonders gut geeignet, um die Evolution der Charakteristika von Ameisenkolonien allgemein zu untersuchen, und insbesondere deren soziogenetische Struktur, da die Biologie für einige ihrer Arten sehr gut bekannt ist, und eine Diversität an Paarungshäufigkeiten und Könniginnenzahlen vorkommt. Diese Variation in der soziogenetischen Struktur der Kolonien erzeugt eine hohe Varianz an Verwandschaftsgraden innerhalb von Kolonien, und kann eine Hauptkomponente darstellen, welche die Evolution verschiedenster Koloniecharakteristika vorantreibt. Um die Variabilität intrakolonialer Verwandschaftsgrade innerhalb der Gattung Pogonomyrmex genau zu bestimmen, wurde für ausgewählte Mitglieder der Gattung, nämlich für P. (sensu stricto) rugosus, P. (sensu stricto) badius and P. (Ephebomyrmex) pima, mit Hilfe der Technik des DNA-Fingerabdruckes die Anzahl an Matrilinien und Patrilinien bestimmt. Es wurde versucht die Evolution dieser Koloniecharakteristika vor dem Hintergrund einer Phylogenie zu erklären. Zu diesem Zweck wurde ein Gen-Stammbaum für 39 Arten der Gattung Pogonomyrmex erstellt. Die Artabdeckung betrug 83% bei den Nord-Amerikanischen, und 43% bei den Süd-Amerikanischen Arten. Effektive Mehrfachpaarung von Königinnen wurde für P. rugosus (me=4.1) und P. badius (me=6.7) bestätigt. Zusätzlich wurde gezeigt, dass beide Arten monogyn sind. Diese Ergebnisse bestätigen Verhaltensbeobachtungen von Mehrfachpaarungen in diesen Arten. Mittlerweile ist Mehrfachpaarung in 9 Pogonomyrmex Arten bekannt (bei 3 Arten durch Verhaltensbeobachtungen – bei 6 Arten durch genetischen Nachweis). In P. (E.) pima hingegen waren alle der untersuchten Königinnen einfach gepaart (me=1.0). Daher könnte es sein, dass Mehrfachpaarung entweder früh in der Evolution der Gattung Pogonomyrmex entstand und nachträglich in der Untergattung Ephebomyrmex verloren wurde (Plesiomorphie-Hypothese), oder sie entstand zum ersten mal in der Untergattung Pogonomyrmex sensu stricto (Apomorphie-Hypothese). In P. huachucanus, einer Art, die basal zu dem Nord-Amerikanischen sensu stricto Komplex ist, könnten die im Vergleich zu ihren sensu stricto Verwandten geringeren effektiven Paarungshäufigkeiten der Königinnen (J. Gadau and C.-P. Strehl, unveröffentlicht) einen Wechsel von Monandrie zu Polyandrie im Verlauf der Entstehung der fortschrittlicheren sensu stricto Arten widerspiegeln, was die Apomorphie-Hypothese unterstützen würde. Die intrakolonialen Verwandtschaftsgrade sind dennoch in P. (E.) pima niedrig. Dies ist möglicherweise auf mehrere reproduktive Königinnen (Polygynie) zurückzuführen. Polygynie ist ebenfalls dokumentiert für mindestens vier weitere Arten der Untergattung Ephebomyrmex, mit genetischer Evidenz allerdings bisher nur für P. (E.) pima. Es könnte sein, dass es einen evolutionären Ausgleich (trade-off) zwischen Polyandrie und Polygynie innerhalb der Untergattung Ephebomyrmex gab, und daher beide Untergattungen eine hohe genetische Vielfalt innerhalb der Kolonien behielten. Diese hohe genetische Vielfalt könnte einer der Gründe sein für den Erfolg und die Radiation der Gattung Pogonomyrmex in Trockengebieten. Evolution könnte eine hohe genetische Vielfalt von Pogonomyrmex Kolonien begünstigt haben, da sie den Kolonien hilft die Organisation der Kolonie und die Effizienz mit der externe Aufgaben ausgeführt werden zu verbessern. Wenigstens in P. badius konnte eine Verknüpfung zwischen Patrilinien und physischem Polyethismus gefunden werden, was auf eine Verbesserung der Kolonieorganisation mit Hilfe von Polyandrie hindeutet. Darüber hinaus könnten die dargelegten extremen Polyandrie- Werte den P. badius-Weibchen helfen die Möglichkeit der Inzucht aufgrund eingeschränkter Ausbreitung zu bewältigen. Eine eingeschränkte Ausbreitung wird auch in P. (E.) pima durch flügellose, intermorphe Königinnen beobachtet. Jedoch wird bei P. (E.) pima die Inzucht durch Auskreuzen mittels Männchen möglicherweise verhindert, da keine signifikante Inzucht gefunden wurde. In den vorliegenden Gen-Stammbäumen war die Untergattung Pogonomyrmex Ephebomyrmex von der Untergattung Pogonomyrmex sensu stricto getrennt. Daher könnte es sein, dass P. Ephebomyrmex in den Status einer Gattung erhoben wird, auch aufgrund distinkter morphologischer und lebensgeschichtlicher Charaktere. Für eine präzise taxonomische Revision müsste allerdings eine breite Ergänzung an Arten vorgenommen werden. Es wurde in P. rugosus Kolonien normalerweise eine geringe Anzahl von unverwandten Arbeiterinnen vorgefunden, die möglicherweise aus Brutraub ausgewachsener Kolonien auf Gündungs-Kolonien stammen. Es ist allseits bekannt, dass die meisten Gründungskolonien von benachbarten, ausgewachsenen Kolonien der eigenen Art zerstört werden, aber es wurde bisher angenommen, dass die Brut dieser Kolonien ebenfalls zerstört wurde. Dieser oft vernachlässigte Aspekt könnte einen wichtigen Stärke-Bonus für ausgewachsene Kolonien darstellen. / The genus Pogonomyrmex is predisposed for analyzing the evolution of ant colony characteristics in general and the sociogenetic structure in particular, due to the renowned biology of several species and the diversity of mating frequency and queen number. This variation in the sociogenetic structure of colonies produces a high variance in intracolonial relatedness which can be a major component driving the evolution of various colony characteristics. To exactly determine the variability of the intracolonial relatedness in the genus Pogonomyrmex both were analyzed, the number of matrilines and patrilines, in selected members of Pogonomyrmex, namely P. (sensu stricto) rugosus, P. (sensu stricto) badius and P. (Ephebomyrmex) pima using DNA fingerprint techniques. The evolution of these colony characteristics were tried to be explained within a phylogenetic framework. For that purpose we constructed a gene-tree of 39 species of the genus Pogonomyrmex. The taxon sampling covered about 83 % of the North American species and 43 % of the South American species. Effective multiple mating of queens was confirmed for P. rugosus (me=4.1) and P. badius (me=6.7). Additionally, both species are monogynous. These results corroborate behavioral observations of multiple mating for these species. Multiple mating is now known from 9 Pogonomyrmex species (behavioral evidence for 3 species – genetic evidence for 6 species). However, in P. (E.) pima all queens that were analyzed were single mated (me=1.0). Therefore, multiple mating may have either evolved early during the evolution of the genus Pogonomyrmex and has subsequently been lost in the subgenus Ephebomyrmex (plesiomorphic hypothesis), or it has first been evolved in the subgenus Pogonomyrmex sensu stricto (apomorphic hypothesis). In P. huachucanus, a species basal to the North- American sensu stricto complex, smaller effective mating number of queens compared to its sensu stricto relatives (J. Gadau and C.-P. Strehl, unpublished) probably do mirror a change from monandry to polyandry during the evolution of more advanced sensu stricto species, which would support the apomorphic hypothesis. The intracolonial relatedness in P. (E.) pima is however rather low. This is probably the result of multiple reproducing queens (polygyny). Polygyny is also documented for at least four other species of the subgenus Ephebomyrex, but so far P. (E.) pima is the only species with genetic evidence. It might be that there was an evolutionary trade-off within the subgenus Ephebomyrmex between polyandry and polygyny. Therefore, both subgenera retained a high intracolonial genetic diversity. This high genetic diversity might be one cause for the success and radiation of the genus Pogonomyrmex in arid environments. Evolution might have favored high genetic diversity of Pogonomyrmex colonies, because it helps colonies to improve their colonial organization and efficiency in performing external tasks. At least in P. badius a link between patrilines and physical polyethism was found, indicative of an improvement of colonial organization via polyandry. Furthermore, the documented extreme levels of polyandry might help P. badius females to overcome the possibility of inbreeding due to restricted dispersal. Restricted dispersal is also found in P. (E.) pima due to wingless, intermorphic queens. However, in P. (E.) pima inbreeding is probably prevented by outcrossing via males because no significant inbreeding is found. In the presented gene trees the subgenus Pogonomyrmex Ephebomyrmex was separated from the subgenus Pogonomyrmex sensu stricto. Therefore, P. Ephebomyrmex might be elevated to generic status, also due to its distinct morphological and life history characters. Nevertheless, for a precise taxonomic revision a broader complement of species has to be applied. Regularly a low number of unrelated workers was found in P. rugosus colonies, which probably stem from brood raids between mature and founding colonies. It is well known that most founding colonies are destroyed by neighboring conspecific mature colonies, but so far it was assumed that the brood of these colonies was also destroyed. This often neglected aspect might be an important fitness token for mature colonies.

Thesis (M.S.)--Boise State University, 2009. / Title from t.p. of PDF file (viewed Aug. 31, 2009). Includes bibliographical references.

Thesis (M.S.)--Boise State University, 2009. / Includes bibliographical references.

abstract: Social insect colonies exhibit striking diversity in social organization. Included in this overwhelming variation in structure are differences in colony queen number. The number of queens per colony varies both intra- and interspecifically and has major impacts on the social dynamics of a colony and the fitness of its members. To understand the evolutionary transition from single to multi-queen colonies, I examined a species which exhibits variation both in mode of colony founding and in the queen number of mature colonies. The California harvester ant Pogonomyrmex californicus exhibits both variation in the number of queens that begin a colony (metrosis) and in the number of queens in adult colonies (gyny). Throughout most of its range, colonies begin with one queen (haplometrosis) but in some populations multiple queens cooperate to initiate colonies (pleometrosis). I present results that confirm co-foundresses are unrelated. I also map the geographic occurrence of pleometrotic populations and show that the phenomenon appears to be localized in southern California and Northern Baja California. Additionally, I provide genetic evidence that pleometrosis leads to primary polygyny (polygyny developing from pleometrosis) a phenomenon which has received little attention and is poorly understood. Phylogenetic and haplotype analyses utilizing mitochondrial markers reveal that populations of both behavioral types in California are closely related and have low mitochondrial diversity. Nuclear markers however, indicate strong barriers to gene flow between focal populations. I also show that intrinsic differences in queen behavior lead to the two types of populations observed. Even though populations exhibit strong tendencies on average toward haplo- or pleometrosis, within population variation exists among queens for behaviors relevant to metrosis and gyny. These results are important in understanding the dynamics and evolutionary history of a distinct form of cooperation among unrelated social insects. They also help to understand the dynamics of intraspecific variation and the conflicting forces of local adaptation and gene flow. / Dissertation/Thesis / Ph.D. Biology 2011

abstract: Gene-centric theories of evolution by natural selection have been popularized and remain generally accepted in both scientific and public paradigms. While gene-centrism is certainly parsimonious, its explanations fall short of describing two patterns of evolutionary and social phenomena: the evolution of sex and the evolution of social altruism. I review and analyze current theories on the evolution of sex. I then introduce the conflict presented to gene-centric evolution by social phenomena such as altruism and caste sterility in eusocial insects. I review gene-centric models of inclusive fitness and kin selection proposed by Hamilton and Maynard Smith. Based their assumptions, that relatedness should be equal between sterile workers and reproductives, I present several empirical examples that conflict with their models. Following that, I introduce a unique system of genetic caste determination (GCD) observed in hybrid populations of two sister-species of seed harvester ants, Pogonomyrmex rugosus and Pogonomyrmex barbatus. I review the evidence for GCD in those species, followed by a critique of the current gene-centric models used to explain it. In chapter two I present my own theoretical model that is both simple and extricable in nature to explain the origin, evolution, and maintenance of GCD in Pogonomyrmex. Furthermore, I use that model to fill in the gaps left behind by the contributing authors of the other GCD models. As both populations in my study system formed from inter-specific hybridization, I review modern discussions of heterosis (also called hybrid vigor) and use those to help explain the ecological competitiveness of GCD. I empirically address the inbreeding depression the lineages of GCD must overcome in order to remain ecologically stable, demonstrating that as a result of their unique system of caste determination, GCD lineages have elevated recombination frequencies. I summarize and conclude with an argument for why GCD evolved under selective mechanisms which cannot be considered gene-centric, providing evidence that natural selection can effectively operate on non-heritable genotypes appearing in groups and other social contexts. / Dissertation/Thesis / M.S. Biology 2012

Tests of optimal foraging theory have shown that many predators are selective about which prey and which patches should be utilized. I hypothesize that prey species "exploit" this choosiness by evolving characteristics that cause predators to choose alternate prey. Specifically, prey should evolve traits that increase the probability of predator death, decrease the per prey or per patch nutritional intake, increase processing time, and advertise (or mimic advertisements of) undesirable traits. Predator choosiness allows prey to divert the predator instead of defeating it. The evolution of a long-term, prudent foraging strategy requires that three conditions be met: (1) The forager must use resources from a discrete subpopulation; (2) use of that subpopulation must be relatively exclusive; (3) the resource population must respond in such a way that a long-term strategy provides an economic advantage. For the horned lizard-ant system, conditions (1) and (2) were tested by tagging lizards with transmitters or radioactive tags. Horned lizards occupy home ranges much smaller than would be expected if they moved at random and home range overlap was less than expected by random placement of home ranges, thus conditions (1) and (2) were not rejected. Most techniques of home range study do not distinguish random from nonrandom movement. Condition (3) was tested by subjecting ant colonies to various levels of artificial predation. In none of five experiments was the result obtained that an increased harvest intensity led to a decrease in long-term yield; condition (3) is tentatively rejected. Ant colonies shut down in response to predation; this puts a ceiling on their losses. Short-term foraging models were tested for horned lizards foraging at ant colonies. A prediction of the marginal value theorem was not rejected: Horned lizards tended to leave colonies when their instantaneous rate of harvest at that colony had fallen to their average rate of harvest for the day. Another short-term prediction, however, was rejected: Lizards did not stay longer at the "better" of two colonies. A more liberal version of the same prediction was not rejected. Apparently, horned lizards forage adaptively but not optimally.

This study examined modifications made by Pogonomyrmex barbatus, by their processes of granivory and nest construction, to forb and grass dynamics under large-scale disturbances of fire, recent drought and long-term, large-mammalian herbivory using comparative studies, field experimental manipulations, and a simulation model on the Edwards Plateau, Texas. Ant nests are refugia for grass survival during extreme droughts as demonstrated during the drought of 1998 to 2002. Significantly greater cover of grasses and lower abundance and cover of forbs was found beside nests compared with surrounding habitat throughout the drought and recovery. Grasses near nests may be the seed source for surrounding habitats during recovery. Seeds were differentially collected among most forbs and grasses despite seed abundance. Harvest was significantly reduced in the fall relative to spring. During preference experiments, harvest differences were found between grazing treatments for two of four species, but only during the spring. High lipid content seeds were unpreferred in fall compared to high protein and carbohydrate content seeds. Granivory influences on seedling establishment were studied by comparing seedling recruitment among sown and naturally occurring seeds excluded and open to foragers. Exclosures were placed in three nest densities and two burn treatments. Seeds in exclosures produced significantly more seedlings than open arenas only during the first year of drought recovery. Densities of grasses and annual forbs were higher in open arenas the second year due to indirect effects of granivory. By reducing seeds ants release seedlings from competition. Sown seedling abundance was unaffected by colony density and fire. Colony density and distribution were influenced by topography, soil types, soil depth and woody cover, but not by historical grazing treatments. Cleared vegetation on nest disks impacted less than 1% of total surface area and losses were compensated by greater basal cover of grasses next to disks compared to surrounding habitats. Foraging areas influenced 17.3-73.6% of surface area and could diminish seed populations for potential seedlings. Model results agree with experimental observations that communities may be modified by P. barbatus presence due to differential responses of grass species to interaction between nests or granivory and rainfall amounts.

abstract: Here I present a phylogeographic study of at least six reproductively isolated lineages of harvester ants within the Pogonomyrmex barbatus and P. rugosus species group. The genetic and geographic relationships within this clade are complex: four of the identified lineages are divided into two pairs, and each pair has evolved under a mutualistic system that necessitates sympatry. These paired lineages are dependent upon one another because interlineage matings within each pair are the sole source of hybrid F1 workers; these workers build and sustain the colonies, facilitating the production of the reproductive caste, which results solely from intralineage fertilizations. This system of genetic caste determination (GCD) maintains genetic isolation among these closely related lineages, while simultaneously requiring co-expansion and emigration as their distributions have changed over time. Previous studies have also demonstrated that three of the four lineages displaying this unique genetic caste determination phenotype are of hybrid origin. Thus, reconstructing the phylogenetic and geographic history of this group allows us to evaluate past insights and plan future inquiries in a more complete historical biogeographic context. Using mitochondrial DNA sequences sampled across most of the morphospecies' ranges in the U.S. and Mexico, I employed several methods of phylogenetic and DNA sequence analysis, along with comparisons to geological, biogeographic, and phylogeographic studies throughout the sampled regions. These analyses on Pogonomyrmex harvester ants reveal a complex pattern of vicariance and dispersal that is largely concordant with models of late Miocene, Pliocene, and Pleistocene range shifts among various arid-adapted taxa in North America. / Dissertation/Thesis / M.S. Biology 2012

abstract: In social insect colonies, as with individual animals, the rates of biological processes scale with body size. The remarkable explanatory power of metabolic allometry in ecology and evolutionary biology derives from the great diversity of life exhibiting a nonlinear scaling pattern in which metabolic rates are not proportional to mass, but rather exhibit a hypometric relationship with body size. While one theory suggests that the supply of energy is a major physiological constraint, an alternative theory is that the demand for energy is regulated by behavior. The central hypothesis of this dissertation research is that increases in colony size reduce the proportion of individuals actively engaged in colony labor with consequences for energetic scaling at the whole-colony level of biological organization. A combination of methods from comparative physiology and animal behavior were developed to investigate scaling relationships in laboratory-reared colonies of the seed-harvester ant, Pogonomyrmex californicus. To determine metabolic rates, flow-through respirometry made it possible to directly measure the carbon dioxide production and oxygen consumption of whole colonies. By recording video of colony behavior, for which ants were individually paint-marked for identification, it was possible to reconstruct the communication networks through which information is transmitted throughout the colony. Whole colonies of P. californicus were found to exhibit a robust hypometric allometry in which mass-specific metabolic rates decrease with increasing colony size. The distribution of walking speeds also scaled with colony size so that larger colonies were composed of relatively more inactive ants than smaller colonies. If colonies were broken into random collections of workers, metabolic rates scaled isometrically, but when entire colonies were reduced in size while retaining functionality (queens, juveniles, workers), they continued to exhibit a metabolic hypometry. The communication networks in P. californicus colonies contain a high frequency of feed-forward interaction patterns consistent with those of complex regulatory systems. Furthermore, the scaling of these communication pathways with size is a plausible mechanism for the regulation of whole-colony metabolic scaling. The continued development of a network theory approach to integrating behavior and metabolism will reveal insights into the evolution of collective animal behavior, ecological dynamics, and social cohesion. / Dissertation/Thesis / Ph.D. Biology 2012