Made available in DSpace on 2015-04-14T13:39:30Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1
466609.pdf: 1179038 bytes, checksum: 5cd6759c8e1a71fe55982083f9205e3a (MD5)
Previous issue date: 2015-01-16 / Broadcasted in the press, usually via newspaper, the cartoon is a genre whose complexity is set as an interesting object of analysis to observe how the senses are constructed themselves in the discourse. Considering this complexity and based on the Bakhtinian theory, this thesis wants to answer the following question: How is the dialogical construction of senses made, considering the production and reception of the discourse in cartoons that are said to be controversial? The overall objective of this thesis is to analyze how the dialogical construction of the senses happens, considering the enunciative project from the cartoons and the reading of its interlocutors, mainly in those considered to be controversial, thus, cartoons that presented discrepancies between the production and the reception of the senses and that had a repercussion in the media due to a diversity of readings. As specific objectives, we had (a) investigate how the different social voices that go through controversial cartoon engender themselves and reflect and refract senses in the discourse and (b) talk about discourse-response that come out from controversial cartoons. We chose to work with four controversial cartoons and eleven discourse-response from these cartoons, all of them broadcasted on-line between 2011 and 2014, referring to the facts in Brazilian media in between these years. As a theoretical framework, we use the ideas postulated by Mikhail Bakhtin and his Circle, to whom every discourse is dialogic, in other words, the discourse establishes a necessary relation with other discourses, unleashing different senses.Thus, the methodology of analysis is based on the methodological guidance provided in Marxism and Philosophy of Language ([1929] 2009, p. 45). That is to say, the discourse is taken into account from the bond with its socio-historical context, which refers to the need of the analysis to be made from the limits of a particular culture in order to understand the discursive issues engendered in the social spheres from which they emerge. After doing the analysis, we can notice that the discrepancy - between the production and reception of the senses from the controversial cartoons picked - is due to the different valuation by the interlocutors in relation to the project of saying from the cartoon. In addition to that, there seems to be no understanding of what this genre is, which prevents a critical reading. We hope that with the discussions about the constructed senses in the observed discourses, we can contribute with reflections aimed at the teaching of reading and textual production in Portuguese classes, considering the importance of the study of language in use, materialized in different discursive genres. / Veiculada na m?dia, geralmente em jornais, a charge ? um g?nero cuja complexidade se configura como um interessante objeto de an?lise para se observar como os sentidos se constroem no discurso. Esta disserta??o, ponderando tal complexidade e tendo como base a teoria bakhtiniana, visa responder a seguinte quest?o: Como se d? a constru??o dial?gica de sentidos, considerando a produ??o e recep??o do discurso, em charges tidas como pol?micas? O objetivo geral desta disserta??o ? analisar como acontece a constru??o dial?gica dos sentidos, considerando o projeto enunciativo das charges e as leituras de seus interlocutores, especificamente naquelas consideradas pol?micas, isto ?, charges que apresentaram discrep?ncias entre a produ??o e a recep??o dos sentidos e que tiveram repercuss?o na m?dia, devido ? diversidade de leituras. Como objetivos espec?ficos, buscamos (a) examinar de que forma diferentes vozes sociais que atravessam charges pol?micas se engendram e refletem e refratam sentidos no discurso e (b) discutir sobre discursos-resposta que emergem a partir das charges pol?micas em quest?o. Delimitamos como recorte de pesquisa quatro charges pol?micas e onze discursos-resposta dessas charges, todos veiculados em meio digital entre 2011 e 2014, que fizessem refer?ncia a fatos divulgados pela m?dia brasileira tamb?m entre esses anos. No que tange ao embasamento te?rico, recorremos ?s ideias postuladas por Mikhail Bakhtin e seu C?rculo, para quem todo discurso ? dial?gico, isto ?, todo discurso estabelece uma necess?ria rela??o com outros discursos, desencadeando diferentes sentidos. A metodologia de an?lise est? alicer?ada nas orienta??es metodol?gicas apresentadas em Marxismo e filosofia da linguagem ([1929] 2009, p. 45). Assim, o discurso ? considerado a partir do v?nculo com seu contexto s?cio-hist?rico, o que remete ? necessidade de as an?lises serem desenvolvidas a partir dos limites de determinada cultura, de modo a compreender as quest?es discursivas engendradas ?s esferas sociais de onde emergem. A partir das an?lises efetuadas, podemos perceber que a discrep?ncia, entre a produ??o e a recep??o dos sentidos das charges pol?micas selecionadas, d?-se na medida em que h? valora??o diferente por parte dos interlocutores em rela??o ao projeto de dizer da charge. Outra considera??o ? que parece n?o haver um entendimento do que seja esse g?nero, o que inviabiliza realizar uma leitura cr?tica. Esperamos que, com as discuss?es em torno dos sentidos constru?dos nos discursos observados, seja poss?vel contribuir para reflex?es voltadas ao ensino de leitura e produ??o textual nas aulas de l?ngua portuguesa, considerando-se a import?ncia do estudo da linguagem em uso, materializada em diferentes g?neros discursivos.
| Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:IBICT/oai:tede2.pucrs.br:tede/2217 |
| Date | 16 January 2015 |
| Creators | Gon?alves, Tamiris Machado |
| Contributors | Fanti, Maria da Gl?ria Corr?a Di |
| Publisher | Pontif?cia Universidade Cat?lica do Rio Grande do Sul, Programa de P?s-Gradua??o em Letras, PUCRS, BR, Faculdade de Letras |
| Source Sets | IBICT Brazilian ETDs |
| Language | Portuguese |
| Detected Language | English |
| Type | info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion, info:eu-repo/semantics/masterThesis |
| Format | application/pdf |
| Source | reponame:Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da PUC_RS, instname:Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio Grande do Sul, instacron:PUC_RS |
| Rights | info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess |
| Relation | 8447345070736321569, 500, 600, -2856882280194242995 |
Page generated in 0.0031 seconds