Submitted by PPG Hist?ria (historia-pg@pucrs.br) on 2018-05-24T16:24:53Z
No. of bitstreams: 1
Uma hist?ria visual impresso para entrega.pdf: 7032655 bytes, checksum: ebe88cc273ab1eee029aabd48596793a (MD5) / Approved for entry into archive by Sheila Dias (sheila.dias@pucrs.br) on 2018-06-04T12:59:30Z (GMT) No. of bitstreams: 1
Uma hist?ria visual impresso para entrega.pdf: 7032655 bytes, checksum: ebe88cc273ab1eee029aabd48596793a (MD5) / Made available in DSpace on 2018-06-04T13:12:25Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1
Uma hist?ria visual impresso para entrega.pdf: 7032655 bytes, checksum: ebe88cc273ab1eee029aabd48596793a (MD5)
Previous issue date: 2018-03-28 / Conselho Nacional de Pesquisa e Desenvolvimento Cient?fico e Tecnol?gico - CNPq / This research aimed to understand the construction of the visual memory of the event of the struggle for land that took place in Pra?a da Matriz, in the city of Porto Alegre, on August 8, 1990. To do so, we sought to build series based on the analysis and interpretation of how the event was constructed, given to see and conveyed by the major regional and national commercial press. In dialogue, a series of eighty-six photographs from different institutional and private collections, entitled SINDJORS series, were analyzed. The dissertation was structured in five chapters. The first chapter is configured in the introduction, where the theoretical basis of the dissertation is presented, based on the concepts of journalistic field (Bourdieu), visuals (Menezes), public photography (Mauad), memory (Candau) and survival (Didi-Huberman). In the second chapter, an immersion was carried out in the context of the construction of the photograph produced in Brazil between the 1960s and 1990s. Emphasis was placed on the professional career of photographers, whose production of images is linked to the land issue. This route was traced to the photographers of the SINDJORS series. Then, aspects of the historical course of the rural social movements in Rio Grande do Sul (Harres), (Eckert) were presented. It was analyzed how the construction of the photographic practices (Mauad) of these professionals, dedicated to the production of images on the question of land, is related, in some aspects, to the very construction of the struggle for land. In chapters three and four, considering the pressures of the market (economic capital) and political on the field of journalism, we identified some strategies adopted by the commercial communication vehicles to report the event, which can be summarized in these points: criminalize the MST act; disqualify the political action, directing the agenda for the death of the soldier Valdeci de Abreu and decontextualizing the history of the struggle for land; and construct the narratives from the idea of ?conflict?. Finally, it was observed that the idea of "confrontation" was present in the relationship between the photographs and the text published in the periodicals. The photographs published in the newspapers analyzed complain of a report of denunciation of police violence, in opposition to the text that tends to value the action of the military police. In chapter five, the series of images of SINDJORS was analyzed, identifying their patterns and survivals, as well as the editions of the labor union newspapers (SINJORS and Sindibanc?rios) and of the newspaper Sem Terra (MST). It was found that the discursive elaboration of the newspaper "Sem Terra? has similarities with the versions reported by the Jornal do SINDJORS and O Banc?rio. However, in "Sem Terra", there is an accentuation on the concern to insert the event of Pra?a da Matriz in the prism of the historical course of the struggle for land in Brazil, highlighting the violent scenario led by the governments to deal with the land issue. It can be said that the construction of the visual memories of the event are shaped by the dispute between the versions of the journalistic text, condensed in repetition and reproduction, and the visualities of photographs, based on the tension between resistance and repression, and in the survivals of images of other temporalities. / Esta pesquisa teve como objetivo compreender a constru??o da mem?ria visual do acontecimento da luta pela terra ocorrido na Pra?a da Matriz, na cidade de Porto Alegre, no dia oito de agosto de 1990. Para tal, buscou-se construir s?ries a partir da an?lise e interpreta??o de como o acontecimento foi constru?do, dado a ver e veiculado pela grande imprensa comercial regional e nacional. Em di?logo, analisou-se uma s?rie de oitenta e seis fotografias provenientes de diferentes acervos institucionais e privados, intitulada neste trabalho de s?rie do SINDJORS. A disserta??o foi estruturada em cinco cap?tulos. O primeiro cap?tulo configura-se na introdu??o, onde se apresenta a base te?rica da disserta??o, pautada pelos conceitos de campo jornal?stico (Bourdieu), visualidades (Maneses), fotografia p?blica (Mauad), mem?ria (Candau) e sobreviv?ncia (Didi-Huberman). No segundo cap?tulo, realizou-se uma imers?o no contexto de constru??o da fotografia produzida no Brasil entre as d?cadas de 1960 e 1990. Destacaram-se aspectos do percurso profissional de fot?grafos cuja produ??o de imagens se vincula ? quest?o da terra. Tra?ou-se esse percurso para os fot?grafos e fot?grafas da s?rie do SINDJORS. Em seguida, apresentaram-se aspectos do percurso hist?rico dos movimentos sociais rurais no Rio Grande do Sul (Harres), (Eckert). Analisou-se como a constru??o das pr?ticas fotogr?ficas (Mauad) desses profissionais, dedicados a produ??o de imagens sobre a quest?o da terra, relaciona-se, em alguns aspectos, com a pr?pria constru??o da luta pela terra. Nos cap?tulos tr?s e quatro, atentando-se para as press?es do mercado (capital econ?mico) e pol?tico sobre o campo jornal?stico, identificaram-se algumas estrat?gias adotadas pelos ve?culos de comunica??o comercial para noticiar o acontecimento, que podem ser resumidas nestes pontos: criminalizar o ato do MST; desqualificar a a??o pol?tica, direcionando a pauta para a morte do soldado Valdeci de Abreu, descontextualizando a hist?ria da luta pela terra; e produzir as narrativas a partir da ideia de ?confronto?. Por fim, observou-se que a ideia de ?confronto? se fez presente na rela??o entre as fotografias e os textos publicados nos peri?dicos. As fotografias publicadas nos jornais analisados reclamam uma mem?ria de den?ncia da viol?ncia policial, contrapondo-se ao texto, que tende a valorizar a a??o dos policiais militares. No cap?tulo cinco, analisou-se a s?rie de imagens do SINDJORS, identificando seus padr?es e sobreviv?ncias, bem como as edi??es dos jornais sindicais (SINJORS e Sindibanc?rios) e do jornal ?Sem Terra? (MST). Constatou-se que a elabora??o discursiva do jornal ?Sem Terra? apresenta semelhan?as com as vers?es noticiadas pelo Jornal do SINDJORS e O Banc?rio. Por?m, em ?Sem Terra?, percebeu-se uma acentua??o maior na preocupa??o em inserir o acontecimento da Pra?a da Matriz sob o prisma do percurso hist?rico da luta pela terra no Brasil, destacando o cen?rio violento capitaneado pelos governos em rela??o ? quest?o da terra. Pode-se dizer que a constru??o das mem?rias visuais do acontecimento molda-se na disputa entre as vers?es do texto jornal?stico, condensadas na repeti??o e reprodu??o, e as visualidades das fotografias, calcadas na tens?o entre resist?ncia e repress?o e nas sobreviv?ncias de imagens de outras temporalidades.
| Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:IBICT/oai:tede2.pucrs.br:tede/8097 |
| Date | 28 March 2018 |
| Creators | Formolo, Deise |
| Contributors | Monteiro, Charles |
| Publisher | Pontif?cia Universidade Cat?lica do Rio Grande do Sul, Programa de P?s-Gradua??o em Hist?ria, PUCRS, Brasil, Escola de Humanidades |
| Source Sets | IBICT Brazilian ETDs |
| Language | Portuguese |
| Detected Language | English |
| Type | info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion, info:eu-repo/semantics/masterThesis |
| Format | application/pdf |
| Source | reponame:Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da PUC_RS, instname:Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio Grande do Sul, instacron:PUC_RS |
| Rights | info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess |
| Relation | 1740700517806534787, 500, 500, 500, 600, -6557531471218110192, -3840921936332040591, -2555911436985713659 |
Page generated in 0.0215 seconds