Return to search

甘願,不甘願?論非典型雇用新聞工作者的勞動 / Manufacturing Consent or Not? The Labor of Atypical Employed Journalists

本研究從勞動觀點出發,檢視台灣媒體組織中的非典型雇用新聞工作者的勞動樣貌,並探討在非典型雇用型態下勞資雙方在生產過程中的互動與關係轉變。非典型雇用新聞工作者則既是受雇於資方的勞工,同時也可視作個人企業。做為勞工,非典型新聞工作者的各項勞動條件幾乎都不如正職工作者;做為個人企業,非典型新聞工作者需獨自面對外在環境變動的風險。正向來看非典型雇用是對於僵化體制的抵抗與反動,脫離組織換取自主性與自由,甚至帶來權力翻轉改變;反向思考則以社會學家Buroway「製造甘願」的概念為基礎,說明非典型新聞工作者對於資方過度剝削的順服,心甘情願參與資方所組織的趕工競賽,透過官僚、科技與價值觀的控制形塑出順服的意識型態。
研究結果依契約型態將新聞媒體產業中的非典型勞動力分為派遣/約聘新聞工作者、自由新聞工作者與獨立/公民記者三種類型,一般非典型雇用新聞工作者勞動條件都比一般正職工作者差,而三種型態的非典型勞動力的契約嚴謹程度會影響到勞動條件與自主性。不同的自主程度會影響到工作者的職業認同感與甘願的機制,派遣與約聘工作者的勞動過程中充滿不甘願的元素但受限於理想與現實卻被迫甘願;自由新聞工作者看似自由自主,但對工作延續性的焦慮也迫使他們落入競爭的遊戲中並自我限縮;獨立與公民記者以無償勞動換取絕對的自主權,然而要在眾多論述中取得框架的定義權,只能以自我剝削換取主流與個人媒體的轉引與跟進,勞動所產生的價值與實際付出不成比例。
本研究建議未來新聞產業界建立良好的新聞鑑價制度,並大力推行公民委製新聞平台,藉此提升台灣新聞產業勞動者的勞動條件與新聞產出品質。 / This research examined the labor of atypical employed journalists in the news industry in Taiwan, discussing the relationship changing between the capitalist and the labor during the production process. Atypical employed journalists are on the one hand the temporary workers who suffer the worse labor condition than permanent employees. On the other hand, they viewed themselves as self enterprise that faced external risks alone. Positive speaking, atypical employment was the resistance of traditional rigid discourse. For the sake of freedom and autonomy, workers leaved organizations and anticipated power reversal. Negatively, based on Buroway’s concept of “manufacturing consent,” this study illustrated how atypical employees submitted to the capitalist’s over-exploitation, willing to making out organized by the capital through the ideology formed by bureaucracy, technology and value control.
The results revealed that atypical employed journalists were separated into three kinds: dispatched/contract workers, freelancers and independent/citizen journalists. Generally speaking, those temporary workers’ the labor condition were worse that permanent employees and the type of contracts would affect their working condition and autonomy. Different degree of autonomy could therefore inference occupational identity and consent. Dispatched and contract workers were forced to make consent with the capitalists due to ideal and reality; freelancers seemed to enjoy the freedom and autonomy, but the anxiety to job sustainability forced them to join the competitive game and self-constraint; independent and citizen journalists’ free labor guaranteed the absolute autonomy, but they had to work hard and even self-exploit in order to take advantage of frame disputes in both main stream and personal media. The value conducted during the labor process and the effort they made were out of proportion.
This study suggested establishing complete news valuation system, and supporting community-funded reporting to upgrade the labor condition and report quality in the news industry in Taiwan.

Identiferoai:union.ndltd.org:CHENGCHI/G0099451016
Creators江慧珺, Chiang, Hui Chun
Publisher國立政治大學
Source SetsNational Chengchi University Libraries
Language中文
Detected LanguageEnglish
Typetext
RightsCopyright © nccu library on behalf of the copyright holders

Page generated in 0.002 seconds