Back to search

Michigan State University

A critical analysis of Habermas's qualified defense of strong judicial review

Abstract

dc:description

"The question of how best to resolve constitutional indeterminacy has recently returned to prominence in American political philosophy. Jurgen Habermas's contribution to this debate, which takes the form of a qualified defense of strong judicial review, is interesting, but it has not been the subject of much scholarly attention. In this dissertation I provide a recapitulation of Habermas's account, locating it within the context of both Habermas's ambitious communication theory of society and the ongoing American debate. This accomplished, I next subject Habermas's defense of strong judicial review to critical scrutiny. Through this process I demonstrate that Habermas's defense of strong judicial review does not sit comfortably with certain main premises of his social theory. Most importantly, I show that Habermas's attempt to legitimate strong judicial review runs afoul of his contention that members of rationalized societies should be expected, on reflection, to endorse a communicative criterion for analysis of the legitimacy of legal institutions. Because history teaches that there are alternative practically realizable forms of constitutional interpretation which come closer to realizing a situation in which communicatively processed public opinion influences constitutional interpretation, Habermas's qualified defense of strong judicial review must ultimately be understood as in significant tension with his overall social theory. I conclude my account by engaging in some speculation about both why Habermas might not have noticed this and what further lines of research are suggested by this analysis."--Page ii.

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Sprague-Rice, Aidan Michael
Contributors dc:contributor
  • Hedrick, Todd
  • Rauscher, Frederick
  • Lotz, Christian
  • Esquith, Stephen

Subjects

dc:subject × 5

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • In Copyright
Language dc:language
English

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
etd:48237
isbn:9781392839300
isbn:1392839300
oclc:1138556376
umi:27543382
local:SpragueRice_grad.msu_0128D_17213

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Michigan State University
Base URL
d.lib.msu.edu/oai
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Sprague-Rice, Aidan Michael. A critical analysis of Habermas's qualified defense of strong judicial review. 2019. https://doi.org/doi:10.25335/d2na-r163