Back to search

The Open University

Losing the Plot: Anti-Narrativism and Mental Health

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Self-narratives are widely accepted to be a good thing - philosophically, morally and for wellbeing. Narrating illness has become an expectation both socially and in many forms of therapy. However, this brings risks including ineffectuality, marginalisation, epistemic injustice and falsehood. In this thesis I highlight the risks of narrative-based approaches to mental wellbeing after first criticising their philosophical foundations. I then make the case for a non-narrative alternative in the form of Buddhist-inspired approaches. <br></br><br></br> Part One rejects what I call <i>philosophical narrativism</i>: the view that experiencing your life as a narrative is necessary for some good. I develop three versions and reject each. <i>Metaphysical narrativism</i> is the view that being narrative is necessary for personal identity. <i>Epistemological narrativism</i> is the view that being narrative is either necessary or advantageous for self-understanding, and <i>normative narrativism</i> is the view that being narrative is necessary for a particular moral good. <br></br><br></br> Part Two is a critique of narrative-based approaches to mental wellbeing. I argue that illness narratives can be an unnecessary burden, can perpetuate existing power relations and can lead to inauthenticity. I develop a new objection to Narrative Therapy called the <i>Falsehood Objection</i>. I argue that in addition to potentially creating false memories, Narrative Therapy can lead to false beliefs through <i>false implicated generalisations</i>, and that the co-creation of false beliefs is deceit, which is unethical. <br></br><br></br> Part Three offers a positive alternative. I outline key principles of Buddhism, Buddhist psychology, and two versions of Buddhist-inspired therapy. I argue that Buddhist-inspired approaches avoid the risks of narrative-based approaches. <br></br><br></br> By highlighting the risks of self-narratives in illness, both in a social and therapeutic setting, and offering an alternative, I hope this research will challenge the dominance of narrative-based approaches to mental wellbeing and contribute more broadly to a cultural shift against the idealisation of self-narratives.

Degree

thesis:*
Name dc:type.qualificationname
phd
Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
doctoral
Grantor dc:publisher.institution
The Open University
Year dc:date.issued
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Latham, Sally Anne

Rights

Language dc:language
en

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
The Open University
Base URL
oro.open.ac.uk/cgi/oai2
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Latham, Sally Anne. Losing the Plot: Anti-Narrativism and Mental Health. doctoral thesis, The Open University, 2025.