Back to search

The Open University

Butterflies in The City: Landscape Connectivity and Conservation of Urban Woodland Butterflies

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Butterflies are charismatic pollinators and bioindicators whose global declines herald wider biodiversity loss. Urbanisation, a principal driver of habitat fragmentation and degradation, poses an acute threat to butterfly populations. Yet urban woodlands, despite providing vital ecosystem services, including opportunities for people to connect with nature, remain poorly studied as butterfly habitat. This thesis offers the first comprehensive study of butterflies in urban woodlands by addressing four core questions: What habitat preferences and life history traits can define an urban butterfly? What habitat characteristics influence butterfly richness, abundance and diversity in urban woodlands? How does woodland habitat connectivity for butterflies compare between different urban areas? And how are individual urban butterfly species distributed across the Milton Keynes habitat network? Chapter 1 introduces the thesis, and discusses the impact of urbanisation on biodiversity, discussions of habitat loss, fragmentation, and general concepts in landscape ecology that apply to the impact of urbanisation on the British countryside. It also describes the importance of butterflies, urban woodlands and the rationale for studying both, closing with research questions to be investigated by the proceeding chapters. Chapter 2 defines “urban‑tolerant” British butterfly species using life‑history and habitat‑association traits across all resident species. Through generalised linear modelling, it identifies a suite of urban‑tolerant species characterised by multiple broods per year, reliance on woodland‑grassland ecotones, and avoidance of egg‑laying on short turf or herbaceous plants. These findings reveal the ecological filters shaping urban butterfly assemblages. Chapter 3 examines how woodland structure influences butterfly richness and diversity. Sampling across a gradient of patch sizes and woodlands with variation in canopy structural complexity shows that larger woodlands with diverse maximum canopy heights host the richest and most varied communities of butterflies. The results underscore the need for management practices that promote structural heterogeneity, such as maintaining rides and glades, opening up the canopy through coppicing while maintaining some dense vegetation to conserve urban woodland butterflies. Chapter 4 explores landscape‑scale connectivity in eleven UK cities using Expected Cluster Size (ECS) metrics. These cities show a range of connectivity patterns from Milton Keynes, which emerges as exceptionally well connected via numerous small patches, to Plymouth which achieves comparable ECS through fewer, larger patches and Kingston-Upon-Hull which is very poorly connected. This contrast raises questions about optimal patch configuration for butterfly movement and gene flow in urban networks. Chapter 5 implements occupancy modelling for butterflies in Milton Keynes using 29 sites supplemented by citizen‑science data from The Parks Trust. The study demonstrates the high survey effort required for robust models and highlights some potential challenges, such as identification—particularly among the “white” butterflies (Large White, Small White, Green‑veined White), which exhibit overlapping detections. Despite these hurdles, occupancy estimates reveal key patterns in species distribution and density across woodland patches. The principal finding of this chapter is that the extent of a truly powerful occupancy model requires more survey effort than one team could likely provide (90 sites visited 5 times) and therefore suggests a multi-city approach. By integrating species‑trait analysis, habitat‑structure assessment, connectivity evaluation, and occupancy modelling, this thesis delivers a broad understanding of urban woodland butterflies. Its findings provide actionable guidance for urban ecology and conservation practitioners—advocating trait‑informed species protection, urban woodland management, with an analysis of landscape scale connectivity in urban areas. Finally, it emphasises the pressing need for empirical movement studies to more directly measure how butterflies navigate complex urban environments.

Degree

thesis:*
Name dc:type.qualificationname
phd
Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
doctoral
Grantor dc:publisher.institution
The Open University
Year dc:date.issued
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Neal, Willow

Rights

Language dc:language
en

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
The Open University
Base URL
oro.open.ac.uk/cgi/oai2
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Neal, Willow. Butterflies in The City: Landscape Connectivity and Conservation of Urban Woodland Butterflies. doctoral thesis, The Open University, 2026.