The Open University
Perceived Trustworthiness in Green Advertising: An Integrative Source Credibility–Elaboration Likelihood Model of Spokesperson Effects
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis thesis develops an integrated theoretical account of how credibility is formed in green advertising by bringing together the Source Credibility Model (SCM) and the Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM). While SCM identifies trustworthiness as a core determinant of persuasion, the model offers limited explanation of when and why perceived trustworthiness becomes influential, or how its antecedents vary across audiences and contexts. Conversely, ELM explains how differing levels of elaboration shape message processing, yet it has rarely been used to explain credibility formation itself. This thesis addresses these gaps by demonstrating that perceived trustworthiness is not a stable source attribute but an evaluative judgement constructed under specific elaboration conditions. In doing so, it extends SCM with an ELM-based account of the cognitive, behavioural, and moral pathways through which credibility emerges. A sequential explanatory mixed-methods design was employed. Four quantitative experiments (n = 320) examined how non-celebrity spokespersons, namely environmental experts and typical consumers, shape perceived trustworthiness and purchase intentions across varying levels of product involvement. Moderated moderated mediation analyses tested how green consumerism, environmental concern, and scepticism towards green advertising claims condition the formation of perceived trustworthiness. Semi-structured interviews (n = 11) provided interpretive depth, revealing the reasoning processes through which consumers construct credibility. Across all experiments, spokesperson type did not exert a direct effect on purchase intentions. Instead, perceived trustworthiness consistently mediated that relationship, confirming its role as the central mechanism of persuasion. Crucially, the antecedents of perceived trustworthiness varied systematically with elaboration conditions: behavioural engagement (green consumerism) shaped credibility under low involvement contexts, whereas attitudinal involvement (environmental concern) became more influential under high involvement conditions. Scepticism towards green advertising claims operated as a boundary condition by attenuating behaviour-based credibility effects, while leaving trust judgements grounded in environmental concern largely unaffected. The qualitative findings reinforced these patterns, showing that consumers evaluate spokespersons through perceived sincerity, independence, and moral integrity rather than formal role categories. The thesis therefore advances SCM by specifying how trustworthiness operates and under which elaboration conditions it is formed, and extends ELM by demonstrating that elaboration shapes not only message processing but the construction of source credibility itself. This integrated model offers a more comprehensive understanding of how persuasion in green advertising occurs and identifies the boundary conditions under which spokespersons can influence consumer judgement.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- phd
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- The Open University
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Fawaz, Issam
Rights
- Language dc:language
- en