The Open University
How is Accountability Understood, Practised, and Performed by Professional Trustees, Investment Consultants, and Other Relevant Actors: A Multi-Sited Ethnography of Socially Responsible Investing by UK Occupational Pension Schemes
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis qualitative study examines accountability within the context of socially responsible investing (‘SRI’) by private-sector UK occupational pension schemes (‘OPSs’). Although pension funds are among the largest and most influential institutional investors globally and are increasingly expected to address systemic challenges such as climate change through responsible investment practices, the accountability of those who manage and invest pension assets remains poorly understood.<br></br><br></br> The study addresses two research questions: (1) how is accountability understood by the relevant institutional and individual actors involved in SRI by UK OPSs; and, (2) how is accountability practised by these actors? In the UK context, decision-making power over OPS assets is concentrated among a relatively small group of actors, most notably professional trustees (‘PTs’) and intermediaries such as investment consultants (‘ICs’) and asset managers (‘AMs’), who operate largely outside of the public’s gaze. Despite their growing influence, these actors have attracted limited empirical scrutiny. This study therefore examines accountability within OPSs by bringing visibility to these typically inaccessible actors and settings.<br></br><br></br> The research is theoretically grounded in the accountability literature and draws on insights from three interrelated bodies of work: SRI literature, which situates OPSs within broader debates about socially responsible investment and climate change; pensions literature, which contextualises the UK institutional environment and investment chain; and accountability literature, which provides the conceptual tools to analyse how accountability is understood, practised, and performed. The study adopts Rached’s (2016) framework of accountability as its primary theoretical lens. Methodologically, the study employs a qualitative, multi-sited ethnographic research design, informed by Burawoy’s extended case method (‘ECM’) (1998; 2009). Empirical data were collected through participant observations of 79 professional industry events between June 2022 and December 2023, alongside 30 semi-structured interviews conducted between March and September 2023 with PTs, ICs, and other actors involved in SRI by OPSs. Data were analysed using an abductive approach and reflexive thematic analysis (Braun and Clarke, 2006; 2022). <br></br><br></br> The findings show that accountability is understood as a relational and context-dependent concept rather than a fixed or uniform one. Actors’ understandings of accountability vary depending on whom they perceive themselves to be accountable to and whether they are positioned as accountors or accountees. PTs associate accountability with the possibility of negative consequences when oriented upwards to The Pensions Regulator, while accountability towards intermediaries is understood in terms of scrutiny without consequences, reflecting more horizontal relationships. In practice, PTs are embedded in multiple accountability relationships oriented in different directions. Accountability to OPS members is weak, indirect, and largely symbolic, while accountability within PT firms is predominantly horizontal and professional in nature. The accountability relationships between SEs and PTs were positioned horizontally and characterised by mutual dependence and tensions. Regulatory requirements have contributed to the mainstreaming of SRI but have also incentivised compliance-focused, upward accountability, particularly through mechanisms such as Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures reports. Participant observations further reveal that industry events function as closed accountability arenas in which accountability is performed through peer-facing, self-regulatory practices, supported by staged presentations and visual props that produce the appearance, rather than the substance, of accountability.<br></br><br></br> The study makes several contributions. Empirically, it demonstrates how imbalances in accountability relationships manifest in practice when actors are subject to multiple and competing demands. Conceptually, it introduces the “problem of few hands,” highlighting how the concentration of decision-making authority among professional actors can obscure accountability. The study also extends Rached’s (2016) framework by introducing ‘directness’ as an additional dimension of accountability, capturing the extent to which accountability is discharged directly or through intermediaries. Finally, the research contributes methodologically through its application and adaptation of the ECM to the study of accountability in financial governance.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- phd
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- The Open University
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Mccarthy, Nargis
Rights
- Language dc:language
- en