The Open University
Practice constellations in the knowledge for-policy landscape – exploring ‘systematic’ and ‘systemic’ modes of practice
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis thesis examines how evidencing practices are enacted within knowledge-for-policy settings. These practices are expected to provide reliability, credibility and accountability for policy, whilst also responding to policy situations characterised by complexity, uncertainty and interdependence. The research asks how systematic evidencing practices and more systemic forms of inquiry coexist in everyday work at the science-policy interface, what constrains them, and under what conditions more systemic forms of practice become possible.<br></br><br></br> Adopting a Systems Thinking in Practice perspective, the research is based on three situated inquiries undertaken between 2021 and 2024 within related practice constellations in the European knowledge-for-policy landscape: Eurofound, the EU Agencies Network for Scientific Advice (EU-ANSA), and the evaluation practitioner community. Conducted from a practitioner-scholar position, the inquiry is grounded in a second-order tradition of systemic inquiry and informed by the Practitioner–Framework–Methodology–Situation heuristic. The research design combines narrative practitioner interviews, participatory workshops, documentary analysis and sustained reflexive practice.<br></br><br></br> The findings show that evidencing practices across the three constellations are organised through the interplay of stabilising, mediating and opening dynamics. Stabilising dynamics reproduce forms of evidencing already recognised as credible, legitimate and defensible within institutional decision environments. Mediating dynamics create limited situated room for manoeuvre through boundary negotiation, translation and accommodation. Opening dynamics create only fragile possibilities for more systemic forms of inquiry, and these remain episodic unless supported through institutional arrangements for reflection, learning and feedback.<br></br><br></br> The thesis contributes an empirically grounded account of practice constellations as an analytic lens for understanding evidencing across organisational, networked and professional settings in the European knowledge-for-policy landscape. It argues that reconciliation between systematic and systemic inquiry is achieved not through methodological choice alone, but through the institutional and relational arrangements within which evidencing is organised. More systemic forms of evidencing are possible, but only where their emergence, legitimacy and persistence are deliberately cultivated.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- phd
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- The Open University
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Schmidt-Abbey, Barbara
Rights
- Language dc:language
- en