The Open University
Carbonates in Carbonaceous Chondrites: Tools for exploring the geology of hydrated asteroids
Abstract
dc:description.abstractCarbonaceous chondrites are primitive meteorites from the outer Solar System. Due to their position beyond the snowline they accreted water-ice and subsequently experienced aqueous alteration. There are three carbonaceous chondrite groups that typically exhibit at least some aqueous alteration; the CMs, CRs and CIs, which have all been extensively studied. There are, however, some meteorites that do not match these groups (ungrouped carbonaceous chondrites), the study of which allows us to investigate the wider geological diversity in the outer Solar System. In this work, the aqueous alteration sequence has been studied through the analysis of carbonate minerals. Carbonates precipitate throughout alteration from the early to final stages and through the combined petrographic and isotopic analysis can be used to track how the conditions changed as alteration evolved. <br></br><br></br> There are four C2-ungrouped meteorites that are recorded falls that have been studied, these are Essebi, Bells, Tarda and Tagish Lake. Each sample was analysed first on the SEM (Tescan Clara) for both petrographic and geochemical analysis. After this, oxygen and carbon isotope compositions were collected from individual carbonate grains using the NanoSIMS 50L also at the Open University. In addition, various bulk analysis techniques were used to provide contextual data, such as evaluating the bulk volatile content and extent of aqueous alteration. <br></br><br></br> Analysis of Essebi revealed a multigenerational sequence of carbonates with varying petrographic and isotopic features. Broadly, these match observations in CM chondrites where two main generations of carbonates (T1 and T2) are found with their own distinct features. Although both Essebi and the CMs have muti-generational carbonate sequences Essebi’s carbonates do not match the petrographic features of CM carbonates. For example, T1 calcite in CMs have tochilinite-cronstedtite intergrowths (TCI) rims, a feature not found in the equivalent early-generation carbonates in Essebi (referred to as GA carbonates). Nor does Essebi contain (in later generations) the Fe-Ni sulphide inclusions found in T2a calcites in CMs. In addition, within Essebi multiple later generations of carbonates indicated that brecciation and aqueous alteration were overlapping events (with some examples of carbonates forming around the edge of the clasts). Again this is distinct from CM chondrites, where alteration predates brecciation. The first generation of carbonates in Essebi (GA) are anhedral calcites with porous texture that have <sup>16</sup>O-poor compositions (δ<sup>18</sup>O = +32.3 to +39.9 ‰, δ<sup>17</sup>O = +17 to +22.8 ‰ and Δ<sup>17</sup>O =+0.2 to +3.4 ‰). The next generation (GB) are also calcite but with higher levels of Mg, Fe and Mn. These calcites have sub-euhedral morphologies and have more <sup>16</sup>O-rich compositions (δ<sup>18</sup>O = 13.9 to +27.7 ‰, δ<sup>17</sup>O = +5.7 to +15.9 and Δ<sup>17</sup>O = -1.5 to +3.3). In addition to these main two generations, minor carbonate expressions can occur as calcites in veins (GC carbonates), dolomites within a clast (GD) and calcite in the main lithology and located around the edge of a clast (GE). Analysis of carbon isotopes revealed systematic variation in δ<sup>13</sup>C across these different carbonate generations, indicating a mixing of carbon sources as alteration progresses. <br></br><br></br> The Bells meteorite revealed a single generation of carbonates (calcite) that showed no clear petrographic trend. The oxygen isotopic compositions of these grains varied from δ<sup>18</sup>O = +20.7 to +40.3 ‰, δ<sup>17</sup>O = +6.9 to +23.4‰ and Δ<sup>17</sup>O = -4.1 to +2.4 and produced a slope of 0.75. This is a mass-independent slope indicating that isotopic evolution during aqueous alteration of Bells was primarily driven by the mixing between rock and water reservoirs rather than by temperature-induced mass-dependent fractionation. In recent studies analysis of olivine in chondrules in Bells demonstrated a link to CR chondrites, with some proposals for a new classification as a CR anomalous member (CR-an). The single calcite generation and the mass-independent slope line of 0.75 are key characteristics that match carbonate populations in CR chondrites, suggesting a CR-an origin for Bells. In previous studies Bells and Essebi have been linked together due to similar magnetite abundance and phyllosilicate content, however this project confirms two distinct alteration histories and, therefore implies distinct parent bodies. <br></br><br></br> This project also studied Tarda and Tagish Lake. Despite being closely linked this work demonstrates they also have distinct alteration histories. Tarda is more intensely altered than Tagish Lake and contains only dolomite. Their oxygen isotope compositions range from δ<sup>18</sup>O = +23.7 to +40.1 ‰, δ<sup>17</sup>O = +12.2 to +22.9 ‰ and Δ<sup>17</sup>O = -1.3 to +3.2 ‰. Conversely, Tagish Lake contains both calcite and dolomite with distinct isotopic compositions. Calcite compositions ranging from δ<sup>18</sup>O = +25.1 to +32.8 ‰, δ<sup>17</sup>O = +11.5 to +19.6 ‰ and Δ<sup>17</sup>O = 4.2 to + 4.1 ‰ and dolomite ranging from δ<sup>18</sup>O = +14.7 to +22.0 ‰, δ<sup>17</sup>O = +5.5 to +11.5 ‰ and Δ<sup>17</sup>O = -3.9 to +2.3 ‰. Carbonates in both Tarda and Tagish Lake had variable size, morphology and texture. <br></br><br></br> Thus, all four meteorites have different parent body origins and display distinct alteration histories illustrating the wide geological diversity in the early Solar System. <br></br><br></br> Carbon isotopic analysis of different calcite generations within Essebi revealed a progressive decrease in δ<sup>13</sup>C as alteration evolved. This implies a mix of carbon source availability during alteration. In dolomite grains in Essebi, Tarda and Tagish Lake, a large range in intragrain variation values were found with no correlation to grain size indicating highly variable mixing rates of carbon reservoirs and heterogeneous distribution of carbon.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- phd
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- The Open University
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Riches, Liza
Rights
- Language dc:language
- en