Back to search

The Open University

Values and valuing in urban road engineering practices: a case study of the "unfinished" Foreshore Freeway, Cape Town

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

How do roads get to be the way they are? More specifically, how do practices of valuing in urban transport planning and road engineering ‘work’ in the shaping of roads? These research questions, motivated by concerns about the role of road transport in environmental sustainability, and debates on resource constraints and human rights, guide this thesis, which uses the case of an ‘unfinished’ freeway in Cape Town, South Africa, as its empirical entry point. Science and Technology Studies (STS), and specifically frameworks which consider values, are used to scrutinise the urban road engineering practices which shaped the Freeway’s eventual form. Interviews, written and graphic archival materials are used to inform the piece. Empirically, the thesis adds to a small body of work considering urban road engineering practices, and the role of valuing within that, from an STS perspective. Drawing particularly on Kuhn’s work on ‘paradigms’ and Bijker’s work on ‘technological frames’, and responses to these, the focus is on valuing over the time of design and construction of the freeway (1930s to 1970s). It is argued that the conventional concept of values as largely stable, held by human actors and exogenous to technical processes is overly simplistic. In the case, valuing processes are shown circulating explicitly; implicitly (the focus is on the professional activities and education); and elusively (through myths and metaphors; experiences and emotion; images and imaginaries). Ways of trusting, particularly in numbers, and ‘escalations in objectivity’ are argued as particularly important to valuing processes in the case. Valuing is thus defined as: “processes of prioritising which may be embedded in materials and technologies; embodied in individuals or social arrangements; or circulating in practices”. Finally, the thesis argues that naming the Foreshore Freeway as ‘unfinished’ tells a story of an elusive desire for speed which resonates to this day. The suggestion is made that the Foreshore Freeway can be reframed, to reflect other ways of valuing.

Degree

thesis:*
Name dc:type.qualificationname
phd
Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
doctoral
Grantor dc:publisher.institution
The Open University
Year dc:date.issued
2015

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Kane, Lisa Adele

Rights

Language dc:language
en

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
The Open University
Base URL
oro.open.ac.uk/cgi/oai2
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Kane, Lisa Adele. Values and valuing in urban road engineering practices: a case study of the "unfinished" Foreshore Freeway, Cape Town. doctoral thesis, The Open University, 2015.