Context: The study of expertise in medical education has tended to follow the traditions of describing either the analytic processes or the non-analytic resources that experts acquire with experience. We argue that a critical function of expertise is the ability to transition from the automatic mode to the more effortful mode when required – a transition referred to as ‘slowing down when you should’. Objectives: To explore the phenomenon of ‘slowing down when you should’ in operative surgical practice and its role in intra-operative surgical judgment, and to develop conceptual models of the factors involved in the display of this transition in surgical operative practice. Design: In Phase 1A, 28 surgeons were interviewed about their views of surgical judgment in general and their perceptions of the role of this phenomenon in operative judgment. In Phase 1B, a subset of surgeons from Phase 1A was re-interviewed to explore their perceptions of automaticity in operative practice. In Phase 2, observational sessions (and brief interviews) were conducted of surgeons in the operating room to explore the nature of this phenomenon in its natural environment. Results: The surgeons in this study recognized the phenomenon of ‘slowing down’ in their operative practice and acknowledged its link to surgical judgment. Two main initiators were described and observed: proactively planned ‘slowing down’ moments occurring intra-operatively initiated by critical events anticipated pre-operatively and situationally responsive ‘slowing down’ moments initiated by emergent cues intra-operatively. Numerous influences of this transition were uncovered. A control dynamic emerged as surgeon’s negotiated ‘slowing down’ moments through trainees in their supervisory academic practice. Numerous manifestations of this phenomenon were observed in the operating room and considered using a cognitive psychology attention capacity model. Conclusions: This study offers a conceptual framework for understanding the role of ‘slowing down when you should’ in operative surgical practice, providing a vocabulary that will allow more explicit consideration of what contributes to surgical expertise. Consideration of this framework with its consequent ability to make surgical practices more explicit has implications for self-regulation in practice, surgical error, and surgical training.

Activated coagulation Factor XII (FXIIa) elevates blood pressure (BP) acutely by stimulating adrenomedullary catecholamine (CA) release in Brown Norway (BN) bioassay rats. These effects are absent in kininogen-deficient BN Katholiek (BNK) bioassay rats, indicating that these FXIIa-induced responses require an intact kallikrein-kinin system (KKS). In three hypertensive anephric pediatric patients, ΔFXIIa concentrations tracked peri-dialytic ΔBP. We hypothesized that FXIIa exerts a vasoconstrictor pro-hypertensive action, via the KKS, particularly evident in chronic renal failure (CRF). In CRF patients (n=11) receiving conventional hemodialysis, mean plasma FXIIa concentrations were 3-fold (p<0.05) greater than in healthy controls. Although conversion from conventional to nocturnal hemodialysis did not change mean FXIIa concentrations there was intra-session variation within individuals, such that ΔFXIIa concentrations correlated with changes in mean arterial pressure (MAP, r=0.66, p=0.026) and total peripheral resistance (TPR, r=0.75, p=0.007). In normotensive BN rats, FXIIa infusion (85 ng/min/kg for 60 mins) increased MAP (10±1 mmHg), TPR (0.5±0.1 Units), and CA, whilst left-ventricular end-diastolic volume (LVEDV) and heart rate decreased (all p<0.05). After adrenalectomy, FXIIa infusion decreased MAP (5±1 mmHg), did not raise CA or induce sustained vasoconstriction, and caused a greater fall in LVEDV (all p<0.05). In the 5/6 nephrectomized (NX) rodent CRF model, MAP and TPR were significantly greater in BN NX (n=16) than in BNK NX (n=15) (147±4 vs. 133±2 mmHg, 2.8±0.2 vs. 2.3±0.2 Units; all p<0.05). Plasma FXIIa measured using our semi-quantitive ELISA was 3-fold higher in both BN NX and BNK NX than in controls (p<0.01), but only correlated with MAP (r=0.48, p=0.01) in the BN NX. Plasma CA were elevated in the BN NX (p<0.05) but not in BNK NX. Infusion of a specific FXIIa inhibitor into BN NX decreased MAP (-12 mmHg) and TPR (-0.5 Units) proportionally to baseline FXIIa (ΔMAP: r=-0.72, p=0.002; ΔTPR: r=-0.57, p=0.021), and plasma CA fell by 40-67% (all p<0.05). No such changes occurred in the BNK NX. In summary, a significant component of the hypertension of CRF can be attributed to FXIIa-induced vasoconstriction mediated via the KKS and stimulated CA release. In normal rats, FXIIa appears also to directly or indirectly decrease preload and heart rate.

Chronic kidney disease (CKD) and its cardiac complications represent a large and growing problem in Canada. The progression of CKD is driven by the activation of several final common pathways of injury, including fibrosis and oxidative stress. If left unchecked, these inter-connected processes lead to progressive damage and subsequent organ dysfunction. Current clinical therapies, consisting of aggressive blood pressure control and blockade of the renin-angiotensin system, fail to arrest this progressive injury in a significant number of patients. Early outgrowth cells (EOCs) represent a novel bone marrow-derived cell population that have been recently described to have tissue protective activity. In this work, we examined the effects of intravascular EOC infusion in two independent models of CKD, demonstrating potent anti-fibrotic renoprotective effects in the subtotally nephrectomized (SNX) rat, a well-established model of non-diabetic progressive CKD, and anti-fibrotic and anti-oxidant effects in the db/db mouse, a commonly used model of type 2 diabetic nephropathy. In the SNX rat, which is characterized by impaired cardiac relaxation reminiscent of a common and high risk clinical CKD phenotype, EOC infusion was also associated with improved cardiac structure and function. In both cases, infused EOCs were not retained in significant numbers within the diseased kidney or heart, but rather localized to distant organs such as the liver, spleen, and bone marrow. We further demonstrated that EOCs release soluble factors with anti-oxidant and anti-fibrotic activity in vitro, and that a cell-free preparation of EOC-derived factors can mimic the reno- and cardiac protective effects of the cells themselves when infused into the SNX rat. Taken together, our results demonstrate the therapeutic potential of an EOC-based strategy for the treatment of CKD and its cardiac complications, and provide the preclinical rationale for the design of clinical trials of EOC-based therapies for this devastating disease.

The purpose of this ministry project is to educate religious leaders about an alternative to approaching organ donation and organ transplantation, using the Theory of Gift Exchange as the model paradigm. This ministry project is based on the premise that religious leaders generally use dated statistical material, life changing stories, and personal experiences to raise awareness on the subject. Thus, the Theory of Gift Exchange is a different approach and a unique model for religious leaders to begin understanding the complex nature of organ donation and organ transplantation, and ultimately embracing it with less reluctance. The results of this ministry project discovered that practically every religious leader was unfamiliar with the idea of Gift Exchange. However, they were familiar with this concept only as it relates to the exchanging of personal gifts around special occasions and holidays. Thus, the conclusion gathered from this ministry project suggests that the 'Theory of Gift Exchange' is an excellent model to educate about organ donation and organ transplantation. This conceptual idea makes it easy for a religious leader to understand and embrace the subject, and feel less threatened by it, particularly because one can see that the overall intent is about gift giving and gift receiving.

Changes in cerebrovascular reactivity (CVR) to carbon dioxide (CO2) are reported in many neurological conditions. My aim was to validate a method for computerized prospective targeting of CO2 levels (RespiractTM) as a bedside tool for impaired CVR. I hypothesized that 1) The RespiractTM and TCD method can be used to detect impairment of CVR after SAH and that 2) CVR is impaired in SAH patients. In 18 SAH patients and 26 controls CVR index was calculated dividing the percentage change in middle cerebral artery blood flow velocity (MCAv) by the change in PETCO2. The absolute MCAv values were similar in both groups, but CVR was significantly different (hypercapnia: 0.044 ± 0.076 - controls; 0.014 ± 0.037 - SAH; p=0.0007). I showed that impaired CVR can be detected at the bedside using TCD and CO2 challenge with the RespiractTM, control of CO2 is precise and minimal changes are required.

Changes in cerebrovascular reactivity (CVR) to carbon dioxide (CO2) are reported in many neurological conditions. My aim was to validate a method for computerized prospective targeting of CO2 levels (RespiractTM) as a bedside tool for impaired CVR. I hypothesized that 1) The RespiractTM and TCD method can be used to detect impairment of CVR after SAH and that 2) CVR is impaired in SAH patients. In 18 SAH patients and 26 controls CVR index was calculated dividing the percentage change in middle cerebral artery blood flow velocity (MCAv) by the change in PETCO2. The absolute MCAv values were similar in both groups, but CVR was significantly different (hypercapnia: 0.044 ± 0.076 - controls; 0.014 ± 0.037 - SAH; p=0.0007). I showed that impaired CVR can be detected at the bedside using TCD and CO2 challenge with the RespiractTM, control of CO2 is precise and minimal changes are required.

Laparoscopic bariatric procedures are complex minimally invasive operations with a potential for substantial morbidity and mortality along the early part of a surgeon’s learning curve. Simulation-enhanced training can improve a surgeon's technical and non-technical performance and lessen the learning curves in the operating room. Unfortunately, despite the convincing evidence supporting the use of simulation in surgical education, there is still a gap in translation of knowledge and technical skills from the research environment into clinically relevant training curricula. The objective of this thesis was to design and validate a comprehensive simulationenhanced training curriculum that addressed cognitive knowledge, technical and non-technical skill in laparoscopic bariatric surgery. This objective was achieved using three experimental studies. The first study employed a modified Delphi methodology and an international panel of experts in surgical and medical education to develop a consensus-based framework for design, validation and implementation of simulation-enahnced training curricula in surgery. The second study used a modified Delphi methodology and an international panel of experienced bariatric surgeons to develop an objective scale for assessment of operative skill in laparoscopic gastric bypass procedure. This scale was feasible to use and had high inter-rater and test-retest reliability, as well as evidence of construct and concurrent validity. The third study used the previously developed consensus-based framework to design a comprehensive simulation-enhanced training curriculum for laparoscopic bariatric surgery. A prospective, single-blinded randomized controlled trial was used to compare the effectiveness of this curriculum in comparison to conventional surgery training. Surgery residents who were trained in this curriculum demonstrated superior technical skills, superior non-technical skills and enhanced safety in the operating room.

Laparoscopic bariatric procedures are complex minimally invasive operations with a potential for substantial morbidity and mortality along the early part of a surgeon’s learning curve. Simulation-enhanced training can improve a surgeon's technical and non-technical performance and lessen the learning curves in the operating room. Unfortunately, despite the convincing evidence supporting the use of simulation in surgical education, there is still a gap in translation of knowledge and technical skills from the research environment into clinically relevant training curricula. The objective of this thesis was to design and validate a comprehensive simulationenhanced training curriculum that addressed cognitive knowledge, technical and non-technical skill in laparoscopic bariatric surgery. This objective was achieved using three experimental studies. The first study employed a modified Delphi methodology and an international panel of experts in surgical and medical education to develop a consensus-based framework for design, validation and implementation of simulation-enahnced training curricula in surgery. The second study used a modified Delphi methodology and an international panel of experienced bariatric surgeons to develop an objective scale for assessment of operative skill in laparoscopic gastric bypass procedure. This scale was feasible to use and had high inter-rater and test-retest reliability, as well as evidence of construct and concurrent validity. The third study used the previously developed consensus-based framework to design a comprehensive simulation-enhanced training curriculum for laparoscopic bariatric surgery. A prospective, single-blinded randomized controlled trial was used to compare the effectiveness of this curriculum in comparison to conventional surgery training. Surgery residents who were trained in this curriculum demonstrated superior technical skills, superior non-technical skills and enhanced safety in the operating room.

This thesis uses the methods of sychometrics and clinimetrics to develop and evaluate a Pediatric Ulcerative Colitis Activity Index (PUCAI). The initial phases of item generation and reduction were performed previously. This thesis comprises five main studies. Study one: the weighting and formatting of an initial draft PUCAI using a cohort of 157 children with ulcerative colitis, enrolled prospectively in five pediatric IBD centers. Study two: the validation of the final draft on a separate prospective cohort of 48 children undergoing complete colonoscopy. The PUCAI was highly correlated with physician global assessment (PGA) (r=0.91), Mayo score (r=0.95) and colonoscopic appearance (r=0.77). The PUCAI was able to differentiate the different categories of disease activity, and cutoff points were defined. Study three: Assessment of the responsiveness of the PUCAI. The index demonstrated excellent responsiveness on 75 children seen twice during the study period (effect size=1.9, standardized response mean=2.2, responsiveness statistics=2.6, correlation with PGA of change=0.84, and area under the ROC curve=0.97 95%CI 0.93- 0.99). Study four was aimed at evaluating the predictive validity of the PUCAI, on a retrospective cohort of 99 children with severe ulcerative colitis admitted for intravenous corticosteroid therapy. The PUCAI, calculated on the third and fifth day of therapy was highly predictive of therapy failure at discharge and one year post discharge (area under the ROC curve 0.84 (95%CI 0.76-0.92). Study five: a methodological study evaluating the preferred way to determine the minimal clinically important difference (MCID) of health-related outcome measures. This study was conducted using the PUCAI and three other well established instruments. It was concluded that the MCID should be determined primarily by the anchor-based approach using the ROC curve method on the entire cohort, supplemented by calculating the minimal detectable difference beyond statistical error using the standard error of measurement. Small, moderate and large MCID values could be presented based on the degree of expected relevant change. Together, these studies have contributed to the rigorous development and thorough evaluation of a novel, non-invasive tool for assessing disease activity in pediatric ulcerative colitis clinical studies and practice.

The past two decades have witnessed an accelerated effort to understand the nature of schizophrenia and related psychotic disorders, but no causative gene(s) has been discovered yet. Family, twin, and adoption studies indicate that genetic factors are clearly implicated in the etiology of these disorders (Cardno and Gottesman, 2000; Cardno et al., 2002; McGuffin et al., 2003; Weinberger, 2005). Several aspects of 22q11 Deletion Syndrome (22qDS) - the most common chromosomal microdeletion found in humans - create a unique opportunity for susceptibility gene identification. For instance, the reported risk of psychotic disorders in 22qDS is 25-fold higher than in the general population (Murphy et al., 1999) and genome-wide linkage studies in families with schizophrenia without 22qDS indicate that the 22q11.2 region is a strong susceptibility locus for psychosis (Badner and Gershon, 2002; Lewis et al., 2003). This thesis aims to identify genetic factors associated with the development of psychosis in 22qDS by i) investigating the relationship between the length of the 22q11.2 deletions and the presence of a psychotic disorder in patients with 22qDS; ii) studying diagnostic molecular methods that improve detection of 22q11.2 deletions and duplications; and iii) exploring the relationship between 22qDS-psychotic phenotype and gene expression patterns. The central hypothesis was that psychosis in 22qDS would not be associated with haploinsufficiency (having one copy of the gene), but rather, it would be associated with distinct 22q11.2 gene expression profiles. Chapter 2 showed that 22q11.2 deletion size did not appear to be associated with the development of psychosis in adults with 22qDS. In Chapter 3, a molecular method that detects and size 22q11.2 deletions and duplications of various sizes was shown to be superior to the traditional molecular diagnostic technique used for molecular diagnostic of 22qDS. Finally, in Chapter 4, decreased gene expression of three genes located in the 22q11.2 region (SNAP29, COMT and BID) was significantly associated with psychosis in adults with 22qDS. Focusing on genes located in the 22q11.2 region has helped revealing genetic alterations associated with the frequent development of psychosis in 22qDS. Future studies focusing on investigating the heterogeneity of the psychotic presentation in 22qDS and further elucidating potential genetic mechanisms likely to explain the gene expression changes in the 22q11.2 region demonstrated here will help advance the scientific understanding of the etiology of psychosis.