Neoclassical Medicine: Transformations in the / History of Science

This thesis explores the ways in which American and Canadian neurosurgeons fashioned their professional identity in the period between 1919 and 1950. This dissertation is an exploration of the ways in which American and Canadian neurosurgeons fashioned their professional identity in the formative period of the specialty’s history. Part I argues that an ethos of elitism and exclusionism structured the cultural landscape of the specialty and was reflected in the membership policy of the Society of Neurological Surgeons and the Harvey Cushing Society, which screened for certain moral and professional values. The meetings of the societies opened with surgical performances designed to encourage particular technical practices, to negotiate and standardize procedures, and to demonstrate the prowess of the neurosurgeon. In theatrical performances at these meetings the neurosurgeons also created a distinctive type of masculinity, which was inflected with a feminine resonance. Part II outlines the extraordinary professional success of the neurosurgeons in the 1930s and 1940s when they assumed leadership of neurological institutes. Wilder Penfield’s effort to build such an institute in Montreal led him to challenge the authority of clinical neurologists by claiming therapeutic superiority and by engineering a public debate about the future of these related specialties. Jurisdictional disputes between neurosurgeons and neurologists played out in animated rhetorical performances at the meetings of professional societies and illustrate the divergent ways in which these specialists envisioned medical specialization. Neurosurgeons cleaved neurology along therapeutic lines, while neurologists, attempting to regain conditions lost to neurosurgeons and psychiatrists, sought authority over all organic and functional disorders. Part III charts the neurosurgeons’ growing authority in popular culture. Although popular representations testify to an increasing glamorization of brain surgeons over the first half of the twentieth century, these narratives reveal culturally contingent tensions. The ideal cure for brain tumors was portrayed as medical, not surgical, while the public expressed an ambivalent reaction to the violence to both body and mind that brain surgery appeared to threaten.

This thesis explores the ways in which American and Canadian neurosurgeons fashioned their professional identity in the period between 1919 and 1950. This dissertation is an exploration of the ways in which American and Canadian neurosurgeons fashioned their professional identity in the formative period of the specialty’s history. Part I argues that an ethos of elitism and exclusionism structured the cultural landscape of the specialty and was reflected in the membership policy of the Society of Neurological Surgeons and the Harvey Cushing Society, which screened for certain moral and professional values. The meetings of the societies opened with surgical performances designed to encourage particular technical practices, to negotiate and standardize procedures, and to demonstrate the prowess of the neurosurgeon. In theatrical performances at these meetings the neurosurgeons also created a distinctive type of masculinity, which was inflected with a feminine resonance. Part II outlines the extraordinary professional success of the neurosurgeons in the 1930s and 1940s when they assumed leadership of neurological institutes. Wilder Penfield’s effort to build such an institute in Montreal led him to challenge the authority of clinical neurologists by claiming therapeutic superiority and by engineering a public debate about the future of these related specialties. Jurisdictional disputes between neurosurgeons and neurologists played out in animated rhetorical performances at the meetings of professional societies and illustrate the divergent ways in which these specialists envisioned medical specialization. Neurosurgeons cleaved neurology along therapeutic lines, while neurologists, attempting to regain conditions lost to neurosurgeons and psychiatrists, sought authority over all organic and functional disorders. Part III charts the neurosurgeons’ growing authority in popular culture. Although popular representations testify to an increasing glamorization of brain surgeons over the first half of the twentieth century, these narratives reveal culturally contingent tensions. The ideal cure for brain tumors was portrayed as medical, not surgical, while the public expressed an ambivalent reaction to the violence to both body and mind that brain surgery appeared to threaten.

Thesis (M.S.P.H.)--University of Michigan, 1935.

Thesis (M.S.P.H.)--University of Michigan, 1935.

Diss. phil.-hist. Bern, 1979.

Thesis (doctoral)--Universität, Regensburg, 2006.

Made available in DSpace on 2012-05-07T14:47:59Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 2 license.txt: 1748 bytes, checksum: 8a4605be74aa9ea9d79846c1fba20a33 (MD5) 000024.pdf: 647127 bytes, checksum: a56d44962060a5ff2bd6d2603a2cbf06 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2005 / Busca analisar as discussões em torno do mal de São Lázaro na cidade do Rio de Janeiro, entre fins do século XVII e primórdios do XIX, tendo em mira as questões médicas e político-administrativas que caracterizaram o problema. Constitui uma história sem grandes rupturas, pois nenhuma mudança na estrutura política ou nas teorias médicas trouxe maiores conseqüências para o trato da lepra e dos leprosos.

Made available in DSpace on 2013-01-07T15:55:03Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 2 license.txt: 1748 bytes, checksum: 8a4605be74aa9ea9d79846c1fba20a33 (MD5) 16.pdf: 632579 bytes, checksum: 23f5237d9f480fc6e882e37ce8193c6c (MD5) Previous issue date: 2007 / Apresenta um estudo das atividades médicas na Província do Ceará na primeira metade do século XIX. Privilegiou-se a análise das ações e as conseqüências dessas atividades do final do século XVIII até meados do século XIX a partir da abordagem proporcionada pela bibliofilia relacionada à história das ciências.

Made available in DSpace on 2013-01-07T15:55:07Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 2 license.txt: 1748 bytes, checksum: 8a4605be74aa9ea9d79846c1fba20a33 (MD5) 8.pdf: 2232442 bytes, checksum: ce1d675226d16b33d67b403803f2b0fd (MD5) Previous issue date: 2006 / Trata das idéias eugênicas no Brasil. Seu objetivo consiste em investigar a trajetória intelectual e o pensamento do médico e eugenista Renato Ferraz Kehl, entre 1917 a 1932. Analisa a um só tempo o papel desempenhado por este autor na organização do movimento eugênico brasileiro e as idéias e concepções com as quais ele e outros eugenistas nacionais se envolveram ao longo deste período.