Orientador: Paulo César Corrêa [Unesp] Borges / Resumo: Este trabalho tem como objetivo geral analisar se o Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF) e o Superior Tribunal de Justiça (STJ) concederam ou não prisão domiciliar como substitutiva da preventiva para gestantes entre 08/03/2016, entrada em vigor do Marco Legal da Primeira Infância (Lei nº 13.257/16), e 20/02/2018, data de concessão do Habeas Corpus coletivo nº 143.641, pelo STF. Com este intuito, primeiramente, no Capítulo II, serão expostas as vulnerabilidades socioeconômicas extramuros enfrentadas pelas mulheres (grávidas) em privação de liberdade no Brasil, as quais são agravadas pelas pressões emocionais, físicas e materiais decorrentes das dificuldades por elas vivenciadas no ambiente prisional. Já no Capítulo III, além da exposição dos dados principais encontrados nos julgados do STF e do STJ, no período acima mencionado, referentes à concessão ou não desta prisão domiciliar, também serão expostas informações secundárias referentes à região em que se originou o recurso cuja decisão irá se analisar; à/ao advogada/advogado ou Defensoria Pública representando a pleiteante; ao mês de gestação em que se encontrava a gestante; à quantidade de filhas/filhos que ela possuía; às idades destas/destes filhas/filhos; aos tipos penais em que foi enquadrada; ao fato de ter sido condenada (em primeira instância) ou não e, se sim, a qual pena e em qual regime inicial. Para isso, o método utilizado será predominantemente o dedutivo e as principais técnicas de pesquisa serão a revisão bibliogr... (Resumo completo, clicar acesso eletrônico abaixo) / Abstract: This study aims to analyze if Brazilian Supreme Court (STF) and Brazilian Superior Court (STJ) have granted or not house arrest as a substitute for pre-trial detention to pregnant women between 08/03/2016 (Law no. 13.257/16) and 02/20/2018, date on which the STF granted the collective habeas corpus nº 143.641. For this purpose, firstly, in Chapter II, the socioeconomic vulnerabilities faced by women (pregnant women) in deprivation of liberty in Brazil will be exposed, which are aggravated by the emotional, physical and material stress derived from difficulties they experience in the prison environment. In Chapter III, the main data will be shown, regarding the granting or not of house arrest, found in judgements by the STF and STJ in the aforementioned period. Furthermore, secondary data will be analyzed, concerning the region from which the appeal originated; to the lawyer or Public Defender representing the plaintiff; to the gestation month; to the number of daughters/sons she possessed; the ages of these daughters/sons; to the felonies in which they were framed; to the conviction sentence (in the first instance) or not, and if so, to what penalty and under what regime. For this, the method used will be predominantly the deductive and the main research techniques will be the bibliographical review and the documental analysis, mainly quantitative, of judgements. / Mestre

Summary: House arrest, its execution and control The aim of this thesis is to give a comprehensive summary of the institute of the house arrest, the actual legal regulation of this punishment, to summarize its advantages and disadvantages and to draw attention to the problematic issues with it related. The thesis is divided into eleven chapters, which are divided into other subchapters. The first chapter deals with the general concept of punishment, it's purpose, functions and the general system of penalties. A separate sub-chapter constitutes a imprisoment as a basic "universal" punishment. Because the house arrest is one of the alternative punishments, the second chapter deals with the general regulation of alternative punishment. Alternative punishments closely related with the restorative justice, which is described in third chapter, in particular its aims and the principles on which it is exposed. The following chapters are the core of the thesis to the actual punishment of house arrest. The fourth chapter describe the history of the house arrest and the fifth chapter describe a general information of this sentence. The sub-chapters describe the crimes for which custodial sentences may be imposed and other conditions of house arrest, in particular the obligations of convicted. The transformation of the...

The main aim of my thesis is to develop an analysis of current legislation governing alternative sentences, their possibilities and limits comparing it with other European Union countries. The thesis also examines the proposals de lege ferenda that could be used as a benchmark and a guide for future amendments to the current regulation. The notion of alternative sentencing became a global trend in the last two to three decades; this is the result of, inter alia, of continuous increase in the number of inmates, prison overcrowding and congestion of the judicial apparatus. Crescent crime and new forms of crime (especially economic) hit the Czech Republic as a former socialist country in the post-revolutionary times, very assertive. The results of studies and language experts warn against lax approach in the form of increased storage imprisonment and criminal policy tightening. There is also talk about crisis imprisonment. It is clear that an unconditional sentence of imprisonment has its benefits, such as preventive effect, in my opinion, however, the left especially serious crime offenders and recidivist behavior: "Nesit summum malum dolor, malum certe est." Instead of intramural prison environment with significant social and deviant subculture find great potential in alternative prison sentences, which are...

Resumé The study relates to the alternatives to unconditional sentence of imprisonment. The purpose of the study is to focus on the advantages and disadvantages of the alternative punishments and to discribe the application of chosen sentences in practise. The first part of my study is the introductory and defines basic terminology and institutes related to the topic. The second part looks at individual alternative punishments, coditions of their imposing and service of the sentences. The study is composed of six chapters. Chapter One explains the term punishment . It is subdivided into three parts. Part One defines the purpose of the punishment. Part Two briefly compares the absolute and the relative theory of the punishment and Part Three describes the principles of imposing the punishments. Chapter Two provides starting points of imposing the alternative punishments. This chapter consists of three parts. Part One is concerned with the restorative justice. Part Two explores the institutes of probation and mediation and Part Threee shows the advantages of the alternatives to unconditional sentence of imprisonment. Chapter Three deals with the alternative punishments. It is subdivided into four parts. Part One describes historical development of the alternative punishments. Part Two analyzes the aplication...

House arrest, its execution and control Abstract The presented diploma thesis deals with the alternative punishment of house arrest. This punishment became the part of Czech penal system when the new Penal Code came into force on the first of January 2010. The aim of this diploma thesis is to summarize valid substantive and procedural legislation of this alternative punishment, to evaluate its advantages and disadvantages and to propose possible changes and improvements of weaknesses of current legislation. First three parts of this diploma thesis are focused on essential concepts, such as punishment, purpose of punishment and its functions, alternative punishments, their introducing to legal orders, negative aspects of custodial sentence and explanation of retributive and restorative conception of justice. Following parts are focused on issues related to valid legislation of house arrest punishment. These parts are major essence of the thesis. In the fourth part of this thesis there is analysed evolution of this punishment and there are described and explained requierements for this punishment. In this part there is also explained the essence and the content of house arrest and issues linked to house arrest execution. The fifth part is dealing with house arrest control and it is divided into two chapters....

My master thesis deals with the topic of alternatives to unconditional sentence of imprisonment. It is a vast topic, thus I have focused on alternative sentences in the narrower sense of the term, in other words, suspended sentence of imprisonment, suspended sentence of imprisonment with surveillance, community service, financial penalty and house arrest. The goal of this thesis is to discuss lawful legislation of alternative sentences, to evaluate their practical usage and potentially, to suggest changes de lege ferenda, which could lead to higher rate of application of these sentences. The thesis consists of an introduction, seven chapters and a conclusion, where the three initial chapters are written in general sense. The first chapter is concerned about the term and the purpose of sentence. The concept of restorative justice, which provides us another way how to react to the criminal acting, is introduced as a part of this chapter, too. The second chapter focuses on unconditional sentence of imprisonment and issues of the short-term sentence. Furthermore, the term of alternative sentence is explained, including a brief commentary on actions of international organizations in this area, namely Council of Europe and UN. The development of these sentences in the Czech republic after 1989 is...

HOUSE ARREST, ITS EXECUTION AND CONROL The thesis gives a comprehensive overview of the institute of home detention as a new sanction incorporated into the penal system with effect from 1 January 2010. It considers certain theoretical issues regarding alternative punishments, investigates the phenomenon of alternative punishments and places home detention in its context. It aims to clarify the function of home detention as an alternative punishment, to analyse its legal status, to asses critically its practical application and to put forward some ways of addressing the problematic aspects de lege ferenda. The thesis also explains the specifics of the imposition of this sanction on young offenders. The author analyses the role of the Probation and Mediation Service in relation to home detention and cites examples of foreign experiences with this punishment from the Netherlands, Slovakia, and the United Kingdom, which constitute a source of inspiration. Special attention is paid to very topical questions regarding electronic monitoring during home detention, the introduction of electronic monitoring in the Czech Republic, its setbacks and current developments. The thesis answers the question whether the imposition of home detention is likely to reduce the numbers of people in prisons. In...

The aim of this thesis is to give a comprehensive overview about the one of alternative sanction incorporated into the czech penal system with effect from 1 January 2010. The thesis devotes definition of general term "punishment", its help to better understanding of house arrest, the crux of this thesis. It aims to clarify the reasons for which legislator has decided to file this sanction to system of punishment, but also it aims to outline arguments standings against these procedure. The thesis also give a historical perspective about possibilities of using house arrest in the past. The primary aim of this thesis is focus on the current legislation of house arrest from the sight of substantive law and also procedural law. My attempt was describe several imperfections of legislation and propose the method to improve it alternatively. Part of the thesis devotes to Probation and mediation service considering to actually during of control the house arrest. Without this service the house arrest probably couldn't be ussed. The thesis is supplemented by probation officials opinions and by issues which they work with every day. With this matter also associate the provision of the act about electronic monitoring which still isn't in effect and actually situation of procurement to operator of electronic...

The problem of resocialization of convicts and the effect of particular penalties on this process is a subject rather relatively neglected, but at the same time socially and legally fundamental. The success of the resocialization of offenders affects not only the entire criminal policy but also society as a whole. However, the view on this social dilemma is evolving over time. We do not longer examine the punishment as mere retribution, rather we expect it to protect society and have a positive effect on the convict. We also realize that most of the sentencing does not mean permanent exclusion from society. Therefore, the consequences of any sentence also affect us, the society. This phenomenon led me to analyze the three most severe sentences: imprisonment, house arrest, and community service. Gradually, I tried to investigate the outcome of the effects of these sentences on the offender's personality. During the analysis, I decided not to only benefit from the secondary data consisting of acknowledged publications, articles, studies, and concepts, but I also acquired findings from several interviews with experts within the sphere and convicts themselves. This allowed deep penetration into the topic not only from a theoretical point of view but also from a practical one. In the thesis, I critically...

House arrest punishment, its enforcement and control The submitted diplom thesis aimed to analyze the legal regulation of house arrest within the Czech legal system, as an alternative punishment. This diplom thesis contains a total of seven consecutive chapters, the first contains the definition of basic criminal law concepts that are needed to understand the issue, especially the concept of punishment, the concept of alternative measures and the system of punishments and alternative measures and principles of sentencing. Another term, which is defined in this chapter, is the concept of restorative justice, which is then widely worked on in other parts of the thesis. In the second chapter, the diploma thesis deals specifically with the sentence of house arrest, when this topic opens the issue of the crisis of unconditional imprisonment, which is of great importance for the future application of alternative measures. The next step in the second chapter is to describe the history of house arrest, both abroad and specifically in the Czech Republic. The following is a definition of the essence of the house arrest sentence itself and the legal conditions for imposing a house arrest sentence. A related topic is the execution of house arrest, for which a separate chapter has been set. In the chapter,...