[pt] A política monetária brasileira opera, desde 1999, sob o regime de metas para a inflação, em que a taxa de juros é o principal instrumento utilizado para o cumprimento das metas. Esta dissertação estuda o efeito da política monetária sobre o nível de atividade, e fatores que possam fazê-lo flutuar, através da estimação de uma curva IS para o Brasil. Inicialmente, encontramos efeitos significantes da taxa real de juros para o produto em uma curva IS backwardlooking. Em seguida, a partir de um modelo teórico, explicamos variações desse efeito como decorrente de ganhos de eficiência da atividade de intermediação financeira. Utilizando a tendência dos spreads bancários como medida da eficiência da atividade de provisão de crédito na economia, testamos empiricamente esta hipótese, e constatamos que o aumento da potência da política monetária observado ao longo dos últimos anos é consistente com essa explicação. Testes realizados com variáveis fiscais não encontram correlação entre estas e a potência da política monetária. / [en] Monetary policy in Brazil has been working, since 1999, under an inflation targeting regime, in which interest rates are the main instruments in achieving the targets. This dissertation studies the effect of monetary policy on the economy`s output and reasons for its fluctuations, through the estimation of an IS curve for Brazil. We find a significant effect of the real interest rate on output in a backward-looking IS curve. We then explain, using a theoretical model, variations in this effect as arising from efficiency gains in the financial intermediation activity. Using the trend over time of bank spreads as a measure of the efficiency of the lending activity, we test this hypothesis empirically, and find that the higher potency observed in the monetary policy on recent years is consistent with this explanation. Tests using fiscal variables do not find correlation between them and the potency of monetary policy.

[pt] A incerteza é um fator relevante na modelagem de variáveis macroeconômi-cas, especialmente em países emergentes. Neste estudo, tentamos entender se me-didas de incerteza oriundas do mercado brasileiro podem melhorar as projeções de PIB do país. Traçando uma curva IS da forma mais simples possível: relacionando o hiato do produto a suas primeiras defasagens e aos juros reais ex-ante, podemos adicionar medidas de incerteza e atestar se estas melhoram as projeções de hiato realizadas para o período imediatamente subsequente. Como medidas de incerte-za, utilizamos a dispersão de expectativas do boletim Focus para PIB e inflação; a volatilidade implícita dos contratos futuros de câmbio; o VIX; a volatilidade observada nas empresas mais relevantes do índice Bovespa e o Índice de Incerteza Econômica (IIE-Br). Conseguimos demonstrar com um exercício de backtest que a previsão de hiatos do PIB se torna melhor com a inclusão de variáveis de incerteza na curva IS. / [en] Uncertainty is a relevant matter when modelling economic variables, especially in emerging countries. Here, we try to understand if measures of uncertainty observed in the Brazilian market allow us to improve GDP forecasting. By defining an IS curve as simply as possible: relating current output gap with its lags and the economy s ex-ante real interest rate, it is possible to introduce an uncertainty measure and examine if the forecasting exercise improves in the next period. As proxies for uncertainty, we shall use dispersion of financial markets expectations for future inflation and future output growth; FX future contracts implied volatility; VIX Index; observed volatility in Brazil s most relevant companies stock prices, and; the Economy Uncertainty Index (IIE-Br). We were able to demonstrate through a backtest exercise that the insertion of uncertainty measures in the IS curve improves the output gap forecasting.

Submitted by Alexis Maka (alexis.maka@ipea.gov.br) on 2014-01-07T17:09:06Z No. of bitstreams: 1 Dissertation - Alexis Maka.pdf: 4105460 bytes, checksum: 61a014ecaca774cf3ae64ddbdd8ea527 (MD5) / Approved for entry into archive by ÁUREA CORRÊA DA FONSECA CORRÊA DA FONSECA (aurea.fonseca@fgv.br) on 2014-01-28T18:27:24Z (GMT) No. of bitstreams: 1 Dissertation - Alexis Maka.pdf: 4105460 bytes, checksum: 61a014ecaca774cf3ae64ddbdd8ea527 (MD5) / Approved for entry into archive by Marcia Bacha (marcia.bacha@fgv.br) on 2014-02-03T15:53:23Z (GMT) No. of bitstreams: 1 Dissertation - Alexis Maka.pdf: 4105460 bytes, checksum: 61a014ecaca774cf3ae64ddbdd8ea527 (MD5) / Made available in DSpace on 2014-02-03T15:53:53Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 Dissertation - Alexis Maka.pdf: 4105460 bytes, checksum: 61a014ecaca774cf3ae64ddbdd8ea527 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2013-11-27 / Esta tese é composta por três ensaios sobre testes empíricos de curvas de Phillips, curvas IS e a interação entre as políticas fiscal e monetária. O primeiro ensaio ('Curvas de Phillips: um Teste Abrangente') testa curvas de Phillips usando uma especificação autoregressiva de defasagem distribuída (ADL) que abrange a curva de Phillips Aceleracionista (APC), a curva de Phillips Novo Keynesiana (NKPC), a curva de Phillips Híbrida (HPC) e a curva de Phillips de Informação Rígida (SIPC). Utilizamos dados dos Estados Unidos (1985Q1--2007Q4) e do Brasil (1996Q1--2012Q2), usando o hiato do produto e alternativamente o custo marginal real como medida de pressão inflacionária. A evidência empírica rejeita as restrições decorrentes da NKPC, da HPC e da SIPC, mas não rejeita aquelas da APC. O segundo ensaio ('Curvas IS: um Teste Abrangente') testa curvas IS usando uma especificação ADL que abrange a curva IS Keynesiana tradicional (KISC), a curva IS Novo Keynesiana (NKISC) e a curva IS Híbrida (HISC). Utilizamos dados dos Estados Unidos (1985Q1--2007Q4) e do Brasil (1996Q1--2012Q2). A evidência empírica rejeita as restrições decorrentes da NKISC e da HISC, mas não rejeita aquelas da KISC. O terceiro ensaio ('Os Efeitos da Política Fiscal e suas Interações com a Política Monetária') analisa os efeitos de choques na política fiscal sobre a dinâmica da economia e a interação entre as políticas fiscal e monetária usando modelos SVARs. Testamos a Teoria Fiscal do Nível de Preços para o Brasil analisando a resposta do passivo do setor público a choques no superávit primário. Para a identificação híbrida, encontramos que não é possível distinguir empiricamente entre os regimes Ricardiano (Dominância Monetária) e não-Ricardiano (Dominância Fiscal). Entretanto, utilizando a identificação de restrições de sinais, existe evidência que o governo seguiu um regime Ricardiano (Dominância Monetária) de janeiro de 2000 a junho de 2008. / This dissertation consists of three essays on empirical testing of Phillips curves, IS curves, and the interaction between fiscal and monetary policies. The first essay ('Phillips Curves: An Encompassing Test') tests Phillips curves using an autoregressive distributed lag (ADL) specification that encompasses the accelerationist Phillips curve (APC), the New Keynesian Phillips curve (NKPC), the Hybrid Phillips curve (HPC), and the Sticky-Information Phillips curve (SIPC). We use data from the United States (1985Q1--2007Q4) and from Brazil (1996Q1--2012Q2), using the output gap and alternatively the real marginal cost as measure of inflationary pressure. The empirical evidence rejects the restrictions implied by the NKPC, the HPC, and SIPC, but does not reject those implied by the APC. The second essay ('IS Curves: An Encompassing Test') tests IS curves using an ADL specification that encompasses the traditional Keynesian IS curve (KISC), the New Keynesian IS curve (NKISC), and the Hybrid IS curve (HISC). We use data from the United States (1985Q1--2007Q4) and from Brazil (1996Q1--2012Q2). The evidence rejects the restrictions implied by the NKISC and the HISC, but does not reject those of the KISC. The third essay ('The Effects of Fiscal Policy and its Interactions with Monetary Policy in Brazil') analyzes the effects of fiscal policy shocks on the dynamics of the economy and the interaction between fiscal and monetary policy using structural vector autoregressions (SVARs). We test the Fiscal Theory of the Price Level for Brazil, analyzing the response of public sector liabilities to primary surplus shocks. For the hybrid identification we find that it is not possible to distinguish empirically between Ricardian (Monetary Dominance) and non-Ricardian (Fiscal Dominance) regimes. However, using sign restrictions there is some evidence that the government followed a Ricardian (Monetary Dominance) regime from January 2000 to June 2008.

Dans cette thèse, je fournis une évaluation empirique des relations entre les principales variables macroéconomiques qui animent le cycle économique. Nous traitons dans chacun des trois chapitres une question empirique en utilisant une approche économétrique bayésienne. Dans le premier chapitre nous étudions la contribution conditionnelle des taux de transition du marché du travail (le taux de retour en emploi et le taux de séparation). La littérature n'est pas parvenue à un consensus sur lequel des taux dominent la dynamique du marché du travail. Alors que Blanchard et Diamond (1990) ont conclu que la baisse de l'emploi en période de récession résulte d'un taux de séparation plus élevé, Shimer (2012), ainsi que Hall (2005), expliquent que les variations du chômage sont principalement expliqués par la variation du taux de retour en emploi. Notre résultat, obtenu grâce à une estimation d'un modèle VAR structurel, montre que l'importance de chaque taux de transition dépend des chocs qui ont frappé le marché du travail et de l'importance des institutions du marché du travail. Dans le second chapitre, nous évaluons l'impact de la réforme du marché du travail réalisée par le Président des États-Unis H. Hoover au début de la Grande Dépression. Nous montrons que ces politiques ont permis à l'économie américaine d'échapper à une grande spirale déflationniste. L'estimation d'un modèle DSGE à l'échelle agrégée, nous permet de comparer deux effets opposés que ces politiques impliquent : effet négatif dû à une baisse de l'emploi et l'effet positif dû aux anticipations inflationnistes qui sont expansionnistes quand l'économie est dans la trappe à liquidité. Les résultats dépendent de la règle de politique monétaire que nous supposons : le principe de Taylor ou le ciblage du niveau de prix. Le troisième chapitre est consacré à la relation entre le taux d'intérêt réel et l'activité économique qui dépend du nombre des participants aux marchés financiers. En utilisant un modèle DSGE et en permettant à la proportion de ces agents d'être stochastiques en suivant une chaîne de Markov, nous identifions les périodes historiques où la proportion était assez faible pour inverser la courbe IS. Pour le cas des États-Unis, nous montrons que cette relation est positive pendant la période de la Grande Inflation et pendant une courte période au début de la Grande Récession. Dans l'union européenne, la proportion de non­-participants a été augmentée pendant les années 2009-2015 mais seulement pour amplifier la corrélation négative entre le taux d'intérêt réel et la croissance de la production. / In this thesis I provide an empirical assessment of the relations between the main macroeconomic variables that drive the Business Cycle. We treat the empirical question that arises in each chapter using Bayesian estimation. In the first chapter we investigate conditional contribution of the labor market transition rates (the job finding rate and the separation rate) to unemployment. The literature did not have a consensus on which rate dominates in explaining the labor market dynamics. While Blanchard and Diamond (1990) concluded that the fall in employment during slumps resulted from a higher separation rate, Shimer (2012), as well as Hall (2005), explain unemployment variations by mainly the job finding rate. Our result, obtained through an estimation of a structural VAR model, shows that the importance of the transition rated depends on the shocks that hit an economy and hence the importance of the labor market institutions. In the second chapter, we assess the impact of the labor market reform of the US president H. Hoover implemented at the beginning of the Great Depression. We show that these policies prevented the US economy to enter a big deflationary spiral. Estimating a medium scale DSGE model, we also compare two opposite effects these policies lead to: negative effect through a fall in employment and positive effect though inflationary expectations which are expansionary when monetary policy is irresponsive to the rise in prices. The results depend on the monetary policy rule we assume: The Taylor principle or price level targeting. The third chapter is devoted to the relation between the real interest rate and the economic activity which depends on the number of asset market participants. Using a DSGE model and allowing to the proportion of these agents to be stochastic and to follow a Markov chain, we identify the historical sub-periods where this proportion was low enough to reverse the IS curve. For the US case, we report the studied relation to be positive during the Great Inflation period and for a short period at the edge of the Great Recession. In the EA, the proportion of non-participants has been increased during 2009-2015, but only to amplify the negative correlation between the real interest rate and output growth.