Thesis (M.S.)--University of Texas at El Paso, 2008. / Title from title screen. Vita. CD-ROM. Includes bibliographical references. Also available online.

Ground improvement by deep mixing (DM) is a generic term used for a number of methods in which a binding agent, often lime and/or cement, is mechanically mixed with the soil to increase its engineering properties. The inherent variability with respect to the engineering properties of the improved soil is high due to the variations in geology and the complex mixing process. High variability introduces uncertainty in estimating improved soil properties and the performance of the structure. Current design methodology deals with soil properties deterministically and the uncertainties involved are incorporated in a single value represented by a total factor of safety (FS). The chosen FS is highly dependent on the engineer’s judgment and past experience, in which both of these factors vary between different geotechnical designers. Therefore, current design methodology used in practice for DM does not deal with uncertainties in a rational way. In order to design a geotechnical system with the desired level of confidence, the uncertainties involved must be integrated in the DM design. This can be achieved by using reliability-based design (RBD) methods. The research work in this thesis is presented as a collection of three papers. In the first paper, a comprehensive statistical analysis of cone penetration test (CPT) data is described. The objective was to make a contribution to empirical knowledge by evaluating the strength variability of lime-cement columns within the group of tested columns. In the second paper, the effect of the spatial variability and statistical uncertainty with regard to the embankment’s reliability was investigated within the framework of RBD. The study in the third paper investigated the strength variability in lime-cement columns based on two test methods, namely CPT and column penetration test (KPS). In this study, the effect of different test methods on the evaluation of the design value was addressed. The main conclusions from this study can be summarized as follows. First, the probability distribution function (PDF) for the undrained shear strength of lime-cement columns can be modeled in RBD as normal or log-normal distributions. However, the use of log-normal distribution is recommended for RBD analyses. Second, the evaluated scales of fluctuation indicate ranges of 2 to 4 m and 0.2 to 0.8 m in the horizontal and the vertical directions respectively. This means that in order to fulfill the requirements of independent/uncorrelated samples for assessment of the design value, the spacing between samples must exceed the horizontal scale of fluctuation. It is therefore proposed that the spacing between individual samples should be at least 4 meters. Third, the design values evaluated using CPT and KPS were approximately the same. However, the inherent variability evaluated differs due to the larger volume tested with the KPS probe than with the CPT probe. However, this difference was not significant between the two tests. Fourthly, due to the limitation in the deterministic design in terms of dealing with uncertainties, it is recommended that RBD design should be used in parallel with the deterministic design of lime-cement column. / <p>QC 20120110</p>

Lime-cement columns were constructed to improve soft ground at the I-95/Route 1 Interchange in Alexandria, Virginia. As part of the test embankment program, two different commercial laboratories performed laboratory tests on treated soil, and they produced strikingly different unconfined compression test results. Further, both sets of results are different from test results for similar soils available in the published literature. This situation created uncertainties and a conservative design philosophy, accompanied by increased construction costs compared to typical lime-cement column projects. The goals of this research project were to assess factors that influence strength gain of lime-cement-soil mixtures and to develop a detailed laboratory test procedure that produces consistent results. Key findings from the research are that a laboratory test procedure that produces consistent results has been developed, drying and subsequent restoration of soil moisture prior to treatment can decrease the strength of the mixture, the mixture strength decreases as the ratio of soil water content to cement content increases for 100 percent cement-soil mixtures, the addition of lime can increase the mixture strength for some soils and decrease the strength for others, and presenting the test results in the form of contour plots of unconfined compressive strength can be very useful. / Master of Science

<p>The thesis is dealing with mixing processes havingapplication to ground improvement by deep mixing. The mainobjectives of the thesis is to make a contribution to knowledgeof the basic mechanisms in mixing binding agents into soil andimprove the knowledge concerning factors that influence theuniformity of stabilised soil.</p><p>A great part of the work consists of a literature surveywith particular emphasis on literature on the processindustries. This review forms a basis for a profounddescription and discussion of the mixing process and factorsaffecting the process in connection with deep mixingmethods.</p><p>The thesis presents a method for a simple field test for thestudy of influential factors in the mixing process. A number offactors in the installation process of lime-cement columns havebeen studied in two field tests using statistical multifactorexperiment design. The effects of retrieval rate, number ofmixing blades, rotation speed, air pressure in the storagetank, and diameter of the binder outlet on the stabilisationeffect and the coefficient of variation determined byhand-operated penetrometer tests for excavated lime-cementcolumns, were studied.</p><p>The literature review, the description of the mixingprocess, and the results from the field tests provide a morebalanced picture of the mixing process and are expected to beuseful in connection to ground improvement projects and thedevelopment of mixing equipments.</p><p>The concept of sufficient mixture quality, i.e. theinteraction between the mixing process and the mechanicalsystem, is discussed in the last section. By means ofgeostatistical methods, the analysis considers thevolume-variability relationship with reference to strengthproperties. According to the analysis, the design values forstrength properties depends on the mechanical system, the scaleof scrutiny, the spatial correlation structure, and the conceptof safety, i.e. the concept of sufficient mixture quality isproblem specific.</p><p><b>Key words:</b>Deep Mixing, Lime cement columns, Mixingmechanisms, Mixture quality, Field test, ANOVA, Variancereduction.</p>

The thesis is dealing with mixing processes havingapplication to ground improvement by deep mixing. The mainobjectives of the thesis is to make a contribution to knowledgeof the basic mechanisms in mixing binding agents into soil andimprove the knowledge concerning factors that influence theuniformity of stabilised soil. A great part of the work consists of a literature surveywith particular emphasis on literature on the processindustries. This review forms a basis for a profounddescription and discussion of the mixing process and factorsaffecting the process in connection with deep mixingmethods. The thesis presents a method for a simple field test for thestudy of influential factors in the mixing process. A number offactors in the installation process of lime-cement columns havebeen studied in two field tests using statistical multifactorexperiment design. The effects of retrieval rate, number ofmixing blades, rotation speed, air pressure in the storagetank, and diameter of the binder outlet on the stabilisationeffect and the coefficient of variation determined byhand-operated penetrometer tests for excavated lime-cementcolumns, were studied. The literature review, the description of the mixingprocess, and the results from the field tests provide a morebalanced picture of the mixing process and are expected to beuseful in connection to ground improvement projects and thedevelopment of mixing equipments. The concept of sufficient mixture quality, i.e. theinteraction between the mixing process and the mechanicalsystem, is discussed in the last section. By means ofgeostatistical methods, the analysis considers thevolume-variability relationship with reference to strengthproperties. According to the analysis, the design values forstrength properties depends on the mechanical system, the scaleof scrutiny, the spatial correlation structure, and the conceptof safety, i.e. the concept of sufficient mixture quality isproblem specific. Key words:Deep Mixing, Lime cement columns, Mixingmechanisms, Mixture quality, Field test, ANOVA, Variancereduction.

Thesis (M.S.)--University of Texas at El Paso, 2008. / Title from title screen. Vita. CD-ROM. Includes bibliographical references. Also available online.

The geotechnical community has since decades been acquainted with the use of statistical approach for design optimizations. This has been approved as an operational method by many practitioners in the field but is yet to see a major full-scale breakthrough and acceptance in practice. The advantage of quantifying the many different sources of uncertainties in a design is already a fairly acknowledged method and is in this report expanded for the use in the case of road embankments founded on soft soil improved by lime-cement columns. Statistical approach was adopted with practice of reliability base design (RBD ) to consider the importance of ingoing variables’ variability with the target of streamlining the result by decreasing uncertainties (by means of increased measurements, careful installation, etc.). By constructing a working model that gives the corresponding area ratio between columns and soil needed to fulfill the different criterion set as input values, weight is put on investigating the effects of different coefficients of variation (COV ). The analyses show that the property variabilities have a significant influence on the requisite area ratio that an active use of RBD is a useful tool for optimizing designs in geotechnical engineering. The methodology favors the contractors own development of the mixing process since higher design values can be utilized when

This thesis presents the results of a series of undrained cyclic triaxial tests carried out on four lime-cement stabilized specimens and clay specimen. The shear resistance degradation rate of lime-cement column subjected to cyclic loading simulated from heavy truck was investigated based on stress-controlled test. The influence of lime and cement on the degradation rate was investigated by comparing the behavior of stabilized kaolin and unstabilized kaolin with similar initial condition. The results indicate an increase in degree of degradation as the number of loading cycles and cyclic strain increase. It is observed that the degradation index has approximately a parabolic relationship with the number of cycles. Generally adding lime and cement to the clay will increase the degradation index which means lower degree of degradation. The degradation parameter, t has a hyperbolic relationship with shear strain, but it loses its hyperbolic shape as the soil getting stronger. On the other hand, for unstabilized clay an approximate linear relationship between degradation index and number of cycles was observed and the degradation parameter has a hyperbolic shape with the increase number of cycles. It was also observed that the stronger the material was, the lesser pore pressure developed in the lime-cement stabilized clay.

Excavations in soft clays come with a number of specific challenges. The use of lime-cement columns in the passive zone of such works represents a promising solution to some of these problems, such as basal heave stability or excessive deformations. Nevertheless, lime-cement columns in the passive zone of excavations in soft clays are not yet widely used and studied. Knowledge about this improvement method is still limited, particularly when it comes to numerical modelling. They have mostly been studied numerically using simple geometries or constitutive models that do not allow to represent the key features of the material, that could influence the behaviour of the structure. Thus, there is a need for more investigations regarding precise modelling tools for this type of problems. In this study, an advanced constitutive model named the Concrete model was employed to capture the mechanical behaviour of the lime-cement improved soil material. A boundary value problem representing an excavation in soft clay supported by sheet pile walls and lime-cement columns was studied using a three dimensional finite element model that included the Concrete model for lime-cement column panels. The results show that the Concrete model is able to capture the behaviour of lime-cement improved clay very well. Key features such as strain hardening and strain softening are well represented. The results of the boundary value problem were compared to field measurements and it was showed that the Concrete model employed in a three dimensional finite element representation of the problem is able to give realistic results. / Schakter i lös lera medför ett antal specifika utmaningar. Användningen av kalk-cementpelare i den passiva zonen i sådana fallen är en lovande lösning på några av dessa problem, t.ex. jordhävning eller stora deformationer. Kalk-cement pelare i den passiva zonen av schakter i lös lera har dock ännu inte använts och studerats i någon större utsträckning i Sverige. Kunskapen om denna metod är fortfarande begränsad, särskilt när det gäller numerisk modellering. Denna förstärkningsmetod har studerats numeriskt med hjälp av enkla geometrier eller konstitutiva modeller som inte gör det möjligt att representera materialets viktigaste egenskaper som kan påverka konstruktionens beteende. Det finns därför ett behov av mer forskning för en precis modellering för denna typ av problem. I den här studien användes en avancerad konstitutiv modell (Concrete model) för att simulera det mekaniska beteendet hos det kalkcementstabiliserade jordmaterialet. Ett gränsvärdesproblem som representerar en schakt i lös lera som stöds av spontväggar och kalkcementpelare studerades med hjälp av en tredimensionell finita elementmodell. Resultaten visar att den advancerade konstitutiva modellen kan simulera beteendet hos kalkcementstabiliserad lera mycket väl. Viktiga egenskaper som t.ex. töjningshärdning och töjningsuppmjukning är väl representerade. Resultaten av gränsvärdesproblemet modellering jämfördes med fältmätningar och det visades att konstitutiva modellen som används kan ge realistiska resultat. / Les excavations dans les argiles molles présentent de nombreuses difficultés. L’utilisation de colonnes en chaux-ciment dans la zone passive de ces structures représente une solution prometteuse à certains de ces défis, tels que le soulèvement de la base ou les déformations excessives. Néanmoins, l’utilisation et l’étude des colonnes en chaux-ciment dans la zone passive des excavations dans les argiles molles ne sont pas généralisées et les connaissances à ce sujet sont encore limitées, notamment en ce qui concerne la modélisation numérique. La plupart des études numériques se basent sur des géométries simples ou des modèles constitutifs ne permettant pas de représenter certaines particularités du comportement du matériau, qui pourraient influencer le comportement de la structure. Il est donc nécessaire d’approfondir les recherches sur les outils de modélisation pour ce type de problème. Dans cette étude, un modèle constitutif avancé (Concrete model) a été utilisé pour reproduire le comportement mécanique de l’argile stabilisée à la chaux et au ciment. Un problème de valeurs aux limites représentant une excavation dans de l’argile molle soutenue par des murs de palplanches et des colonnes en chaux-ciment a été étudié à l’aide d’un modèle d’éléments finis tridimensionnel. Les résultats montrent que le modèle employé permet de reproduire le comportement de l’argile stabilisée à la chaux-ciment de manière très satisfaisante. Les particularités du comportement du matériau, telles que l’écrouissage et l’adoucissement, sont bien représentées. Les résultats du problème de valeurs aux limites ont été comparés aux mesures sur le terrain et il semble que ce modèle constitutif, employé dans une représentation tridimensionnelle par éléments finis du problème, soit capable de donner des résultats réalistes.