Return to search

由合法性危機論數位著作保護爭議 / A Study of digital copyright protection from the perspective of legitimation crisis

摘要

觀察著作權法的演進,可說是一部為因應新興科技帶來著作利用型態改變,所造成衝擊的歷史。而現今著作權法面對資訊科技進步,所造成的法制衝擊時,卻因採取反規避措施等激烈的因應手段,造成著作權法制針對數位著作保護之爭議,出現了原先為平衡權利人利益與促進文化創作發展之兩大目的,發生了失衡的現象。該現象的發生,似乎於某種層度上,驗證了德國學者哈伯瑪斯(Jürgen Habermas)於觀察資本主義社會演進的歷史脈絡後,結合馬克斯的社會進化觀點與盧曼的系統論,所主張的晚期資本主義下的四重危機。

而隨著國際間有關數位著作保護的立法趨勢,無形中賦予了著作權人擁有對於他人接近其著作,幾乎完全的管制權利;而合理使用原則之適用卻遭受科技管制的嚴重限縮,使得著作權的保護對象,究竟是表達方式或是無形的概念,產生了保護界限的模糊,著作權法制似乎已轉往著作權利人之一方傾斜。如此的法制發展,將可能造成法律系統的內在衝突與矛盾,危及系統存在的正當性,進而產生數位著作權法制上的合法性危機。

本文試圖依循哈伯瑪斯有關溝通理性與擴大參與以型塑公共領域的主張,尋求爭議解決的可能途徑。並試圖藉由新興之創作共享授權機制(Creative Commons),結合網際網路之互動特性,嘗試探討網路中出現創作之公共領域(Public Sphere)的可能性。並期待開啟以強化社會對話與互動的溝通模式,來尋求爭議問題解決的討論開端。 / Abstract

The evolution of Copyright Act reflects the change of publication displaying methods due to technology. Legislators create Anti-Circumvention Provision in reaction to the shock of technology progression on Copyright Act. However, these provision triggers the debate on the purpose of Copyright Act on publication protection, whether it is to protect the obligees or to enhance publication development. This phenomenon verifies Jürgen Habermas’s argument on the four crises under advanced capitalism, which combines Marx’s evolution of society, Luhmann’s system theory, and Habermas’s own observation on the transformation of Capitalism.

The legislative trend on digital copyright protection gives the obligees almost complete control over their writings. However,“fair use” is limited by technology restrain. As a result, the Copyright Act seems to be tilted towards obligees. Such development may create inner conflict and endanger the legitimation of the law system. Moreover, the legitimation crisis on Copyright Act may be aroused.

This thesis is aimed to solve the debate based on Harbemas’s claim on creating public sphere through rational communication and enlarging participation. For example, the writer combines creative commons and the interactive feature of the Internet to explore the possibility of public sphere on the Internet. In sum, this thesis is intended to resolve the Copyright Act problem.

Identiferoai:union.ndltd.org:CHENGCHI/G0093651044
Creators張喻閔, Chang, Yu Min
Publisher國立政治大學
Source SetsNational Chengchi University Libraries
Language中文
Detected LanguageEnglish
Typetext
RightsCopyright © nccu library on behalf of the copyright holders

Page generated in 0.003 seconds