O presente trabalho propõe-se a analisar a controvérsia da experimentação animal por meio do método da dialética materialista a partir de duas unidades que compõem a temática: o teor dos argumentos usados por diferentes atores na controvérsia e as contradições que engendram os sistemas de atividade dos sujeitos. Por meio da dialética, buscou-se superar a dualidade dos argumentos apresentados, na busca por novas formas de divulgação científica. Sem julgar a validade e o mérito das argumentações, foram analisados o discurso de duas pesquisadoras, dois ativistas, um político e um representante do Conselho Nacional de Controle de Experimentação Animal. A partir do arcabouço estrutural da Teoria da Atividade, proposto por Engeström, buscamos compreender onde se localizam as contradições mais evidentes no discurso dos sujeitos e discutir como ações de divulgação científica poderiam propiciar um ambiente favorável para a superação dessas contradições e o desenvolvimento qualitativo do sistema de atividade. Por essa razão, queremos trazer, para esta investigação, as conferências de consenso como ferramenta inovadora de comunicação da ciência, em uma abordagem deliberativa e com participação ativa da sociedade, que nos auxilie no avanço desses conflitos. / This study proposes to analyze the controversy of animal experiments by the method of materialist dialectics from two units that make up the theme: the content of the arguments used by different actors in the controversy and contradictions that engender the activity systems subject. Through the dialectic, he sought to overcome the duality of the arguments made in the search for new forms of science communication. Without judging the validity and the merits of the arguments, we analyzed the speech of two researchers, two activists, a politician and a representative of the National Council for Animal Experimentation Control. From the structural framework of Activity Theory, proposed by Engeström, we try to understand where there are the most obvious contradictions in the discourse of subjects and discuss how science communication actions could provide a favorable environment for overcoming these contradictions and the qualitative development of the system activity. For this reason, we want to bring to this research, consensus conferences as an innovative communication tool of science, in a deliberative approach and active participation of society, to assist in the advancement of these conflicts.

Necroptosis, a type of regulated necrotic cell death, involves cell membrane permeabilization and has been implicated in various acute and chronic pro-inflammatory diseases, including ischemia-reperfusion injury and neurodegenerative diseases. By using in vitro reconstitution studies and a chemical inhibitor, the kinase activity of the serine/threonine kinase RIPK1 had been shown to regulate necroptotic signaling downstream of TNF and Toll-like receptors (TLRs). To investigate the contribution of RIPK1 kinase activity to inflammation and necroptosis in vivo, we generated kinase inactive RIPK1 knock-in mice. Utilizing fibroblasts and macrophages from these mice, we demonstrate that RIPK1 kinase activity is required for necroptotic complex formation and death induction downstream of TNFR1 and TLRs 3 and 4. We show that RIPK1 kinase inactive mice are resistant to TNF-induced shock and exhibit impaired upregulation of TNF-induced cytokines and chemokines in vitro and in vivo. By using bone marrow reconstitution experiments, we demonstrate that RIPK1 kinase activity in a non-hematopoietic lineage drives TNF-induced lethality. We establish that RIPK1 kinase activity is required for TNF-induced increases in intestinal and vascular permeability and clotting, and implicate endothelial cell necroptosis as an underlying factor contributing to TNF/zVAD-induced shock. Thus, work in this thesis reveals that RIPK1 kinase inhibitors may have promise in treating shock and sepsis.

This thesis proposes a mechanism for the induction of peripheral tolerance to protein antigens. I have investigated the mechanism of tolerance induction to soluble protein antigens by targeting an antigen to small, resting B cells. For this purpose I have used a rabbit antibody directed at the IgD molecule found on the surface of most small, resting B cells but missing or lowered on activated B cells. Intravenous injection of normal mice with 100 μg of an ultracentrifuged Fab fragment of rabbit anti-mouse IgD (Fab anti-δ) makes these mice profoundly tolerant to challenge with nonimmune rabbit Fab (Fab NRG) fragments. This tolerance is antigen specific since treated mice make normal responses to an irrelevant antigen, chicken immunoglobulin (Ig). Fab fragments of rabbit Ig (rabbit Fab) not targeted to B cells do not induce tolerance as well as Fab anti-δ. Evidence suggests that the B cells must remain in a resting state for tolerance to be induced, since injection of F(ab)'2 anti-δ does not induce tolerance. Investigation of the mechanisms of the tolerance, by adoptive transfer, have shown that rabbit Fab specific B cell function has been impaired. The major effect however is in helper T cell function, as shown by adoptive transfer and lack of help for a hapten response. In vitro proliferation experiments show that the T cell response has not been shifted toward activation of different T cell subsets which do not help Ig production, nor is there any change in the Ig isotypes produced. Suppression does not appear to be the major cause of the helper T cell defect as shown by cell mixing experiments. This work shows that an antigen targeted to small B cells can induce tolerance to a soluble protein antigen, and suggests a role for small B cells in tolerance to self-proteins not presented in the thymus.

Members of the Argonaute family of proteins, which interact with small RNAs, are the key players of RNAi and other related pathways. The C. elegans genome encodes 27 members of the Argonaute family. During this thesis research, we sought to understand the functions of the members of this gene family in C. elegans. Among the Argonaute family members, rde-1 and alg-1/2have previously been shown to be essential for RNAi and development, respectively. In this work, we wanted to assign functions to the remaining members of this large family of proteins. Here, we describe the phenotype of 31 deletion alleles representing all of the previously uncharacterized Argonaute members. In addition to rde-1, our analysis revealed that two other Argonaute members csr-1 and prg-1 are also essential for development. csr-1 is partially required for RNAi, and essential for proper chromosome segregation. prg-1, a member of PIWI subfamily of Argonaute genes, exhibits reduced brood size and temperature-sensitive sterile phenotype, implicating that it is required for germline maintenance. Additionally, we showed that RDE-1 interacts with trigger-derived sense and antisense siRNAs (primary siRNAs) to initiate RNAi, while several other Argonaute proteins, SAGO-1, SAGO-2, and perhaps others, functioning redundantly, interact with amplified siRNAs (secondary siRNAs) to mediate downstream silencing. Moreover, our analysis uncovered that another member of Argonaute gene family, ergo-1, is essential for the endogenous RNAi pathway. Furthermore, we built an eight-fold Argonaute mutant, MAGO8, and analyzed its developmental phenotype and sensitivity to RNAi. Our analysis revealed that the genes deleted in the MAGO8 mutant function redundantly with each other, and are required for RNAi and the maintenance of the stem cell totipotency.

Les lésions d’athérosclérose sont une des causes majeurs du développement de pathologies cardiovasculaires. Cette pathologie chronique à l’origine inflammatoire est caractérisée par des mécanismes moléculaires et cellulaires complexes. L’activité de minéralisation retrouvée au sein des lésions est un critère clé de l’avancée de la maladie. A l’aide d’un modèle murin d’athérosclérose accélérée et de travaux d’optimisation technique, nous avons exploré la faisabilité de l’exploitation de l’imagerie par tomographie à émission de positons au fluorure de sodium associée à l’imagerie à résonance magnétique de la pathologie dans un modèle murin d’athérosclérose accélérée. Dans ce travail nous avons mis en évidence une activité de minéralisation précoce et soutenue associée à un statut inflammatoire plus avancé chez les animaux insuffisants rénaux. Ajouté à cela, nous avons mis en place un nouveau modèle murin de rétrécissement aortique calcifié par irradiation localisée. / Atherosclerosis lesions are a leading cause of cardiovascular events. Atherosclerosis is a chronic inflammatory disease including complex molecular and cellular mechanisms. Mineralization process within the atherosclerosis lesions is a key feature of the disease development. Using a mouse model of accelerated atherosclerosis and imaging optimisation study, we showed the feasability of sodium fluoride positron emission tomography combined to magnetic resonance imaging to assess molecular activity in a mouse model of accelerated atherosclerosis. We showed that uremic animals had an early and sustained mineralization activity associated to an advanced inflammatory state. Furthermore, we developped a new mouse model of calcified aortic stenosis using targeted radiation exposure.

Animals as Laboratory Objects: Analysis of the Power Discourse PhDr. Tereza Vandrovcová Abstract This dissertation thesis encompasses a critical discourse analysis of the power correlates of expert knowledge and other factors that can hinder the open and unbiased discussion concerning the ethical aspects of the use of nonhuman animals in biomedical experiments. A brief history of "the animal" is first provided before the issue is positioned within the theoretical framework of Animal Studies. The fourth chapter is composed of an overview of the most frequent arguments both for and against the use of animals in biomedicine. The author draws upon her research as she analyzes scientific texts to reveal how laboratory animals are socially constructed as scientific objects and subsequently describes the effects this has on the perception of their moral value. A series of semi-structured interviews with critics and advocates of animal experimentation, such as animal rights activists and laboratory workers who conduct experiments on animals, is the pivotal section of the paper. It is established that lab workers in the sample are convinced of the necessity and legitimacy of current practices, that lab workers have a tendency to suppress animals' individuality when describing their work, that lab workers deem their...

A functional central nervous system (CNS) is composed of numerous types of neurons. Neurons are derived from a limited number of multipotent neural stem cells. Previous studies have suggested three major strategies nature uses to diversify neurons: lineage identity specification that gives an individual neural stem cell distinct identity based on its position in the developing CNS; temporal identity specification that gives neurons derived from a neural stem cell distinct identities based on their birth-order within the lineage; and binary cell fate specification that gives different identities to the two sister postmitotic neurons derived from the terminal division of a common precursor. Through the combination of the three strategies, almost unlimited neuron types can be generated. To understand neuronal diversification, we have to understand the underlying molecular mechanisms of each of the three strategies. The fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster, has been an excellent model for studying neuronal diversity, mainly due to its easily traceable nervous system and an impressive collection of genetic tools. Studies in fly have provided us fundamental insights into lineage identity, temporal identity, and binary cell fate specifications. Nevertheless, previous studies mostly centered on the embryonic ventral nerve cord (VNC) because of its simpler organization. Our understanding of the generation of neuronal diversity in the fly brain is still rudimentary. In this thesis work, I focused on the mushroom body (MB) and three antennal lobe neuronal lineages, studying their neuronal diversification during postembryonic brain development. In Chapter I, I reviewed the previous studies that have built our current understanding of the neuronal diversification. In Chapter II, I showed that MB temporal identity changes are instructed by environmental cues. In Chapter III, to search for the potential factors that mediate the environmental control of the MB temporal identity changes, I silenced each of the 18 nuclear receptors (NRs) in the fly genome using RNA interference. Although I did not identify any NR important for the regulation of MB temporal identities, I found that unfulfilled is required for regulating axon guidance and for the MB neurons to acquire all major subtype-specific identities. In Chapter IV, I demonstrated that the Notch pathway and its antagonist Numb mediate binary cell fate determination in the three classical antennal lobe neuronal lineages— anterodorsal projection neuron (adPN), lateral antennal lobe (lAL), and ventral projection neuron (vPN)—in a context-dependent manner. Finally, in Chapter V, I did detailed lineage analysis for the lAL lineage, and identified four classes of local interneurons (LNs) with multiple subtypes innervating only the AL, and 44 types projection neurons (PNs) contributing to olfactory, gustatory, and auditory neural circuits. The PNs and LNs were generated simultaneously but with different tempos of temporal identity specification. I also showed that in the lAL lineage the Notch pathway not only specifies binary cell fates, but is also involved in the temporal identity specification.

Emerging evidence in both vertebrates and invertebrates is redefining glia as active and mobile players in synapse formation, maturation and function. However, the molecular mechanisms through which neurons and glia interact with each other to regulate these processes is not well known. My thesis work begins to understand how glia use secreted factors to modulate synaptic function. We use Drosophila melanogaster, a simple and genetically tractable model system, to understand the molecular mechanisms by which glia communicate with neurons at glutamatergic neuromuscular junctions (NMJs). We previously showed that a specific subtype of glia, subperineurial peripheral glia cells (SPGs), establish dynamic transient interactions with synaptic boutons of the NMJ and is required for synaptic growth. I identified a number of potential functional targets of the glial transcription factor, reverse polarity (repo) using ChIP-chip. I found that one novel target of Repo, Wg, is expressed in SPGs and is regulated by repo in vivo. Wnt/Wg signaling plays a pivotal role during synapse development and plasticity, including the coordinated development of the molecular architecture of the synapse. While previous studies demonstrated that Wg is secreted by motor neurons, herein I provide evidence that a significant amount of Wg at the NMJ is additionally provided by glia. I found that Wg derived from SPGs is required for proper GluR distribution and electrophysiological responses at the NMJ. In summary, my results show that Wg expression is regulated by Repo in SPGs and that glial-derived Wg, together with motor neuron-derived Wg, orchestrate different aspects of synapse development. My thesis work identifies synapse stabilization and/or assembly as a new role for SPGs and demonstrates that glial secreted factors such as Wg regulate synaptic function at the Drosophila NMJ.

The minimal element of the nervous system, the synapse, is a plastic structure that has the ability to change in response to various internal and external factors. This property of the synapse underlies complex behaviors such as learning and memory. However, the exact molecular and cellular mechanisms involved in this process are not fully understood. To understand the mechanisms that regulate synapse development and plasticity I took advantage of a powerful model system, the Drosophila larval neuromuscular junction (NMJ). In this system, both anterograde and retrograde signaling pathways critical for coordinated synapse development and plasticity have been documented. An anterograde WNT/Wingless (Wg) signaling pathway plays a crucial role in both developmental and activity-dependent synaptic plasticity at the NMJ. Presynaptic motor neuron terminals secrete highly hydrophobic Wg, which travels to relatively distant postsynaptic sites where it activates a signal transduction pathway required for postsynaptic development. In the first half of my thesis I unraveled a previously unrecognized cellular mechanism by which Wg is shuttled to postsynaptic sites. In this mechanism Wg rides on secreted microvesicles or exosomes that contain a dedicated WNT secretion factor, the WNT-binding transmembrane protein, Evenness Interrupted/Wntless/Sprinter (Evi/Wls/Srt). To our knowledge, this was the first in vivo study demonstrating that neurons release exosomes, which are involved in trans-synaptic communication. Moreover, this was the first study showing that hydrophobic WNT signals are transported to the extracellular space on exosomes to reach WNT-receptor containing target cells. Retrograde signals are also critical during development and plasticity of synaptic connections. These signals function to adjust the activity of presynaptic cells according to postsynaptic cell outputs, to maintain synaptic function within a dynamic range. However, the mechanisms that trigger the release of retrograde signals and the role of presynaptic cells in this signaling event are not clear. In the second half of my thesis, I provided evidence that a crucial component of retrograde signaling at the fly NMJ, Synaptotagmin-4 (Syt4), is transmitted to the postsynaptic cell through anterograde delivery of Syt4 via exosomes. Drosophila Syt4 is known to reside on postsynaptic vesicles at the NMJ and function as a calcium sensor to release a retrograde signal upon synaptic activity. This event is required for coordinated maturation of the presynaptic terminal. We demonstrated that retrograde Syt4 function in postsynaptic muscle is required for activity-dependent presynaptic growth. However, surprisingly, Syt4 protein was not synthesized in postsynaptic muscles. Instead, Syt4 was produced in motorneurons and transferred to postsynaptic muscle cells via exosome secretion by presynaptic cells. The above study provided evidence for a presynaptic control of postsynaptic retrograde signaling through exosomal transfer of an essential retrograde signaling component. In summary, this body of work reveals a novel mechanism of trans-synaptic communication through exosomes. While intercellular communication through exosomes had been demonstrated during antigen presentation in the immune system, our studies were the first to substantiate this mode of communication in the nervous system. Thus, these studies provide a significantly deeper and novel understanding of the mechanisms underlying synapse development and plasticity.

The formation of the anterior-posterior axis requires a symmetry-breaking event that starts gastrulation. Ultimately, the morphogenetic movements of gastrulation reshape the embryo to its final tri-dimensional form. In mouse embryos, the identity of the molecule that breaks the bilateral symmetry and sets in motion gastrulation remains elusive. The Wnt signaling pathway plays a pivotal role during axial specification and gastrulation in metazoans. Loss-of-function experiments have demonstrated a requirement of Wnt3 for gastrulation in mice. But because Wnt3 is expressed sequentially in two tissues, the visceral endoderm and the epiblast, its tissue specific requirements remain uncertain. Here, we report that embryos lacking Wnt3 specifically in the visceral endoderm do not form a primitive streak, mesoderm, endoderm or any derivatives. Visceral endoderm-specific Wnt3 mutants also lack primordial germ cells. Moreover, we provide data demonstrating that Wnt3 carries out its actions in the epiblast via the canonical Wnt pathway. Together, these data suggest that the posterior visceral endoderm via Wnt3, regulates the development of mouse embryos in a similar fashion to the amphibian Nieuwkoop center. Next, we conditionally ablated Wnt3 locus in the epiblast to investigate whether Wnt3 expression is also required in that tissue. Embryos lacking Wnt3 expression in the epiblast, but retaining its expression in the visceral endoderm, show delayed but not absent gastrulation. We conclude that the expression of Wnt3 in the epiblast is required for maintenance but not initiation of gastrulation in mouse embryos. Furthermore, we used in vitro and in vivo approaches to demonstrate that the Wnt3-mediated activation of the canonical Wnt pathway leads to β-catenin occupancy followed by transcription of key loci, including the Wnt3 locus itself, during gastrulation in mice. Our data indicate the presence of an autoregulatory loop in which Wnt3 controls its own expression and orchestrates the process of gastrulation in the mouse embryo.