Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) / In the forensic science community, there is an immense need for tools to help assist investigations where conventional DNA profiling methods have been non-informative. Forensic DNA Phenotyping (FDP) aims to bridge that gap and aid investigations by providing physical appearance information when other investigative methods have been exhausted. To create a “biological eye witness”, it becomes necessary to constantly improve these methods in order to develop a complete and accurate image of the individual who left the sample. To add to our previous prediction systems IrisPlex and HIrisPlex, we have developed the HIrisPlex-S system for the all-in-one combined prediction of eye, hair, and skin color from DNA. The skin color prediction model uses 36 variants that were recently proposed for the accurate prediction of categorical skin color on a global scale, and the system is completed by the developmental validation of a 17-plex capillary electrophoresis (CE) genotyping assay that is run in conjunction with the HIrisPlex assay to generate these genotypes. The predicted skin color output includes Very Pale, Pale, Intermediate, Dark and Dark-to-Black categories in addition to categorical eye (Blue, Intermediate, and Brown) and hair (Black, Brown, Blond, and Red) color predictions. We demonstrate that the HIrisPlex-S assay performs in full agreement with guidelines from the Scientific Working Group on DNA Analysis Methods (SWGDAM), achieving high sensitivity levels with a minimum 63pg DNA input. In addition to adding skin color to complete the pigmentation prediction system termed HIrisPlex-S, we successfully designed a Massively Parallel Sequencing (MPS) assay to complement the system and bring Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) to the forefront of forensic DNA analyses methods. Using Illumina’s MiSeq system enables the generation of HIrisPlex-S’s 41 variants using sequencing data that has the capacity to xiii better deconvolute mixtures and perform with even more sensitivity and accuracy. This transition opens the door for a plethora of new ways in which this physical appearance assay can grow as sequencing technology is not limited by variant number; therefore, in essence many more traits have the potential to be included in this one assay design. For now, the HIrisPlex-S design of 41 variants using MPS is being fully assessed according to SWGDAM validated guidelines; therefore, this design paves the way for Forensic DNA Phenotyping to be used in any forensic laboratory. This new and improved HIrisPlex-S system will have a profound impact on casework, missing persons cases, and anthropological cases, as it is relatively inexpensive to run, HIrisPlex-S is easy to use, developmentally validated and one of the largest systems freely available online for physical appearance prediction from DNA using the freely available online web tool found at https://hirisplex.erasmusmc.nl/. Lastly, moving forward in our aim to include additional traits for prediction from DNA, we contributed to a large-scale research collaboration to unearth variants associated with hair morphology. 1026 samples were successfully sequenced using an inhouse MPS design at 91 proposed hair morphological loci. From this reaction, we were able to contribute to the identification of significant correlations between the SNPs rs2219783, rs310642 and rs80293268 with categorical hair morphology: straight, wavy or curly.

Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) / Forensic DNA phenotyping is an up and coming area in forensic DNA analyses that enables the prediction of physical appearance of an individual from DNA left at a crime scene. At present, there has been substantial work performed in understanding what genes/markers are required to produce a reliable prediction of categorical eye and hair color from the DNA of an individual of interest. These pigmentation markers (variants from HERC2, OCA2, TYR, SLC24A4, SLC45A2, IRF4 to name a few) are at the core of several prediction systems for eye and hair color such as IrisPlex, HIrisPlex, and the Snipper 2.5 suite. The contribution of these markers towards prediction in most cases however, only factors in an independent effect and do not take into account potential interactions or epistasis in the production of the final phenotypic color. Epistasis is a phenomenon that occurs when a gene’s effect relies on the presence of ‘modifier genes’, and can display different effects (enhance/repress a particular color) in genotype combinations rather than individually. In an effort to detect such epistatic interactions and their influence on hair color prediction models, for this current study, 872 individuals were genotyped at 61 associative and predictive pigmentation markers from several diverse population subsets. Individuals were phenotypically evaluated for eye and hair color by three separate independent assessments. Several analyses were performed using statistical approaches such as multifactor dimensionality reduction (MDR) for example, in an effort to detect if there are any SNP- SNP epistatic interactions present that could potentially enhance eye and hair color prediction model performances. The ultimate goal of this study was to assess what SNP-SNP combinations amongst these known pigmentation genes should be included as an additional variable in future prediction models and how much they can potentially enhance overall pigmentation prediction model performance. The second part of the project involved the analyses of several differentially expressed candidate genes between different hair color follicles of the same individual using quantitative Real Time PCR. We looked at 26 different genes identified through a concurrent non-human primate study being performed in the laboratory. The purpose of this study was to gain more insight on the level of differentially expressed mRNA between different hair color follicles within the same human individual. Data generated from this part of the project will act as a pilot study or ‘proof of principle’ on the mRNA expression of several pigmentation associated genes on individual beard hair of varying phenotypic colors. This analysis gives a first glimpse at expression levels that remain constant or differentiate between hairs of the same individual, therefore limiting the contribution of individual variation.

Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) / Modern DNA profiling techniques have increased in sensitivity allowing for higher success in producing a DNA profile from limited evidence sources. However, this can lead to the amplification of more DNA profiles that do not get a hit on a suspect or DNA database and more mixture profiles. The work here aims to address or improve these consequences of current DNA profiling techniques. Based on allele-specific PCR and quantitative color measurements, a 24-SNP forensic phenotypic profile (FPP) assay was designed to simultaneously predict eye color, hair color, skin color, and ancestry, with the potential for age marker incorporation. Bayesian Networks (BNs) were built for model predictions based on a U.S sample population of 200 individuals. For discrete pigmentation traits using an ancestry influenced pigmentation prediction model, AUC values were greater than 0.65 for the eye, hair, and skin color categories considered. For ancestry using an all SNPs prediction model, AUC values were greater than 0.88 for the 5 continental ancestry categories considered. Quantitative pigmentation models were also built with prediction output as RGB values; the average amount of error was approximately 7% for eye color, 12% for hair color, and 8% for skin color. A novel sequencing method, methyl-RADseq, was developed to aid in the discovery of candidate age-informative CpG sites to incorporate into the FPP assay. There were 491 candidate CpG sites found that either increased or decreased with age in three forensically relevant xii fluids with greater than 70% correlation: blood, semen, and saliva. The effects of exogenous microbial DNA on human DNA profiles were analyzed by spiking human DNA with differing amounts of microbial DNA using the Promega PowerPlex® 16 HS kit. Although there were no significant effects to human DNA quantitation, two microbial species, B. subtilis and M. smegmatis, amplified an allelic artifact that mimics a true allele (‘5’) at the TPOX locus in all samples tested, interfering with the interpretation of the human profile. Lastly, the number of contributors of theoretically generated 2-, 3-, 4-, 5-, and 6-person mixtures were evaluated via allele counting with the Promega PowerPlex® Fusion 6C system, an amplification kit with the newly expanded core STR loci. Maximum allele count in the number of contributors for 2- and 3-person mixtures was correct in 99.99% of mixtures. It was less accurate in the 4-, 5-, and 6-person mixtures at approximately 90%, 57%, and 8%, respectively. This work provides guidance in addressing some of the limitations of current DNA technologies.

Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) / In the forensic science community, there is a vast need for tools to help assist investigations when standard DNA profiling methods are uninformative. Methods such as Forensic DNA Phenotyping (FDP) and proteomics aims to help this problem and provide aid in investigations when other methods have been exhausted. FDP is useful by providing physical appearance information, while proteomics allows for the examination of difficult samples, such as hair, to infer human identity and ancestry. To create a “biological eye witness” or develop informative probability of identity match statistics through proteomically inferred genetic profiles, it is necessary to constantly strive to improve these methods. Currently, two developmentally validated FDP prediction assays, ‘HIrisPlex’ and ‘HIrisplex-S’, are used on the capillary electrophoresis to develop a phenotypic prediction for eye, hair, and skin color based on 41 variants. Although highly useful, these assays are limited in their ability when used on the CE due to a 25 variant per assay cap. To overcome these limitations and expand the capacities of FDP, we successfully designed and validated a massive parallel sequencing (MPS) assay for use on both the ThermoFisher Scientific Ion Torrent and Illumina MiSeq systems that incorporates all HIrisPlex-S variants into one sensitive assay. With the migration of this assay to an MPS platform, we were able to create a semi-automated pipeline to extract SNP-specific sequencing data that can then be easily uploaded to the freely accessible online phenotypic prediction tool (found at https://hirisplex.erasmusmc.nl) and a mixture deconvolution tool with built-in read count thresholds. Based on sequencing reads counts, this tool can be used to assist in the separation of difficult two-person mixture samples and outline the confidence in each genotype call. In addition to FDP, proteomic methods, specifically in hair protein analysis, opens doors and possibilities for forensic investigations when standard DNA profiling methods come up short. Here, we analyzed 233 genetically variant peptides (GVPs) within hair-associated proteins and genes for 66 individuals. We assessed the proteomic methods ability to accurately infer and detect genotypes at each of the 233 SNPs and generated statistics for the probability of identity (PID). Of these markers, 32 passed all quality control and population genetics criteria and displayed an average PID of 3.58 x 10-4. A population genetics assessment was also conducted to identify any SNP that could be used to infer ancestry and/or identity. Providing this information is valuable for the future use of this set of markers for human identification in forensic science settings.

Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) / The biological underpinnings that control iris pigmentation and facial morphology are two areas of research that over the last decade are becoming more thoroughly investigated due to the increased affordability of genotyping and advances in technology allowing for more advanced analysis techniques. Despite the ease of access to the data and the tools required to perform iris pigmentation and facial morphological studies, there are still numerous challenges researchers must overcome when exploring the genetics of these complex phenotypes. Some of these challenges include difficulty in working with the bioinformatic programs designed to analyze genetic associations, the inability to define a phenotype that captures the true nature of these traits, and analysis techniques that fail to model complex gene-gene interactions and their effect on a phenotype or phenotypes of interest. In this body of work, I attempted to address these challenges by designing a bioinformatic pipeline, Odyssey, that bridges the communication gaps between various data preparation programs and the programs that analyze genomic data. With this program, genome-wide association studies (GWAS) could be conducted in a quicker, more efficient, and easier manner. I also redefined iris color as a quantitative measurement of pre-defined color classes. In this way it is possible to define and quantify the unique and intricate mixtures of color, which allows for the identification of known and novel variants that affect individual iris color. I also improved upon current prediction models by developing a neural network model capable of predicting a quantitative output to four pre-defined classes; blue/grey, light brown (hazel), perceived green, and dark brown. I examined the effects of defining a simple facial morphology phenotype that more accurately captures the lower face and jaw shape. I then analyzed this phenotype via a GWAS and found several novel variants that may be associated with a square and diamond shaped face. Lastly, I demonstrated that structural equation modeling can be used in combination with traditional GWAS to examine interactions amongst associated variants, which unearths potential biological relationships that impact the multifaceted phenotype of facial morphology.

<div>The biological underpinnings that control iris pigmentation and facial morphology are two areas of research that over the last decade are becoming more thoroughly investigated due to the increased affordability of genotyping and advances in technology allowing for more advanced analysis techniques. Despite the ease of access to the data and the tools required to perform iris pigmentation and facial morphological studies, there are still numerous challenges researchers must overcome when exploring the genetics of these complex phenotypes. Some of these challenges include difficulty in working with the bioinformatic programs designed to analyze genetic associations, the inability to define a phenotype that captures the true nature of these traits, and analysis techniques that fail to model complex gene-gene interactions and their effect on a phenotype or phenotypes of interest.</div><div><br></div><div>In this body of work, I attempted to address these challenges by designing a bioinformatic pipeline, Odyssey, that bridges the communication gaps between various data preparation programs and the programs that analyze genomic data. With this program, genome-wide association studies (GWAS) could be conducted in a quicker, more efficient, and easier manner. I also redefined iris color as a quantitative measurement of pre-defined color classes. In this way it is possible to define and quantify the unique and intricate mixtures of color, which allows for the identification of known and novel variants that affect individual iris color. I also improved upon current prediction models by developing a neural network model capable of predicting a quantitative output to four pre-defined classes; blue/grey, light brown (hazel), perceived green, and dark brown. I examined the effects of defining a simple facial morphology phenotype that more accurately captures the lower face and jaw shape. I then analyzed this phenotype via a GWAS and found several novel variants that may be associated with a square and diamond shaped face. Lastly, I demonstrated that structural equation modeling can be used in combination with traditional GWAS to examine interactions amongst associated variants, which unearths potential biological relationships that impact the multifaceted phenotype of facial morphology.</div>

Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) / In the past, the present and the future, Lebanon has been an important link between the East and the West. It was always known as the ‘Switzerland of the East’. Over the years, it was a hotspot for different civilizations that uniquely shaped the genomic backbone of the current Lebanese. It is also a good representation of genetically admixed individuals with diverse phenotype characteristics and unique features. Lebanon, quite like other Middle Eastern populations, lacks sufficient genetic studies that helps to better comprehend the complex genomic composition of different traits and diseases. The lack of good representation of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region in global studies has led to ambiguity in discovering special ancestry markers and patterns in the Lebanese genome. Yet, in this study, a thorough investigation into a Lebanese collection shows new patterns that potentially would be helpful in forensic and genealogical applications. The investigation into the autosomal and Y-STRs revealed unique alleles that would be valuable in future forensic investigation analysis. In addition, the assessment of phenotype prediction models to predict eye, hair and skin color showed promising results in terms of prediction performance. Those results encourage the future use of intelligence tools in the regions that in return would aid in serving justice and furthering science research. In fact, ancestry and genetic distance studies confirms the presence of admixture within Lebanon between Europe and North Africa. / 2029-06-01

<div><div>In the forensic science community, there is a vast need for tools to help assist investigations when standard DNA profiling methods are uninformative. Methods such as Forensic DNA Phenotyping (FDP) and proteomics aims to help this problem and provide aid in investigations when other methods have been exhausted. FDP is useful by providing physical appearance information, while proteomics allows for the examination of difficult samples, such as hair, to infer human identity and ancestry. To create a “biological eye witness” or develop informative probability of identity match statistics through proteomically inferred genetic profiles, it is necessary to constantly strive to improve these methods. </div><div><br></div><div>Currently, two developmentally validated FDP prediction assays, ‘HIrisPlex’ and ‘HIrisplex-S’, are used on the capillary electrophoresis to develop a phenotypic prediction for eye, hair, and skin color based on 41 variants. Although highly useful, these assays are limited in their ability when used on the CE due to a 25 variant per assay cap. To overcome these limitations and expand the capacities of FDP, we successfully designed and validated a massive parallel sequencing (MPS) assay for use on both the ThermoFisher Scientific Ion Torrent and Illumina MiSeq systems that incorporates all HIrisPlex-S variants into one sensitive assay. With the migration of this assay to an MPS platform, we were able to create a semi-automated pipeline to extract SNP-specific sequencing data that can then be easily uploaded to the freely accessible online phenotypic prediction tool (found at https://hirisplex.erasmusmc.nl) and a mixture deconvolution tool with built-in read count thresholds. Based on sequencing reads counts, this tool can be used to assist in the separation of difficult two-person mixture samples and outline the confidence in each genotype call.<br></div><div><br></div><div>In addition to FDP, proteomic methods, specifically in hair protein analysis, opens doors and possibilities for forensic investigations when standard DNA profiling methods come up short. Here, we analyzed 233 genetically variant peptides (GVPs) within hair-associated proteins and genes for 66 individuals. We assessed the proteomic methods ability to accurately infer and detect genotypes at each of the 233 SNPs and generated statistics for the probability of identity (PID). Of these markers, 32 passed all quality control and population genetics criteria and displayed an average PID of 3.58 x 10-4. A population genetics assessment was also conducted to identify any SNP that could be used to infer ancestry and/or identity. Providing this information is valuable for the future use of this set of markers for human identification in forensic science settings. </div></div><div><br></div>

La reconstruction faciale permet d’approximer un visage sur la base d’un crâne, lorsque des restes humains sont retrouvés. En science forensique, elle est l’un des outils utilisés dans un but d’identification post-mortem. Les procédures actuelles d’approximation ne sont pas standardisées et constamment revisitées. Il est également possible d’obtenir des prédictions du phénotype d’un individu (caractères physiques apparents) à partir de son ADN, qui pourraient être ajoutées aux reconstructions pour maximiser les chances de reconnaissance. Cette recherche vise à étudier l’approximation faciale à des fins de reconnaissance et l’apport du phénotypage par l’ADN à cette pratique. Le crâne et le relevé biologique d’un donneur du laboratoire d’anatomie de l’UQTR ont été utilisés. Six praticiens ont approximé son visage à partir d’une copie de son crâne et de ses données phénotypiques et anthropologiques. Les résultats corroborent qu’il existe un manque de standardisation des méthodes et techniques, menant à différents résultats selon le praticien. Des tests de reconnaissance et de ressemblance ont été effectués à l’aide d’un échantillon de 46 participants. Malgré la variabilité des approximations, elles ont toutes été reconnues au moins une fois lors des tests de reconnaissance, soulevant la possibilité que la reconnaissance d’un visage est idiosyncratique. Les caractéristiques qui semblent influencer davantage la reconnaissance sont la forme, la taille et la position des yeux, de la bouche et du nez. Finalement, au regard des incertitudes propres à la méthode et du rôle investigatif de l’approximation faciale, il est recommandé que le phénotypage accompagne l’accompagne par écrit. / Facial reconstruction is a process by which a face is approximated from a skull when human remains are found. In forensic science, it is one of the many tools used for the purpose of post-mortem identification. The current approximation procedures are not standardized and are always revisited. Nowadays, it is possible to obtain phenotype (apparent physical traits) predictions from an individual’s DNA. These predictions could be added to facial approximations to maximize the chances of recognition. This research aims to study facial approximation for recognition purposes and the plus-value of DNA phenotyping to facial approximation. The skull and biological material from one donor of the UQTR’s anatomy laboratory were used. Six practitioners approximated the donor’s face using a copy of his skull, and phenotyping and anthropological data. The results corroborated the lack of standardization regarding the approximating methods and techniques, which leads to different resulting approximations depending on the practitioner. Recognition and resemblance tests were carried out with a sample of 46 participants. Despite the wide variability of the approximations, they were all recognized at least once during the recognition tests, raising the possibility that the recognition of a face is idiosyncratic. The characteristics that seemed the most important to recognition were the shape, size and position of the eyes, the mouth, and the nose. Finally, with regard to the uncertainties specific to the method and the final investigative role of facial approximation, phenotyping would benefit in feeding a spoken portrait.