Spelling suggestions: "subject:"thesis:political cience."" "subject:"thesis:political cscience.""
311 |
A decade of democracy : comparing trends in support for democracy in South Africa and Brazil since democratic transitionCorkin, Lucy Jane 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--University of Stellenbosch, 2004. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Brazil and South Africa were both part of the global “third-wave” of democracy, the
beginnings of their democratic transitions occurring in 1985 and 1994 respectively.
Despite having been formerly subjected to decades of authoritarian rule, both countries
experienced a modicum of democratic practice, however limited in franchise, under the
previous regimes.
The purpose of this study is to investigate the levels of support for democracy in Brazil
and South Africa since democratic transition. Two types of political support are identified
as crucial for democratic sustainability: diffuse support, or support for democracy’s
intrinsic principles, and specific support, support which is conditional on the positive
evaluation of the regime institutions and incumbents. These two types of political support
are conceptualized as encompassing five levels or objects of political support, according
to the Norris model: the political community, regime principles, regime performance
(diffuse support), regime institutions and political actors (specific support).
This study proposes that because vestiges of democratic norms and practices have been
present within these countries’ political systems for some time, it is possible that they
will manifest trends in support similar to much older, more established democracies.
These global trends indicate that diffuse support for democracy is being maintained while
specific support for democracy is waning.
A longitudinal quantitative study was conducted, using consecutive waves of World
Values Survey to operationalize support for democracy in terms of the five
abovementioned political objects and the results of South Africa and Brazil compared.
These results show that both case studies could be interpreted as having fairly high levels
of diffuse support and decreasing levels of specific support for democracy. It is however
acknowledged that results are not conclusive and further research is required, especially
with respect to how respondents conceptualize the term ‘democracy’. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Brasilië en Suid-Afrika was albei deel van die globale “derde golf” van demokrasie, met
die aanvang van hulle oorgang na demokrasie onderskeidelik in 1985 en 1994. Ten spyte
daarvan dat hierdie twee lande voormalig aan dekades van outoritêre gesag onderwerp is,
het albei, hoewel beperk in stemreg, ’n mate van demokratiese praktyk onder ’n vorige
bestel ervaar.
Die doel van hierdie studie is om die steunvlakke vir demokrasie in Brasilië en Suid-
Afrika sedert hulle oorgang na demokrasie te ondersoek. Twee soorte politieke steun
word geïdentifiseer as deurslaggewend vir demokratiese volhoubaarheid: verspreide
steun – of steun vir die intrinsieke beginsels van demokrasie – en spesifieke steun – steun
wat van die positiewe evaluering van die regime se instellings en ampsbekleders afhang.
Hierdie twee soorte politieke steun word deur vyf konsepte voorgestel wat die vyf vlakke
of voorwerpe van politieke steun volgens die Norris-model dek: die politieke
gemeenskap, regimebeginsels, regimeprestasie (verspreide steun), regime-instellings en
politieke akteurs (spesifieke steun).
Hierdie studie stel voor dat, aangesien spore van demokratiese norme en praktyke vir ’n
geruime tyd binne hierdie lande se politieke stelsels teenwoordig was, dit moontlik is dat
hulle steuntendense sal toon wat aan baie ouer, meer gevestigde demokrasieë soortgelyk
is. Hierdie globale tendense toon dat verspreide steun vir demokrasie gehandhaaf word
terwyl spesifieke steun vir demokrasie aan die kwyn is.
’n Longitudinale kwantitatiewe studie is onderneem wat van opeenvolgende siklusse van
die “World Values Survey” gebruik maak om steun vir demokrasie in terme van die vyf
bogenoemde politieke voorwerpe uit te beeld. Die resultate van Suid-Afrika en Brasilië is
daarna vergelyk. Uit hierdie resultate sou afgelei kon word dat redelik hoë vlakke van
verspreide steun en dalende vlakke van spesifieke steun vir demokrasie in beide gevalle
voorkom. Daar word egter erken dat resultate nie beslissend is nie en dat verdere
navorsing nodig is, in besonder met betrekking tot respondente se begrip van die term
‘demokrasie’.
|
312 |
The politics of bidding and the politics of planning : a comparison of the FIFA World Cup in Germany and South AfricaKachkova, Anna 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA (Political Science))--Stellenbosch University, 2008. / This study focuses on the bidding for sports mega-events, their subsequent planning,
and the politics surrounding these processes. The specific examples analysed here are
those of the FIFA Football World Cup™ in Germany in 2006, and the forthcoming
2010 World Cup to be hosted by South Africa. The events are examined against a
backdrop of increasing competition to host mega-events, spurred on by a widespread
belief in the economic benefits that result from hosting, with a frequent disregard for
the social and economic costs involved. Four central research questions are addressed
in the course of this thesis. The first is the role of corporate actors and their influence
on mega-events, the second is the question of what processes characterise both the
bidding and planning stages of an event, including the main actors, agendas and
discourses involved in both of these stages. Thirdly, the significance of hosting the
World Cup in both the German and South African case is examined, and fourthly, the
long-term implications of South Africa’s hosting of the 2010 World Cup, both for the
country itself and for developing nations more broadly, is considered. The research
methodology used for this thesis is predominately qualitative, and utilises mostly
secondary sources, including books, academic articles, press articles, and information
off the official websites of the football organisations involved. The main findings of
this thesis are that while both countries in question had seemingly compelling reasons
for hosting the World Cup, and while benefits can stem from the event, the longevity
of such benefits is questionable, and the costs involved can be especially heavy in a
developing context such as that of South Africa. Furthermore, those that stand to
benefit the most from the events include transnational corporate actors, with the
implication that significant financial gains never reach the host economy.
Nevertheless, an ever-increasing willingness on the part of numerous nations to host
mega-events means that the German and South African cases can provide lessons for
future hosts, and South Africa’s World Cup has particular significance as a test case
for mega-events hosted by developing nations. Finally, this thesis stresses the need for
further research in this field. It also aims to break some new ground by examining the
commonalities and contrasts to be found in the bidding and planning processes of a
mega-event as carried out by a developed and a developing nation.
|
313 |
CREC7‘s infrastructural investment in the DRC : an in-depth study of the motives for Chinese outward FDIVan Der Lugt, Sanne 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2011. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The purpose of this Masters‘ thesis was twofold, namely, to contribute to a more holistic approach of the study of the motives of Chinese overseas investors and, secondly, to contribute to the adjustment of general FDI theory in such a way that it becomes more suited to the study of the motives of investors from any country of origin. FDI scholars who study emerging markets argue that general FDI theory needs to be adjusted because most of its theories are derived from studying outward FDI in an Anglo-Saxon context. The theories are therefore not necessarily applicable to investors from a non-Anglo-Saxon context. Furthermore, the study of the motives of foreign investors is of importance to policy makers of FDI host countries in order to create a balance between attracting FDI by deregulating, and controlling FDI by enforcing strict laws and regulations, thereby harnessing the full potential of incoming FDI. Therefore, the model that Lee (1966) developed in migration theory was introduced to FDI theory and tested by applying it to the case of the infrastructural investments in the DRC of a subsidiary of CREC, the world‘s largest contractor, namely CREC7. The main factors that influence the motives of CREC7 were investigated using the Four Factors Model, an adjusted version of Lee‘s model. A single-case study design was chosen in order to shed light on certain dynamics – in particular, the interrelation between the particular firm-specific, push, pull and intervening factors that influence CREC7‘s motives to invest in the DRC. In order to maximise the validity of this study, multiple sources of evidence were used, namely: documentation, face-to-face interviews and direct observations, the latter two of which occurred during August 2010. Lee‘s (1966) model indeed appeared to be useful for identifying the main factors that influence the motives of CREC7 for investing in the infrastructure sector in the DRC and the interrelatedness of these factors. The collected data from the desktop research and the fieldwork showed how conditions in the country of origin, conditions in the country of destination, firm-specific factors, and intervening factors influence each other in a highly complex way. In order to illustrate this complexity, the factors that influence each other most actively were grouped together in clusters. The two clusters of factors that were of specific importance for CREC7‘s decision to invest in the DRC, are: (1) relationship with the central government, access to finance, experience and skills, market access, and intervening factors; (2) experience and skills, experience of operating in a challenging institutional environment, high level of competition in the domestic market, high demand for infrastructure in the DRC, and the relatively low level of competition in large infrastructure projects in the DRC. Because the Four Factors Model uses broad categories of factors that apply to all foreign investors, this model can be applied to the study of the motives of foreign investors from both developed and developing countries, thereby contributing to make general FDI theory more relevant. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die doelstelling van dié Meesterstesis is tweevoudig. Eerstens, om `n meer holistiese benadering tot die studie van die motiewe van Sjinese buitelandse beleggers by toe te voeg en tweedens om by te dra tot die aanpassing van algemene direkte buitelandse beleggings teorie dat dit meer bruikbaar vir die studie van die motiewe van beleggers, onafhanklik van hulle land van herkoms, kan wees. Algemene direkte buitelandse beleggings moet aangepas word aangesien meeste van die teorie ontwikkel is deur uitwaartse direkte buitelandse beleggings binne `n Anglo-Saxon konteks. Die studie van die motiewe van buitelandse beleggers is ook belangrik vir beleidsmakers aan die ontvangkant van direkte buitelandse beleggings aangesien `n balans tussen deregulasie met die doel om buitelandse beleggings aan te lok en direkte buitelandse belegging te reguleer deurmiddel van streng wetgewing en sodoende die volle potensiaal van direkte buitelandse belegging te ontsluit. Sodoende is die model wat Lee (1966) ontwikkel het in migrasie teorie toegepas op direkte buitelandse beleggings teorie en getoets op infrastruktuur beleggings in die Demokratiese Republiek van die Kongo (DRK) deur CREC7 `n vleuel van die grootste kontrakteerder CREC. Die hooffaktore wat CREC7 beïnvloed is ondersoek deurmiddel van die Four Factors Model, `n aanpasing van Lee se model, gebruik te maak. `n Enkele gevallestudie was gebruik om lig te werp op sekere verwikkelinge veral die interverhouding tussen verskeie faktore spesifieke tot die maatskappy en die mark wat werk op die beleggingsmotiewe van CREC7 in die DRK. Om die geldigheid van hierdie studie te maksimeer is verskeie bronne gebruik. Naamlik dokumentasie asook onderhoude en direkte observering tydens Augustus 2010. Lee (1966) se model was bruikbaar gewees vir die identifisering van die hooffaktore wat CREC7 se motiewe om te belê in infrastruktuur in die DRK beïnvloed asook die interafhanklikheid tussen hierdie faktore. The versamelde data het geïllustreer hoe omstandighede in die land van oorsprong, die land van ontvangs en omstandighede spesifiek tot die firma mekaar beïnvloed in `n baie komplekse manier. Om die kompleksitieit te illustreer is die faktore wat die meeste op mekaar inwerk in clusters gegroepeer. Die twee clusters wat die meeste op CREC7 se beleggingsbesluit ingewerk het is: (1) verhoudinge met die sentrale regering, toegang tot bevondsing, ondervinding en vaardighede, marktoegang en ingrypende faktore; (2) ondervinding en vaardighede, ondervinding om in `n uitdagende institutionele ongewing, hoë vlakke van kompetisie in die plaaslike mark, hoë aanvraag na infrastruktuur in die DRK. Aangesien die Four Factors Model breë kategorieë van fakore wat van toepassing is op alle buitelandse beleggers kan die model toegepas word op die studie an motiewe van buitelandse beleggers van ontwikkelde en ontwikkelende lande en sodoende daartoe bydra om direkte buitelandse belegging teorie meer relevant te maak.
|
314 |
The impact of HIV and AIDS on democratic consolidation : a comparative assessment of Botswana and South AfricaMeintjes, Cara Hugo 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA )--Stellenbosch University, 2011. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The purpose of this thesis is to assess the impact of HIV and AIDS on democratic
consolidation in two democracies in Southern Africa: Botswana and South Africa. Mattes
(2003), Barnett and Whiteside (2006) and others warned that in states with high HIV
infection levels, the negative impact of the pandemic - especially in terms of socio-economic
conditions, budgetary pressures and a loss of human capital in the state and the economy -
was potentially so great that it may affect democracy detrimentally. In contrast, some
scholars, particularly Anthony Butler (2005a) and Alex de Waal (2006), contended that
although the pandemic had negative effects, democracies might survive it and that in some
specific ways, democratic consolidation might even benefit from the its consequences. For
instance, they argued that in South Africa, the civil society response to the government’s
controversial HIV and AIDS policy deepened the institutional framework of democracy.
The methodology for the above comparative analysis is based on the application of a
minimalist multivariate model which, following the thinking of Bratton and Van de Walle
(1997) consists of both institutional and socio-economic factors. Factors are selected for
their relevance to democratic consolidation, as argued by scholars such as Linz and Stepan
(1996), Przeworski, Alvarez, Cheibub and Limongi (1996), Bratton and Van de Walle (1997)
and Leftwich (2000).
The chosen factors are the system of government (the relationship between the branches of
government); the electoral system; political rights and civil liberties; economic indicators
(affluence, economic growth and the reduction of inequality); human development (as
measured by the United Nations Development Program) and civil society.
This is a descriptive, qualitative, desktop study, using secondary literature in books, as well as
articles. There is no empirical component, such as fieldwork, surveys or questionnaires. As
stated below, such methodology may be used for further elaboration and refining of the
findings of this desktop-based comparative analysis.
The main finding is that currently, despite the cost and human implications of the disease,
there are no indications that it is directly threatening to destroy the democracies of Botswana
or South Africa. This finding differs from the more negative expectations of the scholars
mentioned above. It is suggested that the increasing provision and effectiveness of antiretroviral
treatment (ART) enables these democracies and their economies to avoid some of
the ravages of the disease that seemed inevitable a few years ago. Furthermore, it is suggested
that the comparative affluence of the two states in question shields them from some negative effects of HIV and AIDS and that this may be different in poorer Southern African states.
This is an issue for further research. Such research should go beyond desktop research to
include fieldwork and questionnaires. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die doel van hierdie tesis is om die impak van MIV en VIGS op demokratiese konsolidering
in twee Suider-Afrikaanse demokrasieë, Botswana en Suid-Afrika, vas te stel. Mattes (2003),
Barnett en Whiteside (2006) en ander het gewaarsku dat die negatiewe uitwerking van die
pandemie - veral in terme van sosio-ekonomiese toestande, begrotingsdruk en ’n verlies aan
menslike hulpbronne in die staat en ekonomie - potensieel so groot is dat dit demokrasie
nadelig sou beïnvloed. In teenstelling hiermee het ander akademici, soos Anthony Butler
(2005a) en Alex de Waal (2006), geredeneer dat demokrasieë die pandemie mag oorleef ten
spyte van die negatiewe effekte wat dit wel het en dat demokrasieë selfs op sekere wyses by
die gevolge daarvan mag baatvind. Byvoorbeeld, het hulle geargumenteer, in Suid-Afrika het
die burgerlike samelewing se reaksie op die Mbeki-regering se kontroversiële MIV en VIGSbeleid
die institusionele raamwerk van demokrasie verdiep.
Die metodologie vir hierdie vergelykende analise is gebaseer op die toepassing van ’n
minimalistiese multiveranderlike model. Soos gepostuleer deur Bratton en Van de Walle
(1997), wat beide institusionele en sosio-ekonomiese faktore insluit. Faktore is gekies op
grond van hulle relevansie tot demokratiese konsolidering (volgens vakkundiges soos Linz en
Stepan (1996), Przeworski, Alvarez, Cheibub en Limongi (1996), Bratton en Van de Walle
(1997) en Leftwich (2000), asook vir dié se moontlike relevansie tot demokrasieë wat
spesifiek deur MIV en VIGS geaffekteer word.
Die gekose faktore is die regeringstelsel (die verhouding tussen die uitvoerende, wetgewende
en regsprekende gesag), die verkiesingstelsel, politieke regte en burgerlike vryhede,
ekonomiese aanwysers (welvaart; ekonomiese groei en die vermindering van ongelykheid),
menslike ontwikkeling (soos gemeet deur die Verenigde Nasies se Ontwikkelingsprogram) en
die burgerlike samelewing.
Hierdie tesis is ’n literatuurstudie van ’n beskrywende, kwalitatiewe aard. Daar is gebruik
gemaak van sekondêre literatuur in boeke, asook van artikels. Daar is geen empiriese
komponent soos veldwerk en meningspeilings nie. Soos hieronder beklemtoon word, kan
empiriese metodes in toekomstige studies gebruik word om op die bevindinge wat hierdie
navorsing opgelewer het, uit te brei en dit te verfyn.
Die hoofbevinding is dat daar tans, ten spyte van die finansiële en menslike koste van MIV
en VIGS, geen aanduiding is dat die siekte ‘n direkte bedreiging inhou vir die voortbestaan
van demokrasie in Botswana en Suid-Afrika nie. Hierdie bevinding verskil van die meer negatiewe verwagtinge hierbo uitgespreek. Dit word voorgestel dat die toenemende
voorsiening en effektiwiteit van antiretrovirale behandeling hierdie demokrasieë en hulle
ekonomieë daartoe in staat stel om gedeeltelik die verwoesting van hierdie pandemie te
vermy, iets wat enkele jare gelede nog as onvermydelik beskou is. Verder word die voorstel
gemaak dat die impak van die pandemie op armer Suider-Afrikaanse state vergelyk behoort
te word met die bevindinge wat hier aangebied word. Sulke toekomstige navorsing behoort
nie net literatuurstudie in te sluit nie, maar ook veldwerk en meningsopnames.
|
315 |
EPA negotiations between the EU and SADC/SACU grouping: partnership or asymmetry?Van der Holst, Marieke 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA (Political Science. International Studies))--University of Stellenbosch, 2009. / Europe and Africa share a long history that is characterized both by oppression and
development. The relationship between the European Union (EU) and the African, Caribbean
and Pacific (ACP) countries is a particularly important aspect of EU development cooperation
policy. The developmental history between the EU and Africa started with the Yaoundé
Conventions of 1963 and 1969, which were replaced by the Lomé Convention. Unfortunately,
the favourable terms and preferential access for the ACP countries to Europe failed and the
Lomé Convention was replaced by the Cotonou Partnership Agreement (CPA) in 2000. As a
result of a WTO-waiver, the discriminatory non-reciprocal trade preferences, which were
previously enjoyed under the Lomé Convention, continued until December 2007. The
Cotonou Agreement points out that these trade preferences will be replaced by joint WTOcompatible
Economic Partnership Agreements (EPAs).
During the EPA negotiations, the EU preferred to negotiate on a regional basis
instead of negotiating with the ACP as a whole or with individual countries. Consequently,
Sub-Saharan Africa formed two negotiation groups; the Eastern and Southern Africa (ESA)
EPA group and the Southern African Development Community (SADC) EPA group,
represented by the five Southern African Customs Union (SACU) countries, together with
Mozambique and Angola. Although Southern Africa is the region that leads the continent;
from an economic perspective, the Southern African states show considerable disparities.
Due to the economic differences between South Africa and the BLNS countries (Botswana,
Lesotho, Namibia and Swaziland), the interests of the individual SACU countries are diverse
and often contradictory, which resulted in complicated EPA negotiations. However,
maintaining a favourable long-term trading relationship with the EU is of great importance to
the economic and political well-being of the SADC, since the EU is the main trading partner
of most African countries. By December 2007, an interim EPA (IEPA) was initialled by the
BLNS countries as a result of the pressure to fall back to the unfavourable Generalized
System of Preferences (GSP). Due to the bilateral Trade Development and Cooperation
Agreement (TDCA) that is in force between South Africa and the EU, South Africa was not
negatively influenced by the expiry of the WTO-waiver.
The EPA will have a negative impact on regional integration within SADC and will
promote distinction within the regional economic communities. Duty free, quota free access
was offered to the BLNS countries, but the EU did not extend this offer to South Africa
because of the developmental status of the country and the pre-existing TDCA.
Consequently, South Africa will be required to export at higher prices and will experience
increased competition within the region. The downside of the removal of import tariffs for the
BLNS countries is that government revenues will decrease, which might result in income
losses and will accentuate poverty. The standstill-clause of the IEPA prevents the SACU
countries from diversifying economically and from developing new industries. The Most-
Favoured Nation clause primarily impacts negatively on South Africa, since it prevents South
Africa from negotiating freely with other countries such as Brazil and China. Furthermore, the
strict intellectual property rules of the IEPA undermine access to knowledge and hereby fail
to support innovation. The content of a chapter on liberalization of services, that will be
included in the full EPA, is still being negotiated. Liberalization of services might lead to more
foreign investments in the BLNS countries, as a result of which the quality of services will
increase, leading to better education, infrastructure and more job opportunities. However,
foreign companies will gain power at the expense of African governments and companies.
South Africa is the main supplier of services in the BLNS countries and will therefore be
confronted with economic losses when the services sector is liberalized.
From an economic nationalist perspective, the EU included numerous provisions in
the IEPA that were not necessary for WTO compatibility. However, the EU is aware of the
importance of trade agreements for the BLNS countries and found itself in the position to do
so to fulfil its own interests. By making use of the expiry date of the WTO waiver; the IEPA
was initialled by the BLNS countries within a relatively short period of time. South Africa, in
its own national interests, opposed the provisions of the IEPA, which has led to the
negotiations deadlock.
Because of the economic power and negotiating tactics of the EU and the selfinterested
attitude of South Africa in this respect, regional integration is undermined and the
poorest countries are once again the worst off. Although Economic Partnership Agreements
have to be established, the partnership-pillar is, in my opinion, hard to find.
|
316 |
Liberation movements in Southern Africa : the ANC (South Africa) and ZANU (Zimbabwe) comparedSkagen, Kristin 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis MA (Political Science. International Studies))--Stellenbosch University, 2008. / Liberation movements came into being across the entire African continent as a
political response to colonisation. However, Africa has in this field, as in so many
others, been largely understudied, in comparison to revolutionary movements in
South America and South East Asia. While many case studies on specific liberation
movements exist, very few are comparative in nature. This study will do precisely
that using the framework of Thomas H. Greene.
The resistance movements in South Africa and Zimbabwe, then Rhodesia, consisted
of several organisations, but the ones that emerged as the most powerful and
significant in the two countries were the ANC and ZANU respectively. Although
their situations were similar in many ways, there were other factors that necessarily
led to two very different liberation struggles. This study looks closer at these factors,
why they were so, and what this meant for the two movements. It focuses on the
different characteristics of the movements, dividing these into leadership, support
base, ideology, organisation, strategies and external support. All revolutionary
movements rely on these factors to varying degrees, depending on the conditions they
are operating under. The ANC and ZANU both had to fight under very difficult and
different circumstances, with oppressive minority regimes severely restricting their
actions. This meant that the non-violent protests that initially were a great influence
for the leadership of both movements – especially with the successes of Mahatma
Gandhi in South Africa and India, inevitably had to give way to the more effective
strategies of sabotage and armed struggle. Like other African resistance movements,
nationalism was used as the main mobilising tool within the populations. In South
Africa the struggle against apartheid was more complex and multidimensional than in
Zimbabwe. Ultimately successful in their efforts, the ANC and ZANU both became
the political parties that assumed power after liberation. This study does not extend to
post-liberation problems.
|
317 |
A security community in Africa : a critical assessment of the African Union’s contribution towards the construction of a potential security community since 2002De Vos, Johannes Nicolaas 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2012. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This thesis seeks to provide a critical discussion of the contributions of the African
Union towards the potential development of an African security community since its
inception in 2002. Utilising Security Community Theory, and the framework for the
study of security communities developed by Adler & Barnett (1998) it commences
with an interrogation of the AU. This interrogation is arranged along the three tiers of
the framework.
The first tier is the precipitating conditions, which cause states to orient themselves
in each other’s direction and desire to coordinate their relations. The second tier
investigates the factors conducive to the development of mutual trust and collective
identity. The third, and final, tier identifies the necessary conditions of dependable
expectations of peaceful change.
The study goes on and introduces three African case studies, which illustrate the
contributions of the African Union towards the potential development of an African
security community. The case studies are the African Union mission in Burundi, the
African Union mission in Sudan, and the recent intervention of the African Union in
the post-election crisis in Côte d'Ivoire. All three case studies were able to provide
ample evidence to illustrate the AU’s contributions.
The study concludes with two major findings. Firstly, this study is able to illustrate
that the AU has made significant contributions towards the development of peace
and security in Africa. Secondly, that the AU has made significant contributions at all
three tiers of the framework, and therefore major contributions to the potential
development of an African security community. However, the AU is still in its
embryonic phase, and any prediction concerning the existence, or potential
existence of an African security community would be premature. Even though there are ostensibly, positive developments in the area of continental
peace and security this study is able to illustrate several remaining challenges to
further contributions by the AU. The first is a lack of resources. The AU is heavily
dependent on the contributions of its member states, and a number of members
persistently fail to meet their contributions to the organization. A second challenge is
the loosely defined relationship with the UN (and other external partners). It is crucial that a constructive relationship be established, if not, differences might antagonise
the two organisations and negatively affect any future contributions of the AU
towards the development of an African security community. Finally, the role of core
states, most notably regional hegemons such as South Africa and Nigeria will remain
important for stabilizing and encouraging the further development of an African
security community. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Hierdie tesis poog om n kritiese bespreking te bied van die bydra wat die Afrika Unie
na die potensiele ontwikkeling van n Afrika sekuriteits gemeenskap gemaak het
sedert sy intrede in 2002. Deur gebruik te maak van Sekuriteits Gemeeenskap
Teorie, en die raamwerk vir die studie van sekuriteits gemeenskappe deur Adler &
Barnett (1998) begin die studie met n direkte ondersoek van die AU. Hierdie
ondersoek vind plaas volgens die drie vlakke van die raamwerk.
Die eerste vlak is die kondisies wat veroorsaak dat state hulself na mekaar orienteer,
en n wil ontwikkel om hulle sake te koordineer. Die tweede vlak ondersoek die
faktore vir die ontwikkeling van wedersydse vertroue en gesamentlike identiteit. Die
derde, en finale, vlak identifiseer die nodige kondisies van afhanklike verwagtinge vir
vreedsame verandering.
Die studie gaan voort met drie Afrika geval studies, wat die bydra van die AU na die
potensiele ontwikkeling van n Afrika sekuriteits gemeenskap illustreer. Die geval
studies sluit in die Afrika missie in Burundi, die Afrika missie in Sudan, en die
onlangse intervensie deur die AU in die na-eleksie krisis in Côte d'Ivoire. Al drie
geval studies verskaf wye getuienis wat die bydra van die AU illustreer.
Die studie sluit af met twee hoof bevindings. Eerstens, kon hierdie studie illustreer
dat die AU betekenisvolle bydraes na die ontwikkeling van vrede en sekuriteit in
Afrika gemaak het. Tweedens, dat die AU betekenisvolle bydraes op al drie vlakke
van die raamwerk gemaak het, en daarom ook mondige bydraes tot die potensiele
ontwikkeling van n Afrika sekuriteits gemeenskap gemaak het. Nogtans, is die AU
self nog in n onvolwasse stadium, en enige voorspelling in verband met die bestaan,
of oor die potensiele bestaan van n Afrika sekuriteits gemeenskap is voortydig. Al is daar opmerkilike positiewe ontwikkelinge in die area van kontinentale vrede en
sekuriteit, kan hierdie studie steeds verskeie uitdagings identifiseer wat verdere
bydraes deur die AU kan hinder. Die eerste uitdaging is n tekort aan bevondsing. Die
AU is hoogs afhanklik op die bydrae van sy lidmaat state, maar n paar lede mis
aanhoudend hulle bydraes tot die orginasasie. n Tweede uitdaging is die
ongedefineerde verhouding tussen die AU en die VN (en ander eksterne vennote).
Dit is belangrik dat n konstruktiewe verhouding in werk gestel word, indien nie, kan verskille die twee organisasies van mekaar dryf en enige toekomstige bydraes van
die AU na die potensiele ontwikkeling van n Afrika sekuriteits kompleks negatief
beinvloed. Laastens, sal die rol van kern state, mees aanmerklik streek leiers soos
Suid Afrika en Nigerie, belangrik bly om die sekuriteits kompleks te stabiliseer en
verdere ontwikkeling in die toekoms te bevorder.
|
318 |
Managing political risk : corporate social responsibility as a risk mitigation tool. A focus on the Niger Delta, southern NigeriaMoen, Siri 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2012. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The petroleum industry concern itself with natural resource extracting activities which are highly
sensitive for contributing to environmental degradation by oil spills or gas flaring. A large
proportion of the world’s oil and gas reserves is located in developing countries where the
presence of multinational oil corporations (MNOCs) is high as host countries often lack the
infrastructure needed or are financially unable to conduct extracting operations on their own. The
Niger Delta in southern Nigeria has one of the largest oil reserves in Africa and is one of the
world’s leading oil exporters. MNOCs like Shell, Chevron, Total, ExxonMobil and Statoil are
some of the firms present in the Niger Delta region. The oil-rich area in the developing country
poses high levels of political risk for the MNOCs. Local grievances, paired with environmental
degradation and human rights violations by the oil companies, have led to a tense relationship
between the local stakeholders and the MNOCs, with so-called petro-violence at the center of the
oil conflict. Frequently, oil installations are sabotaged and crude oil is stolen, causing major
financial losses for the firms, and armed attacks on oil facilities and kidnapping of MNOCs’ staff
constitute the majority of political risks facing MNOCs operating in the Niger Delta.
This study investigates how MNOCs can successfully manage such political risks, providing a
business advantage in a challenging business environment. By addressing the companys’ own
behaviour, the research analyses if social engagement through corporate social responsibility
(CSR) can mitigate political risk in the Niger Delta. The study looks at two different MNOCs
operating in the Niger delta, Shell and Statoil, and scrutinises their methods of implementation of
their CSR initiatives. The difference in approaches to CSR is elucidated where Shell claims it
has repositioned its approach from a top-down angle during the first years of conducting CSR
projects, to a more stakeholder-oriented approach. Yet, their approach is still found to carry
elements of the previous top-down approach, and has not resulted in satisfactory performance in
relation to stated goals. Statoil undertakes a stakeholder-oriented bottom-up approach, executed
with a high level of commitment. The stated CSR goals have to a great extent been met. By
assessing the two companies’ CSR strategies in relation to the frequency of political risks
experienced by each MNOC, the study finds that CSR has the potential to mitigate political risk
depending on the approach to implementation, and could serve as a political risk management
strategy. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die brandstofbedryf is betrokke by die ontginning van natuurlike hulpbronne, ’n aktiwiteit wat
hoogs sensitief is vir sy bydrae tot omgewingsbesoedeling as gevolg van storting van olie en
opvlamming van gas. ’n Baie groot deel van die wêreld se olie en gas reserwes word aangetref in
ontwikkelende lande. Die teenwoordigheid van Multinasionale Olie Korporasies (MNOKs) in
hierdie lande is groot omdat daar gewoonlik ’n gebrek aan toepaslike infrastruktuur is en die
lande ook nie finansieel in staat mag wees om die ontginning op hulle eie te doen nie. Die Niger
Delta in die Suide van Nigerië beskik oor een van die grootste olie reserwes in Afrika en is een
van die voorste olie uitvoerders in die wêreld. Shell, Chevron, Total, ExxonMobil en Statoil is
van die bekende MNOK wat ontginning doen in die Niger Delta gebied. Die olieryke gebiede in
’n ontwikkelende land kan groot politieke risiko vir die MNOKs inhou. Plaaslike griewe
gekoppel aan omgewings besoedeling en menseregte skendings deur die oliemaatskappye het
gelei tot ’n gespanne verhouding tussen hulle en die plaaslike belange groepe, en sogenaamde
“petrogeweld” staan sentraal hierin. Heel gereeld word olie-installasies gesaboteer en ru-olie
word gesteel, wat natuurlik groot finansiële verliese die firmas inhou. Daarby word gewapende
aanvalle op die olie-installasies uitgevoer en van die MNOKs se personeel ontvoer. Al hierdie
dinge vorm die groot politieke risiko’s wat die MNOKs in die Niger Delta in die gesig staar.
Hierdie studie ondersoek hoe die MNOKs met welslae hierdie politieke risiko’s kan teenwerk
om vir hulle ’n suksesvolle besigheid te vestig in ’n baie mededingende bedryfsomgewing. Deur
te kyk na die maatskappy se eie gedrag, sal die navorsing analiseer of
gemeenskapsbetrokkenheid deur korporatiewe sosiale verantwoordelikheid (KSV) die politieke
risiko in die Niger Delta kan temper. Die studie kyk na twee verskillende MNOK wat in die
gebied bedryf word, Shell en Statoil, en kyk noukeurig na die manier waarop hulle KSV
inisiatiewe toegepas word. Die verskil in benadering tot die probleem word toegelig deur die feit
dat Shell beweer dat hulle ’n bo-na-onder benadering in die beginjare van KSV projekte
verander het na ’n beleid waar meer na die betrokkenheid van belangegroepe gekyk word. Tog
word gevind dat daar nog oorblyfsels is van die bo-na-onder benadering en dat doelwitte wat
gestel is nie bevredigend bereik is nie. Statoil daarenteen. Implementeer ’n onder-na-bo
benadering met betrokkenheid van belangegroepe en ’n hoë vlak van toewyding deur die
maatskappy. Die gestelde KSV doelwitte is grootliks behaal. Deur te kyk na die twee
maatskappye se ervaring van politieke risiko in verhouding met hulle KSV strategieë bevind
hierdie studie dat KSV wel die potensiaal het om, as dit suksesvol toegepas word, politieke risiko
te temper en dus kan die as ’n strategie om sodanige risiko te bestuur.
|
319 |
African leadership and the role of the presidency in African conflicts : a case study of Uganda's president Yoweri MuseveniBotha, Maryke 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2012. / Includes bibliography / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: As a wave of political uprisings swept across North Africa since January 2011, ridding the region
of longstanding autocratic leaders, presidents in Sub-Saharan Africa were still imprisoning
opposition leaders, deploying military and police to clamp down on protest, and promising their
citizens change - all this in a bid to avoid being ousted by their own people.
Leadership has long been the main constraint on political and economic progress in Africa. This
study analyses African leadership and especially the role of the presidency as a cause of conflict
and instability in Africa.
The modern-day African president might no longer be the absolute autocrat from yesteryear, but
he still rules with awesome power and vast state resources at his disposal. African leaders have
assumed an imperial character; many regard themselves as largely above the law; accountable to
no one and entitled to remain in power or to pass the sceptre to their offspring. Due to this rather
imperial character, conflict has been inevitable in Africa.
As a theoretical basis the study proposes a framework for analysing leaders’ behavioural patterns
that contribute to conflict and instability domestically as well as regionally. Six relevant
behavioural patterns are identified: political deprivation, patronage and clientelism,
personalisation of power, use of the military, staying to office, underdevelopment and conflict.
Additionally, and as a case study, this framework is applied to Uganda’s president Yoweri
Museveni. Each of the six behavioural patterns are analysed and evaluated in relation to
Museveni’s rule of the past 25 years. Applying the framework demonstrates how Museveni
contributed to conflict across the region in Somalia, Sudan, Kenya and the Democratic Republic
of the Congo (DRC). Museveni is found to be a power point man in the region and his imperial
nature is likely to contribute to future instability and conflict in Uganda and the Great Lakes
region.
The study also addresses the genesis of the imperial African leader and investigates why, despite
waves of democratisation and the expulsion of a few autocratic rulers in Africa in the late 1990s,
the imperial character still persist today. Constitutional limitations are found to be one of the major reasons why absolute powers end up being vested in the hands of the president. Lack of
proper separation of powers, and a culture conducive to suppressing the legislature and
parliamentary role, provides additional reasons for this phenomenon.
Furthermore, both internationally and locally, the leadership deficit in Africa is drawing
continuing attention and even funding. However, in order for Africa to make progress in
eradicating poor and unaccountable leadership, local initiatives should be further encouraged.
The African Union Peer Review Mechanism and the African Charter on Elections, Democracy
and Governance are discussed as two African initiatives; also the Mo Ibrahim Index and Prize
are evaluated. Although all three these initiatives are admirable in theory, they have failed to
deliver because real commitment to action is lacking in most African countries.
A speedy and conclusive solution to the problem seems unlikely because of the complex nature
of humans and their environment. Thus, the aim of this study is to make a contribution to the
scholarly body of work regarding the causes of African conflict, focusing on the African
presidency as one cause of such conflict in Africa. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Vanaf Januarie 2011 het ’n vlaag politieke opstande Noord-Afrika getref waartydens weggedoen
is met langdurige outokratiese leiers. In Afrika Suid van die Sahara het heersers egter steeds
opposisieleiers opgesluit en militêre- en polisiemagte ontplooi om opstande die hoof te bied,
terwyl vae beloftes aan die bevolking gemaak word oor moontlike veranderinge.
Swak Afrika-leierskap word dikwels beskou as ‘n belangrike faktor wat politieke en ekonomiese
vooruitgang op die vasteland strem. Hierdie studie analiseer leierskap in Afrika, veral die rol wat
die president speel in die skepping van konflik en onstabiliteit.
Die hedendaagse Afrika-leier mag dalk nie meer voorkom as die absolutistiese outokraat van die
verlede nie, maar hy regeer steeds met oorweldigende mag en ekstensiewe staatshulpbronne tot
sy beskikking. Dit is duidelik dat die Afrika-leier dikwels ‘n imperiale karakter aanneem en
homself verhewe ag bo die wet. In welke geval hy dus geen verantwoording hoef te doen aan
enige ander party nie. Die hoofdoelwit blyk dikwels te wees om beheer te behou. Die
gevolgtrekking wat gemaak kan word, is dat die imperiale karakter van die Afrika-president tot
konflik kan lei. Die teoretiese basis van hierdie studie bied ’n raamwerk om die leiers van Afrika
se gedragspatrone te bestudeer wat aanleiding kon gee tot onstabilitiet asook interne-en
streekskonflik.
Ses gedragspatrone is geïdentifiseer om hierdie proefskrif te illustreer: politieke vervreemding;
beskermheerskap en kliëntilisme; personalisering van mag; gebruik van militêre mag om aan
bewind te bly; gebrek aan ontwikkeling en konflik.
In besonder word hierdie raamwerk toegepas op die president van Uganda, Yoweri Museveni, as
‘n gevallestudie. Hierdeur word aangedui hoe Museveni bygedra het tot konflik, nie net in
Uganda nie, maar inderwaarheid ook in Somalië, Sudan, Kenia en die Demokratiese Republiek
van die Kongo (DRK) tydens sy bewind van die afgelope 25 jaar.
Museveni word allerweë beskou as die “sterkman” in die streek en sy imperiale karakter sal heel
waarskynlik ook in die toekoms bydra tot onstabiliteit en konflik in Uganda en die Groot-
Merestreek. Hierdie studie spreek ook die oorsprong van die imperiale Afrika-leier aan en ondersoek
waarom, ten spyte van die sterk strewe na demokrasie en die omverwerping van outokratiese
leiers in Afrika in die laat 1990s, die imperiale karakter van sodanige leiers steeds kan
voortbestaan.
Konstitusionele beperkings word beskou as een van die hoofredes waarom totale mag in die
hande van ‘n president beland. Gebrek aan behoorlike verdeling van mag en ‘n kultuur
bevorderlik vir die onderdrukking van die wetgewende en parlementêre funksies, is bydraende
redes vir hierdie verskynsel. Verder ontlok die tekortkominge van Afrikaleierskap plaaslik en
internasionaal heelwat aandag en selfs befondsing. Die ideaal sou egter wees dat Afrika
aangemoedig moet word om tot ‘n groter hoogte plaaslike inisiatiewe te gebruik om swak en
onbevoegde leierskap te verwerp. Die African Union Peer Review Mechanism en die African
Charter on Elections, Democracy and Governance word gesien as twee nuttige Afrikainisiatiewe.
Ook die Mo Ibrahim Index and Prize word geëvalueer. Alhoewel al drie inisiatiewe
in teorie goed blyk te wees, het dit misluk as gevolg daarvan dat ‘n verbintenis tot aksie ontbreek
in die meeste Afrika lande.
Waarskynlik is geen spoedige of permanente oplossing vir die konflik moontlik nie – grotendeels
weens die kompleksiteit van mense en hulle omgewing. Dus is die doel van hierdie studie om ‘n
bydrae te maak tot akademiese navorsing betreffende die oorsake van konflik in Afrika en dan
spesifiek hoe die institusionele aard van leierskap in Afrika fungeer as ‘n bydraende oorsaak.
|
320 |
The commodification and commercialisation of peace operations and security operations : a case study of Operation RachelTheron, Jenny 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA (Political Science. International Studies))--Stellenbosch University, 2005. / Peace operations and security co-operations are expensive. Even though there are a variety of factors that influences peace agents when they consider approving a new, expanding an existing, or closing down a peace operation or security co-operation, one of these factors is the cost factor. If we were to isolate the cost factor it would follow that a reduction in the cost of peace operations and security co-operations, are likely to contribute to peace agents being more willing to approve new, expand existing or to give existing missions more time to consolidate before closing them down.
There are a variety of ways how the cost of peace operations or security co-operations can be lowered. This thesis suggests an alliance with the private sector in the form of corporate sponsorships. In short, that peace operations and security co-operations be commodified and commercialised. This would entail introducing corporate sponsorship of some of the commodities that are used in peace operations and security co-operations, followed by the corporate sponsor using their involvement in the peace operation or security co-operation to their commercial advantage. The commodification and commercialisation of peace operations and security co-operations should result in the relevant operations and co-operations benefiting in a cost-effective as well as practical effectiveness sense, whereas the private sponsor should benefit in either or both a financial (profit) or an image-making sense.
The psychological theory supporting such an argument is that of social identity theory. This theory explains how positive connotations made with peacemaking in warlike conditions will motivate industries to use this opportunity to show that their products can succeed in such demanding circumstances. Accordingly, social identity theory provides us with evidence as to how the commercialisation and commodification of peace operations and security co-operations can succeed. We also support our argument by providing a case study, Operation Rachel, which serves as a successful example of an operation that was (partially) commodified and commercialised. Operation Rachel, which can be seen as either or both a peace operation and security co-operation, shows that in the case of security co-operations, these operations should be presented as peace operations during the commodification and commercialisation processes.
|
Page generated in 0.0808 seconds