The dual problem space model of writing (Scardamalia, Bereiter and Steinbach, 1984) shows how writers develop their knowledge and understanding of the world by reflecting on problems of substance and problems of presentation in planning a composition. Reflective thought is attributed to a two-way communication between a content problem space and a rhetorical problem space. The content space involves the development of ideas, while the rhetorical space is concerned with achieving various purposes in composition. This thesis reports an instructional experiment comparing alternative approaches to teaching the self-regulatory strategies required for the two-way process of reflection. The experiment compared the dialogue approach of current practice, which relies on the teacher to provide the linking operations between the two problem spaces, with two experimental approaches which promote development of self-regulatory strategies of reflection, so that students are able to sustain such a two-way process independently. The experimental approaches are described as a guided discovery approach proposed by Evans (1991) and an approach described as cognitive apprenticeship developed by Scardamalia, Bereiter and Steinbach (1984). Three instructional programs were prepared by the author to represent the three alternative approaches examined in the present study. The control program utilised the dialogue approach of current practice in which the dialectical process is carried on between teacher and student. The two experimental programs focused on promoting processes of self-questioning rather than questioning by an external agent such as a teacher. The guided discovery program consisted of activities which prompted self-questioning processes. The cognitive apprenticeship program employed scaffolding in the form of procedural facilitation cues to stimulate the self-questioning process. A pre-test and post-test control group design was used involving three groups, two experimental (guided discovery and cognitive apprenticeship) and one control (dialogue), with instructional method as the independent variable and rated reflectiveness of writing as the dependent variable. Instruction was concentrated on teaching the two-way problem formulating and problem solving strategies of the reflective process for opinion essays and factual exposition essays. The experiment compared the effectiveness of programs by measuring changes in overall reflectiveness of writing. Significant improvements were obtained for the experimental teaching methods withrespect to opinion essays. This research provided some support for the hypothesis that instruction which fosters self-regulation of the planning process through processes of reflection results in more reflective writing than instruction in which such regulation is prompted by the teacher.

Thesis (M. Ed.) -- University of Limpopo, 2019 / The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of guided discovery instructional strategy on the grade 9 learners’ performance in chemical reactions. Secondly, to determine the effect of guided discovery instructional strategy on gender (boy and girl). The quantitative, descriptive and inferential research was conducted to determine if there were any differences between the performance of learners taught using Guided discovery and learners taught using direct instruction. Data collection was done using pre-test and post-test. Two groups of learners participated in the study. The experimental group (n = 40) was taught through Guided discovery. The second was Control Group (n = 35) taught through direct instruction. The findings reveal that guided discovery instructional strategy resulted in better performance of learners in science than direct instruction. Learners expressed an increased interest, motivation and self-efficacy after being exposed to guided discovery. Therefore, the study recommends that teachers need to move learners from dependent direct instruction to more independent learning through guided instruction. KEY TERMS Guided discovery learning, performance, learner

Content analyses of research in the literature of gifted education (Coleman, 2006; Rogers, 1999, 2006) has shown a consistent absence of research investigating methodology for instructing gifted students and for the development of expertise using new technologies. In this study, utilising electronic instructional delivery, an investigation was undertaken of the differential effects and appropriateness of matching the prior knowledge of the learner to the instructional method. Underpinned with a theoretical understanding of gifted education and cognitive load theory, a series of three experiments was designed and implemented to determine whether gifted students learn more effectively under guided discovery design than with example based instruction, while not identified as gifted ability students perform significantly better under direct example based instruction than with guided discovery. Data were collected and analysed in three stages. Experiment 1 was conducted in the novel domain of Boolean switching equations. Experiments 2 and 3 used identical test instruments with novel tasks in the semi-familiar domain of geometry. A total of 155 Years 7, 8 and 9 students at three metropolitan secondary schools participated. The study explored whether the presence of schemas, that facilitated greater problem-solving ability in gifted students, would generate clear evidence of instructional efficiency and preference for either mode of instruction. As students advanced from novice state to expert in particular domains of learning, it was anticipated that gifted students would progress from benefiting from worked example instruction to more efficient learning in guided discovery mode. This hypothesis was rejected as the results from each of the experiments did not confirm the hypothesised outcomes. There was no manifested expertise-reversal effect. The absence of any clear delineation of enhanced learning proficiency mode of instruction for gifted students does, however, contribute to the advancement and understanding of cognitive load theory and the complexity of learning strategies necessary for gifted learners.

This study aimed to investigate the effects of using dynamic geometry software while teaching by guided discovery compared to paper-and-pencil based guided discovery and traditional teaching method on sixth grade students&rsquo / van Hiele geometric thinking levels and geometry achievement. The study was conducted in one of the private schools in Ankara and lasted six weeks. The sample of the study consisted 47 sixth grade students in the school. The present study was designed as pretest-posttest control group quasi-experimental study.In order to gather data, Geometry Achievement Test (GAT) and Van Hiele Geometric Thinking Level Test (VHL) were used. At the end of the research, the data were analyzed by means of analysis of covariance. The results of the study indicated that there was a significant effect of methods of teaching on means of the collective dependent variables of the sixth grade students&rsquo / scores on the POSTVHL after controlling their PREVHL scores, and there was a significant effect of methods of teaching on means of the collective dependent variables of the sixth grade students&rsquo / scores on the POSTGAT after controlling their PREGAT scores.

Content analyses of research in the literature of gifted education (Coleman, 2006; Rogers, 1999, 2006) has shown a consistent absence of research investigating methodology for instructing gifted students and for the development of expertise using new technologies. In this study, utilising electronic instructional delivery, an investigation was undertaken of the differential effects and appropriateness of matching the prior knowledge of the learner to the instructional method. Underpinned with a theoretical understanding of gifted education and cognitive load theory, a series of three experiments was designed and implemented to determine whether gifted students learn more effectively under guided discovery design than with example based instruction, while not identified as gifted ability students perform significantly better under direct example based instruction than with guided discovery. Data were collected and analysed in three stages. Experiment 1 was conducted in the novel domain of Boolean switching equations. Experiments 2 and 3 used identical test instruments with novel tasks in the semi-familiar domain of geometry. A total of 155 Years 7, 8 and 9 students at three metropolitan secondary schools participated. The study explored whether the presence of schemas, that facilitated greater problem-solving ability in gifted students, would generate clear evidence of instructional efficiency and preference for either mode of instruction. As students advanced from novice state to expert in particular domains of learning, it was anticipated that gifted students would progress from benefiting from worked example instruction to more efficient learning in guided discovery mode. This hypothesis was rejected as the results from each of the experiments did not confirm the hypothesised outcomes. There was no manifested expertise-reversal effect. The absence of any clear delineation of enhanced learning proficiency mode of instruction for gifted students does, however, contribute to the advancement and understanding of cognitive load theory and the complexity of learning strategies necessary for gifted learners.

Ledarstilars påverkan på idrottarens prestation och psykologiska tillstånd har visat sig vara signifikant och betydelsefull. Valet av ledarstil från en tränare kan både förbättra och försämra en individens prestation. Det har också visat sig påverka idrottarens upplevda ångest och självförtroende inom flera sporter. Dock finns det bristande kunskap om hur ledarstilar påverkar idrottarnas ångest och självförtroende inom klättring, vilket denna interventionsstudie ämnar undersöka. Ledarstilarna som används i studien inkluderar Direkt och Guided discovery och har definierats utifrån relevant litteratur. Ledarstilarnas effekt på klättrarnas upplevda ångest och självförtroende mättes med hjälp av Competitive State Anxiety Inventory - 2 Revised (CSAI-2R). Urvalet bestod av 40 deltagare i åldern 18-40 år, varav 10 var kvinnor (25%) och 30 var män (75%), som randomiserades till två grupper (Direkt och Guided Discovery). Forskningsfrågan besvarades genom upprepade ANOVA-test där resultaten från CSAI-2R jämfördes mellan de olika ledarstilarna. Inga signifikanta interaktionseffekter mellan ledarstil och test (före och efter) återfanns för någon av utfallsvariablerna. Dock fanns signifikanta resultat gällande förändringar i upplevd kognitiv och somatisk ångest oberoende av ledarstil. Således uppmuntras framtida forskning att vidare undersöka om ledarstilar har en signifikant påverkan på idrottarnas upplevda ångest och självförtroende eller inte, samt om det finns andra faktorer som kan ha en större betydande effekt på idrottarnas psykologiska tillstånd än ledarstilar. / The impact of leadership styles on athletes' performance and psychological state has been shown to be significant and meaningful. The choice of leadership style by a coach can both improve and impair an individual's performance. It has also been found to affect athletes' perceived anxiety and self-confidence in several sports. However, there is a lack of knowledge regarding the influence of leadership styles on athletes' anxiety and self-confidence in the sport of climbing, which this study aims to investigate. The leadership styles used in the study include Direct and Guided Discovery, and they have been defined based on relevant literature. Perceived anxiety and self-confidence were measured using the Competitive State Anxiety Inventory - 2 Revised (CSAI-2R). The sample consisted of 40 participants between the ages of 18 and 40, including 10 women (25%) and 30 men (75%), who were divided into two groups (Direct and Guided Discovery). The research question was answered through repeated ANOVA tests, where the results from the CSAI-2R were compared across the different leadership styles. No significant difference was found between the leadership styles. However, there were significant results regarding changes in perceived cognitive and somatic anxiety independent of the leadership style. Therefore, future research is encouraged to further investigate whether leadership styles have a significant impact on athletes' perceived anxiety and self-confidence or not, as well as whether there are other factors that may have a greater significant effect on athletes' psychological state than leadership styles.

Aim and research questions The over-all aim of this study was to gain insight info how two male coaches of a specific soccer team behave in a practice environment with regards to educating the players. More specifically, the study sought to map the extent to which said behaviour matched two specific methods of learning; these being Teaching Games for Understanding (TgfU) and Enhanced Guided Discovery (EGD). Research questions: (1) Do the coaches employ the methods and guidelines, which are outlined in the educational plan provided by the soccer association? If so, what form does this application take in practice? (2) To what extent and in what ways do the coaches utilize feedback and questioning techniques in the education of players? (3) What similarities and differences in behaviour can be identified between the chosen soccer team’s two coaches? Method: The data for the study was collected through field observation. The subjects were two youth elite soccer coaches and observation of these coaches took place during five regular practice sessions on the soccer field. All data gathering and analysis were carried out using a modified version of the Coach Analysis and Intervention System (CAIS). Apart from the twenty-one original coaching behaviours of the CAIS, this specific modification also included two training forms with related training activities. These training forms are called training form and playing form. Results: The analysis showed that they utilized the teaching methods, specifically the TGfU and EGD, both when planning and executing practice sessions. The most common kinds of feedback that were used were specific positive and general positive feedback. The coaches frequently relied on questioning as an educational technique during practice, with open questions being the most commonly used type. The observations revealed several similarities and some differences in behaviour between the coaches. Conclusion: The methods that the two coaches employ when training their players correspond to the methods laid out in TGfU and EGD. Both coaches rely heavily on questioning and feedback as behavioural techniques, with open questions and specific positive feedback being among their most common teaching behaviours. The study shows that the practical behaviour of the coaches is firmly based in theories of learning and long-term athletic development. In this way, the coaches have managed to create a learning environment that is successful over time. / Syfte och frågeställningar Syftet med denna studie är att, genom observationer av en manlig huvudtränare och en manlig assisterande tränare för ett specifikt fotbollslag, samla kunskap om hur tränarna beter sig i träningsmiljö i avseende att ut-veckla sina spelare. Syftet är även mer specifikt att undersöka om, och i så fall hur tränarnas beteenden är kopplade till inlärningsmetoderna Teaching Games for Understanding (TGfU) och Enhanced Guided Discovery (EGD). Studiens frågeställningar var: (1) Arbetar fotbollstränarna med de metoder och riktlinjer för inlärning som står skrivet i föreningens spelarutbildningsplan? Hur arbetar de i så fall? (2) Hur arbetar dessa två fotbollstränare med feedback och frågeteknik till sina spelare? (3) Finns det någon/några likheter och/eller skillnader i beteende för de två fotbollstränarna för samma lag? Metod Metoden för att samla in data till denna studie var genom observationer. Deltagarna i studien bestod av två fotbollstränare på ungdomselitnivå (U17). Observationerna av tränarna skedde i deras träningsmiljö, på fotbollsplan under fem träningstillfällen. Observationsinstrumentet som användes i studien var en modifierad version av Coach Analysis and Intervention System (CAIS). Studiens observations-instrument innehåller 21 ursprungliga tränarbeteenden. Denna modifiering av CAIS innehåller även två träningsformer med tillhörande träningsaktiviteter. Dessa träningsformer är training form och playing form. Resultat Observationerna visade att tränarna använde sig av de två inlärningsmetoderna TGfU och EGD när de strukturerade sina träningar, samt när de agerade under träningarna. Vanligast förekommande feedback som användes var specifik positiv- och generell positiv feedback. Tränarna använde sig ofta av frågeteknik under träning, den vanligaste typen av frågor var öppna frågor. Det fanns många likheter i beteende mellan tränarna, men även vissa skillnader. Slutsats Sammanfattningsvis är analysen att tränarna använder sig av metoderna för inlärning; TGfU och EGD i träningsmiljö med sina spelare. Frågeteknik i form av öppna frågor, samt specifik positiv feedback var bland de vanligast använda beteendena hos båda tränarna. Resultatet av observationerna påvisar en nära anknytning mellan tränarnas praktik och teorier kring inlärning och långsiktig idrottslig utveckling. Sålunda lyckas tränarna med tiden forma ett inlärningsklimat som är hållbart över tid.

My inquiry, centered on the applied practice of teaching, confronts the detachment that often disassociates the intellectual study of music theory from the physical experience of music. This pedagogical detachment, perceived as a split between opposing views of knowledge, privileges positivist science over interpretive art (Aróstegui, 2003), producing written competencies that have little or no musical meaning (Rogers, 2004). Endeavouring to re-attach music theory and the music it was initially intended to explain (Dirié, 2014), I constructed four Listening Guides to align with the intermediate-level theory curriculum of the Royal Conservatory of Music. Their construction incorporates elements of design research along with an underlying framework derived from the Kodály Method’s four-step instructional process. Given my multi-faceted personal/professional interactions with music theory, my research project is presented in the form of a quest narrative that weaves together my story and the stories of participant teachers who established the Listening Guides’ potential usefulness through reviewing and implementing interactions. This narrative, as a creative representation of arts-based research practices (Leavy, 2015), is derived from the blurring of specific cognitive findings and less definable aesthetic knowings (Greenwood, 2012). My data, both the prototypical data I designed and the empirical data I collected from focus group discussions with my participants, are filtered through an a/r/tographic lens that acknowledges the coexistence of my artist/researcher/teacher identities. The analysis of our aggregate narrative, as an exploration of music theory pedagogy with, about, in, and through music, relies on the evaluative tools of educational criticism (Eisner, 1991). Unfolding in a mostly linear climb, my quest for a fully integrated music/theory (art/science) pedagogy reaches its apex in the understanding that a music-logic organization confounds the subject-logic of traditional teaching approaches. Thus, my inquiry challenges the customary practices of scientific knowledge-building with a model for artistic “ways-of-knowing” in music theory pedagogy.