Made available in DSpace on 2014-07-29T16:21:18Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 Dissertacao Fernando Landa Sobral.pdf: 687284 bytes, checksum: 9d1a927bc9b256832a9a05b06ad62d7e (MD5) Previous issue date: 2011-05-26 / Communities are assemblages of co-occurring species that potentially interact with each other. They are the result not only of a series of ecological processes or "assembly rules", but also of past and ongoing evolutionary processes. In recent years, the assembly rules have received increased attention from ecologists and two different processes have been explored: environmental filtering and limiting similarity. As the processes involved in the formation of the assemblages appear to vary in a manner dependent on scale, it is expected that such assembly rules have different effects over different spatial scales. Understanding this relationship between ecological processes and spatial scales in which they act has been a great challenge among scholars. In this context, the incorporation of phylogenetic and functional data to diversity classical approaches have established the basis for an emerging area of research in community ecology, promoting the development of many tools to detect the underlying structure of the assemblages and, therefore, to infer the processes assembly responsible for the formation of the assemblages. Here, we demonstrate how the use of different measures of phylogenetic and functional diversity along with the use of different null models can be a promising approach in solving paradigms still poorly understood, discussing how such methods can increase the predictive power of this growing area of research. / As comunidades são assembleias de espécies co-ocorrentes que interagem potencialmente umas com as outras. Elas são resultado não apenas de uma série de processos ecológicos ou regras de montagem , mas também de processos evolutivos passados e contínuos. Nos últimos anos, as regras de montagem têm recebido maior atenção dos ecólogos e dois processos diferentes têm sido explorados: os filtros ambientais e a similaridade limitante. Como os processos envolvidos na formação das assembleias parecem variar de uma forma dependente de escala, espera-se que tais regras de montagem tenham diferentes efeitos ao longo de diferentes escalas espaciais. Compreender essa relação entre os processos ecológicos e as escalas espaciais nas quais eles atuam tem sido um grande desafio entre os estudiosos. Nesse contexto, a incorporação de dados filogenéticos e funcionais às abordagens clássicas de diversidade tem estabelecido a base de uma emergente área de pesquisa em ecologia de comunidades, impulsionando o desenvolvimento de muitas ferramentas para detectar a subjacente estrutura das assembleias e, portanto, inferir os processos de montagem responsáveis pela formação das assembleias. Aqui, demonstramos como a utilização de diferentes medidas de diversidade filogenética e funcional juntamente com o uso de diferentes modelos nulos pode ser uma abordagem promissora na solução de paradigmas ainda pouco compreendidos, discutindo como tais métodos podem aumentar o poder preditivo dessa crescente área de pesquisa.

Os paradigmas da teoria de metacomunidades atribuem diferentes graus de importância à dispersão, filtros ambientais, interações bióticas e processos estocásticos na organização de comunidades. Incluir atributos funcionais em conjunto com aspectos espaciais da estrutura da paisagem pode resultar em uma poderosa ferramenta para a investigação dos diferentes processos que atuam na organização de comunidades biológicas. Neste estudo, utilizamos o potencial de análise e de levantamento de hipóteses que os atributos funcionais proporcionam em uma metacomunidade de peixes, formada por 37 lagoas em uma bacia hidrográfica na região costeira do sul do Brasil (29º37’ a 30º30’ de latitude Sul e 49º74’ a 50º24’ de longitude Oeste). Os objetivos deste trabalho foram identificar qual é a relação entre a diversidade taxonômica com índices de redundância e diversidade funcional. Também verificar se variáveis espaciais são determinantes na variação de índices funcionais, e das composições taxonômica e funcional, e se ocorrem padrões de convergência e de divergência de atributos. Através de sistemas de informação geográfica (imagens Spot e Landsat-TM5), estas lagoas foram mapeadas e delas foram obtidas variáveis estruturais (área, forma, distância do mar, coeficiente de variação da área, conectividade primária e conectividade estuarina). Os dados da ictiofauna foram obtidos através de amostragem padronizada, utilizando-se redes de espera, e uma série de atributos relacionados às habilidades de dispersão e de uso de recursos alimentares foram tomados. A diversidade taxonômica demonstrou ser fortemente correlacionada com a redundância e a diversidade funcional. Os modelos que melhor explicam a redundância funcional são aqueles que incluíram a forma e o coeficiente de variação da área das lagoas, mas a diversidade funcional não foi predita significativamente por nenhuma variável espacial. Não foram encontrados padrões de convergência e de divergência de atributos, e lagoas semelhantes em suas características espaciais não possuem composição funcional similar. Nossos resultados sugerem que o paradigma neutro de metacomunidades é a abordagem que melhor explica a estruturação deste sistema, o qual prediz equivalência funcional entre espécies. / The metacommunity theory paradigms attribute different degrees of importance to dispersal, environmental filtering, biotic interactions and stochastic processes in community assembly. To include the jointly use of functional traits with the spatial aspects of landscape structure could result in a powerful tool for the investigation of the different processes involved in the organization of biological communities. In this study, we used the potential of analysis and survey of hypotheses that functional traits provide in a fish metacommunity, composed by 37 lagoons in a river basin in the coastal region of southern Brazil (29º37' to 30°30' south latitude and 49º74' to 50°24' west longitude). The aims of this work were to identify the relation between taxonomic diversity indices with redundancy and functional diversity. Also, it was verified if spatial variables are determinants for the variation in functional indices, taxonomic and functional composition of fishes. We also look for trait convergence and trait divergence assembly patterns. Through geographic information systems (Spot e Landsat-TM5 images), these lagoons were mapped and were quantified structural variables (area, shape, distance to the ocean, coefficient of variation of area, primary connectivity and estuarine connectivity). Ichthyofauna data were obtained through standardized sampling, using gillnets, and a set of traits related to dispersal abilities and use of food resource were obtained. The taxonomic diversity showed to be strongly correlated with functional diversity and redundancy. The models that best explain the functional redundancy are those involving the shape and area variation coefficient, however, the functional diversity was not significantly predicted by any spatial variable. We did not find trait convergence and trait divergence assembly patterns, and lagoons that share similar spatial features do not have similar functional composition. Our results suggest that the neutral metacommunity paradigm is the approach which has the best explanation for the structure of this system, which predicts functional equivalence among species.

Les modèles d'occupation de niche au sein des communautés locales, la variabilité spatiale de la biodiversité le long des gradients environnementaux du stress et des perturbations, et les processus de succession végétale sont plusieurs sujets fondamentaux en écologie. Récemment, l'approche basée sur les traits est apparue comme un moyen prometteur de comprendre les processus structurant les communautés végétales et cette approche a même été proposée comme méthode pour reconstruire l'écologie communautaire en fonction des traits fonctionnels. Par conséquent, lier ces thèmes fondamentaux en utilisant une lentille fonctionnelle devrait nous donner un aperçu de certaines questions fondamentales en écologie et sera l'objectif principal de ma thèse. En général, mon projet de doctorat vise à étudier les structures de l'occupation de l'espace fonctionnel dans les gradients spatio-temporels. Plus précisément, l'objectif du chapitre 2 est (i) d'étudier les modèles d'occupation de la niche fonctionnelle en calculant trois métriques clés de niche (le volume total de niche fonctionnelle , le chevauchement des niches fonctionnelles et le volume de niche fonctionnel moyen) des communautés pauvres en espèces aux communautés riches en espèces et (ii) de déterminer le principal facteur de la structure observée de l'occupation de la niche fonctionnelle dans les communautés végétales du monde entier. Dans le chapitre 3, je vise à prédire et à expliquer la variation de la richesse en espèces selon les gradients de stress et de perturbation, en reliant le modèle d'équilibre dynamique et l'occupation de la niche fonctionnelle en fonction du cadre développé au chapitre 2. L'objectif du chapitre 4 est de tester expérimentalement l’application d'une méthode d'ordination CSR évaluée globalement en fonction de trois traits de feuilles (surface foliaire, teneur en matière sèche des feuilles et surface foliaire spécifique) dans les études locales. Enfin, l'objectif du chapitre 5 est de tester expérimentalement les hypothèses qui concilient les points de vue déterministes et historiquement contingents de la succession végétale, en étudiant la variation des divergences taxonomiques et fonctionnelles entre les communautés selon des gradients de stress et de perturbation. L'étude globale (chapitre 2) est basée sur une collection de 21 jeux de données, couvrant les biomes tropicaux et tempérés, et se compose de 313 communautés végétales représentant différentes formes de croissance. Les études locales (chapitre 3, 4 et 5) sont basées sur le même système expérimental constitué de 24 mésocosmes présentant différents niveaux de stress et de perturbation. L'expérience a commencé en 2009 avec le même mélange de graines de 30 espèces herbacées semées sur les 24 mésocosmes et s'est terminée en 2016. Nous avons permis la colonisation naturelle de graines de la banque commune de graines de sol et de l'environnement pendant la succession de sept ans. Dix traits ont été mesurés sur cinq individus (échantillonnés directement à partir des mésocosmes) par espèce par mésocosme en 2014 (chapitre 3 et 4). Un autre ensemble de traits (16 traits, y compris certains traits qui ne pouvaient pas être mesurés directement dans les mésocosmes), ont été mesurés au niveau de l'espèce (valeurs moyennes des traits) pour les 34 espèces les plus abondantes (certaines espèces disparues dans les mésocosmes) au cours des sept Ans, en les regroupant séparément pour une saison de croissance. Au chapitre 2, nous avons constaté que les communautés étaient plus diverses en termes fonctionnels (une augmentation du volume fonctionnel total) dans les communautés riches en espèces et que les espèces se chevauchaient davantage au sein de la communauté (augmentation du chevauchement fonctionnel), mais ne divisaient pas plus finement l'espace fonctionnel (aucune réduction du volume fonctionnel moyen). En outre, le filtrage de l'habitat est un processus répandu qui conduit à la caractérisation de l'occupation de niche fonctionnelle dans les communautés végétales. Dans le chapitre 3, nous avons trouvé un modèle similaire d'occupation de niche fonctionnelle sur un système expérimental avec une taille spatiale communautaire constante et un effort d'échantillonnage des traits, qui, avec le chapitre 2, nous a fourni une image plus complète et plus solide de l'occupation de niche fonctionnelle dans les communautés végétales. De plus, nous avons réussi à relier le modèle de l'occupation de la niche fonctionnelle et le modèle d'équilibre dynamique et avons constaté que le filtrage concurrentiel était le processus dominant qui détermine le mode d'occupation de la niche fonctionnelle et la richesse des espèces le long du stress et de la perturbation des gradients. Au chapitre 4, nous fournissons un soutien empirique à une méthode d'ordination CSR calibrée globalement en montrant une relation entre l'abondance relative d'espèces en croissance dans les mésocosmes ayant différents niveaux de fertilité du sol et mortalité indépendante de la densité et leur classification CSR. Au chapitre 5, nous avons montré que la succession d'installations au cours de sept ans dans ces mésocosmes était plus déterministe d'un point de vue fonctionnel, mais plus historiquement contingent d'un point de vue taxonomique et que l'importance relative de la contingence historique a diminué à mesure que l'environnement devenait plus stressé ou perturbé. En conclusion, les structures de l'occupation de l'espace fonctionnel dans (le volume fonctionnel total, le chevauchement fonctionnel et le volume fonctionnel moyen, les Chapitre 2 et 3) ou entre les communautés locales (dissimilarité fonctionnelle, chapitre 5) sont déterministes plutôt que neutres (ou contingence historique ). Les espèces tolératrices de stress sont plus avantagées dans les mésocosmes moins fertiles tandis que les espèces rudérales sont plus avantagées dans les mésocosmes avec plus de mortalité indépendante de la densité. / Abstract : The patterns of niche occupancy within local communities, the spatial variability of biodiversity along environmental gradients of stress and disturbance, and the processes of plant succession are several fundamental topics in ecology. Recently, the trait-based approach has emerged as a promising way to understand the processes structuring plant communities and has even been proposed as a method to rebuild community ecology based on functional traits. Therefore, linking these fundamental themes through a functional lens should give us more insight into some basic questions in ecology and will be the main objective of my thesis. Generally, my PhD project is to investigate the structures of functional space occupancy along both spatial and temporal gradients. Specifically, the objective of Chapter 2 is to investigate the patterns of functional niche occupancy by calculating three key niche metrics (the total functional niche volume, the functional niche overlap and the average functional niche volume) from speciespoor communities to species-rich communities and to determine the main driver of the observed pattern of functional niche occupancy across plant communities worldwide. In Chapter 3, I aim to predict and explain the variation of species richness along gradients of stress and disturbance, by linking the dynamic equilibrium model and functional niche occupancy based on the framework developed in Chapter 2. The objective of Chapter 4 is to experimentally test the application of a globally calibrated CSR ordination method based on three leaf traits (leaf area, leaf dry matter content and specific leaf area) in local studies. Finally, the aim of Chapter 5 is to experimentally test the hypotheses reconciling the deterministic and historically contingent views of plant succession, by investigating the variation of taxonomic and functional dissimilarities between communities along gradients of stress and disturbance. The global study (Chapter 2) is based on a collection 21 trait datasets, spanning tropical to temperate biomes, and consisting of 313 plant communities representing different growth forms. The local studies (Chapter 3, 4 and 5) are based on the same experimental system consisting of 24 mesocosms experiencing different levels of stress and disturbance. The experiment started in 2009 with the same seed mixture of 30 herbaceous species broadcast over the 24 mesocosms and ended in 2016. We allowed natural colonization of seeds from the common soil seed bank and from the surroundings during the seven-year succession. Ten traits were measured on five individuals (sampled directly from the mesocosms) per species per mesocosms in 2014 (Chapter 3 and 4). Another set of traits (16 traits including some traits that were not able to measured directly in the mesocosms) were measured at the species level (species mean traits values) for the 34 most abundant species (some species disappeared in the mesocosms) over the seven years, by regrowing them separately for one growing season. In Chapter 2, we found communities were more functionally diverse (an increase in total functional volume) in species-rich communities, and species overlapped more within the community (an increase in functional overlap) but did not more finely divide the functional space (no decline in average functional volume). Moreover, habitat filtering is a widespread process driving the pattern of functional niche occupancy across plant communities. In Chapter 3, we found a similar pattern of functional niche occupancy on an experimental system with a constant community spatial size and trait-sampling effort, which together with Chapter 2 provided us a more comprehensive and robust picture of functional niche occupancy across plant communities. In addition, we succeeded in linking the pattern of functional niche occupancy and the dynamic equilibrium model and found that habitat filtering was the dominant process determining the pattern of functional niche occupancy and species richness along the gradients stress and disturbance. In Chapter 4, we provide empirical support for a globally calibrated CSR ordination method by showing a relationship between the relative abundance of species growing in mesocosms having different levels of soil fertility and density-independent mortality and their CSR classification. In Chapter 5, we showed that plant succession over seven years in these mesocosms was more deterministic from a functional perspective but more historically contingent from a taxonomic perspective, and that the relative importance of historical contingency decreased as the environment became more stressed or disturbed. In conclusion, the structures of functional space occupancy within (the total functional volume, the functional overlap and the average functional volume; Chapter 2 and 3) or between local communities (functional dissimilarity, Chapter 5) are deterministic rather than neutral (or historical contingency). Stress-tolerators were more favored in high stress communities, while ruderals are more favored in high disturbed mesocosms (Chapter 4).