This thesis investigates the effect of added asphalt binder content on the performance and volumetric properties of asphalt concrete mixes containing Reclaimed Asphalt Pavement (RAP). Mixes with three different percentages of RAP (0%, 20%, 40%) obtained from an asphalt producer and three different percentages of asphalt binder (design asphalt content, design +0.5%, and design +1.0%) were evaluated. Additionally, a laboratory produced mix containing 100% RAP with four asphalt binder contents (0.0%, 0.5%, 1.0% and 1.5%) was also evaluated in order to determine the binder level that optimizes mix performance for the extreme case in RAP utilization. Performance of the mixtures was evaluated based on three criteria: stiffness (dynamic modulus), fatigue resistance (flexural beam), and rutting resistance (flow number). Results showed that a 0.5% increase in binder content improved both the fatigue and rutting resistance of the 0% and 20% RAP mixes with only slight decreases in dynamic modulus. However, the addition of various amounts of binder to the 40% RAP mix led to a significant decrease in rutting resistance with little or no improvement to fatigue resistance. Volumetric analysis was performed on all of the mixes to determine how the added binder content affected mix volumetric properties. Results of volumetric testing, specifically asphalt content and Voids in the Total Mix (VTM) at the design compaction effort, Ndesign, revealed that the 40% RAP mix incorporated a significantly higher level of binder during plant production which very likely contributed to the decrease in rutting resistance once additional binder was added in the laboratory. Additionally, the gyratory compaction effort that would result in 4 percent VTM at the optimal binder content over the three performance tests, N4%, was calculated for each mix. Results indicated that the VTM for the optimally performing 20% and 40% RAP mixes were well below current Virginia Department of transportation (VDOT) production standards. In addition, N4%, for the optimally performing 20% and 40% RAP mixes was 50% or less than the current design compaction effort of 65 gyrations. / Master of Science

Master of Science / Department of Civil Engineering / Mustaque Hossain / The ultra-thin bonded bituminous surface (UBBS), popularly known as Novachip, is a thin hot-mix asphalt layer with high-quality, gap-graded aggregates bonded to the existing surface with a polymer-modified emulsion membrane. This thin surfacing improves ride quality, reduces road-tire noise, minimizes back spray, and increases visibility under wet conditions. The Kansas Department of Transportation (KDOT) has been using UBBS since 2002. Performance of this thin surface treatment strategy has been good in Kansas and elsewhere. However, some of these projects are now being rehabilitated. The objective of this study is to evaluate whether reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP) materials from existing UBBS layers can be used in chip seal and Superpave mixtures. UBBS millings were studied with two different polymer-modified emulsions to assess their performance as precoated aggregates in chip seal. The ASTM D7000-04 sweep test was used to assess chip retention of UBBS millings. Three different mix designs were developed for both 12.5-mm and 9.5-mm nominal maximum aggregate size (NMAS)Superpave mixtures using a PG 70-22 asphalt binder and three different percentages (0%, 10%, and 20%) of reclaimed UBBS materials. The designed Superpave mixes were then tested for performance in terms of rutting and stripping using the Hamburg wheel tracking device (HWTD)and moisture sensitivity by modified Lottman tests. Sweep test results showed that UBBS millings did not improve chip retention. Superpave mix design data indicated volumetric properties of Superpave mixes with UBBS millings met all requirements specified by KDOT. HWTD and modified Lottman test results indicated all designed mixes performed better with the addition of UBBS millings as RAP materials. Field performance of UBBS projects was also evaluated. It was found that pavements treated with UBBS showed high variability in service life with majority serving six years. Before and after (BAA) studies showed that UBBS reduces pavement roughness, transverse and fatigue cracking one year after the treatment. However, no consistent improvement in rutting condition was found.

Os procedimentos de dosagem Marshall e Superpave definem os teores de ligante de projeto baseados em parâmetros volumétricos. Nessa situação, sistemáticas de dosagem com tipos de compactação diferentes podem conduzir a teores de ligante de projeto distintos que definirão a vida útil dos revestimentos asfálticos. O objetivo principal desse trabalho é avaliar o comportamento mecânico de misturas asfálticas moldadas por diferentes métodos de compactação de laboratório e analisar a relação com os resultados de amostras obtidas a partir de misturas compactadas por rolagem pneumática na mesa compactadora francesa. A fase experimental consistiu na dosagem de misturas pelos métodos Marshall e Superpave (este último com dois tamanhos de moldes), além da compactação na Prensa de Cisalhamento Giratória (PCG) e da moldagem de placas na mesa compactadora. Avaliou-se o efeito do tipo de compactação, do tamanho do molde e do número de giros do Compactador Giratório Superpave (CGS) no teor de projeto, nos parâmetros volumétricos, no comportamento mecânico e no desempenho quanto à fadiga e à resistência ao afundamento em trilha de roda. Adicionalmente, foi avaliada a eficiência do método Bailey de composição granulométrica quanto à resistência à deformação permanente em função do tipo de agregado. Constatou-se que o método Bailey, por si só, não garante resistência à deformação permanente, sendo essa dependente do tipo de agregado incluindo seus parâmetros de forma. O principal produto da pesquisa, com efeitos práticos no projeto de misturas asfálticas, traduz-se na recomendação do método Superpave com molde de 100 mm (para TMN <= 12,5 mm) para volume de tráfego médio a alto em detrimento ao método Superpave com 150 mm, tendo em vista que o primeiro apresenta densificação mais semelhante às amostras preparadas na compactação por rolagem (similar ao que ocorre em pista) o que resulta em comportamento mecânico também mais próximo da realidade de campo. A utilização dos moldes de 150 mm de diâmetro no CGS pode ser viabilizada desde que se adote um número de giros menor do aquele proposto para projeto pelo Asphalt Institute (2001). Por fim, é fundamental que os ensaios e os cálculos para obtenção dos parâmetros volumétricos e escolha do teor de projeto sigam ao normatizado pela ASTM, pelo Asphalt Institute (2001) e pela ABNT. / The Marshall and Superpave mixture designs procedures are based mainly on volumetric parameters. Despite this similarity, the definition of the optimum asphalt content is highly influenced by the laboratory compaction method. The main objective of this study is to evaluate the effect of the compaction method on the volumetric and mechanical properties of asphalt mixtures. Furthermore, the results are compared with the performance of samples prepared on the LCPC roller compactor. The experimental procedure included Marshall and Superpave mixture design methods (the second one with two mold sizes), the French gyratory shear compactor (PCG), and also the LCPC roller compactor. The effect of compaction method, mold size and number of gyrations on the air voids content (and consequently, on the optimum asphalt binder content), mechanical properties and on the fatigue and rutting performance were evaluated. Moreover, the efficiency of the Bailey method for aggregate gradation selection on rutting was evaluated by the wheel tracking test of the LCPC. It was found that the Bailey method itself does not ensure resistance to rutting. It depends on the aggregate source, specially its shape. The main contribution of this study is the recommendation of the Superpave 100 mm (NMS <= 12,5 mm) for medium and high traffic, once its densification was similar to the roller compacted samples. The use of 150 mm molds in the SGC is recommended only if the number of gyrations is smaller than the one used in this study. It is essential that the laboratory standard procedures used for the tests and volumetric parameters calculations follow ASTM, Asphalt Institute (2001) and ABNT.

Dentre os diversos tipos de defeitos estruturais a que um pavimento está sujeito, a deformação permanente em trilha de roda da camada de rolamento é um dos mais importantes, pois além de propiciar uma degradação acelerada da estrutura do pavimento, ele reduz consideravelmente a segurança do usuário. Este trabalho pesquisa os processos que levam à deformação permanente de revestimentos asfálticos, utilizando como estudo de caso uma pista-teste localizada na Rodovia BR 376 PR, construída com a finalidade principal de estudar os afundamentos em trilha de roda. Foram executados 10 trechos, com 200 m de extensão cada um, em aclive, na 3ª faixa de rolamento, sujeita a tráfego pesado de caminhões lentos. Os trechos experimentais consistem de restauração de pista existente, onde foram executados diferentes tipos de revestimentos asfálticos, variando-se o tipo de graduação e também o tipo de ligante asfáltico, todas dosadas pelo método Marshall. Três dos dez trechos foram submetidos ao ensaio acelerado por um simulador de tráfego móvel de pista, em escala real. As misturas asfálticas foram igualmente ensaiadas em laboratório para verificação da dosagem por equipamento giratório francês e por simulador de tráfego tipo LPC. Além disso, foram extraídas placas do revestimento asfáltico da pista-teste as quais foram submetidas ao simulador de tráfego de laboratório. O objetivo central desta pesquisa foi de estudar a consistência dos resultados obtidos em campo e em laboratório, e a previsibilidade de deformações em campo através do método laboratorial. A pesquisa verificou e analisou a redução do volume de vazios das misturas asfálticas em pista e em laboratório associadas à deformação permanente, procurando relacionar a redução do volume de vazios com a deformação. A pesquisa mostrou que os ensaios de laboratório com o simulador de tráfego LPC podem ser empregados para prever as ocorrências de afundamentos em pista. Os resultados indicam a adoção do limite máximo de 5% de deformação permanente no equipamento de laboratório para os tipos de misturas asfálticas testadas para reduzir as possíveis ocorrências de deformações permanentes de revestimentos asfálticos sujeitos a tráfego muito pesado. Nas condições dos ensaios laboratoriais da pesquisa, que se aplicam à pista-teste, as misturas asfálticas mais recomendadas quanto à resistência à deformação permanente são as misturas com asfalto modificado por polímero SBS e RET, e as misturas com asfalto-borracha. Dependendo das características do ligante, o CAP 30/45 também pode ser empregado; no entanto, o CAP 50/70 mostrou-se inadequado para tráfego pesado e lento. A graduação é uma característica relevante para a estabilidade das misturas asfálticas, devendo os agregados estarem bem entrosados no caso das graduações contínuas e bem-graduadas; no entanto a macrotextura resultante deve ser estudada para evitar superfícies fechadas que reduzam a segurança dos usuários em pistas molhadas. Foram estudadas duas misturas descontínuas gap-graded que se mostraram adequadas para tráfego pesado quanto à deformação permanente e à textura superficial. A pesquisa mostra a importância da seleção criteriosa dos materiais e rigor nos estudos de dosagem, com determinação de propriedades mecânicas para melhor prever comportamento em campo de revestimentos asfálticos sujeitos a tráfego pesado e lento. / Among the many types of structural distresses that a pavement is subjected, wheel track rutting is one of the most important because it leads to accelerated deterioration of the pavement structure and also reduces the road safety. This research focus on the processes that lead to rutting in asphalt mixes, using experimental test sites located at Highway BR 376 PR (heavy and slow traffic), which were built with the primary purpose of studying wheel path depressions. Ten testing tracks of 200 m long (total of 2 km) were built on the third lane (upward sloping). The testing tracks were part of the rehabilitation of an existing pavement. Different asphalt mixtures were designed by the Marshall method, varying the aggregate size distribution and the type of asphalt binder. Three of the ten sections were subjected to Accelerated Pavement Testing by the Heavy Vehicle Simulator (in situ). The asphalt mixtures were also prepared and tested in laboratory by the French gyratory compactor and LPC traffic simulator, respectively, in order to verify the mixtures design. In addition, plates were extracted from the asphalt surfaces in the field and then subjected to the traffic simulator in laboratory. The main purpose of this study was to compare the permanent deformation of asphalt mixtures observed in the field to that obtained in the laboratory; and also to evaluate the prediction of permanent deformation based on laboratory evaluation. This research verified the correlation between reduction in the air voids of asphalt mixtures and rutting potential (samples extracted from the field and also prepared in laboratory were analyzed). The research showed that the LPC traffic simulator is a good device to predict permanent deformation of asphalt mixtures in the field. The results indicate 5% as the threshold for the permanent deformation in laboratory to reduce the occurrence of permanent deformation of asphalt mixtures subjected to heavy traffic. For the test conditions used, the mixtures that presented better resistance to permanent deformation were the ones with asphalt modified by SBS and RET, and the asphalt-rubber mixtures. Depending on the asphalt binder characteristics, the CAP 30/45 (classification by penetration) can be used; however the CAP 50/70 presented inadequate behavior for heavy and slow traffic. The aggregate gradation is another important parameter for the stability of asphalt mixtures, where the stones need to present a good interlocking and be wellgraded. The resulting macrotexture should also be evaluated to avoid surfaces with reduced safety to the users in wet conditions. Two mixtures with gap-graded gradation were evaluated and presented good results in respect to permanent deformation and superficial characteristics (texture). This research shows the importance of materials selection, design procedure, and mechanical behavior evaluation to predict the performance of asphalt surfaces subjected to heavy and slow traffic.

As the cost of designing and building new highway pavements increases and the number of new construction and major rehabilitation projects decreases, the importance of ensuring that a given pavement design performs as expected in the field becomes vital. To address this issue in other fields of civil engineering, reliability analysis has been used extensively. However, in the case of pavement structural design, the reliability component is usually neglected or overly simplified. To address this need, the current dissertation proposes a framework for estimating the reliability of a given pavement structure regardless of the pavement design or analysis procedure that is being used. As part of the dissertation, the framework is applied with the Mechanistic-Empirical Pavement Design Guide (MEPDG) and failure is considered as a function of rutting of the hot-mix asphalt (HMA) layer. The proposed methodology consists of fitting a response surface, in place of the time-demanding implicit limit state functions used within the MEPDG, in combination with an analytical approach to estimating reliability using second moment techniques: First-Order and Second-Order Reliability Methods (FORM and SORM) and simulation techniques: Monte Carlo and Latin Hypercube Simulation. In order to demonstrate the methodology, a three-layered pavement structure is selected consisting of a hot-mix asphalt (HMA) surface, a base layer, and subgrade. Several pavement design variables are treated as random; these include HMA and base layer thicknesses, base and subgrade modulus, and HMA layer binder and air void content. Information on the variability and correlation between these variables are obtained from the Long-Term Pavement Performance (LTPP) program, and likely distributions, coefficients of variation, and correlation between the variables are estimated. Additionally, several scenarios are defined to account for climatic differences (cool, warm, and hot climatic regions), truck traffic distributions (mostly consisting of single unit trucks versus mostly consisting of single trailer trucks), and the thickness of the HMA layer (thick versus thin). First and second order polynomial HMA rutting failure response surfaces with interaction terms are fit by running the MEPDG under a full factorial experimental design consisting of 3 levels of the aforementioned design variables. These response surfaces are then used to analyze the reliability of the given pavement structures under the different scenarios. Additionally, in order to check for the accuracy of the proposed framework, direct simulation using the MEPDG was performed for the different scenarios. Very small differences were found between the estimates based on response surfaces and direct simulation using the MEPDG, confirming the accurateness of the proposed procedure. Finally, sensitivity analysis on the number of MEPDG runs required to fit the response surfaces was performed and it was identified that reducing the experimental design by one level still results in response surfaces that properly fit the MEPDG, ensuring the applicability of the method for practical applications. / text

The roads in our society are in a state of constant degradation. The reasons for this are many, and therefore constructed to have a certain lifetime before being reconstructed. To minimize the cost of maintaining the important transport road network high quality prediction models are needed. This report presents new models for flexible pavement structures for initiation and propagation of fatigue cracks in the bound layers and rutting for the whole structure. The models are based on observations from the Swedish Long Term Pavement Performance (LTPP) database. The intention is to use them for planning maintenance as part of a pavement management system (PMS). A statistical approach is used for the modeling, where both cracking and rutting are related to traffic data, climate conditions, and the subgrade characteristics as well as the pavement structure.

Mechanistic-Empirical  (M-E)  pavement  design  procedures  are  composed  of  a  reliable  response model to estimate the state of stress in the pavement and distress models in order to predict the different types of pavement distresses due to the prevailing traffic and environmental conditions. One of the main objectives of this study was to develop a response model based on multilayer elastic  theory   (MLET)  with  improved  computational  performance  by   optimizing  the   time consuming parts of the MLET processes. A comprehensive comparison of the developed program with  two  widely  used  programs  demonstrated  excellent  agreement  and  improved  computational performance.  Moreover,  the  program  was  extended  to  incorporate  the  viscoelastic  behaviour  of bituminous materials through elastic-viscoelastic correspondence principle. A procedure based on collocation of linear viscoelastic (LVE) solutions at selected key time durations was also proposed that improved the computational performance for LVE analysis of stationary and moving loads. A comparison  of  the  LVE  responses  with  measurements  from  accelerated  pavement  testing  (APT) revealed a good agreement. Furthermore the developed response model was employed to evaluate permanent deformation models  for  bound  and  unbound  granular  materials  (UGMs)  using  full  scale  APTs.  The  M-E Pavement  Design  Guide  (MEPDG)  model  for  UGMs  and  two  relatively  new  models  were evaluated  to  model  the  permanent  deformation  in  UGMs.  Moreover,  for  bound  materials,  the simplified  form  of  the  MEPDG  model  for  bituminous  bound  layers  was  also  evaluated.  The measured  and  predicted  permanent  deformations  were  in  general  in  good  agreement,  with  only small discrepancies between the models. Finally, as heavy traffic loading is one of the main factors affecting the performance of flexible pavement, three types of characterizations for heavy traffic axle load spectrum for M-E analysis and design of pavement structures were evaluated. The study recommended an improved approach that enhanced the accuracy and computational performance. / <p>QC 20140512</p>

The aim of this thesis was to assess the relationship between motion activity of dairy cattle as measured using activity meters and reproduction, production and health parameters. For a one-year period the motion activity of 210 dairy cows was monitored. The results show that at the start of the rutting period there is a noticeable increase in motion activity (mainly during nighttime hours), specifying the exact start of rutting and the subsequent insemination. If the rutting period is detected accurately the percentage of dairy cows that are impregnated increases. Using activity meters improves reproduction indicators. Motion activity in sick cattle is generally reduced and after a warning the animals can be treated in time. The relationship between motion activity and production parameters is statistically inconclusive.

Dentre os diversos tipos de defeitos estruturais a que um pavimento está sujeito, a deformação permanente em trilha de roda da camada de rolamento é um dos mais importantes, pois além de propiciar uma degradação acelerada da estrutura do pavimento, ele reduz consideravelmente a segurança do usuário. Este trabalho pesquisa os processos que levam à deformação permanente de revestimentos asfálticos, utilizando como estudo de caso uma pista-teste localizada na Rodovia BR 376 PR, construída com a finalidade principal de estudar os afundamentos em trilha de roda. Foram executados 10 trechos, com 200 m de extensão cada um, em aclive, na 3ª faixa de rolamento, sujeita a tráfego pesado de caminhões lentos. Os trechos experimentais consistem de restauração de pista existente, onde foram executados diferentes tipos de revestimentos asfálticos, variando-se o tipo de graduação e também o tipo de ligante asfáltico, todas dosadas pelo método Marshall. Três dos dez trechos foram submetidos ao ensaio acelerado por um simulador de tráfego móvel de pista, em escala real. As misturas asfálticas foram igualmente ensaiadas em laboratório para verificação da dosagem por equipamento giratório francês e por simulador de tráfego tipo LPC. Além disso, foram extraídas placas do revestimento asfáltico da pista-teste as quais foram submetidas ao simulador de tráfego de laboratório. O objetivo central desta pesquisa foi de estudar a consistência dos resultados obtidos em campo e em laboratório, e a previsibilidade de deformações em campo através do método laboratorial. A pesquisa verificou e analisou a redução do volume de vazios das misturas asfálticas em pista e em laboratório associadas à deformação permanente, procurando relacionar a redução do volume de vazios com a deformação. A pesquisa mostrou que os ensaios de laboratório com o simulador de tráfego LPC podem ser empregados para prever as ocorrências de afundamentos em pista. Os resultados indicam a adoção do limite máximo de 5% de deformação permanente no equipamento de laboratório para os tipos de misturas asfálticas testadas para reduzir as possíveis ocorrências de deformações permanentes de revestimentos asfálticos sujeitos a tráfego muito pesado. Nas condições dos ensaios laboratoriais da pesquisa, que se aplicam à pista-teste, as misturas asfálticas mais recomendadas quanto à resistência à deformação permanente são as misturas com asfalto modificado por polímero SBS e RET, e as misturas com asfalto-borracha. Dependendo das características do ligante, o CAP 30/45 também pode ser empregado; no entanto, o CAP 50/70 mostrou-se inadequado para tráfego pesado e lento. A graduação é uma característica relevante para a estabilidade das misturas asfálticas, devendo os agregados estarem bem entrosados no caso das graduações contínuas e bem-graduadas; no entanto a macrotextura resultante deve ser estudada para evitar superfícies fechadas que reduzam a segurança dos usuários em pistas molhadas. Foram estudadas duas misturas descontínuas gap-graded que se mostraram adequadas para tráfego pesado quanto à deformação permanente e à textura superficial. A pesquisa mostra a importância da seleção criteriosa dos materiais e rigor nos estudos de dosagem, com determinação de propriedades mecânicas para melhor prever comportamento em campo de revestimentos asfálticos sujeitos a tráfego pesado e lento. / Among the many types of structural distresses that a pavement is subjected, wheel track rutting is one of the most important because it leads to accelerated deterioration of the pavement structure and also reduces the road safety. This research focus on the processes that lead to rutting in asphalt mixes, using experimental test sites located at Highway BR 376 PR (heavy and slow traffic), which were built with the primary purpose of studying wheel path depressions. Ten testing tracks of 200 m long (total of 2 km) were built on the third lane (upward sloping). The testing tracks were part of the rehabilitation of an existing pavement. Different asphalt mixtures were designed by the Marshall method, varying the aggregate size distribution and the type of asphalt binder. Three of the ten sections were subjected to Accelerated Pavement Testing by the Heavy Vehicle Simulator (in situ). The asphalt mixtures were also prepared and tested in laboratory by the French gyratory compactor and LPC traffic simulator, respectively, in order to verify the mixtures design. In addition, plates were extracted from the asphalt surfaces in the field and then subjected to the traffic simulator in laboratory. The main purpose of this study was to compare the permanent deformation of asphalt mixtures observed in the field to that obtained in the laboratory; and also to evaluate the prediction of permanent deformation based on laboratory evaluation. This research verified the correlation between reduction in the air voids of asphalt mixtures and rutting potential (samples extracted from the field and also prepared in laboratory were analyzed). The research showed that the LPC traffic simulator is a good device to predict permanent deformation of asphalt mixtures in the field. The results indicate 5% as the threshold for the permanent deformation in laboratory to reduce the occurrence of permanent deformation of asphalt mixtures subjected to heavy traffic. For the test conditions used, the mixtures that presented better resistance to permanent deformation were the ones with asphalt modified by SBS and RET, and the asphalt-rubber mixtures. Depending on the asphalt binder characteristics, the CAP 30/45 (classification by penetration) can be used; however the CAP 50/70 presented inadequate behavior for heavy and slow traffic. The aggregate gradation is another important parameter for the stability of asphalt mixtures, where the stones need to present a good interlocking and be wellgraded. The resulting macrotexture should also be evaluated to avoid surfaces with reduced safety to the users in wet conditions. Two mixtures with gap-graded gradation were evaluated and presented good results in respect to permanent deformation and superficial characteristics (texture). This research shows the importance of materials selection, design procedure, and mechanical behavior evaluation to predict the performance of asphalt surfaces subjected to heavy and slow traffic.

Os procedimentos de dosagem Marshall e Superpave definem os teores de ligante de projeto baseados em parâmetros volumétricos. Nessa situação, sistemáticas de dosagem com tipos de compactação diferentes podem conduzir a teores de ligante de projeto distintos que definirão a vida útil dos revestimentos asfálticos. O objetivo principal desse trabalho é avaliar o comportamento mecânico de misturas asfálticas moldadas por diferentes métodos de compactação de laboratório e analisar a relação com os resultados de amostras obtidas a partir de misturas compactadas por rolagem pneumática na mesa compactadora francesa. A fase experimental consistiu na dosagem de misturas pelos métodos Marshall e Superpave (este último com dois tamanhos de moldes), além da compactação na Prensa de Cisalhamento Giratória (PCG) e da moldagem de placas na mesa compactadora. Avaliou-se o efeito do tipo de compactação, do tamanho do molde e do número de giros do Compactador Giratório Superpave (CGS) no teor de projeto, nos parâmetros volumétricos, no comportamento mecânico e no desempenho quanto à fadiga e à resistência ao afundamento em trilha de roda. Adicionalmente, foi avaliada a eficiência do método Bailey de composição granulométrica quanto à resistência à deformação permanente em função do tipo de agregado. Constatou-se que o método Bailey, por si só, não garante resistência à deformação permanente, sendo essa dependente do tipo de agregado incluindo seus parâmetros de forma. O principal produto da pesquisa, com efeitos práticos no projeto de misturas asfálticas, traduz-se na recomendação do método Superpave com molde de 100 mm (para TMN <= 12,5 mm) para volume de tráfego médio a alto em detrimento ao método Superpave com 150 mm, tendo em vista que o primeiro apresenta densificação mais semelhante às amostras preparadas na compactação por rolagem (similar ao que ocorre em pista) o que resulta em comportamento mecânico também mais próximo da realidade de campo. A utilização dos moldes de 150 mm de diâmetro no CGS pode ser viabilizada desde que se adote um número de giros menor do aquele proposto para projeto pelo Asphalt Institute (2001). Por fim, é fundamental que os ensaios e os cálculos para obtenção dos parâmetros volumétricos e escolha do teor de projeto sigam ao normatizado pela ASTM, pelo Asphalt Institute (2001) e pela ABNT. / The Marshall and Superpave mixture designs procedures are based mainly on volumetric parameters. Despite this similarity, the definition of the optimum asphalt content is highly influenced by the laboratory compaction method. The main objective of this study is to evaluate the effect of the compaction method on the volumetric and mechanical properties of asphalt mixtures. Furthermore, the results are compared with the performance of samples prepared on the LCPC roller compactor. The experimental procedure included Marshall and Superpave mixture design methods (the second one with two mold sizes), the French gyratory shear compactor (PCG), and also the LCPC roller compactor. The effect of compaction method, mold size and number of gyrations on the air voids content (and consequently, on the optimum asphalt binder content), mechanical properties and on the fatigue and rutting performance were evaluated. Moreover, the efficiency of the Bailey method for aggregate gradation selection on rutting was evaluated by the wheel tracking test of the LCPC. It was found that the Bailey method itself does not ensure resistance to rutting. It depends on the aggregate source, specially its shape. The main contribution of this study is the recommendation of the Superpave 100 mm (NMS <= 12,5 mm) for medium and high traffic, once its densification was similar to the roller compacted samples. The use of 150 mm molds in the SGC is recommended only if the number of gyrations is smaller than the one used in this study. It is essential that the laboratory standard procedures used for the tests and volumetric parameters calculations follow ASTM, Asphalt Institute (2001) and ABNT.