Deep mixing (DM) is the modification of in situ soil to increase strength, control deformation, and reduce permeability. Multi–axis augers and mixing paddles are used to construct overlapping columns strengthened by mixing cement with in situ soils. This method has been used for excavation support to increase bearing capacity, reduce movements, prevent sliding failure, control seepage by acting as a cut–off barrier, and as a measure against base heave. DM is effectively used in excavations both in conjunction with and in substitution of traditional techniques, where it results in more economical and convenient solutions for the stability of the system and the prevention of seepage. Although DM is currently used for excavation control in numerous projects, no standard procedure has been developed and the different applications have not been evaluated. As this technique emerges as a more economical and effective alternative to traditional excavation shoring, there is a need for guidelines describing proven procedures for evaluation of design, analysis and construction. The main objective of this research is to develop a methodology to design retaining systems using deep mixing technology. The method will be evaluated using numerical analysis of one selected case history.

Deep mixing (DM) is the modification of in situ soil to increase strength, control deformation, and reduce permeability. Multi–axis augers and mixing paddles are used to construct overlapping columns strengthened by mixing cement with in situ soils. This method has been used for excavation support to increase bearing capacity, reduce movements, prevent sliding failure, control seepage by acting as a cut–off barrier, and as a measure against base heave. DM is effectively used in excavations both in conjunction with and in substitution of traditional techniques, where it results in more economical and convenient solutions for the stability of the system and the prevention of seepage. Although DM is currently used for excavation control in numerous projects, no standard procedure has been developed and the different applications have not been evaluated. As this technique emerges as a more economical and effective alternative to traditional excavation shoring, there is a need for guidelines describing proven procedures for evaluation of design, analysis and construction. The main objective of this research is to develop a methodology to design retaining systems using deep mixing technology. The method will be evaluated using numerical analysis of one selected case history.

Organic soils are formed as deceased plant and animal wildlife is deposited and decomposed in wet environs. These soils have loose structures, low undrained strengths, and high natural water contents, and require improvement before they can be used as foundation materials. Previous researchers have found that the deep mixing method effectively improves organic soils. This study presents a quantitative and reliable method for predicting the strength of one organic soil treated with deep mixing. For this thesis, organic soils were manufactured from commercially available components. Soil-binder mixture specimens with different values of organic matter content, OM, binder content, water-to-binder ratio, and curing time were tested for unconfined compressive strength (UCS). Least-squares regression was used to fit a predictive equation, modified from the findings of previous researchers, to this data. The equation estimates the UCS of a deep-mixed organic soil specimen using its total water-to-binder ratio and mixture dry unit weight. Soil OM is incorporated into the equation as a threshold binder content, aT, required to improve a soil with a given OM; the aT term is used to calculate an effective total water-to-binder ratio. This thesis reached several important conclusions. The modified equation was successfully fitted to the data, meaning that the UCS of some organic soil-binder mixtures may be predicted in the same manner as that of inorganic soil-binder mixtures. The fitting coefficients from the predictive equations indicated that for the soils and binder tested, specimens of organic soil-binder mixtures have a greater relative gain of UCS immediately after mixing compared to specimens of inorganic soil-binder mixtures. However, the inorganic mixtures generally have a greater relative gain of UCS during the curing period. The influence of curing temperature was found to be similar for organic and inorganic mixtures. For the organic soils and binder tested in this research, aT may be expressed as a linear or power function of OM. For both functions, the value of aT was negligible at values of OM below 45%, which reflects the chemistry of the organic matter in the peat moss. For projects involving deep mixing of organic soils, the predictive equation will be used most effectively by fitting it to the results of bench-scale testing and then checking it against the results of field-scale testing. / Master of Science / Organic soils are formed continuously as matter from deceased organisms – mainly plants – is deposited in wet environs and decomposes. Organic soils are most commonly found in swamps, marshes, and coastal areas. These soils make poor foundation materials due to their low strengths. Deep mixing, or soil mixing, involves introducing a binder like Portland cement or lime into soil and blending the soil and binder together to form columns or blocks. Upon mixing, cementitious reactions occur, and the soil-binder mixture gains strength as it cures. Deep mixing may be performed using either a dry binder, known as dry mixing, or a binder-water slurry, referred to as wet mixing. Deep mixing may be used to treat either inorganic or organic soils to depths of 30 meters or greater. Contractor experience has shown that deep mixing is one of the most effective methods of improving the strength of organic soils. Lab-scale studies (by previous researchers) of wet mixing of inorganic soils have found that the strength of soil-binder mixtures can be expressed as a function of mixture curing time and curing temperature, as well as the quantity of binder used, or binder factor, and the consistency of the binder slurry. No corresponding expression has been generated for wet mixing of organic soils, although many studies on the subject have been performed by previous researchers. The goal of this research was to generate such an expression for one organic soil. The soil used was made of sphagnum peat moss, an organic material commonly found in nature, and an inorganic clay used by previous researchers in studies of deep mixing in inorganic soils. The binder used in this research was a Portland cement. For this research, 43 unique soil-binder mixtures were manufactured. Each mixture involved a unique combination of soil organic matter content, binder factor, and binder slurry consistency. After a soil-binder mixture was made, it was divided, placed into cylindrical molds, and allowed to cure. The temperature of the curing environment of the mixture was monitored. Mixture compressive strength was assessed after 7, 14, and 28 days of curing using two cylindrically molded specimens of the mixture. Data on mixture strength was then evaluated to assess whether it could be expressed as a function of the variables tested. iv This research determined that the strength of at least some organic soils improved with wet mixing can be expressed as a function of soil organic matter content, binder factor, binder slurry consistency, and mixture curing time and curing temperature. The function will likely prove useful to deep mixing contractors, who routinely perform lab-scale deep mixing trials on samples of the soils to be improved in the field. Assuming wet mixing is used, the results of the trials are used to select values of binder factor and binder slurry consistency for the project. The function generated from this research will allow deep mixing contractors to select these values more reliably during the lab-scale phase of their work.

The wet method of deep mixing constructs binder-treated soil columns by mixing a binder-water slurry with soft soil in-situ to improve the engineering properties of the soil. The strength of binder-treated soil is affected by characteristics of the in-situ soil and binder, mixing conditions, and curing conditions.The study presented herein aims to investigate the influences of curing time, curing temperature, mix design proportion, organic matter in the soil, and curing stress on the strength of cement-treated soil. Fabricated and natural soft soils were mixed with a cement-water slurry to mimic soil improved by the wet method of deep mixing. Laboratory-size samples were cured under various curing conditions and tested for unconfined compressive strength (UCS).The experimental test results showed that (1) a higher curing temperature and longer curing time generally increase the strength; (2) organic matter in cement-treated soil decrease and/or delay the strength development; and (3) curing stress affects the strength but its effect is influenced by drainage conditions. Based on the test results, strength-predicting correlations for cement-treated soil that account for various curing conditions and organic contents were proposed and validated.This research contributes to advancing the knowledge about the effects of strength-controlling factors of soil improved by cement and to improving the reliability of strength predictions with the proposed correlations. Therefore, the number of sample batches that need to be prepared and tested in a deep mixing project can be reduced, thereby saving the project's time and costs while achieving the target strength of the improved soil. / Doctor of Philosophy / The deep mixing method has gained popularity in the U.S. as a ground improvement technique since the late 1990s. This method involves blending the native soil that needs to be improved with a binder such as cement and/or lime. Two types of deep mixing methods are available, depending on how to add binder to the soil: the wet method injects a binder-water slurry, while the dry method uses a powder form of binder.The binder reacts with water and soil thereby enhancing the engineering properties of the soil. The strength of binder-treated soil is influenced by many factors: (1) characteristics of native soil and binder; (2) mixing conditions (e.g., the amount of binder added and mixing energy); and (3) curing conditions (e.g., curing time, temperature, and stress). In this dissertation, the effects of curing conditions and organic matter in the soil on the strength of cement-treated soil were investigated. Fabricated and natural soils were mixed with cement-water slurry to simulate the wet method, and the prepared samples were cured under various conditions. The strength results of cured samples showed that the characteristics of cement-treated soil are significantly affected by the amount of cement in the mixture, curing time, curing temperature, organic matter in soil, and curing stress. The test results were also used to derive correlations that account for the influences of curing conditions and organic matter.The findings and strength-predicting correlations presented in this research are expected to improve the knowledge about the deep mixing method and the reliability of strength prediction in a deep mixing project. This research, eventually, contributes to reducing time and cost of the project.

Foundations constructed by the deep mixing method have been used to successfully support embankments, structures, and excavations in Japan, Scandinavia, the U.S., and other countries. The current state of practice is that design is based on deterministic analyses of settlement and stability, even though deep mixed materials are highly variable. Conservative deterministic design procedures have evolved to limit failures. Disadvantages of this approach include (1) designs with an unknown degree of conservatism and (2) contract administration problems resulting from unrealistic specifications for deep mixed materials. This dissertation describes research conducted to develop reliability-based design procedures for foundations constructed using the deep mixing method. The emphasis of the research and the included examples are for embankment support applications, but the principles are applicable to foundations constructed for other purposes. Reliability analyses for foundations created by the deep mixing method are described and illustrated using an example embankment. The deterministic stability analyses for the example embankment were performed using two methods: limit equilibrium analyses and numerical stress-strain analyses. An important finding from the research is that both numerical analyses and reliability analyses are needed to properly design embankments supported on deep mixed columns. Numerical analyses are necessary to address failure modes, such as column bending and tilting, that are not addressed by limit equilibrium analyses, which only cover composite shearing. Reliability analyses are necessary to address the impacts of variability of the deep mixed materials and other system components. Reliability analyses also provide a rational basis for establishing statistical specifications for deep mixed materials. Such specifications will simplify administration of construction contracts and reduce claims while still providing assurance that the design intent is satisfied. It is recommended that reliability-based design and statistically-based specifications be implemented in practice now. / Ph. D.

A laboratory testing program was conducted on cement-treated soil mixtures fabricated to represent materials produced by the wet method of deep mixing. The testing program focused on investigating the influences that variations in laboratory testing conditions and in the mix design have on measured property values. A base soil was fabricated from commercially available soil components to produce a very soft lean clay that is relatively easy to mix and can be replicated for future research. The mix designs included a range of water-to-cement ratios of the slurries and a range of cement factors to produce a range of mixture consistencies and a range of unconfined compressive strengths after curing. Unconfined compressive strength (UCS) tests and unconsolidated-undrained (UU) triaxial compression tests were conducted. Secant modulus of elasticity were determined from bottom platen displacements, deformations between bottom platen and cross bar, and from LVDT's placed directly on the cement-treated soil specimens. Five end-face treatment methods were used for the specimens: sawing-and-hand-trimming, machine grinding, sulfur capping, neoprene pads, and gypsum capping. Key findings of this research include the following: (1) The end-face treatment method does not have a significant effect on the unconfined compressive strength and secant modulus; (2) a relationship of UCS with curing time, total-water-to-cement ratio, and dry density of the mixture; (3) the secant modulus determined by bottom platen displacements is significantly affected by slack and deformations in the load frame; (4) the secant modulus determined by local strain measurements was about 630 time the UCS; (5) typical values of Poisson's ratio range from about 0.05 to 0.25 for stress levels equal to half the UCS and about 0.15 to 0.35 at the UCS; (6) Confinement increased the strength at high strains from less than 20% the UCS to about 60% the UCS. In addition to testing the cured mixtures, the consistency of the mixtures were measured right after mixing using a laboratory miniature vane. A combination of the UCS relationship along with the mixture consistency may provide useful information for deep mixing contractors. / MS

<p>The thesis is dealing with mixing processes havingapplication to ground improvement by deep mixing. The mainobjectives of the thesis is to make a contribution to knowledgeof the basic mechanisms in mixing binding agents into soil andimprove the knowledge concerning factors that influence theuniformity of stabilised soil.</p><p>A great part of the work consists of a literature surveywith particular emphasis on literature on the processindustries. This review forms a basis for a profounddescription and discussion of the mixing process and factorsaffecting the process in connection with deep mixingmethods.</p><p>The thesis presents a method for a simple field test for thestudy of influential factors in the mixing process. A number offactors in the installation process of lime-cement columns havebeen studied in two field tests using statistical multifactorexperiment design. The effects of retrieval rate, number ofmixing blades, rotation speed, air pressure in the storagetank, and diameter of the binder outlet on the stabilisationeffect and the coefficient of variation determined byhand-operated penetrometer tests for excavated lime-cementcolumns, were studied.</p><p>The literature review, the description of the mixingprocess, and the results from the field tests provide a morebalanced picture of the mixing process and are expected to beuseful in connection to ground improvement projects and thedevelopment of mixing equipments.</p><p>The concept of sufficient mixture quality, i.e. theinteraction between the mixing process and the mechanicalsystem, is discussed in the last section. By means ofgeostatistical methods, the analysis considers thevolume-variability relationship with reference to strengthproperties. According to the analysis, the design values forstrength properties depends on the mechanical system, the scaleof scrutiny, the spatial correlation structure, and the conceptof safety, i.e. the concept of sufficient mixture quality isproblem specific.</p><p><b>Key words:</b>Deep Mixing, Lime cement columns, Mixingmechanisms, Mixture quality, Field test, ANOVA, Variancereduction.</p>

The thesis is dealing with mixing processes havingapplication to ground improvement by deep mixing. The mainobjectives of the thesis is to make a contribution to knowledgeof the basic mechanisms in mixing binding agents into soil andimprove the knowledge concerning factors that influence theuniformity of stabilised soil. A great part of the work consists of a literature surveywith particular emphasis on literature on the processindustries. This review forms a basis for a profounddescription and discussion of the mixing process and factorsaffecting the process in connection with deep mixingmethods. The thesis presents a method for a simple field test for thestudy of influential factors in the mixing process. A number offactors in the installation process of lime-cement columns havebeen studied in two field tests using statistical multifactorexperiment design. The effects of retrieval rate, number ofmixing blades, rotation speed, air pressure in the storagetank, and diameter of the binder outlet on the stabilisationeffect and the coefficient of variation determined byhand-operated penetrometer tests for excavated lime-cementcolumns, were studied. The literature review, the description of the mixingprocess, and the results from the field tests provide a morebalanced picture of the mixing process and are expected to beuseful in connection to ground improvement projects and thedevelopment of mixing equipments. The concept of sufficient mixture quality, i.e. theinteraction between the mixing process and the mechanicalsystem, is discussed in the last section. By means ofgeostatistical methods, the analysis considers thevolume-variability relationship with reference to strengthproperties. According to the analysis, the design values forstrength properties depends on the mechanical system, the scaleof scrutiny, the spatial correlation structure, and the conceptof safety, i.e. the concept of sufficient mixture quality isproblem specific. Key words:Deep Mixing, Lime cement columns, Mixingmechanisms, Mixture quality, Field test, ANOVA, Variancereduction.

Since the 1970's deep mixing columns have been widely used all over the world to improve the performance of soft soil in regard to bearing capacity or deformation behaviour. They are installed by mixing a binding agent, e.g. cement, in situ with the soil. The choice of installation method affects the properties of the column and the surrounding as the soil is disturbed by the installation process. However, the effects of the installation are often neglected during design even though they are plentiful. Besides the lateral displacement that could destabilize neighbouring constructions, the soil in the direct vicinity of the installed column is affected. Laboratory and field tests revealed the formation of three distinct zones outside the nominal diameter of the column which have different strength properties than the initial clay. They are formed due to cylindrical expansion, clay fracturing, and the migration of ions from the binding agent and their strength changes with time due to consolidation, cementation, heating, and thixotropy. Within this thesis, the installation effects that occur in the direct vicinity of the column have been studied in the context of a construction project in Sweden, where deep mixing columns are considered for the reduction of settlements of road and parks areas located on a thick clay layer. Based on analytical calculation methods and field measurements described in the literature, the occurrence and the magnitude of the installation effects have been assessed. The influence of considering these effects was then studied numerically using the finite element program PLAXIS. The simulation included one column within a column group and was performed in 2D assuming axisymmetry. The presence of the neighbouring columns was considered over the boundary conditions. The installation effects in the vicinity of the column comprised three zones which were implemented in the numerical model. For comparison, the simulations were also performed using the "wish-in-place" approach for the column that ignores the occurrence of any installation effects. The stabilized soil is loaded with two layers of new filling material which results in excess pore pressures and settlements that have been studied. The results for the model in which the installation effects were considered could be compared to the results for the model in which the column was wished-in-place. The comparison showed that the consideration of the installation effects leads to a faster consolidation and a significant reduction in settlements. This was observed for different installation patterns, i.e. triangular and square, and varying column spacings of 1.2 and 2.4 m. The positive installation effects were greatest for a smaller spacing and a triangular installation pattern. For a square installation pattern with a spacing of 2.4 m, the consolidation time and the final settlements were both reduced by more than 40%. Even though the assumptions and simplifications require verification, a clear positive influence can be seen for the project in Sweden. If these numerical results are confirmed by field observations, more efficient construction designs could be obtained which ultimately result in reduced costs and carbon dioxide emissions.

<p>QC 20120703</p>