Esta tese decorre do seguinte problema de pesquisa: qual a importância das ideias de docentes sobre educação em sua adesão a reformas educacionais? A hipótese levantada foi a de que o(a) docente de ensino fundamental em escolas estaduais de São Paulo resiste às reformas, entre outros fatores, porque suas ideias sobre educação entram em conflito com as ideias que orientam estas reformas. Dada a complexidade do problema e da hipótese levantada, bem como o prazo para realizar a pesquisa, priorizou-se oferecer uma contribuição parcial ao enfrentamento do problema, concentrando-se em explicitar como variam as ideias sobre educação nas quais se baseia a prática profissional docente, segundo um conjunto de características. Como procedimento metodológico, foi realizado o estudo de caso em duas escolas estaduais (centro e periferia) paulistas e abordando-se doze docentes em cada uma. Empregou-se o instrumental teórico-conceitual e metodológico de investigação construído por Maurice Tardif e colaboradores, assim como o de Bernard Lahire. Verificou-se que as ideias docentes estão fundadas no modelo de escola clássica humanista de base científica em que o magistério foi formado e que o professorado resiste às práticas contrárias a esse modelo. / This thesis stems from the following research problem: what is the importance of educators ideas about education in their adherence to educational reforms? The hypothesis was that elementary school teachers in state schools in São Paulo resist the reforms because their opinions about education conflict with the ideas that guide these reforms, among other factors. Given the complexity of the problem and the hypothesis raised, as well as the period to carry out the research, it was prioritized to provide a partial contribution in tackling the problem, focusing on explaining how the ideas about education upon which the professional teaching practice is based vary, according to a set of characteristics. As a methodological procedure, the case study was conducted in two state schools in São Paulo city (central and peripheral areas), addressing twelve teachers in each. We used the theoretical-conceptual and methodological research instrument built by Maurice Tardif and collaborators, as well as that of Bernard Lahire. It was found that the teachers ideas are based on a humanist classical school model of scientific basis upon which teaching was built, and that the teachers resist practices contrary to this model.

Esta tese decorre do seguinte problema de pesquisa: qual a importância das ideias de docentes sobre educação em sua adesão a reformas educacionais? A hipótese levantada foi a de que o(a) docente de ensino fundamental em escolas estaduais de São Paulo resiste às reformas, entre outros fatores, porque suas ideias sobre educação entram em conflito com as ideias que orientam estas reformas. Dada a complexidade do problema e da hipótese levantada, bem como o prazo para realizar a pesquisa, priorizou-se oferecer uma contribuição parcial ao enfrentamento do problema, concentrando-se em explicitar como variam as ideias sobre educação nas quais se baseia a prática profissional docente, segundo um conjunto de características. Como procedimento metodológico, foi realizado o estudo de caso em duas escolas estaduais (centro e periferia) paulistas e abordando-se doze docentes em cada uma. Empregou-se o instrumental teórico-conceitual e metodológico de investigação construído por Maurice Tardif e colaboradores, assim como o de Bernard Lahire. Verificou-se que as ideias docentes estão fundadas no modelo de escola clássica humanista de base científica em que o magistério foi formado e que o professorado resiste às práticas contrárias a esse modelo. / This thesis stems from the following research problem: what is the importance of educators ideas about education in their adherence to educational reforms? The hypothesis was that elementary school teachers in state schools in São Paulo resist the reforms because their opinions about education conflict with the ideas that guide these reforms, among other factors. Given the complexity of the problem and the hypothesis raised, as well as the period to carry out the research, it was prioritized to provide a partial contribution in tackling the problem, focusing on explaining how the ideas about education upon which the professional teaching practice is based vary, according to a set of characteristics. As a methodological procedure, the case study was conducted in two state schools in São Paulo city (central and peripheral areas), addressing twelve teachers in each. We used the theoretical-conceptual and methodological research instrument built by Maurice Tardif and collaborators, as well as that of Bernard Lahire. It was found that the teachers ideas are based on a humanist classical school model of scientific basis upon which teaching was built, and that the teachers resist practices contrary to this model.

Penser, représenter et étudier la nature a constitué un axe majeur du projet éducatif de l’école de la Troisième République. Pour comprendre les enjeux autour des façons de penser et d’éduquer à la nature, il est nécessaire de garder à l’esprit que la géographie, les sciences, l’histoire, l’agronomie et la littérature ont déversé une foule de savoirs et soulevé autant de questions, aux réponses parfois indisciplinées. L’essentiel pourtant n’est pas dans la recherche des contradictions que le discours a immanquablement générées. Non, il est à trouver dans le cap que les fondateurs ont tracé : éduquer et instruire. A notre sens, l’un des leviers pour atteindre ce double objectif a consisté à rendre l’enseignement le plus attractif possible. On s’en doute, les pédagogues n’ont pas été à court d’idées mais l’étude de la nature a plus que d’autres, servi à enchanter l’école républicaine. Pas toujours, pas partout évidemment : le succès et l’essor de l’Education nouvelle ne peuvent se comprendre si l’on oublie que beaucoup d’écoles dirigées par des maîtres consciencieux rechignèrent à rompre avec les méthodes et les contenus pédagogiques classiques. Cet arrachement à la tradition, l’Education nouvelle l’incarne parfaitement. Porté par le souffle de la rénovation pédagogique, ce mouvement progressiste a emboîté le pas des réformateurs de l’école traditionnelle pour faire de la nature le pivot de son enseignement… Au milieu des finalités de l’éducation à la nature à l’école, la dimension enchanteresse de la nature fut absolument centrale. Toute la littérature scolaire a participé à cette entreprise de fabrication d’une nature capable de dire la grandeur de la nation, apte à concurrencer les interprétations théologiques du monde et susceptible de faire oublier les malheurs du temps. Acharnée à former des petits républicains volontaires, l’école a également promu, avec la nature, des méthodes actives. Jardins, promenades, voyages, leçons sur le vif, géographie de terrain dessinent une école moderne, davantage en phase avec les besoins des enfants. C’est autour de ce double mouvement de construction de représentations : l’enchantement de l’école d’un côté, et une nature enchantée de l’autre, que nous avons articulé l’essentiel de notre réflexion. En gardant à l’esprit qu’il y a eu là un processus de fabrique d’une nature dont l’image – et non sa matérialité - se reflète encore dans la mémoire collective. / Thinking, representing and studying nature has been a major component of the educational project of Third Republic Schools. To understand the issues surrounding ways of thinking and educating people about nature, it is necessary to keep in mind that geography, science, history, agronomy and literature have brought out a wealth of knowledge and raised as many questions, sometimes with unruly answers. However, the essential thing is not in the search for the contradictions that the discourse has inevitably generated. No, it is to be found in the course that the founders have set: to educate and instruct. In our opinion, one of the levers to achieve this dual objective has been to make education as attractive as possible. As we can imagine, pedagogues were not short of ideas, but the study of nature has more than others served to enchant the republican school. Not always, not everywhere, of course: the success and development of new education cannot be understood if we forget that many schools run by conscientious teachers were reluctant to break with traditional teaching methods and content. This tearing away from tradition is perfectly embodied in the new Education. Carried by the wind of pedagogical renovation, this progressive movement followed in the footsteps of the reformers of the traditional school to make nature the pivot of its teaching... In the midst of the aims of nature education at school, the enchanting dimension of nature was absolutely central. All school literature has participated in this process of manufacturing a nature capable of expressing the greatness of the nation, capable of competing with the theological interpretations of the world and capable of making people forget the misfortunes of time. Hard at work training young volunteer Republicans, the school has also promoted, with nature, active methods. Gardens, walks, trips, lessons, geography of the field draw a modern school, more in tune with the needs of children. It is around this double movement of building representations: the enchantment of the school on the one hand, and an enchanted nature on the other, that we have organized the essential of our reflection. Bearing in mind that there has been a manufacturing process of a nature whose image - and not its materiality - is still reflected in the collective memory.

No description available.