Bacteria have small, streamlined genomes and evolve rapidly. Their large population sizes allow selection to be the main driver of evolution. With advances in sequencing technologies and precise methods for genetic engineering, many bacteria are excellent models for studying elementary questions in evolutionary biology. The work in this thesis has broadly been devoted to adaptive evolution and fitness effects of different types of mutations. In Paper I we experimentally tested the fitness constrains of horizontal gene transfer (HGT), which could be used to predict how the fixation of HGT events are affected by selection and fitness effects. We found that the majority of the examined HGT inserts were indistinguishable from neutral, implying that extra DNA transferred by HGT, even though it does not confer an immediate selective advantage, could be maintained at transfer-selection balance and serve as a reservoir for the evolution of novel beneficial functions. Paper II examined why four synonymous mutations in rpsT (encoding ribosomal protein S20) reduced fitness, and how this cost could be genetically compensated. We found that the cause for the fitness reduction was low S20 levels and that this lead to a defective subpopulation of 30S subunits lacking S20. In an adaptive evolution experiment, these impairments were compensated by up-regulation of S20 though various types of mutations. In Paper III we continued the studies of how the deleterious rpsT mutations could be compensated. The mutations either down-regulated the global regulator Fis or altered a subunit of the RNA polymerase (rpoA). We found that the decreased S20 levels in the cells causes an assembly defect of the 30S particles and that the fis and rpoA mutations restored the skewed S20:ribosome ratio by both increasing S20 levels and decreasing other ribosomal components. Paper IV examined adaptation of two bacterial species to different growth media. A total of 142 different adaptive mutations were identified and 112 mutants were characterized in terms of fitness. We found that the experimental variation in fitness measurements could be reduced 10-fold by introducing some adaptive mutations prior to the experiment, allowing measurements of fitness differences as small as 0.04%.

Ecological processes have the potential to influence evolution through their effects on selection. This thesis explores the effects of two ecological factors - competition and ecological opportunity. Intraspecific (within-species) competition is often expected to drive adaptation and diversification by increasing selection for the use of novel resources, thereby alleviating the detrimental effects of competition. However, this is not always the expected outcome; theory suggests that intraspecific competition can also drive convergent evolution. On the other hand, interspecific (between-species) competition is usually expected to impede adaptation and diversification because competitor species occupy potential available niches, preventing the focal species from diversifying to do so. In this thesis, I review previous experimental studies exploring the effects of competition on adaptive diversification, and then directly test these effects using experimental evolution of the bacterium Pseudomonas fluorescens. I confirm that intraspecific competition drives adaptive diversification, while the effects of interspecific competition are varied. Strong interspecific competition impedes adaptation and diversification, while the presence of weak, non-diversifying interspecific competitors drives diversification through increased resource competition. The presence of ecological opportunity is essential for adaptation and diversification, and so variation in attributes of those opportunities is expected to have important effects on the dynamics of adaptive evolution. In another evolution experiment with P. fluorescens, I tested the effects of variation in ecological opportunity on adaptive evolution and found that the type and arrangement of ecological opportunities drives adaptation but, in this system, not diversification. I also show that ecological opportunity drives differences in the degree of parallel evolution at the phenotypic and genotypic level. Finally, I explore some unexpected genetic changes identified in one of these evolved populations - two synonymous mutations that conferred fitness benefits, and show that the observed fitness improvements are the result of increased gene expression. I have shown that ecological processes can play an important role in shaping the evolutionary trajectories taken by populations. Understanding the interactions between ecological and evolutionary processes is vital for our understanding of evolutionary dynamics as a whole, and the studies laid out in this thesis represent valuable contributions to this field of study.

Ecological processes have the potential to influence evolution through their effects on selection. This thesis explores the effects of two ecological factors - competition and ecological opportunity. Intraspecific (within-species) competition is often expected to drive adaptation and diversification by increasing selection for the use of novel resources, thereby alleviating the detrimental effects of competition. However, this is not always the expected outcome; theory suggests that intraspecific competition can also drive convergent evolution. On the other hand, interspecific (between-species) competition is usually expected to impede adaptation and diversification because competitor species occupy potential available niches, preventing the focal species from diversifying to do so. In this thesis, I review previous experimental studies exploring the effects of competition on adaptive diversification, and then directly test these effects using experimental evolution of the bacterium Pseudomonas fluorescens. I confirm that intraspecific competition drives adaptive diversification, while the effects of interspecific competition are varied. Strong interspecific competition impedes adaptation and diversification, while the presence of weak, non-diversifying interspecific competitors drives diversification through increased resource competition. The presence of ecological opportunity is essential for adaptation and diversification, and so variation in attributes of those opportunities is expected to have important effects on the dynamics of adaptive evolution. In another evolution experiment with P. fluorescens, I tested the effects of variation in ecological opportunity on adaptive evolution and found that the type and arrangement of ecological opportunities drives adaptation but, in this system, not diversification. I also show that ecological opportunity drives differences in the degree of parallel evolution at the phenotypic and genotypic level. Finally, I explore some unexpected genetic changes identified in one of these evolved populations - two synonymous mutations that conferred fitness benefits, and show that the observed fitness improvements are the result of increased gene expression. I have shown that ecological processes can play an important role in shaping the evolutionary trajectories taken by populations. Understanding the interactions between ecological and evolutionary processes is vital for our understanding of evolutionary dynamics as a whole, and the studies laid out in this thesis represent valuable contributions to this field of study.

Made available in DSpace on 2015-04-11T13:38:47Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 Janaina de Araujo Evangelista.pdf: 5258011 bytes, checksum: f25739b96a1b2d123d21c1753b3204e8 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2011-05-06 / Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior / subtropical regions of the planet. In North America, Plasmodium vivax is responsible for the most part of the infections. In 2011, 250,498 cases of malaria fever were studied; 80% of these cases were caused by Plasmodium vivax. The purpose of this study was to investigate the diversity generation of the gene MSP1 from Plasmodium vivax through the analisys of a specific mutation in the region from the block 2 genetic precombination events. In order to identify the existing mutations in multiclonal infections and generation of diversity in PvMSP1 a series of experiments were done, respectively, the extraction of genomic DNA of the parasite, PCR (polymerase chain reaction) using specific primers for the block 2, ligation of the fragment to cloning vector (top), processing using Escherichia coli competent cells, selection of colonies belonging to the same sample, DNA sequencing and analysis of synonymous and nonsynonymous mutations as their location in the prediction of B and T cell epitopes (not synonymous). The calculation of genetic distance between recombinant clones of the same sample by the MEGA 4.0 program confirmed the multiclonality of samples. The alignment of amino acid sequences showed the presence of genetic recombination events using DNASP program. DNA sequences obtained showed another interesting result: several synonymous and non-synonymous mutations in a relatively small stretch of DNA. Genetic diversity showed most mutations are not synonymous, and that most of them were located in regions referred to as B and T cell epitopes by BcPred and ProPred. So, as expected, the genetic diversity based on synonymous mutations and not synonymous possible sustains the phenomenon of escape on the immunity of the host. The characterization of these polymorphisms may contribute to immunological studies aiming at the development of a vaccine against malaria on stages caused by p. vivax. / A malária é um problema da saúde pública amplamente distribuída nas regiões tropicais e subtropicais do globo. No continente americano, o Plasmodium vivax é responsável por maior parte das infecções. No ano de 2011, 250.498 casos de malária foram observados no estado do Amazonas; 80% destes casos foram causados por Plasmodium vivax. O objetivo desse trabalho foi Investigar a geração de diversidade do gene MSP1 de Plasmodium vivax através da análise de mutações pontuais na região do bloco 2, eventos de precombinação genética. Para identificar as mutações existentes nas infecções multiclonais e geração de diversidade em PvMSP1 realizou-se uma série de experimentos, respectivamente, a extração de DNA genômico do parasita, PCR (Reação da Polimerase em Cadeia) utilizando primers específicos para o bloco 2, ligação do fragmento ao vetor de clonagem ( TOPO), transformação utilizando células de E.coli competentes , seleção de colônias pertencentes a uma mesma amostra, seqüenciamento de DNA e análise das mutações não sinônimas e sinônimas quanto sua localização em regiões de predição de epítopos de células B e T (não sinônimas). O cálculo da distância genética entre clones recombinantes de uma mesma amostra pelo programa MEGA 4.0 confirmou a multiclonalidade das amostras. O alinhamento das sequências de aminoácidos mostrou a presenção de eventos de recombinação genética utilizando o programa DNASP. As sequências de DNA obtidas demonstrou outro resultado interessante: várias mutações sinônimas e não sinônimas num trecho relativamente pequeno de DNA. A diversidade genética mostrou mais mutações não sinônimas, sendo que maior parte delas estavam localizadas em regiões previstas como epítopos das células B e T pelo programa BcPred e ProPred. Assim, como esperado, a diversidade genética baseado nas mutações sinônimas e não sinônimas sustenta o fenômeno de escape sobre a imunidade do hospedeiro. A caracterização desses polimorfismos poderá contribuir para estudos imunológicos visando o desenvolvimento de uma vacina contra os estágios eritrocitários da malária causada por P.vivax.

Inspired by Gould, who claimed life would be arriving at a different outcome each time it were allowed to run from the same beginning, I have attempted to determine the repeatability of the adaptive course of one Pseudomonas fluorescens lineage. In addition, my study aimed to establish whether the likelihood of parallel evolution of the two synonymous single-nucleotide substitutions was contingent upon a prior motility-impairing deletion or a prior increase in fitness. Further, the study was designed to provide empirical data addressing the long-standing question of the effect of starting fitness on the ensuing rate of adaptation. Although no exact replay of the initial evolutionary trajectory was observed, I have demonstrated that gtsB, but not gtsC gene, is likely to be a mutational hotspot under the low glucose with a recovery of two undescribed mutations in gtsB. My data are consistent with a notion that substitutions in gtsB may be contingent upon Δ35kB(fliJ-PFLU4466) motility-impairing deletion, but not the fitness increase associated with it. Finally, the features of the adaptive landscape of P. fluorescens in the minimal glucose provide languid support for Fisher’s hypothesis of a decrease in adaptation rate with the rise in the starting fitness. Taken together, these original results reinforce the non-negligible role of history in shaping the outcomes of biological evolution and call for caution in attempting a formulation of rigid predictive models of evolutionary change. Inspiré par les travaux de Stephen J. Gould qui affirmait que la vie sur terre arriverait à une forme différente si elle repartait à zéro, je présente ici mes travaux où je teste la reproductibilité du cours adaptatif d’une lignée expérimentale de Pseudomonas fluorescens. L’objectif de cette étude était de déterminer si la probabilité que deux mutations synonymes évoluent en parallèle est affectée par la présence d’une délétion affectant la motilité de la bactérie ou de l’augmentation de la valeur sélective de celle-ci. De plus, le design expérimental de cette étude permet de tester si la valeur sélective initiale d’une population affecte le taux d’adaptation de cette même population. Bien d’une reproductibilité exacte du cours adaptatif initial ne fut pas observée, je démontre que le gène gtsB est probablement un « hotspot »mutationnel permettant l’adaptation à de bas niveau de glucose, ayant trouvé deux mutations dans ce site; alors que le gène gtsC ne l’est pas. Mes données sont également conséquentes avec le fait que les mutation dans le gène gtsB dépendent de l’effet de la délétion Δ35kB(fliJ-PFLU4466) affectant la motilité de la bactérie, mais non de l’augmentation de la valeur sélective qui y est associée. Finalement, la forme du plateau adaptative associé à de bas niveaux de glucose chez P. fluorescens supporte l’hypothèse émise par Fisher qui stipule que le taux d’adaptation d’un organisme diminue avec la valeur sélective initiale qui y est associée. L’ensemble de ces résultats supporte le rôle non-négligeable de l’histoire de vie d’une population en ce qui attrait à l’évolution future de cette même population. Aussi, ces résultats appelle à la prudence quand vient le temps de formuler des modèles prédictifs des changements évolutifs d’une population.

Inspired by Gould, who claimed life would be arriving at a different outcome each time it were allowed to run from the same beginning, I have attempted to determine the repeatability of the adaptive course of one Pseudomonas fluorescens lineage. In addition, my study aimed to establish whether the likelihood of parallel evolution of the two synonymous single-nucleotide substitutions was contingent upon a prior motility-impairing deletion or a prior increase in fitness. Further, the study was designed to provide empirical data addressing the long-standing question of the effect of starting fitness on the ensuing rate of adaptation. Although no exact replay of the initial evolutionary trajectory was observed, I have demonstrated that gtsB, but not gtsC gene, is likely to be a mutational hotspot under the low glucose with a recovery of two undescribed mutations in gtsB. My data are consistent with a notion that substitutions in gtsB may be contingent upon Δ35kB(fliJ-PFLU4466) motility-impairing deletion, but not the fitness increase associated with it. Finally, the features of the adaptive landscape of P. fluorescens in the minimal glucose provide languid support for Fisher’s hypothesis of a decrease in adaptation rate with the rise in the starting fitness. Taken together, these original results reinforce the non-negligible role of history in shaping the outcomes of biological evolution and call for caution in attempting a formulation of rigid predictive models of evolutionary change. Inspiré par les travaux de Stephen J. Gould qui affirmait que la vie sur terre arriverait à une forme différente si elle repartait à zéro, je présente ici mes travaux où je teste la reproductibilité du cours adaptatif d’une lignée expérimentale de Pseudomonas fluorescens. L’objectif de cette étude était de déterminer si la probabilité que deux mutations synonymes évoluent en parallèle est affectée par la présence d’une délétion affectant la motilité de la bactérie ou de l’augmentation de la valeur sélective de celle-ci. De plus, le design expérimental de cette étude permet de tester si la valeur sélective initiale d’une population affecte le taux d’adaptation de cette même population. Bien d’une reproductibilité exacte du cours adaptatif initial ne fut pas observée, je démontre que le gène gtsB est probablement un « hotspot »mutationnel permettant l’adaptation à de bas niveau de glucose, ayant trouvé deux mutations dans ce site; alors que le gène gtsC ne l’est pas. Mes données sont également conséquentes avec le fait que les mutation dans le gène gtsB dépendent de l’effet de la délétion Δ35kB(fliJ-PFLU4466) affectant la motilité de la bactérie, mais non de l’augmentation de la valeur sélective qui y est associée. Finalement, la forme du plateau adaptative associé à de bas niveaux de glucose chez P. fluorescens supporte l’hypothèse émise par Fisher qui stipule que le taux d’adaptation d’un organisme diminue avec la valeur sélective initiale qui y est associée. L’ensemble de ces résultats supporte le rôle non-négligeable de l’histoire de vie d’une population en ce qui attrait à l’évolution future de cette même population. Aussi, ces résultats appelle à la prudence quand vient le temps de formuler des modèles prédictifs des changements évolutifs d’une population.