Orientador: Marco Aurélio Pizo Ferreira / Banca: Wesley Rorigues da Silva / Banca: Claudio José Von Zuben / Resumo: Os dispersores de sementes possuem um papel fundamental na ecologia e evolução das plantas de frutos carnosos, especialmente em ambientes tropicais onde mais de 70% das espécies lenhosas são dispersas por vertebrados. A recente perda destas interações causada pela ação antrópica pode acarretar importantes perdas de biodiversidade. Este trabalho visou identificar quais espécies de aves são potenciais dispersoras de sementes em uma Ilha continental da Mata Atlântica, com um alto grau de perturbação. De dezembro de 2005 a janeiro de 2007, foi realizado um levantamento da avifauna da Ilha Anchieta baseado no método de amostragem por pontos (n= 360), que foram distribuídos em três ambientes, Floresta Densa (FD), Floresta Rala (FR) e Campos Antrópicos (CA). Foram registradas 75 espécies de aves, distribuídas em 27 famílias e 12 categorias alimentares. Tyrannidae e Thraupidae foram as famílias melhor representadas, com 17 e 8 espécies, respectivamente. Os ambientes não apresentaram diferenças significativas em relação ao número de indivíduos, mas diferiram quanto ao número de espécies frugívoras, com 26, 24 e 29 espécies para FD, FR e CA, respectivamente. Frugívoros especialistas foram considerados raros. Com o registro das interações entre aves frugívoras e plantas em frutificação foi obtido um total de 1341 visitas completas em 303,6 h de observações a 16 espécies arbóreas. Vinte e cinco espécies de aves se alimentaram de frutos que variaram entre 4,0 e 19,8 mm de comprimento e entre 3,3 e 14,7 mm de largura. Os principais potenciais dispersores foram Turdus leucomelas, Saltator similis, Tachyphonus coronatus, Thraupis sayaca e Turdus albicollis. Assim, os frugívoros generalistas destacam-se como importantes dispersores na Ilha, pois levam sementes de espécies pioneiras para as áreas alteradas, acelerando a sucessão vegetacional, tendo um papel fundamental na recuperação de áreas degradadas. / Abstract: Seed dispersers play a key role in the ecology and evolution of fleshy-fruited plants; especially in tropical forests where from 70% to 90% of all woody species are dispersed by vertebrates. The recent disruption of these interactions caused by human activities may bring about a considerable loss of biodiversity. The aim of this study was to identify wich species are potencial seed dispersers in a highly perturbed continental Island of the Atlantic Forest. From December 2005 to January 2006, a survey using point-counts was carried out at the Anchieta Island to record the avifauna in 360 points-counts stations distributed in three successional stages: old fields (CA), early secondary forest (FR), old growth forest (FD). A total of 75 birds species was recorded, distributed over a range of 27 families and 12 diet categories. Tyrannidae and Thraupidae were the most abundant families, with 17 and 8 species, respectively. The three successional stages were not significantly different in bird abundance, but differed in number of frugivorous species, where 29 species were recorded at CA, 24 at FR, and 26 at FD. Specialized frugivorous were rare. To identify the frugivorous birds and their potential role as seed dispersers in the three successional stages, focal-individual observations were performed on fruiting plants. Sixteen plant species were observed during 303.6 plant-hours. Twenty-five bird species were observed consuming fruits in a total of 1341 visits to fruiting plants. Fruits averaged 4.0 e 19.8 mm length, and 3.3 e 14.7 mm width. The main potential seed dispersers were Turdus leucomelas, Saltator similis, Tachyphonus coronatus, Thraupis sayaca and Turdus albicollis. Thus, generalist frugivorous birds were considered main potential seed dispersers, which may play a important role in accelerating the plant regeneration process at Anchieta Island. / Mestre

<p>Conservatism is a central theme of organismic evolution. Related species share characteristics due to their common ancestry. Some concern have been raised among evolutionary biologists, whether such conservatism is an expression of natural selection or of a constrained ability to adapt.</p><p>This thesis explores adaptations and constraints within the plant reproductive phase, particularly in relation to the evolution of fleshy fruit types (berries, drupes, etc.) and the seasonal timing of flowering and fruiting. The different studies were arranged along a hierarchy of scale, with general data sets sampled among seed plants at the global scale, through more specific analyses of character evolution within the genus <i>Rhamnus </i>s.l. L. (Rhamnaceae), to descriptive and experimental field studies in a local population of <i>Frangula alnus</i> (Rhamnaceae). Apart from the field study, this thesis is mainly based on comparative methods explicitly incorporating phylogenetic relationships. The comparative study of <i>Rhamnus</i> s.l. species included the reconstruction of phylogenetic hypotheses based on DNA sequences.</p><p>Among geographically overlapping sister clades, biotic pollination was not correlated with higher species richness when compared to wind pollinated plants. Among woody plants, clades characterized by fleshy fruit types were more species rich than their dry-fruited sister clades, suggesting that the fleshy fruit is a key innovation in woody habitats. Moreover, evolution of fleshy fruits was correlated with a change to more closed (darker) habitats.</p><p>An independent contrast study within <i>Rhamnus</i> s.l. documented allometric relations between plant and fruit size. As a phylogenetic constraint, allometric effects must be considered weak or non-existent, though, as they did not prevail among different subclades within <i>Rhamnus</i> s.l. Fruit size was correlated with seed size and seed number in <i>F. alnus</i>. This thesis suggests that frugivore selection on fleshy fruit may be important by constraining the upper limits of fruit size, when a plant lineage is colonizing (darker) habitats where larger seed size is adaptive.</p><p>Phenological correlations with fruit set, dispersal, and seed size in <i>F. alnus</i>, suggested that the evolution of reproductive phenology is constrained by trade-offs and partial interdependences between flowering, fruiting, dispersal, and recruitment phases. Phylogenetic constraints on the evolution of phenology were indicated by a lack of correlation between flowering time and seasonal length within <i>Rhamnus cathartica</i> and <i>F. alnus</i>, respectively. On the other hand, flowering time was correlated with seasonal length among <i>Rhamnus</i> s.l. species. Phenological differences between biotically and wind pollinated angiosperms also suggested adaptive change in reproductive phenology.</p> / <p>Äpplet faller inte långt från trädet. Men varför? Den biologiska mångfalden präglas i stor utsträckning av fylogenetiskt bevarade karaktärsdrag; närbesläktade arter är lika. Det pågår en diskussion bland evolutionsbiologer om i vilken utsträckning denna konservatism är ett resultat av naturlig selektion eller av en begränsad anpassningsförmåga.</p><p>Denna avhandling diskuterar begreppet evolutionära begränsningar i relation till den reproduktiva fasen hos växter. I fokus ligger särskilt evolutionen av bärliknande (endozoochora) frukter respektive evolutionen av säsongsmässiga mönster (fenologi) för blomning och fruktsättning. Avhandlingen är hierarkiskt organiserad så att olika delstudier gjordes på olika skalnivåer: fenologi- och fruktevolution analyserades för fröväxter respektive gömfröiga växter; inom brakvedssläktena Rhamnus och Frangula (Rhamnaceae); samt för en lokal population av brakved (Frangula alnus). Populationsstudien baserades på såväl experimentella som deskriptiva data, medan övriga studier i huvudsak genomfördes med fylogenetisk komparativ metodik baserade på litteraturdata. Som en del av de komparativa studierna rekonstruerades fylogenetiska hypoteser för Rhamnus s.l. utifrån DNA-sekvenser (ITS, trnL-F), vilka gav stöd för att Frangula och Rhamnus är monofyletiska systersläkten.</p><p>I en biogeografiskt kontrollerad fylogenetisk kontrastanalys upptäcktes inga skillnader i artrikedom mellan djur- och vindpollinerade växter. Bärliknande frukter verkar dock vara en betydelsefull karaktär (key innovation) i skogsmiljöer. För det första var fylogenetiska klader med bärliknande frukter mer artrika än systerklader med torra frukter. Dessutom var uppkomster av bärliknande frukt korrelerad till habitat med mer sluten vegetation.</p><p>En fylogenetisk kontrastanalys av allometriska effekter visade på en positiv korrelation mellan växtindividens och fruktens storlek inom Rhamnus s.l. Upprepade analyser av dessa allometriska samband i olika monofyletiska subklader inom Rhamnus s.l. indikerar dock att allometri, såsom evolutionär begränsning, är svag. I populationsstudien av F. alnus var fruktstorlek positivt korrelerad till såväl fröantal som frövikt. En generell hypotes utifrån denna avhandling blir därför att frugivorer (de djur som äter bären och därmed sprider växtens frön) utövar ett starkt selektionstryck på växter som koloniserar ett habitat där fröstorlek är adaptivt, eftersom fruktstorlek påverkar frugivorernas (ssk. fåglars) sätt att hantera frukten.</p><p>Reproduktiv fenologi var korrelerad till fruktsättning, fröspridning och fröstorlek hos F. alnus. Detta stödjer tanken att evolutionen av blomnings- och fruktsättningstider begränsas av avvägningar (trade-offs) och partiella beroenden mellan blomning-, fruktsättnings-, spridnings och rekryteringsfaserna. Inomartsvariation i blomningstid för F. alnus respektive getapel (Rhamnus cathartica) över en nordeuropeisk latitudinell transekt var inte korrelerad till säsongslängd, vilket antyder att utvecklingen av blomningstider är evolutionärt begränsad. Å andra sidan påvisades en sådan korrelation mellan blomningstid och säsongslängd i en mellanartsstudie inom Rhamnus s.l. Den fylogenetiska kontrastanalysen mellan djur- och vindpollinerade växter visade också på adaptiva skillnader i fenologi. Blomningstiderna inom en klad med biotiskt pollinerade arter var mer åtskilda än inom den vindpollinerade systerkladen, och den välkända iakttagelsen att vindpollinerade träd blommor tidigare på säsongen fick även stöd i ett fylogenetiskt komparativt perspektiv.</p>

Conservatism is a central theme of organismic evolution. Related species share characteristics due to their common ancestry. Some concern have been raised among evolutionary biologists, whether such conservatism is an expression of natural selection or of a constrained ability to adapt. This thesis explores adaptations and constraints within the plant reproductive phase, particularly in relation to the evolution of fleshy fruit types (berries, drupes, etc.) and the seasonal timing of flowering and fruiting. The different studies were arranged along a hierarchy of scale, with general data sets sampled among seed plants at the global scale, through more specific analyses of character evolution within the genus Rhamnus s.l. L. (Rhamnaceae), to descriptive and experimental field studies in a local population of Frangula alnus (Rhamnaceae). Apart from the field study, this thesis is mainly based on comparative methods explicitly incorporating phylogenetic relationships. The comparative study of Rhamnus s.l. species included the reconstruction of phylogenetic hypotheses based on DNA sequences. Among geographically overlapping sister clades, biotic pollination was not correlated with higher species richness when compared to wind pollinated plants. Among woody plants, clades characterized by fleshy fruit types were more species rich than their dry-fruited sister clades, suggesting that the fleshy fruit is a key innovation in woody habitats. Moreover, evolution of fleshy fruits was correlated with a change to more closed (darker) habitats. An independent contrast study within Rhamnus s.l. documented allometric relations between plant and fruit size. As a phylogenetic constraint, allometric effects must be considered weak or non-existent, though, as they did not prevail among different subclades within Rhamnus s.l. Fruit size was correlated with seed size and seed number in F. alnus. This thesis suggests that frugivore selection on fleshy fruit may be important by constraining the upper limits of fruit size, when a plant lineage is colonizing (darker) habitats where larger seed size is adaptive. Phenological correlations with fruit set, dispersal, and seed size in F. alnus, suggested that the evolution of reproductive phenology is constrained by trade-offs and partial interdependences between flowering, fruiting, dispersal, and recruitment phases. Phylogenetic constraints on the evolution of phenology were indicated by a lack of correlation between flowering time and seasonal length within Rhamnus cathartica and F. alnus, respectively. On the other hand, flowering time was correlated with seasonal length among Rhamnus s.l. species. Phenological differences between biotically and wind pollinated angiosperms also suggested adaptive change in reproductive phenology. / Äpplet faller inte långt från trädet. Men varför? Den biologiska mångfalden präglas i stor utsträckning av fylogenetiskt bevarade karaktärsdrag; närbesläktade arter är lika. Det pågår en diskussion bland evolutionsbiologer om i vilken utsträckning denna konservatism är ett resultat av naturlig selektion eller av en begränsad anpassningsförmåga. Denna avhandling diskuterar begreppet evolutionära begränsningar i relation till den reproduktiva fasen hos växter. I fokus ligger särskilt evolutionen av bärliknande (endozoochora) frukter respektive evolutionen av säsongsmässiga mönster (fenologi) för blomning och fruktsättning. Avhandlingen är hierarkiskt organiserad så att olika delstudier gjordes på olika skalnivåer: fenologi- och fruktevolution analyserades för fröväxter respektive gömfröiga växter; inom brakvedssläktena Rhamnus och Frangula (Rhamnaceae); samt för en lokal population av brakved (Frangula alnus). Populationsstudien baserades på såväl experimentella som deskriptiva data, medan övriga studier i huvudsak genomfördes med fylogenetisk komparativ metodik baserade på litteraturdata. Som en del av de komparativa studierna rekonstruerades fylogenetiska hypoteser för Rhamnus s.l. utifrån DNA-sekvenser (ITS, trnL-F), vilka gav stöd för att Frangula och Rhamnus är monofyletiska systersläkten. I en biogeografiskt kontrollerad fylogenetisk kontrastanalys upptäcktes inga skillnader i artrikedom mellan djur- och vindpollinerade växter. Bärliknande frukter verkar dock vara en betydelsefull karaktär (key innovation) i skogsmiljöer. För det första var fylogenetiska klader med bärliknande frukter mer artrika än systerklader med torra frukter. Dessutom var uppkomster av bärliknande frukt korrelerad till habitat med mer sluten vegetation. En fylogenetisk kontrastanalys av allometriska effekter visade på en positiv korrelation mellan växtindividens och fruktens storlek inom Rhamnus s.l. Upprepade analyser av dessa allometriska samband i olika monofyletiska subklader inom Rhamnus s.l. indikerar dock att allometri, såsom evolutionär begränsning, är svag. I populationsstudien av F. alnus var fruktstorlek positivt korrelerad till såväl fröantal som frövikt. En generell hypotes utifrån denna avhandling blir därför att frugivorer (de djur som äter bären och därmed sprider växtens frön) utövar ett starkt selektionstryck på växter som koloniserar ett habitat där fröstorlek är adaptivt, eftersom fruktstorlek påverkar frugivorernas (ssk. fåglars) sätt att hantera frukten. Reproduktiv fenologi var korrelerad till fruktsättning, fröspridning och fröstorlek hos F. alnus. Detta stödjer tanken att evolutionen av blomnings- och fruktsättningstider begränsas av avvägningar (trade-offs) och partiella beroenden mellan blomning-, fruktsättnings-, spridnings och rekryteringsfaserna. Inomartsvariation i blomningstid för F. alnus respektive getapel (Rhamnus cathartica) över en nordeuropeisk latitudinell transekt var inte korrelerad till säsongslängd, vilket antyder att utvecklingen av blomningstider är evolutionärt begränsad. Å andra sidan påvisades en sådan korrelation mellan blomningstid och säsongslängd i en mellanartsstudie inom Rhamnus s.l. Den fylogenetiska kontrastanalysen mellan djur- och vindpollinerade växter visade också på adaptiva skillnader i fenologi. Blomningstiderna inom en klad med biotiskt pollinerade arter var mer åtskilda än inom den vindpollinerade systerkladen, och den välkända iakttagelsen att vindpollinerade träd blommor tidigare på säsongen fick även stöd i ett fylogenetiskt komparativt perspektiv.

Frugivorous insects, specialised herbivores that consume fruit and seeds, are considered detrimental to host plant fitness. Their direct link to genetic fitness via consumption of plant reproductive tissue, and their negative socioeconomic association with agriculture exacerbates their harmful status. However, empirical testing of insect frugivore effects on host plants, and ecological research on the contribution of insect frugivores to multitrophic frugivory systems, is lacking. In the current study, direct effects of a non-mutualistic, insect frugivore/host plant system were tested and results showed variable effects. Beneficial, detrimental, but predominantly neutral effects on germination and seed production were observed between the Queensland fruit fly (Bactrocera tryoni) and tomato and capsicum plants. Significant effects on seed production were unexpected because infestation occurs after seed set. It was also found that eggplant, although a recorded host of B. tryoni, is inconsistent in its ability to sustain B. tryoni larvae through to its final instar. These results confirmed a simplification and presumption associated with insect frugivore (specifically fruit fly)/host plant interactions. Larval movement, infestation-induced fruit decay, pulp removal and germination were then investigated. For all hosts (tomato, apple and paw paw), treatments infested by B. tryoni decayed significantly quicker and to a greater extent than uninfested treatments, with obvious but variable changes to the texture and appearance. The movement of B. tryoni larvae, pattern of infestation-induced decay and pulp removal was unique and host dependent for all hosts. Only seeds from infested tomato were shown to germinate during the experiment. This indicated that host fruit characteristics are responsible, in part, for variable direct effects on host plant fitness by insect frugivores. Variable direct effects between insect frugivores and host plants, combined with the more rapid decay of infested fruits is likely to have implications for seed dispersal and seed predation by a third trophic level. The characteristics of fruit that are changed by infestation by an insect frugivore were then tested for their effect on a vertebrate frugivore, to illustrate the importance of recognising multitrophic interactions and indirect effects in frugivory. Specifically, seed predating rodents were incorporated into the study and their response to infested and uninfested fruits were recorded, as well as their reaction to the changes in fruit caused by insect frugivores (i.e. texture, smell, larvae presence and sound). Apple and pear infested with B. tryoni larvae were found to attract rodents, while infested tomato and paw paw had a neutral effect on the native rats. This differed from the predominant finding in the literature, which was a deterrent effect on avian seed dispersers. Vertebrate response to fruit infested with insect frugivores therefore, is variable. Assessing the indirect effect of insect frugivores on host plant fitness by attracting or deterring another trophic level requires knowledge of the direct effect between the introduced trophic level and the host plant. For example, the attraction of a seed predator may be as detrimental to host plant fitness as the deterrence of a seed disperser. This illustrates the complexity associated with assessing insect frugivore effects on host plant fitness. Results also indicated that differences in pulp texture, caused by infestation, have a significant effect on rodent preference for infested or uninfested treatments. Pulp texture is likely to effect rodent foraging efficiency, whereas the presence of B. tryoni larvae was observed to be inconsequential to rodent response to fruits. For rodents, and indeed any trophic level motivated by foraging efficiency, this finding raises the issue that for long lived fruiting plants, outside factors such as food abundance and competition for food, may cause a variable response to fruits infested by insect frugivores. From these investigations it has become apparent that insect frugivores are not consistently harmful to host plant fitness, as suggested by their negative stigma, but are likely to contribute variable effects, directly and indirectly, on multiple components of plant fitness and multitrophic frugivory systems.

No description available.