Imperfect Personality in Commercial Law Robert Pelikán Abstract In the theory of law, legal personality (the terms "legal person" and "legal personality" are used in this text in their continental sense, i.e. describing both non-human and human entities and their legal capacity) is usually seen as a simple quality having only values, true or false. The existing theories of legal personality were, therefore, trying to find such characteristics of legal personality, which will fully describe all legal persons existing in practice. Such an effort had to fail or, more precisely, the process of search for such a common denominator had to result in the disappearance of all the key characteristics necessary for understanding of the phenomenon of legal personality. The exploration of legal personality must hence begin with the finding that legal personality is not a quality having only values - true or false - but rather a full scale of values from nil to a (rarely seen) full legal personality, moreover appearing in many dimensions. In order to duly explain the phenomenon, the theory must not search for a common denominator of existing persons, but describe the concept of full legal personality and explain the consequences of imperfection of existing legal persons in any of such qualities. Those requirements cannot...

The presented PhD. thesis deals with effective strategies of forming legal consciousness of upper-secondary school students, and with methods that can be used for developing it. So far, legal scholars have paid only insufficient attention to this topic, even though many law experts have repeatedly pointed out its importance. Moreover, they stress the fact that a more detailed understanding of legal consciousness of citizens and of ways of influencing it can help us better understand how law works within the society. The thesis opens with the theoretical part, which defines the concept of legal consciousness, describes its level captured by the available empirical research and identifies effective strategies, which possess the potential to cultivate legal consciousness of the youth. In the following practical part, the author seeks to verify effectiveness of these strategies by means of student questionnaires, interviews with teachers and observations of their lessons. The theoretical part firstly introduces legal consciousness as the basic concept of the whole thesis. The first chapter presents the understanding of legal consciousness as one of the key terms of every law because it connects the world of law in books with the world of law actually experienced by people on day to day basis. Legal...

1 Material Tensions between Natural Law and Positive Law and Approaches to its Solution Jakub Kříž Abstract The title of my dissertation - "Material Tensions between Natural Law and Positive Law and Approaches to its Solution" - refers to everlasting contrapositions of two different approaches to law: (i) natural law tradition which is concerned with a necessary continuity between law and the requirements of practical reasonableness and that describes law as "rational standard for conduct"1 and (ii) tradition of legal positivism, which understands law only as a social fact. Actually, in the world of jurisprudence, there is no single natural law theory on one side2 and unique legal positivism on the other side.3 It is 1 MURPHY, Mark C. Natural Law Jurisprudence. Legal Theory. 2003, No. 9, p. 244, MURPHY, Mark C. Natural Law Theory. In: GOLDING , Martin P., EDMUNSON, William A. (eds.). The Blackwell Guide to the Philosophy of Law and Legal Theory. s.l. : Blackwell Publishing, 2006, p. 15. 2 For many of them we can mention classical natural law theory of the thomistic philosophy, new natural law theory of G. Grisez and J. Finnes, legal realism of J. Hervada, "modern" natural law theories such as L. Fuller's concept of the Rule of Law and the inner morality of law or R. Dworkin's theory of the unique right...

The submitted dissertation thesis analyses the principle of primacy of EU law from the basic point of view of legal theory. It points out different approaches to the primacy principle and examines the arguments on which these approaches are based. The fist part of the thesis deals with the examination of the primacy principle related to its legal basis, using the sources most frequently listed in the literature: the founding treaties, the case law of the Court of Justice, legal theory (Kelsen's basic norm, Hart's rule of recognition and the legal sociology approaches), and international and national law. I have focused on the historical documents (Treaty Establishing the European Coal and Steel Community, Treaty Establishing the European Economic Community), the concepts based on them (doctrine of the conferred powers and the principle of subsidiarity), and the non-ratified Treaty Establishing a Constitution for Europe and legally non-binding Declaration No. 17 attached to the Lisbon Treaty. I have applied a critical approach to the argumentation of the Court of Justice in the decisions establishing the principle of primacy: Van Gend en Loos, Costa, Internationale Handelsgesellschaft, Simmenthal. Taking into account the existing objections against the arguments used by the Court of Justice, I have...

The phenomenon of the case law and publication of the case law reports has been present in our legal culture at least since the 13th century, as well as in some other European countries. Court decisions in writing occurred through several types of documents and sources. We can trace the case law documents in the public royal records ("the plates"), the law books and the first constitutional codifications of law. There is even particular group of the law collections which we can actually name as the original case law reports. The case law reports were designed even before this period of time. Unfortunately, no such original law reports survived up to the present day. We can strongly state the sustainable tradition of typical case law collections in the Czech legal culture since the medieval times. The very first case law reports in modern sense of meaning came in late 1850`s. But the periodicals case law reports in the Czech language eventually appeared with the year of 1918 when the Czech state was restored. Creating the case law reports and its headnotes falls within the process of court decisions publication. The courts, which constitute the top of the judicial pyramid, operate with their special individual instruments on their case law publication. The official law reports have been established...

Václav Pilík. Unjustified Enrichment in the Czech Law. PhD thesis 1 Abstract This PhD thesis explores the legal institution of unjustified enrichment in the Czech private law. The subject is dealt in larger historical, theoretical and partly comparative relationships in order not to be reduced only to internal problems of the national regulation. A general view of unjustified enrichment (part one of this work), providing a systematic introduction to the problem, is hinder by different approaches, their overlapping and largely opened discourse on conceptual questions. Despite all that difficulties, found out by comparative legal studies of unjustified enrichment in the civil law and common law systems, it is necessary to undergo an attempt at expression of common features of the unjustified enrichment as a legal concept. Supposing that, we can describe three common features of unjustified enrichment: it is enrichment obtained at the expense of another and in a lawless way; the modern legal institute of unjustified enrichment rests on fragmentary historical basis, substantially completed by national factors of legal development (legislation, justice and doctrine); the enrichment is viewed as objective fact (at least in certain states of facts). Legal development of unjustified enrichment runs differently in...

A Floresta Amazônica é palco de um grande número de atividades de desflorestamento, como a mineração artesanal, agropecuária e comércio de madeira. A fim de se ter uma diminuição dos impactos ambientais, os órgãos fiscalizadores têm tentado regular estas atividades e orientá-las para métodos de operação mais responsável. Este trabalho descreve a iniciativa por meio do monitoramento dessas áreas de floresta localizadas perto dessas regiões de desmatamento, porque os elementos fundamentais, tais como a biomassa e acúmulo de carbono das árvores podem ser adequadamente monitorados contra distúrbios ocasionais trazidos por essas atividades. A atual abordagem padrão na Amazônia é monitorar todas as árvores da floresta dentro de uma área chamada de transecto, também designado como inventário florestal, mantendo um registro rigoroso de seu comportamento e crescimento. No entanto, essas atividades são restritas às áreas de controle que estão localizados em regiões estratégicas e não representam toda a área a ser monitorada. Esta pesquisa explora uma nova metodologia baseada na geoestatística e destinada a otimização da amostragem, estendendo-se para o estudo de áreas florestais muito maiores, mantendo a utilização dos recursos humanos unitária inalterada, e, ao mesmo tempo, aumentar a superfície das áreas de estudo e a manter a confiança nos resultados. A metodologia proposta permite a seleção da Reserva Legal - RL, a ser feita de acordo com a distribuição real de acumulação de carbono da floresta, em vez de confiar na utilização de área percentual proposta por lei e no senso comum de proprietários / órgãos fiscalizadores. Esta metodologia foi aplicada na Floresta Nacional de Tapajós (FLONA Tapajós), no Estado do Pará, Brasil, utilizou-se de conjunto de dados disponíveis, para otimizar as amostras e monitorar a capacidade da floresta de armazenar carbono. A presente metodologia pretende contribuir para uma diminuição do custo das atividades de monitoramento por unidade de área, aumento da precisão para localização RL, e simplificação dos procedimentos através da aplicação de um conjunto de ferramentas de fácil utilização. Os resultados mostraram que a aplicação de estudos geoestatísticos para determinação de RL é um procedimento viável, pois a estrutura do variograma se mantém mesmo com a amostragem sofrendo uma diminuição randômica de até 50% da área de cobertura vegetal, conseguindo manter o mesmo resultado da amostragem na totalidade da cobertura vegetal. / The Amazon Rainforest is the scene of a large number of deforestation activities such as artisanal mining, agriculture and timber trade. For the purpose of have reduced environmental impacts, regulatory agencies have attempted to regulate these activities and direct them towards more responsible methods of operation. This paper describes the initiative by monitoring these forest areas located near these regions of deforestation, because the core elements, such as biomass and carbon accumulation of the trees can be adequately monitored against occasional disturbances brought by these activities. The current standard approach in the Amazon is to monitor all the trees of the forest within an area called the transect, also designated as forest inventory, keeping a strict record of their behavior and growth. However, these activities are restricted to control areas that are located in strategic regions and do not represent the whole area to be monitored. This research explores a new methodology based on geostatistics and designed to optimize the sampling, extending the study of much larger forest areas, keeping unchanged the use of human resources unit, and at the same time increase the surface areas of study and to maintain confidence in the results. The proposed methodology allows the selection of the Legal Reserve - RL, to be made according to the actual distribution of carbon accumulation in the forest, instead relying in using area percentage proposed by law and common sense of proprietary / regulatory agencies. This methodology was applied in the Tapajós National Forest (FLONA Tapajós), State of Pará, Brazil, we used the data set available, to optimize the sample and monitor the forest\'s ability to store carbon. This methodology intends to contribute to reducing the cost of monitoring activities per unit area, increased precision for location RL, and simplifying procedures by applying a set of easy to use tools. The results showed that application of geostatistical studies for determination of RL is a viable procedure, because the structure of the variogram is maintained even with a random sampling suffering decreased to 50% of the area of vegetation, even managing to keep the sampling result the total vegetation cover.

Recentemente, o capítulo da Comunicação em Odontologia sofreu grande abertura. Inicialmente pensou-se que as infrações pudessem diminuir, na medida em que as restrições à publicidade diminuíram. Entretanto, cresce a publicidade anti-ética em todos os campos de atuação profissional. A partir da promulgação do Código de Defesa do Consumidor (CDC) a matéria, que antes era dispersa e tratada por outros diplomas legais, ganhou um lugar próprio. Os dispositivos do Código de Defesa do Consumidor são rigorosos nas sanções aplicadas aos infratores, por isso se faz necessária uma adequação da comunicação odontológica em acordo com o novo ordenamento jurídico. Assim, o presente estudo teve como objetivo trazer subsídios sobre os parâmetros doutrinários da publicidade no Código de Defesa do Consumidor, a fim de suscitar uma mais aprofundada reflexão do assunto por parte da classe. / Recently, the chapter on dentistry communication has suffered a great opening. At first, lots of people thought that the infractions could have diminished, as long as the restriction to publicity has dwindled as well. However, anti-ethical publicity has increased in all professional fields. From the promulgation of the Consumer’s Defence Code (CDC) on, this issue, which was sparsely focused and taken care by other legal professionals, has gained its own place in discussions. The CDC dispositions are extremely strict in the sanctions applied to the infringers, that is why it is necessary na adequacy on dentistry communication accordingly with the new judicial arrangements. Therefore, this present study aims at bringing subsidies on doctrinal publicity parameters of the CDC in order to incite a more profound reflection on this issue by part of these professionals.

A identificação humana é algo que vem sendo estudado desde o século XIV e a cada dia vem se aperfeiçoando mais. Desta forma este estudo tem como proposta um método de identificação auxiliar aos já existentes, obtido por meio das rugas palatinas, que são estruturas localizadas na mucosa do palato duro, envolvendo papila incisiva, rafe mediana e rugas palatinas. Este estudo objetivou criar uma metodologia mais simples no uso deste método de identificação, por meio do uso de imagens digitalizadas e programas específicos para tal fim. A amostra foi constituída por 100 modelos e os respectivos prontuários. Inicialmente foram delimitadas as rugas palatinas, a papila incisiva e a rafe mediana com lapiseira 0,1 mm de espessura e grafite tipo HB, nos modelos dos sujeitos da pesquisa. Participaram da pesquisa três avaliadores, para que o estudo fosse cego: o avaliador 1 foi responsável pela seleção dos modelos iniciais; o avaliador 2 fez as cópias em scanner (para criar banco de dados); e o avaliador 3 re-numerou os modelos para que fossem sobrepostos pelo avaliador 2 e na seqüência fosse analisada a coincidência de pontos, para a possível identificação. Os modelos foram digitalizados e analisados por meio do programa Photoshop 7.0.1. Os resultados, encontrados por meio de análise de concordância de pontos não coincidentes, permitiram um percentual de 100 % de acerto na identificação, sendo então possível a identificação de todos os indivíduos por meio da metodologia proposta. A amostra apresentou 85% de pessoas do fenótipo cor da pele branco, 10 % negro, 5 % amarelo, a faixa etária envolveu indivíduos entre 8 e 30 anos de idade. Os resultados encontrados suportam as seguintes conclusões: que é possível realizar a identificação humana por meio das rugas palatinas, desde que haja um banco de dados prévio; as imagens podem ser arquivadas em CD-ROM, portanto, diminuindo o espaço utilizado para armazenamento dos dados pessoais de cada indivíduo; é um método de identificação seguro, por permitir análise relacionando 5 critérios, o que excluiu as chances de erros, pois nenhum modelo foi coincidente em nenhum ponto com outro, que não com o próprio. / The identification human being is something that comes being studied since century XIV and to each day it comes if perfecting more. In such a way this study a method of identification auxiliary to already the existing ones has as proposal, gotten by means of palatal rugae, that are structures located in the mucosa of the hard palate, involving papila incisive, rafe medium and palatal rugae. Having as objective to create a simpler methodology in the use of this method of identification, through the use of digitalized images and specific programs for such end. The sample was constituted by 100 models and respective handbooks. Initially they had been delimited palatal rugae, papila incisive and rafe medium with pencil 0.1 mm of thickness and graphite type HB, in the models of the citizens of the research. Three appraisers had participated of the research, so that the study he was blind: appraiser 1 was responsible for the election of the initial models; appraiser 2 made the copies in scanner (to reate data base); e appraiser 3 re-numbered the models so that they were overlapped by appraiser 2 and in the sequence the coincidence of points was analyzed, for the possible identification. The models had been digitalized and analyzed by means of the program Photoshop 7.0.1. The results, found by means of analysis of agreement of not coincident points, had allowed to a percentage of 100% of rightness in the identification, being possible the identification of all the individuals by means of the methodology proposal. The sample presented 85% of people of color of the white skin, 10% black, 5% yellow, the aged band involved individuals between 8 and 30 years of age. The joined results support the following conclusions: that she is possible to carry through the identification human being by means of palatal rugae, since that has a previous data base; the images can be filed in CD-ROM, therefore, decreased the space used for storage of the personal datas of each individual; it is a safe method of identification, for allowing to analysis relating 5 criteria, what it excluded the possibilities of errors, therefore no model was coincident in no point with another one, that not with the proper one.

SOARES, A.T.C. Perfil antropológico das ossadas analisadas no Centro de Medicina Legal (CEMEL) da Faculdade de Medicina de Ribeirão Preto USP. 2007. 169 p. Dissertação (Mestrado) Faculdade de Medicina de Ribeirão Preto, Ribeirão Preto, 2007. A Antropologia Forense é uma área do conhecimento que aplica os métodos da antropologia física e arqueologia para coleta e análise de evidências legais, buscando estabelecer a identidade de um ser. O Centro de Medicina Legal (CEMEL) da Faculdade de Medicina de Ribeirão Preto da Universidade de São Paulo (FMRP-USP) possui um Laboratório de Antropologia Forense, criado em 2005 durante o desenvolvimento de um projeto em parceria com a University of Sheffield (UK) e financiado pelo British Foreign and Commonwealth Office Global Opportunities Fund. Durante esse projeto, um protocolo para análise de ossadas foi implementado dentro de uma estrutura científica atualizada para aplicação em contextos de importância social. Após dois anos de funcionamento, constatou-se que muitas das ossadas encaminhadas ao CEMEL estavam incompletas, tornando a realização de um perfil biológico difícil e postergando a sua identificação devido à ausência de informações e literatura nacional recente sobre Antropologia Forense. Assim, 42 ossadas humanas examinadas no CEMEL desde sua inauguração em 1999 foram analisadas e revisadas. Os resultados mostraram que a maioria dos casos era de indivíduos do sexo masculino, de ancestralidade caucasiana, com idade entre 32,71 e 46,29 anos, estatura entre 1,64 e 1,73m, destros, sem achados patológicos, com elementos odontológicos informativos, mas sem roupas ou outros pertences. Observou-se que 61,90% das ossadas possuíam menos de 50% dos ossos, com média de 79,64±52,40 ossos por caso. Os ossos mais encaminhados foram occipital, parietal esquerdo, temporal esquerdo, parietal direito, temporal direito, fêmur direito e vértebras torácicas de um a 12. Os ossos menos encaminhados foram hióide, piramidal esquerdo, falange distal superior um direita, falanges distais superiores dois a cinco direitas e falanges médias superiores dois a cinco esquerdas. Os dentes mais encaminhados foram o 2º molar superior direito e o 1º molar superior direito, enquanto que os dentes menos encaminhados foram o incisivo central superior direito, os incisivos centrais inferiores direito e esquerdo. Roupas e outros pertences estavam presentes em 20 casos, totalizando 66 itens. Trinta e um casos têm potencial para identificação somente através de técnicas de Antropologia Forense. Para os demais 11 casos provavelmente será necessário utilizar DNA para identificação. Diante dos resultados observados, discute-se a necessidade de melhorias na capacitação técnica e infra-estrutura, assim como a forma de coleta e o transporte, de forma a aumentar o número de elementos ósseos coletados e, conseqüentemente, de informações úteis para identificação. Dois crânios apresentaram evidência de craniotomia realizada durante necropsia e um apresentou resíduos de vela, o que sugere que podem ter sido retirados indevidamente do local de sepultamento, ou até mesmo vendidos, além da sua utilização em rituais religiosos. Conclui-se que campanhas de conscientização e melhorias na fiscalização dos cemitérios podem reduzir os casos de roubos e comércio de elementos ósseos. / SOARES, A.T.C. Anthropological profile of the skeletons analyzed at the Medico Legal Centre (CEMEL) of the Faculty of Medicine of Ribeirão Preto USP. 2007. 169 p. Dissertation (Masters Degree) Faculty of Medicine of Ribeirão Preto, Ribeirão Preto, 2007. Forensic Anthropology is an area of knowledge that applies the methods of physical anthropology and archeology to the collection and analysis of legal evidence, including the search for individual identity. The Medico Legal Centre (CEMEL) of the Faculty of Medicine of Ribeirão Preto of University of São Paulo (FMRP-USP) has a Laboratory of Forensic Anthropology, created in 2005 during a development project in partnership with the University of Sheffield (UK) and financed by the British Foreign and Commonwealth Office Global Opportunities Fund. During this project, a protocol for skeletal analysis was implemented within an upgraded scientific infrastructure for application in a socially important context. After two years of work, it was noticed that many skeletons forwarded to CEMEL were incomplete, making completion of a biological profile difficult and postponing identification due to the lack of information and recent national literature about Forensic Anthropology. Therefore, 42 human skeletons examined at CEMEL since its inauguration in 1999 were analyzed and reviewed. The results showed most cases to be of male individuals, of Caucasian ethnic origin, aged between 32.71 and 46.29 y.o., of height between 1.64 and 1.73 m, right handed, without any pathological findings, with informative odontological findings, but with no clothes or other belongings. It was observed that 61.90% of the skeletons were less than 50% complete, with a mean of 79.64±52.40 bones per case. The most frequently found bones were the occipital, left parietal, left temporal, right parietal, right temporal, right femur and one to 12 thoracic vertebrae. The least frequent bones were the hyoid, left triquetral, 1st right superior distal phalanx, two to five right superior distal phalanges and two to five left superior intermediate phalanges. The most frequently found teeth were the right superior 2nd molar and right superior 1st molar, while the least frequent teeth were the right superior central incisor, and right and left inferior central incisors. Clothes or other belongings were present in 20 cases, totaling 66 items. Thirty one cases have potential to be identified only via forensic anthropological analysis. For the remaining 11 cases it will be probably necessary to use DNA for identification. In view of these observations the necessity for improvements in technical qualifications and infrastructure are discussed, as well as recovery and transport, in order to maximize the number of skeletal elements recovered andas a consequenceof information useful in identification. Two skulls presented evidence of a craniotomy conducted during autopsy and one of candle residue, suggesting that it may have been taken improperly from the place of burial, or even sold, for its use in religious rituals. It is concluded that public awareness campaigns and better inspection of cemeteries may reduce cases of robbery and trade in skeletal remains.