Spelling suggestions: "subject:"SWAT delmodell""
1 |
Impact of Land Management Practices on Water Balance and Sediment Transport in the Morogoro Catchment, Uluguru Mountains (Tanzania)Kilemo, Dominico Benedicto 15 February 2018 (has links) (PDF)
Tanzania, like other developing countries in the tropics is severely affected by the degradation of water resources owing to improper land management practices. Such practices affect water supply through soil erosion which does not only cause sedimentation of rivers and water bodies but also leads to a reduction in the rainwater infiltration capacity of soils. This thesis seeks to demonstrate how the implementation of proper land management measures can reduce soil erosion and increase water supply in the Morogoro River catchment (Uluguru Mountains). The proper practices referred to are the soil and water conservation (SWC) approaches which include contour farming, fanya juu terracing and bench terracing. The thesis combines social science and geoscience methods in a synergetic manner to address this research problem. To understand how and to what degree SWC methods affect water fluxes and sediment yields, the hydrological model SWAT (Soil and Water Assessment Tool) was applied. Before carrying out the modelling procedures, it was necessary to examine the level of SWC adoption among farmers and factors influencing the process so as to establish the baseline. To this end, biophysical and socio-economic factors assumed to affect farmers’ adoption tendency were examined using a household questionnaire.
Modelling results indicate that if correctly implemented contour farming, fanya juu terracing and bench terracing would significantly reduce sediment yield at different rates. The reduction would range approximately between 1% - 85% with the highest percentage change achieved by practicing the three SWC methods simultaneously. However, such SWC measures would not increase water flow annually owing to evapotranspiration losses. Nevertheless, according to modelling results groundwater storage would be increased by about 14% and hence contributing to water supply during the dry season. The household questionnaire survey suggests that the adoption of SWC methods in the study area is very low and complex. While age of the head of household, access to extension (professional) services, household annual income and proximity to the farm significantly influenced farmers’ decision to adopt SWC, gender of the head of household, slope characteristics of the farm, number of adults in the household and farmer’s perception on soil erosion effects had no considerable influence on adoption. Therefore, to successfully realize the SWC benefits demonstrated by the modelling results, smallholder farmers upstream of the catchment should be incentivized to implement proper land management practices. Payment for ecosystem services scheme appears to be a suitable strategy. To make this operational, the Tanzanian government should establish a national water fund which will finance watershed management activities. The methodological approach employed in this thesis is transferrable to other sites with problems comparable to the studied catchment.
|
2 |
Impact of Land Management Practices on Water Balance and Sediment Transport in the Morogoro Catchment, Uluguru Mountains (Tanzania)Kilemo, Dominico Benedicto 14 December 2017 (has links)
Tanzania, like other developing countries in the tropics is severely affected by the degradation of water resources owing to improper land management practices. Such practices affect water supply through soil erosion which does not only cause sedimentation of rivers and water bodies but also leads to a reduction in the rainwater infiltration capacity of soils. This thesis seeks to demonstrate how the implementation of proper land management measures can reduce soil erosion and increase water supply in the Morogoro River catchment (Uluguru Mountains). The proper practices referred to are the soil and water conservation (SWC) approaches which include contour farming, fanya juu terracing and bench terracing. The thesis combines social science and geoscience methods in a synergetic manner to address this research problem. To understand how and to what degree SWC methods affect water fluxes and sediment yields, the hydrological model SWAT (Soil and Water Assessment Tool) was applied. Before carrying out the modelling procedures, it was necessary to examine the level of SWC adoption among farmers and factors influencing the process so as to establish the baseline. To this end, biophysical and socio-economic factors assumed to affect farmers’ adoption tendency were examined using a household questionnaire.
Modelling results indicate that if correctly implemented contour farming, fanya juu terracing and bench terracing would significantly reduce sediment yield at different rates. The reduction would range approximately between 1% - 85% with the highest percentage change achieved by practicing the three SWC methods simultaneously. However, such SWC measures would not increase water flow annually owing to evapotranspiration losses. Nevertheless, according to modelling results groundwater storage would be increased by about 14% and hence contributing to water supply during the dry season. The household questionnaire survey suggests that the adoption of SWC methods in the study area is very low and complex. While age of the head of household, access to extension (professional) services, household annual income and proximity to the farm significantly influenced farmers’ decision to adopt SWC, gender of the head of household, slope characteristics of the farm, number of adults in the household and farmer’s perception on soil erosion effects had no considerable influence on adoption. Therefore, to successfully realize the SWC benefits demonstrated by the modelling results, smallholder farmers upstream of the catchment should be incentivized to implement proper land management practices. Payment for ecosystem services scheme appears to be a suitable strategy. To make this operational, the Tanzanian government should establish a national water fund which will finance watershed management activities. The methodological approach employed in this thesis is transferrable to other sites with problems comparable to the studied catchment.
|
3 |
Analysis and Model-Based Assessment of Water Quality under Data Scarcity Conditions in two rural WatershedsLopes Tavares Wahren, Filipa Isabel 10 June 2020 (has links)
Pollution of surface and groundwater, due to improper land management, has become a major problem worldwide. Integrated watershed modelling provides a tool for the understanding of the processes governing water and matter transport at different scales within the watershed. The Soil Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) has been successfully utilized for the combined modelling of water fluxes and quality within a large range of scales and environmental conditions across the world. For suitable assessments integrated watershed models require large data sets of measured information for both model parameterization as for model calibration and validation. Data scarcity represents a serious limitation to the use of hydrologic models for supporting decision making processes, and may lead unsupported statements, poor statistics, misrepresentations, and, ultimately, to inappropriate measures for integrated water resources management efforts. In particular, the importance of spatially distributed soil information is often overlooked. In this thesis the eco-hydrological SWAT model was been applied to assess the water balance and diffuse pollution loadings of two rivers within a rural context at the mesoscale watershed level: 1) the Western Bug River, Ukraine, 2) the Águeda River, Portugal. Both watersheds in focus serve as examples for areas where the amount and quality of the measured data hinders a strait forward hydrologic modelling assessment. The Dobrotvir watershed (Western Bug River, Ukriane) is an example of such a region. In the former Soviet Union, soil classification primarily focused on soils of agricultural importance, whereas, forested, urban, industrial, and shallow soil territories were left underrepresented in the classification systems and resulting soil maps. Similarly the forest-dominated Águeda watershed in North-Central Portugal is a second example of a region with serious soil data availability limitations. Through the use of pedotransfer functions (PTFs) and the construction of soil-landscape models the data gaps could be successfully diminished, allowing a subsequent integrated watershed modelling approach. A valuable tool for the data gap closure was the fuzzy logic Soil Land Inference Model (SoLIM) which, combined with information from several soil surveys, was used to create improved maps. In the Dobrotvir watershed the fuzzy approach was used to close the gaps of the existing soil map, while in the Águeda watershed a new soil properties map, based upon the effective soil depths of the landscape, was constructed. While the water balance simulation in both study areas was successful, a calibration parameter ensemble approach was tested for the Águeda watershed. In the common modelling practice the individual best simulation and best parameter set is considered, the tested approach involved merging individual model outputs from numerous acceptable parameter sets, tackling the problematic of parameter equifinality. This procedure was tested for both original soil map and the newly derived soil map with differentiation of soil properties. It was noticeable that a better model set-up, with a better representation of the soil spatial distribution, was reflected in tighter model output spreads and narrower parameter distances. A further challenge was the calibration of water quality parameters, namely nitrate-N in the Dobrotvir watershed and sediment loads in the Águeda watershed. The limited amount of water quality observations were handled by assessing and by process verification at the smallest modelling unit, the hydrological response unit (HRU). The ruling hydrological processes could be depicted by combining own measured data and modelling outputs. The management scenario simulations showed the anticipated response to changes in management and reflected the rational spatial variation within the watershed reasonably well. The impacts of the different intervention options were evaluated on water balance, nitrate-N export and sediment yield at the watershed, sub-watershed and, when feasible, HRU level. This thesis covers two regional case studies with particular data limitations and specific processes of water and matter fluxes. Still, data reliability is a problem across the globe. This thesis demonstrates how relevant it is to tackle shortages of spatially differentiated soil information. The considered approaches contribute toward more reliable model predictions. Furthermore, the tested methods are transferable to other regions with differing landscape and climate conditions with similar problems of data scarcity, particularly soil spatially differentiated information.
|
4 |
A Multi-Scale Assessment of Land-Use Impacts on Hydrologic Ecosystem Services in the Vouga Basin, North-Central PortugalHawtree, Daniel Robert 20 December 2019 (has links)
Sustainable water resource management requires understanding how hydrologic processes are impacted by environmental management and land-use decisions across multiple spatial and temporal scales. A key concept in this respect is hydrologic ecosystem services (HES), which are the water related ‘goods’ produced by the environment which are valuable to humans. This dissertation assesses a range of topics concerning HES in the Vouga basin (north-central Portugal), and their connection with land-cover and land-use practices. Specifically, the relationship between changes in forest and agricultural land-cover and management practices, and associated changes in HES were examined using a range of statistical and modeling approaches. To quantify the effects of different agricultural scenarios on both HES and potential stakeholders, the ‘Soil and Water Assessment Tool’ (SWAT) was utilized, in conjunction with economic assessment methods.
The first research section (Section 6) of the dissertation assesses the trends in streamflow quantity and yield in the Águeda watershed (a sub-basin of the Vouga) over a 75-yr period which coincided with large-scale afforestation of Pinus pinaster and (later) Eucalyptus globulus. Counter to the findings from meta-analysis studies of the effect of forest change on water availability, this study did not detect statistically significant trends in streamflow. By contrast, these findings support the view that there are prerequisite climatic, pedological, and eco-physiological watershed conditions that are necessary to observe hydrologic impacts at the watershed scale (which are not present in the Águeda watershed). By contrast, the significant changes which were detected are related to baseflow, which correspond with different periods of afforestation, and may be attributable to the promotion of soil water repellency under the mature pine and eucalypt stands.
In the second research section (Section 7), an assessment is carried out on the hydrologic and nitrate dynamics at the whole basin scale, using the SWAT model. This assessment indicated that there is a high degree of variability in nitrate export from the different parts of the basin, with the highest rates coming from the lower (agriculturally dominated portion) of the basin. The main flow pathways for nitrate export were found to be leaching from agricultural land-cover types, which consistently had the highest export for all land-use and pathways. These findings indicate that the water bodies at the highest risk of nitrate pollution in the Vouga basin are the groundwater aquifers.
The final research section (Section 8) utilizes the SWAT model to examine how reduced rates of fertilizer inputs would affect nitrate leaching, crop yields, and agricultural profitability in the lower Vouga basin. This research found that reduced rates of fertilization would reduce the amount of leached nitrate substantially, but that this would also lead to a large decrease in crop yield and profitability. A large difference in the inefficiency (i.e. crop production vs. nitrate export) between different HRUs was found, which could provide a focus for potential management action. This research strongly indicates that such actions may be needed to reduce the negative impacts of this pollution on the value of the groundwater aquifers, and to avoid associated costs which are otherwise passed on to local water users (e.g. through higher water treatment costs).
The overall findings of the dissertation highlight the importance of the upper (forested) basin as a drinking water supply area, given the prevalence of nitrate pollution in the lower basin. However, the historic afforestation in the Vouga basin has resulted in a reduction in baseflow, which is negative from a drinking water supply perspective. Therefore, while the forested uplands are beneficial from water quality standpoint (compared to intensive agriculture), they also have altered flow patterns in a manner which will reduce available supply. The findings from the upper basin contrast sharply with the lower basin, where there are potentially large negative HES impacts due to current agricultural practices. These practices will primarily impact groundwater aquifers, and therefore the water quality within the lower basin receive little benefit from the relatively high-quality water from the upper basin. This highlights the importance of considering the interconnectivity of HES across spatial scales, which will depend on the specific site characteristics of the river basin.
|
5 |
Integrated watershed modeling in Central Brazil / Integrierte Einzugsgebietsmodellierung in Zentralbrasilien: Beiträge zur robusten prozessbasierten ModellsimulationStrauch, Michael 03 July 2014 (has links) (PDF)
Over the last decades, fast growing population along with urban and agricultural sprawl has drastically increased the pressure on water resources of the Federal District (DF), Brazil. Various socio-environmental problems, such as soil erosion, non-point source pollution, reservoir silting, and conflicts among water users evoked the need for more efficient and sustainable ways to use land and water. Due to the complexity of processes relevant at the scale of river basins, a prior analysis of impacts of certain land use and/or land management changes is only feasible by means of modeling. The Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) has been proven to be useful in this context, across the globe and for different environmental conditions. In this thesis, the SWAT model is utilized to evaluate the impact of Best Management Practices (BMPs) on catchment hydrology and sediment transport.
However, model applications in tropical regions, such as the DF, are hampered by severe challenges, (i) the lack of input and control data in an adequate temporal and spatial resolution and (ii) model structural failures in representing processes under tropical conditions. The present (cumulative) thesis addresses these challenges in model simulations for two contrasting watersheds, which both are important sources of the DF’s drinking water supply, i.e. (i) the agriculture-dominated Pipiripau river basin where conflicting demands put immense pressure on the available water resources and (ii) the Santa Maria / Torto river basin, which is to large parts protected as national park and, thus, covered by native vegetation of the Cerrado biome.
Perhaps one of the most challenging issues facing watershed modelers in tropical regions is the fact that rain gauge networks can usually not reflect the high spatio-temporal variability of mostly convective precipitation patterns. Therefore, an ensemble of different reasonable input precipitation data-sets was used to examine the uncertainty in parameterization and model output. Acceptable streamflow and sediment load predictions could be achieved for each input data-set. However, the best-fit parameter values varied widely across the ensemble. Due to its enhanced consideration of parameter uncertainty, this ensemble approach provides more robust predictions and hence is reasonable to be used also for scenario simulations. BMP scenarios for the Pipiripau River Basin revealed that erosion control constructions, such as terraces and small retention basins along roads (Barraginhas) are promising measures to reduce sediment loads (up to 40%) while maintaining streamflow. Tests for a multi-diverse crop rotation system, in contrast, showed a high vulnerability of the hydrologic system against any increase in irrigation. Considering the BMP implementation costs, it was possible to estimate cost-abatement curves, which can provide useful information for watershed managers, especially when BMPs are supported by Payments for Environmental Services as it is the case in the study area due to the program Produtor de Água.
While for agricultural areas the model has proven to generate plausible results, the plant growth module of SWAT was found to be not suitable for simulating perennial tropical vegetation, such as Cerrado (savanna) or forest, which can also play a crucial role in river basin management. For temperate regions SWAT uses dormancy to terminate growing seasons of trees and perennials. However, there is no mechanism considered to reflect seasonality in the tropics, i.e. the phenological change between wet and dry season. Therefore, a soil moisture based approach was implemented into the plant growth module to trigger new growing cycles in the transition period from dry to wet season. The adapted model was successfully tested against LAI and ET time series derived from remote sensing products (MODIS). Since the proposed changes are process-based but also allow flexible model settings, the modified plant growth module can be seen as a fundamental improvement useful for future model application in the tropics.
The present thesis shows insights into the workflow of a watershed model application in the semi-humid tropics – from input data processing and model setup over source code adaptation, model calibration and uncertainty analysis to its use for running scenarios. It depicts region-specific challenges but also provides practical solutions. Hence, this work might be seen as one further step toward robust and process-based model predictions to assist land and water resources management. / Starkes Bevölkerungswachstum, ungeplante Suburbanisierung und Landnutzungsänderungen (z.B. Intensivierung in der Landwirtschaft) verstärkten innerhalb der letzten Jahrzehnte zunehmend den Druck auf die Wasserressourcen des Bundesdistrikts Brasilien (zentralbrasilianisches Hochland), in dessen Mitte die junge Hauptstadt Brasília liegt. Damit verbundene negative Umweltauswirkungen, wie Bodenerosion, Stoff- und Sedimenteinträge in Fließgewässer und Talsperren sowie Konflikte zwischen den Wassernutzern erfordern daher dringend effektive und nachhaltige Lösungen im Land- und Wasserressourcen-management.
Der Einfluss von möglichen zukünftigen Landnutzungs- und Bewirtschaftungsänderungen auf Wasserverfügbarkeit und -qualität hängt vom jeweiligen, oftmals sehr komplexen, landschaftsökologischen Prozessgefüge ab und kann nur mithilfe von prozessbasierten Simulationsmodellen quantitativ auf der Ebene von Einzugsgebieten abgeschätzt werden. Das “Soil and Water Assessment Tool” (SWAT) ist ein solches Modell. Es findet weltweite Anwendung für verschiedene Umweltbedingungen in Einzugsgebieten der Meso- bis Makroskala, um Landnutzungseffekte auf den Wasserhaushalt und den Transport von Nährstoffen, Pestiziden und Sedimenten zu prognostizieren. Seine Anwendung in tropischen Regionen, wie etwa in Zentralbrasilien, ist jedoch mit erheblichen Herausforderungen verbunden. Das betrifft sowohl die Verfügbarkeit von Eingangs- und Referenzdaten in ausreichender raum-zeitlicher Auflösung, als auch modellstrukturelle Unzulänglichkeiten bei der Prozessabbildung. Die vorliegende kumulative Dissertation zeigt dies anhand von Modellanwendungen für zwei unterschiedliche wasserwirtschaftlich relevante Einzugsgebiete (EZG): Das landwirtschaftlich intensiv genutzte EZG des Rio Pipiripau mit aktuell besonders konfliktträchtiger Wassernutzung, und das Santa Maria/Torto-EZG, welches - geschützt als Nationalpark - durch größtenteils natürliche Vegetationsformationen der brasilianischen Savanne (Cerrado) gekennzeichnet ist.
Eine der größten Herausforderungen für die Einzugsgebietsmodellierung in tropischen Regionen liegt in der Abschätzung des Gebietsniederschlages, da vorhandene Messstationsdichten oft nicht ausreichen, um die hohe räumliche und zeitliche Variabilität der meist konvektiven Niederschläge zu erfassen. Mithilfe eines Ensembles verschiedener, plausibel generierter Niederschlagsreihen ist der Einfluss von Niederschlagsdaten-Unsicherheit auf die Modellparametrisierung und -vorhersage explizit berücksichtigt und untersucht worden. Zufriedenstellende Abfluss- und Sedimentfrachtsimulationen waren mit jeder der als Modelinput verwendeten Niederschlagsreihen möglich, jedoch nur bei entsprechender, z.T. stark voneinander abweichender Einstellung der Kalibrierungsparameter. Da diese umfassendere Betrachtung von Parameterunsicherheit zu robusteren Modellvorhersagen führt, wurde der Ensemble-Ansatz auch in der Simulation von Bewirtschaftungsszenarien, dem eigentlichen Modellzweck, verwendet. Die Szenariosimulationen zeigten, dass Maßnahmen zur Erosionsvermeidung (Terrassierung) und zum Sedimentrückhalt (kleine Sedimentrückhaltebecken entlang von Straßen - Barraginhas) die Sedimentfracht des Rio Pipiripau durchschnittlich um bis zu 40% reduzieren können, ohne dabei die Wasserverfügbarkeit zu beeinträchtigen.
Modellszenarien mit einer vielgliedrigen Fruchtfolge auf großer Fläche verdeutlichten dagegen die hohe Vulnerabilität des Niedrigwasserabflusses in der Trockenzeit gegenüber jedweder Erhöhung der Bewässerungsmenge. Auf Grundlage von Kostenschätzungen für einzelne Maßnahmen konnten Kostenkurven zur Verringerung der Sedimentfracht und damit nützliche Informationen für das Wasserressourcen-Management abgeleitet werden, insbesondere weil eine Auswahl solcher Agrar-Umweltmaßnahmen im Pipiripau-EZG durch das Programm Produtor de Água finanziell gefördert werden sollen. Während das Modell in landwirtschaftlich genutzten Gebieten plausible Ergebnisse produzierte, wurden erhebliche Schwachstellen in der Simulation ausdauernder Vegetation (z.B. Cerrado) identifiziert. Zur Unterbrechung jährlicher Vegetationszyklen verwendet SWAT eine tageslängenabhängige Dormanzperiode. Diese ist zwar zweckmäßig zur Abbildung der Vegetationsdynamik in den gemäßigten Breiten, steuert aber nicht tropische Vegetationszyklen. Um den Wechsel zwischen Trocken- und Regenzeit in der pflanzenphänologischen Simulation in SWAT abzubilden, wurde daher im Rahmen dieser Arbeit das Pflanzenwachstumsmodul modifiziert, und zwar unter anderem durch Einbeziehung der simulierten Bodenfeuchte zur Unterbrechung der Wachstumszyklen. Das angepasste Modul wurde erfolgreich anhand von Fernerkundungsdaten (MODIS) zum zeitlichen Verlauf von Blattflächenindex und Evapotranspiration getestet. Es ist prozessbasiert und erlaubt flexible Einstellungen, so dass es als grundlegende Modellverbesserung auch für andere SWAT-Anwender von großem Nutzen sein kann.
Die vorliegende Dissertation bringt neue Einsichten in verschiedene wichtige Aspekte der integrierten Modellierung tropischer Einzugsgebiete, von der Eingangsdatenaufbereitung über Quellcode-Anpassung, Modellkalibrierung und Unsicherheitsanalyse bis hin zu Szenariosimulationen. Sie veranschaulicht regionsspezifische Herausforderungen, liefert gleichzeitig aber auch praktikable Lösungen und damit einen wichtigen Beitrag für robustere prozessbasierte Modellanwendungen als Entscheidungsunterstützung im Bereich Land- und Wasserressourcenmanagement.
|
6 |
Integrated watershed modeling in Central Brazil: Toward robust process-based predictionsStrauch, Michael 16 April 2014 (has links)
Over the last decades, fast growing population along with urban and agricultural sprawl has drastically increased the pressure on water resources of the Federal District (DF), Brazil. Various socio-environmental problems, such as soil erosion, non-point source pollution, reservoir silting, and conflicts among water users evoked the need for more efficient and sustainable ways to use land and water. Due to the complexity of processes relevant at the scale of river basins, a prior analysis of impacts of certain land use and/or land management changes is only feasible by means of modeling. The Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) has been proven to be useful in this context, across the globe and for different environmental conditions. In this thesis, the SWAT model is utilized to evaluate the impact of Best Management Practices (BMPs) on catchment hydrology and sediment transport.
However, model applications in tropical regions, such as the DF, are hampered by severe challenges, (i) the lack of input and control data in an adequate temporal and spatial resolution and (ii) model structural failures in representing processes under tropical conditions. The present (cumulative) thesis addresses these challenges in model simulations for two contrasting watersheds, which both are important sources of the DF’s drinking water supply, i.e. (i) the agriculture-dominated Pipiripau river basin where conflicting demands put immense pressure on the available water resources and (ii) the Santa Maria / Torto river basin, which is to large parts protected as national park and, thus, covered by native vegetation of the Cerrado biome.
Perhaps one of the most challenging issues facing watershed modelers in tropical regions is the fact that rain gauge networks can usually not reflect the high spatio-temporal variability of mostly convective precipitation patterns. Therefore, an ensemble of different reasonable input precipitation data-sets was used to examine the uncertainty in parameterization and model output. Acceptable streamflow and sediment load predictions could be achieved for each input data-set. However, the best-fit parameter values varied widely across the ensemble. Due to its enhanced consideration of parameter uncertainty, this ensemble approach provides more robust predictions and hence is reasonable to be used also for scenario simulations. BMP scenarios for the Pipiripau River Basin revealed that erosion control constructions, such as terraces and small retention basins along roads (Barraginhas) are promising measures to reduce sediment loads (up to 40%) while maintaining streamflow. Tests for a multi-diverse crop rotation system, in contrast, showed a high vulnerability of the hydrologic system against any increase in irrigation. Considering the BMP implementation costs, it was possible to estimate cost-abatement curves, which can provide useful information for watershed managers, especially when BMPs are supported by Payments for Environmental Services as it is the case in the study area due to the program Produtor de Água.
While for agricultural areas the model has proven to generate plausible results, the plant growth module of SWAT was found to be not suitable for simulating perennial tropical vegetation, such as Cerrado (savanna) or forest, which can also play a crucial role in river basin management. For temperate regions SWAT uses dormancy to terminate growing seasons of trees and perennials. However, there is no mechanism considered to reflect seasonality in the tropics, i.e. the phenological change between wet and dry season. Therefore, a soil moisture based approach was implemented into the plant growth module to trigger new growing cycles in the transition period from dry to wet season. The adapted model was successfully tested against LAI and ET time series derived from remote sensing products (MODIS). Since the proposed changes are process-based but also allow flexible model settings, the modified plant growth module can be seen as a fundamental improvement useful for future model application in the tropics.
The present thesis shows insights into the workflow of a watershed model application in the semi-humid tropics – from input data processing and model setup over source code adaptation, model calibration and uncertainty analysis to its use for running scenarios. It depicts region-specific challenges but also provides practical solutions. Hence, this work might be seen as one further step toward robust and process-based model predictions to assist land and water resources management. / Starkes Bevölkerungswachstum, ungeplante Suburbanisierung und Landnutzungsänderungen (z.B. Intensivierung in der Landwirtschaft) verstärkten innerhalb der letzten Jahrzehnte zunehmend den Druck auf die Wasserressourcen des Bundesdistrikts Brasilien (zentralbrasilianisches Hochland), in dessen Mitte die junge Hauptstadt Brasília liegt. Damit verbundene negative Umweltauswirkungen, wie Bodenerosion, Stoff- und Sedimenteinträge in Fließgewässer und Talsperren sowie Konflikte zwischen den Wassernutzern erfordern daher dringend effektive und nachhaltige Lösungen im Land- und Wasserressourcen-management.
Der Einfluss von möglichen zukünftigen Landnutzungs- und Bewirtschaftungsänderungen auf Wasserverfügbarkeit und -qualität hängt vom jeweiligen, oftmals sehr komplexen, landschaftsökologischen Prozessgefüge ab und kann nur mithilfe von prozessbasierten Simulationsmodellen quantitativ auf der Ebene von Einzugsgebieten abgeschätzt werden. Das “Soil and Water Assessment Tool” (SWAT) ist ein solches Modell. Es findet weltweite Anwendung für verschiedene Umweltbedingungen in Einzugsgebieten der Meso- bis Makroskala, um Landnutzungseffekte auf den Wasserhaushalt und den Transport von Nährstoffen, Pestiziden und Sedimenten zu prognostizieren. Seine Anwendung in tropischen Regionen, wie etwa in Zentralbrasilien, ist jedoch mit erheblichen Herausforderungen verbunden. Das betrifft sowohl die Verfügbarkeit von Eingangs- und Referenzdaten in ausreichender raum-zeitlicher Auflösung, als auch modellstrukturelle Unzulänglichkeiten bei der Prozessabbildung. Die vorliegende kumulative Dissertation zeigt dies anhand von Modellanwendungen für zwei unterschiedliche wasserwirtschaftlich relevante Einzugsgebiete (EZG): Das landwirtschaftlich intensiv genutzte EZG des Rio Pipiripau mit aktuell besonders konfliktträchtiger Wassernutzung, und das Santa Maria/Torto-EZG, welches - geschützt als Nationalpark - durch größtenteils natürliche Vegetationsformationen der brasilianischen Savanne (Cerrado) gekennzeichnet ist.
Eine der größten Herausforderungen für die Einzugsgebietsmodellierung in tropischen Regionen liegt in der Abschätzung des Gebietsniederschlages, da vorhandene Messstationsdichten oft nicht ausreichen, um die hohe räumliche und zeitliche Variabilität der meist konvektiven Niederschläge zu erfassen. Mithilfe eines Ensembles verschiedener, plausibel generierter Niederschlagsreihen ist der Einfluss von Niederschlagsdaten-Unsicherheit auf die Modellparametrisierung und -vorhersage explizit berücksichtigt und untersucht worden. Zufriedenstellende Abfluss- und Sedimentfrachtsimulationen waren mit jeder der als Modelinput verwendeten Niederschlagsreihen möglich, jedoch nur bei entsprechender, z.T. stark voneinander abweichender Einstellung der Kalibrierungsparameter. Da diese umfassendere Betrachtung von Parameterunsicherheit zu robusteren Modellvorhersagen führt, wurde der Ensemble-Ansatz auch in der Simulation von Bewirtschaftungsszenarien, dem eigentlichen Modellzweck, verwendet. Die Szenariosimulationen zeigten, dass Maßnahmen zur Erosionsvermeidung (Terrassierung) und zum Sedimentrückhalt (kleine Sedimentrückhaltebecken entlang von Straßen - Barraginhas) die Sedimentfracht des Rio Pipiripau durchschnittlich um bis zu 40% reduzieren können, ohne dabei die Wasserverfügbarkeit zu beeinträchtigen.
Modellszenarien mit einer vielgliedrigen Fruchtfolge auf großer Fläche verdeutlichten dagegen die hohe Vulnerabilität des Niedrigwasserabflusses in der Trockenzeit gegenüber jedweder Erhöhung der Bewässerungsmenge. Auf Grundlage von Kostenschätzungen für einzelne Maßnahmen konnten Kostenkurven zur Verringerung der Sedimentfracht und damit nützliche Informationen für das Wasserressourcen-Management abgeleitet werden, insbesondere weil eine Auswahl solcher Agrar-Umweltmaßnahmen im Pipiripau-EZG durch das Programm Produtor de Água finanziell gefördert werden sollen. Während das Modell in landwirtschaftlich genutzten Gebieten plausible Ergebnisse produzierte, wurden erhebliche Schwachstellen in der Simulation ausdauernder Vegetation (z.B. Cerrado) identifiziert. Zur Unterbrechung jährlicher Vegetationszyklen verwendet SWAT eine tageslängenabhängige Dormanzperiode. Diese ist zwar zweckmäßig zur Abbildung der Vegetationsdynamik in den gemäßigten Breiten, steuert aber nicht tropische Vegetationszyklen. Um den Wechsel zwischen Trocken- und Regenzeit in der pflanzenphänologischen Simulation in SWAT abzubilden, wurde daher im Rahmen dieser Arbeit das Pflanzenwachstumsmodul modifiziert, und zwar unter anderem durch Einbeziehung der simulierten Bodenfeuchte zur Unterbrechung der Wachstumszyklen. Das angepasste Modul wurde erfolgreich anhand von Fernerkundungsdaten (MODIS) zum zeitlichen Verlauf von Blattflächenindex und Evapotranspiration getestet. Es ist prozessbasiert und erlaubt flexible Einstellungen, so dass es als grundlegende Modellverbesserung auch für andere SWAT-Anwender von großem Nutzen sein kann.
Die vorliegende Dissertation bringt neue Einsichten in verschiedene wichtige Aspekte der integrierten Modellierung tropischer Einzugsgebiete, von der Eingangsdatenaufbereitung über Quellcode-Anpassung, Modellkalibrierung und Unsicherheitsanalyse bis hin zu Szenariosimulationen. Sie veranschaulicht regionsspezifische Herausforderungen, liefert gleichzeitig aber auch praktikable Lösungen und damit einen wichtigen Beitrag für robustere prozessbasierte Modellanwendungen als Entscheidungsunterstützung im Bereich Land- und Wasserressourcenmanagement.
|
Page generated in 0.0481 seconds