published_or_final_version / Language Studies / Master / Master of Arts

This research is a case study which sought to investigate the educational implication of code switching in a multilingual school in Matatiele. Since the dawn of democracy in South Africa, the language policy has sought to promote multilingualism and also honours the cultural diversity existing in this country. It is against this background that the study was conducted. The present study also sought to investigate the occurrences and nature of code switching in the classroom context. In South Africa, the Language in Education Policy prescribes that English as Language of Learning and Teaching be practiced from Grade 4 upwards, alongside home languages. At school, it seems that teachers are not empowered regarding the approach towards code switching. The study investigates whether the use of code switching in a classroom context is in line with the Language in Education Policy. It also looks at the implications of trilingual instruction (which is the use of three languages) in content subjects in the classroom. Functions of code switching were examined as well. This empirical research study used qualitative research methods. Qualitative research provided the study with insight into code switching in the educational context. This study encompassed specific techniques for collecting data, mainly observations. Notes were also of some assistance and were jotted down while observation was underway to supplement what could not be captured by the video, such as emotion and feelings. The study concluded that code switching plays a significant role in an English as Second Language (ESL) classroom context. / Linguistics and Modern Languages / M. A. (Linguistics)

L'objectif de ce travail de thèse était de déterminer si l’expertise linguistique peut moduler les capacités d’apprentissage, et plus spécifiquement les capacités d’apprentissage statistique. Il a été démontré que l'utilisation régulière de deux langues par les personnes bilingues a un impact sur les capacités langagières mais également sur le fonctionnement cognitif de manière plus générale. Cependant, on ne sait que très peu concernant les effets du bilinguisme sur les capacités d'apprentissage. L’acquisition du langage repose en partie sur le traitement des régularités statistiques de la parole. Etant spécifiques à chaque langue, cette information doit être traitée en partant de zéro lors de l’apprentissage d’une nouvelle langue. Les personnes bilingues ont donc traité au moins deux fois plus d'information statistique que les personnes ne maîtrisant qu'une langue. Est-ce que le bilinguisme et l’expérience accrue de traitement statistique de la parole peuvent conférer un avantage en termes de capacités d’apprentissage de régularités ?Nous avons analysé cette question à trois niveaux: la disponibilité des connaissances acquises à la conscience, le décours temporel du traitement statistique et la nature des représentations formées lors de l'apprentissage statistique. Explorer comment l'expertise linguistique module l'apprentissage statistique contribuera à une meilleure compréhension des conséquences cognitives du bilinguisme, mais pourrait également fournir des indices concernant le lien entre l'apprentissage statistique et le langage.<p>Dans un premier temps, la question de la disponibilité des connaissances acquises à la conscience a été traitée (Etude 1 et 2). L'étude 1 présente une adaptation d’une méthode largement utilisée dans le domaine de l’apprentissage implicite pour rendre compte du caractère conscient ou inconscient des connaissances acquises lors d’un apprentissage, la procédure de dissociation des processus (Jacoby, 1991). Nous avons adapté cette méthode à une situation de traitement des probabilités transitionnelles entre des syllabes afin de déterminer si les représentations acquises suite à l’exposition à un langage artificiel sont disponibles à la conscience. Nous nous sommes ensuite intéressés à la question de savoir comment le caractère conscient des connaissances acquises peut être modulé par l’expertise linguistique. Les résultats suggèrent que bien que les sujets apprennent de manière semblable, les connaissances acquises semblent être moins disponibles à la conscience chez les sujets bilingues.<p>Dans un deuxième temps nous nous sommes intéressés au décours temporel de l’apprentissage statistique (Etude 3 et 4). L'étude 3 présente une adaptation de la Click location task (Fodor & Bever, 1965) comme mesure online du traitement des probabilités transitionnelles lors de la segmentation de la parole. Nous nous sommes ensuite intéressés à comment le traitement des régularités du langage pouvait être modulé par l’expertise linguistique (Etude 4) et les résultats suggèrent que les deux groupes ne diffèrent pas en termes de décours temporel du traitement statistique.<p>Dans un troisième temps, nous avons posé la question de ce qui est appris dans une situation d’apprentissage statistique. Est-ce que le produit de cet apprentissage correspond à des fragments d’information, des « candidats mots » ?Ou est-ce que, au contraire, l’apprentissage résulte en une sensibilité aux probabilités de transition entre les éléments ?L’Etude 5 propose une méthode pour déterminer la nature des représentations formées lors de l’apprentissage statistique. Le but de cette étude était d’opposer deux modèles d’apprentissage de régularités statistiques afin de déterminer lequel rend mieux compte des résultats observés lors d’une situation d’apprentissage statistique. Dans l’étude 6, nous nous sommes intéressés à l’influence de l’expertise linguistique sur la nature des représentations formées. Les résultats suggèrent que les sujets bilingues forment des représentations plus fidèles à la réalité du matériel, comparé aux monolingues.<p>Enfin l'étude 7 avait pour but d'explorer une situation d'apprentissage statistique plus complexe, à savoir l'apprentissage d'une grammaire artificielle. La comparaison entre des sujets monolingues et bilingues suggère que les sujets ne diffèrent pas en termes de décours temporel de l'apprentissage. Par contre, les sujets bilingues semblent former de meilleures représentations du matériel présenté et posséder des connaissances non disponibles à la conscience, alors que les monolingues se basent sur des connaissances conscientes pour effectuer la tâche.<p>Ainsi, les études présentées dans ce travail suggèrent que l'expertise linguistique ne module pas la vitesse de traitement de l'information statistique. Par contre, dans certaines situations, le fait d'être bilingue pourrait constituer un avantage en termes d'acquisition de connaissances sur base d'un traitement statistique et aurait également un impact sur la disponibilité des connaissances à la conscience. / The aim of this thesis was to determine whether linguistic expertise can modulate learning abilities, and more specifically statistical learning abilities. The regular use of two languages by bilingual individuals has been shown to have a broad impact on language and cognitive functioning. However, little is known about the effect of bilingualism on learning abilities. Language acquisition is a complex process that depends substantially on the processing of statistical regularities contained in speech. Because statistical information is language-specific, this information must be learned from scratch when one learns a new language. Unlike monolinguals, individuals who know more than one language, such as bilinguals or multilinguals, therefore face the challenge of having to master more than one set of statistical contingencies. Does bilingualism and increased experience with statistical processing of speech confer an advantage in terms of learning abilities? In this thesis, we address these questions at three different levels. We compared monolinguals and bilinguals in terms of (1) the nature of the representations formed during learning, (2) the time course of statistical processing, and (3) the availability of statistical knowledge to consciousness. Exploring how linguistic expertise modulates statistical learning will contribute to a better understanding of the cognitive consequences of bilingualism, but could also provide clues regarding the link between statistical learning and language.<p>First, the present work aimed to determine whether knowledge acquired based on statistical regularities is amenable to conscious control (Study 1 and 2). Study 1 presents an adaptation of the Process Dissociation Procedure (PDP, Jacoby, 1991), a widely used method in the field of implicit learning to account for the conscious nature of knowledge acquired during a learning situation. We adapted this method to a statistical learning paradigm in which participants had to extract artificial words from a continuous speech stream. In Study 2, we used the PDP to explore the extent to which conscious access to the acquired knowledge is modulated by linguistic expertise. Our results suggest that although monolinguals and bilinguals learned the words similarly, knowledge seems to be less available to consciousness for bilingual participants.<p>Second, in Studies 3 & 4, we investigated the time course of statistical learning. Study 3 introduces a novel online measure of transitional probabilities processing during speech segmentation, — an adaptation of the Click Localizaton Task (Fodor & Bever, 1965) as. In Study 4, explored whether processing of statistical regularities of speech could be modulated by linguistic expertise. The results suggest that the two groups did not differ in terms of time course of statistical processing.<p>Third, we aimed at exploring what is learned in a statistical learning situation. Two different kinds of mechanisms may account for performance. Participants may either parse the material into smaller chunks that correspond to the words of the artificial language, or they may become progressively sensitive to the actual values of the transitional probabilities between syllables. Study 5 proposes a method to determine the nature of the representations formed during learning. The purpose of this study was to compare two models of statistical learning (PARSER vs. SRN) in order to determine which better reflects the representations formed as a result of statistical learning. In study 6, we investigated the influence of linguistic expertise on the nature of the representations formed. The results suggests that bilinguals tend to form representations of the learned sequences that are more faithful to the reality of the material, compared to monolinguals.<p>Finally, Study 7 investigates how linguistic expertise influences a more complex statistical learning situation, namely artificial grammar learning. Comparison between monolingual and bilingual subjects suggests that subjects did not differ in terms of the time course of learning. However, bilinguals outperformed monolinguals in learning the grammar and seem to possess both conscious and unconscious knowledge, whereas monolinguals’ performance was only based on conscious knowledge.<p>To sum up, the studies presented in the present work suggest that linguistic expertise does not modulate the speed of processing of statistical information. However, bilinguals seem have make better use of the learned regularities and outperformed monolinguals in some specific situations. Moreover, linguistic expertise also seems to have an impact on the availability of knowledge to consciousness. / Doctorat en Sciences Psychologiques et de l'éducation / info:eu-repo/semantics/nonPublished

The study investigates prediction factors of children's proficiency in Russian among children from Russian-speaking families in Saskatchewan. For that purpose, 5-7 year old children and their parents were interviewed about their language use, proficiency, and language attitudes, as well as children's Russian language proficiency was measured and compared to monolingual children in Russia.

Vocabulary is well acknowledged as playing a critical role in language and reading development for young children, particularly for children learning English as an Additional Language (EAL) in school (Scarborough, 2001; Stahl & Nagy, 2005). However, most previous research on vocabulary has focused on measuring individual words and failed to examine knowledge of multi-word phrases, despite corpus evidence that these items are common in the English lexicon (Erman & Warren, 2000). The nature of multi-word vocabulary knowledge and its possible contribution to literacy skills among children remains underexplored, possibly due to a lack of available suitable measures. The current thesis details the development and administration of an original multi-word phrase task containing transparent, semi-transparent and non-transparent verb + object phrases to 108 British monolingual English speakers and learners with EAL in school years 3, 4 and 5. Results showed a strong effect of item transparency, even greater than frequency. Year 4 monolingual English speakers had significantly higher scores than year 3 monolingual learners on non-transparent items, while among learners with EAL year 3 and 4 performances were similar and year 5 learners’ scores were significantly higher. The second phase of the study explored the contribution of multi-word phrase knowledge to reading among 40 year 4 monolingual English speaking children and Bengali speakers with EAL. Multiple regression analysis showed that multi-word task performance accounted for a significant amount of variance in reading scores, when controlling for non-verbal intelligence, receptive and expressive single word vocabulary and language background. These findings are of import for increasing our understanding of vocabulary development among young learners and provide insight into the particular needs of learners with EAL.

In this dissertation, the traditional dichotic listening paradigm was integrated with the notion of working memory capacity (WMC) to explore the cognitive mechanism of bilingual speech comprehension at the passage level. A bilingual dichotic listening (BDL) task was developed and administered to investigate characteristics of bilingual listening comprehension, which include semantic relatedness, unattended language, ear preference, auditory attentional control, executive control, voluntary note-taking, and language switching. The central concept of the BDL paradigm is that the auditory stimuli are presented in the bilinguals’ two languages and their attention is directed to one of their ears while they have to overcome cognitive and linguistic conflicts caused by information in the other ear. Different experimental manipulations were employed in the BDL task to examine the characteristics of bilingual listening comprehension. The bilingual population examined was Japanese- English bilinguals with relatively high second language (L2) proficiency and WMC. Seven experiments and seven cross-experimental comparisons are reported. Experiment 1 employed the BDL task with pairs of passages that had different semantic relationships (i.e., related or unrelated) and were heard in different languages (i.e., L1 or L2). The semantically related passages were found to interfere with comprehension of the attended passage more than the semantically unrelated passages, whether the attended and unattended languages were the same or different. Contrary to the theories of bilingual language control, unattended L1 was found to enhance comprehension of the attended passage, regardless of semantic relationships and language it was heard in. L2 proficiency and WMC served as good predictors of resolution of the cognitive and linguistic conflicts. The BDL task is suggested to serve as an experimental paradigm to explore executive control and language control in bilingual speech comprehension. Experiment 2 was conducted to investigate language lateralisation (i.e., ear preference) on bilingual speech comprehension, hence, the participants in Experiment 1 used their preferred ear, whereas participants in Experiment 2 used their non-preferred ear, whether it was left or right, in the BDL task. Comprehension was better through the preferred ear, indicating that there is a favourable ear-to-hemisphere route for understanding bilinguals’ two languages. Most of the participants were found to be left-lateralised (i.e., right-eared) and some to be right-lateralised (i.e., left-eared) presumably depending on their L2 proficiency and WMC. Experiment 3 was concerned with auditory attentional control, and explored whether there would be a right-ear advantage (REA). The participants indicated an REA whether the attended and unattended languages were L1 or L2. When they listened to Japanese in the left ear, they found it more difficult to suppress Japanese in the right ear than English. WMC was not required as much as expected for auditory attentional control probably because the passages in Experiment 3 did not yield as much semantic competition as those in Experiment 1. L2 proficiency was crucial for resolving within- and between-language competition in each ear. Experiments 4, 5, and 6 were replications of Experiments 1, 2 and 3, but these latter experiments considered the effect of note-taking that is commonly performed in everyday listening situations. Note-taking contributed to better performance and clearer understanding of the role of WMC in bilingual speech comprehension. A cross-experimental analysis between Experiments 1, 2, 4, and 5 revealed not only a facilitatory role of note-taking in bilingual listening comprehension in general, but also a hampering role when listening through the preferred ear. Experiment 7 addressed the effect of predictability of language switching by presenting L1 and L2 in a systematic order while switching attention between ears and comparing the result with that of Experiment 6 where language switching was unpredictable. The effect of predictability of language switching was different between ears. When language switches were predictable, higher comprehension was observed in the left ear than the right ear, and when language switches were unpredictable, higher comprehension was observed in the right ear than the left ear, thereby suggesting a mechanism of asymmetrical language control. WMC was more related to processing of predictable language switches than that of unpredictable language switches. The dissertation ends with discussions of the implications from the seven BDL experiments and possible applications, along with experimental techniques from other relevant disciplines that might be used in future research to yield additional insight into how bilingual listeners sustain their listening performance in their two languages in the real-life situations.

Purpose: This study examines potential cross-linguistic effects on accuracy of codas in newly learned English-like nonwords produced by bilingual Spanish-English-speaking children. Methods: Forty-two bilingual Spanish-English-speaking second-graders (age 7-9) were matched individually with monolingual peers on age (+/- 6 months), sex, and percentile score on the Goldman-Fristoe Test of Articulation (GFTA-2; Goldman & Fristoe, 2000), and matched for group on mother's level of education. Participants named various sea monsters as part of computerized word-learning games. Sixteen syllable-final coda consonants were analyzed for accuracy. These were drawn from thirteen nonwords distributed across five word-learning tasks. Results: Bilingual children were less accurate than monolingual children in production of both shared and unshared codas, though the gap was greater for unshared codas. Both bilingual and monolingual children were more accurate in production of shared codas than unshared codas. Conclusion: The results suggest that native language phonotactics influence accuracy of coda production in bilingual Spanish-English-speaking school-age children during word learning. Influences of native phonology on word learning could potentially impact academic achievement through vocabulary learning in the classroom.

Thesis (PhD)--Stellenbosch University, 2012. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This study investigates the effect of the increased use of a second language (L2) (English) as language of teaching and learning on the bilingual individual in a specific bilingual higher education context. The specific interest is in the development of conceptual fluency, and the role that bilingualism and the increased exposure to an L2 in a teaching and learning context plays in such development. In order to serve the interest of the study, the theoretical framework includes theories developed in language and cognition, bilingualism and cross-linguistic influence. The theoretical stance that is taken in this thesis is one that: recognises that bilingual individuals cannot be expected to exhibit the same kind of linguistic and conceptual knowledge as monolinguals, investigates the possibility that language can affect certain aspects of cognition, acknowledges that bilingual individuals themselves can contribute to the knowledge about the bilingual mind. The participants in the study are L1 speakers of Afrikaans who finished their secondary schooling in Afrikaans. At university they are increasingly exposed to more English as language of teaching and learning than in previous formal education. The effects of the increased use of English on conceptual fluency, academic achievement and self-perception of language proficiency were investigated. The study used university records, language tests and interviews to collect data. No concrete evidence could be found that English has a significantly positive or negative effect on 'conceptual fluency', academic achievement or self-perception of language proficiency. The study however provided valuable information about how bilinguals use the languages they have in their repertoires. The findings from the study suggest that increased exposure to an L2 leads to a unique form of language competence. This 'multi-competence' enables the participants in the study to use both languages in the understanding and learning of concepts in their respective fields of study. Thus this dissertation provides evidence that bilinguals can transfer knowledge and skills between the languages they know. Theories developed by Cook (1999, 2003) and Jarvis and Pavlenko (2008), that suggest transfer is bidirectional, is partly supported by the findings of the study. The study has various implications for the field of bilingualism in education. It illustrates how a multilingual context such as the one we have in South Africa complicates the use of certain methodologies and theoretical frameworks. This also means that models of bilingual education designed elsewhere cannot be implemented in the South African context without considered modification. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING : Hierdie studie het die effek van die toenemende gebruik van Engels (tweede taal) as medium van onderrig, op die tweetalige individu in 'n spesifieke tweetalige hoër onderwys konteks probeer peil. Die spesifieke belangstelling is in die ontwikkeling van konseptuele vlotheid en die rol wat tweetaligheid en die toenemende blootstelling aan 'n tweede taal (T2) in 'n onderrig en leer konteks speel in sodanige ontwikkeling. Om die belangstelling van die studie te dien, sluit die teoretiese raamwerk teorieë oor taal en kognitiewe vaardighede, tweetaligheid, en kruislinguistiese taal invloed in. Die teoretiese standpunt wat in die tesis geneem word, is een wat: erken dat tweetalige individue nie noodwendig dieselfde talige en konseptuele kennis as eentaliges vertoon nie, die moontlikheid ondersoek dat taal sekere aspekte van kognisie kan beïnvloed, en erken dat tweetalige individue kan bydra tot kennis oor die tweetalige denke. Die deelnemers aan die studie is eerstetaal sprekers van Afrikaans wat hulle sekondêre skoolloopbaan in Afrikaans voltooi het. In hulle universiteitsopleiding word hulle toenemend blootgestel aan meer Engels as taal van leer en onderrig as in hul vorige formele opleiding. Spesifiek is die effek van die gebruik van Engels op die Afrikaanse 'konsepsuele vlotheid', algehele akademiese prestasie en self-persepsie ondersoek. Die studie het universiteitsrekords, taaltoetse en onderhoude gebruik om data in te samel. Geen konkrete bewyse kon gevind word dat die gebruik van Engels, enige van die aspekte beduidend negatief of positief beïnvloed nie. Die studie het egter waardevolle inligting verskaf oor hoe tweetaliges die tale tot hul beskikking gebruik, en het ook bewyse gelewer dat toenemende blootstelling aan die tweede taal, 'n unieke vorm van taalvaardigheid tot gevolg het. Hierdie "multi-vaardigheid" het tot gevolg dat die deelnemers aan die studie toenemend beide tale gebruik in die leer en verstaan van konsepte in hul onderskeie studievelde. Die studie het ook ondersteuning gebied dat tweetaliges kennis en vaardighede kan oordra tussen die tale wat hulle ken. Teorieë wat deur Cook (1999, 2003) en Jarvis en Pavlenko (2008) ontwikkel is, wat voorstel dat oordrag bi-direksioneel is, word dus gedeeltelik ondersteun deur die studie. Die studie het verskeie implikasies vir die terrein van tweetaligheid in opvoedkunde. Dit illustreer hoe 'n veeltalige konteks soos ons dit in Suid-Afrika vind, die gebruik van sekere metodologieë en teoretiese raamwerke kompliseer. Dit beteken ook dat huidige modelle van tweetalige onderrig wat elders ontwikkel is nie sonder meer gebruik kan word in die Suid-Afrikaanse konteks sonder om dit aan te pas nie.

published_or_final_version / Law / Doctoral / Doctor of Philosophy

published_or_final_version / Education / Master / Master of Philosophy