More than a third of the earths marine mammal species are threatened. This study aims to analyze and evaluate the conservation of the proper Baltic harbour porpoisein Sweden. The population is estimated to consist of only 500 individuals and are likely to be extinct if measures are not taken. A new Swedish conservation planfor harbour porpoises will be implemented in 2021 and will be the first since 2013. This study analyzes the suggested conservation plan and aims to identify strengths and weaknesses in the actions. Through a grounded theory approach, a qualitative content analysis is performed to identify the action strengths and weaknesses. A scoring matrix was developed to create indicators of the actions effort, delivery and conservation. The findings show that the short-term goals and the actions have a multidirectional approach which lack an alignment to the vision and the long-term goal of the plan. The study presents the action efficiency, which shows the need for, and importance of prioritizing the actions with the most potential impact for conservation. Mainly, the study provides a framework for species conservation plan evaluation and by performing the plan evaluation prior to implementation, the study contributes to the field of environmental evaluations. / Över en tredjedel av jordens marina däggdjursarterär hotade. Studien analyserar och utvärderar Sveriges planer för bevarandet av Östersjötumlaren. Populationen beräknas bestå av endast 500 individer och är trolig att utrotas om förändring inte implementeras. En bevarandeplan för tumlare ska implementeras under 2021 och kommer att vara den första bevarandeplanen sedan 2013. Studien analyserar den föreslagna bevarandeplanen och identifierar styrkor och svagheter i de föreslagna åtgärderna. Genom en grundad teori genomförs en kvalitativ innehållsanalys av åtgärdernas styrkor och svagheter. En poängmatris utvecklades för att möjliggöra indikatorer för åtgärdernas ansträngning, utdelning och bevarandepotential. Studien presenterar huvudsakligen ett ramverk för utvärdering av artbevarandeplaner. Genom att utvärdera bevarandeplanen innan implementering bidrar studien till området för miljöutvärderingar.

The bycatch of cetaceans in fishing gear is considered to be one of the biggest conservation threats to these species. Gear modifications have the potential to reduce these bycatches in global fisheries but there is little available information on how such modifications may change the fishing performance of gear, or indeed the behavior of cetaceans interacting with fishing gear. Generalized linear models (GLMs) were used to identify factors related to cetacean bycatches in UK bottom set gillnets. Rigged net height had a significant positive relationship with harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) bycatch in ICES Area VII suggesting that lowering the profile of gillnets may have the potential to reduce bycatch rates. Modifications to gillnets, such as changing the amount of floatation or increasing the density of the meshes, were found to have significant effects on the active fishing heights of these nets. However, results from a bycatch mitigation trial in Argentina showed that the reduced fishing profile of one experimental net did not result in a concurrent reduction in the bycatch rate of Franciscana dolphins (Pontoporia blainvillei). While there was no significant difference in the rate, length or intensity of harbour porpoise encounters in the presence or absence of gillnets, the proportion of fast echolocation click trains were significantly higher when a net was present, indicating that porpoises either increased acoustic inspection of the net or foraging in the vicinity of the net. An analysis of underwater video footage collected inside trawl nets in an Australia fishery showed that bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops sp.) were present inside nets more frequently than they were caught and were actively foraging inside these nets. The orientation of dolphins inside these nets indicates that the current design of excluder devices used in this fishery could be improved to further reduce bycatch rates.

published_or_final_version / Environmental Management / Master / Master of Science in Environmental Management

The main purpose of this study was to produce and test the reliability of predictive models of cetacean distributions off the west coast of Scotland. Passive acoustic and visual surveys were carried out from platforms of opportunity between 2003 and 2005. Acoustic identifications were made primarily of harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena), delphinids, and sperm whales (Physeter macrocephalus). Generalised Additive Models (GAMs) were used to relate species’ distributions to a range of environmental variables over a range of temporal and spatial scales. Predictive models of delphinid distributions showed both inter-annual and inter-month variations. Combining all data for all months and years resulted in a model that combined the environmental influences from each monthly and yearly model. Overall, delphinids were found to associate with the deep (> 400m) warm water (10.5°C-12.5°C), and in areas of deep thermocline. Relationships between sperm whales and environmental variables were consistent over changes in grain size (9 km or 18 km), but not between areas. Although sperm whales were distributed in deep water characterised by weak thermoclines and strong haloclines in the most northerly area (Faroe-Shetland Channel), they were found in deep productive areas with cold surface temperature in the more southerly waters (Rockall Trough). Within the southern Inner Hebrides, high use areas for harbour porpoises were consistently predicted over time (in years) and with differing survey techniques (acoustic versus visual), but not over space (southern Inner Hebrides versus whole of the Inner Hebrides). Harbour porpoises were mainly distributed in areas with low tidal currents and with higher detection rates during spring tides. The use of prey as a predictor variable within models of delphinid distribution shows some promise: there were correlations between delphinid and herring (Clupea harengus) in shelf-waters in 2005 but not in 2004. These models can be used in mitigating acoustic threats to cetaceans in predicted high use areas off the west coast of Scotland.

The Baltic Sea is a brackish body of water in the heart of Europe, and within it lives a small whale: the Baltic Sea harbor porpoise. However, this animal is becoming increasingly more endangered. Due to various man-made threats, less than 500 animals remain in the sea. This thesis aims to provide a comprehensive overview of this issue with a political approach through discussing how the state of this animal reflects on the European Union. Furthermore, it investigates the European Commission's role and takes a closer look at EU Biodiversity Strategy 2030 to detect potential greenwashing. Through the case study of the harbor porpoise, the central conflict between the European Union and the conservationists aiming to save the animal gets illuminated from different perspectives. The analysis makes use of European integration theory as well as a deconstructive approach, through which the study is able to detect that the issue largely stems from the respective member states. Moreover, it finds that the approaches of the European Commission and the conservationist align at the core principles. With the help of an interview conducted with a field expert, these points can be emphasized. Reflecting on the findings it can be concluded that essential regulations are finally being put into place, but there is still a long way to go to save the Baltic Sea harbor porpoise.

Incidental catch, or bycatch, of harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) in fishing operations is an international conservation issue. The main objective of this thesis was to develop methods for determining the impact of bycatch on the state and dynamics of porpoise populations and for calculating bycatch limits that will achieve conservation objectives in the future. I applied these methods to the North Sea as a case study. First, I analysed sighting rates of harbour porpoise on seabird surveys in the North Sea during 1980-2003 to determine whether these data could provide informative time-series of relative abundance. Some general patterns and trends in sighting rates were consistent with previous studies. However, the standardised indices of abundance were relatively imprecise and thus have limited value for a monitoring framework that relies on statistical detection of trends. Second, I used a population model to integrate available data on harbour porpoise in the North Sea and to assess the dynamics of the population during 1987-2005. There was a high probability that bycatch resulted in a decrease in abundance. The estimated life history parameters suggested a limited scope for population growth even in the absence of bycatch. The model and data were not informative about maximum population growth rate or carrying capacity. The model suggested that dispersal was the most plausible explanation for observed changes in distribution within the North Sea. Third, I considered management procedures for calculating bycatch limits. I performed simulations to compare the behaviour of the procedures, to tune the procedures to specific conservation objectives and to test the robustness of the procedures to a range of uncertainties regarding population dynamics and structure, the environment, observation and implementation. Preliminary annual bycatch limits for harbour porpoise in the North Sea ranged from 187-1685 depending on the procedure, tuning and management areas used.

Genetic variation is essential for biological evolution, for maintaining viability of populations, and to ensure ecosystem resilience. Increased human exploitation and environmental change result in rapid loss of biological variation, including genetic diversity. Measures to halt this trend require that biological diversity is assessed and monitored. Assessment of biodiversity includes identifying patterns of distribution of genetic variation within individual species. This thesis focuses on spatial genetic structure and assessment of units for conservation in continuous environments without apparent migration barriers. Empirical data refer to Scandinavia and the model species are northern pike (Esox lucius), brown trout (Salmo trutta), and harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena). Questions regarding monitoring genetic diversity and releases of alien populations are also addressed.  The spatial genetic structure of the northern pike in the Baltic Sea is characterized by isolation by distance and continuous genetic change. Positive genetic correlation was found among pike within geographical distances of less than 150 km. This distance may be used to suggest management units in this area. For the brown trout, genetic monitoring identified two sympatric populations within a small mountain lake system. The situation is characterized by a clear genetic but no apparent phenotypic dichotomy. Scientific support for a genetically distinct Baltic harbour porpoise population is limited, and the spatial genetic structure of the harbour porpoise in Swedish waters needs to be clarified. Data for launching conservation genetic monitoring programs is available for only a few Swedish species. Millions of forest trees, fish, and birds are released annually in Sweden and the documentation on these releases is poor. To meet responsibilities of safeguarding biodiversity and surveying biological effects of releases, there is an urgent need for studies aimed at evaluating genetic diversity. / At the time of the doctoral defense, the following paper was unpublished and had a status as follows: Paper 2: Manuscript.

published_or_final_version / Ecology and Biodiversity / Doctoral / Doctor of Philosophy

Incidental bycatch in gillnets is a substantial threat to small cetaceans. Using Acoustic Deterrent Devices, “pingers”, have successfully reduced bycatch of harbour porpoises in gillnets. However, seals can use pingers as “dinner-bells” to easier find gillnets in order to raid and destroy them, further aggravating the existing conflicts between seals and coastal fisheries. Therefore, in the present study, the efficiency of two alleged “seal-safe” pingers, an experimental Banana pinger “SSB” and a Future Oceans F70 pinger “FO”, in deterring harbour porpoises from the vicinity of gillnets and thereby reducing bycatch in commercial gillnet fisheries, was tested. This was done by deploying click detectors, “C-PODs”, recording Detection Positive Minutes per hour, at each end of gillnets, provided with the two pinger types or no pingers at all. Bycatch instances were recorded into logbooks by participating fishermen and verified using video footage from on-board video cameras. Results showed that video monitoring was a reliable method for verifying the number of bycatches of porpoises and seals, but not seabirds, recorded in the fishermen’s logbooks. The experimental SSB pingers and the FO pingers significantly reduced porpoise presence, measured as Detection Positive Minutes per hour in the vicinity of the nets, compared to gillnets without pingers. However, the sample size was too small to yield a significant result regarding the bycatch reducing efficiency and dinner bell effect of the experimental pingers. Nevertheless, bycatch trends suggest that pingers did in fact reduce porpoise bycatch. Although both successful, FO pingers were slightly more efficient in deterring porpoises than SSB pingers. The SSB pinger sounds had bigger directionality variations than the FO pinger, which may have affected its deterrent effects. Therefore, additional trials are needed to further investigate this aspect.

Um total de 142 crânios do boto-de-Burmeister, Phocoena spinipinnis depositados em museus e coleções cientificas da Argentina, Brasil, Chile, Peru e Uruguai foram utilizados para explorar a variação geográfica em relação ao tamanho e forma do crânio de P. spinipinnis. Ademais, foi realizada uma caracterização oceanográfica da área de distribuição do boto-de- Burmeister através de dados históricos de temperatura, salinidade e oxigênio a 0 e 50m de profundidade na costa Atlântica e Pacifica. As idades dos animais foram obtidas pelas leituras das GLGs na dentina. A idade mais alta atingida por ambos os sexos foi de 10 anos. Medições na dentina mostraram dimorfismo sexual na primeira GLG e diferenças geográficas entre botos do Peru e Atlântico. Três tipos de anomalias foram registrados nos dentes, e a linha marcadora parece estar associada ao “El Niño”. Vinte e oito caracteres métricos foram utilizados para explorar o dimorfismo sexual e crescimento. A maturidade física do crânio foi estabelecida quando o comprimento côndilo-basal atingiu 95% do comprimento total (≥266mm nos machos e ≥277mm nas fêmeas). Diferenças no tamanho e forma do crânio foram analisadas através de morfometria tradicional e geométrica. Os resultados revelaram dimorfismo sexual, sendo as fêmeas maiores do que os machos. As diferenças em tamanho e forma concentraram-se principalmente na região rostral e neurocrânio. Foi observada variação geográfica entre os botos do Atlântico, Chile e Peru. P. spinipinnis do Peru são de menor tamanho em relação a os botos do Chile e Atlântico. Botos do Chile apresentam um tamanho e forma intermediária, e os botos do Atlântico são maiores (especialmente na região orbital, altura do crânio e região rostral). A distância de Mahalanobis mostrou maior separação entre os botos do Peru e do Atlântico, e menor distância entre os exemplares do Chile e Atlântico. A morfometria geométrica explica com maior clareza as diferenças entre botos do Chile e Atlântico, especialmente nas vista ventral e lateral. A correlação entre variáveis ambientais e morfométricas através da análise de correlações canônicas e dos quadrados mínimos parciais de dois blocos sugere que as diferenças observadas no tamanho e na forma dos crânios têm uma importante influência espacial, associada à variabilidade sazonal das condições oceanográficas presentes nos dois oceanos e diretamente relacionada às três áreas oceanográfica propostas neste estudo: (1) de Paita, Peru (05°01’S, 81ºW) até o sul do Golfo de Arauco, Chile (∼39°S); (2) do sul do Golfo de Arauco até o sul do Rio da Prata (∼38°S); e (3) do Rio da Prata até Santa Catarina, Brasil (28º48’S; 49°12W). Adicionalmente, propõe-se que P. spinipinnis apresenta uma distribuição contínua desde Paita, Peru ate a bacia do Rio da Prata, Argentina, podendo alcançar águas uruguaias e brasileiras em determinadas condições oceanográficas (entrada de águas mais frias e menos salinas com direção ao norte, associadas à Convergência Subtropical) / A total of 142 skulls from Burmeister’s porpoises, Phocoena spinipinnis from museums and scientific collections from Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Peru and Uruguay were analyzed to explore the geographical variation in relation to size and shape on skulls of P. spinipinnis. In addition, an oceanographic characterization of the area of distribution of Burmeister’s porpoise by historical data of temperature, salinity and oxygen the 0 and 50m of depth on the Pacific and Atlantic coast was carried out. The age of the animals was obtained by reading the Growth Layer Group in dentine. The oldest male and female were 10 years of age. Measurements in dentine showed sexual dimorphism in the first GLG and geographic differences between porpoises from Peru and Atlantic. Three types of anomalies were recorded in teeth, and the marker lines seem to be associated to “El Niño”. Twenty-eight characters were used to explore sexual dimorphism and growth. Physical maturity of the skull was established when 95% of condylobasal length was attained (≥266mm in the males and ≥277mm in the females). Differences in size and shape of skull were analyzed by traditional and geometric morphometrics. The results revealed sexual dimorphism, being the females larger than male, and the differences in size and shape are concentrated mainly in the rostral region and neurocranium. Geographic variation between porpoises from Atlantic, Chile, and Peru was observed. P. spinipinnis from Peru are smaller compared to porpoises from Chile and Atlantic. Porpoises from Chile have an intermediate shape, and porpoises from Atlantic are larger (mainly related to orbital region, skull height and rostral region). The distance of Mahalanobis showed more separation between porpoises from Peru and Atlantic, and less distance between specimens from Chile and Atlantic. Geometric morphometrics was more useful for show differences between specimens from Chile and Atlantic, especially in the ventral and lateral views. The correlation between environmental and morphometric variables by canonical analysis and two-block partial least squares suggests that the differences observed in the size and shape of skulls would have an important spatial influence, associated to the seasonal variability of the oceanographic conditions present in the two oceans, and directly related to the three oceanographic areas proposed in this study: (1) from Paita, Peru (05°01’S, 81ºW) to south of Arauco Gulf, Chile (∼39°S); (2) from south of Arauco Gulf to south of La Plata River, Argentina (∼38°S); and (3) from La Plata River to Santa Catarina, Brazil (28º48’S; 49°12W). In addition, it is proposed that P. spinipinnis presents a continuous distribution from Paita, Peru to La Plata River basin, Argentina, being able to reach Uruguayan and Brazilian waters under certain oceanographic conditions (intrusion of colder and less saline waters toward the north associated with the Subtropical Convergence).