The following research aims to examine the interaction of law, either hard law (legislation) or soft law (governing body regulation), on achieving a balance between racial equality and success in sport. Nearly all national jurisdictions have legislated to some degree in an attempt to affect equality or equality of opportunity for its citizens. This might be based on achieving equality of opportunity or by means of affirmative action. The research aim is to ascertain how far racial discrimination laws have positive or negative impacts on the success of sports in different countries. The research also has a series of supplementary objectives: to ascertain and consider critically the extent to which the law in various jurisdictions (Malaysia, South Africa, England and the United States) has been used to promote equality; to develop a sequential model to describe general trends to predict the influence of affirmative action and equal opportunity legislation upon the potential success of countries’ sporting achievements; to review tensions inherent in reconciling the equality of citizens at a national level and their impacts upon the international sporting success of that nation; to establish a correlative relationship between the types of anti-discrimination law within nations and the impact of these upon the degree of international sporting success of those nations. The research conducted concentrates primarily on qualitative methods by first adopting a doctrinal approach in a comparative legal study of four jurisdictions (Malaysia, South Africa, England and the United States). A non-doctrinal approach is then adopted and a qualitative intrinsic case study completed, including interviews concerning the subject area. Thus, the research has used multi-method qualitative approaches. The research indicated different anti-discrimination approaches taken in achieving equality. This can be typified by countries such as the United States or England based primarily on meritocracy and countries such as South Africa and Malaysia based primarily on preferential treatment. There is evidence to suggest that these approaches do have a certain correlation, albeit not similar in the outcome of achieving equality for selection. From the evidence presented, the overall study illustrates that racial discrimination laws in the four jurisdictions produced a mixed outcome in relation to the success of professional team sports. Specifically, England and the United States witnessed a positive impact in terms of achieving international success in sports even though there are inherent difficulties in reconciling the equality of citizens at a national level. For Malaysia and South Africa, the result tends to be positive in general at this stage although it is equally recognised that this approach might result in some negative impacts in the long run. The research however is subject to certain limitations which are outside the scope of this thesis, but it is recognised that these might affect the overall success of professional team sports within those countries.

In this study I analyzed the 1089 desegregation outcomes in federal district courts that occurred between 1994 and 2004 in order to identify a) the legal and non-legal factors in the litigation process that predict pro-desegregation outcomes and b) the judicial patterns that impact the future of desegregation policy. Twenty-one legal and non-legal variables were analyzed via logistic regression analysis to identify factors that predict pro-desegregation outcomes. Only three predictor variables were statistically significant: Government Litigants; Region 3 (West) and Region 4 (Northeast.) Descriptive analyses of the data identified two trends in the pattern of litigation: The percentage of defendant wins increased after 1991 at a lesser rate than has been previously reported. I conclude that based on the results of both the quantitative and qualitative analyses the federal district courts are not a barrier to desegregation and can still be a part of a comprehensive desegregation strategy.

A presente dissertação tem como objetivo analisar o contexto constitucional da integração Europeia, tendo como base as Constituições dos Estados Membros da União Europeia (UE).(1) O tema O Direito da Integração nas Constituições dos Estados Membros da União Europei pode ser visto por dois caminhos principais. O primeiro deles tem como foco o direito europeu, o direito comunitário, e a análise dos textos normativos que os compõem. (2) Para isso, seria necessário analisar com profundidade os principais tratados que constroem o direito europeu (notadamente, mas não apenas, os Tratados de Roma, Maastricht, Amsterdã, Nice e Lisboa) para em seguida discorrer sobre a possibilidade de atribuição de caráter constitucional a essa série de tratados que, ao abordar temas diversos e simultaneamente complementares, criaram e vêm construindo o que hoje é a União Europeia. Na tentativa de integrar o conceito de União Europeia e o de direito constitucional, optou-se por tratar do aspecto estatal da dimensão constitucional da União Europeia. O foco dessa dissertação é saber de que modo ocorre, ou se ocorre, a previsão da União Europeia nas Constituições dos vinte e sete Estados que a compõem. Serão destacadas, na medida do possível, as modificações experimentadas pelas Constituições dos Estados Membros relacionadas aos artigos analisados. Longe de esgotar o tema, essa dissertação apresentará a maneira como as Constituições dos Estados Membros tratam da inserção do ordenamento comunitário no ordenamento interno ou, nos casos onde não há menção expressa à Europa, de que maneira os tratados internacionais são recepcionados na ordem jurídica interna. Finalmente, tentar-se-á responder às seguintes questões: existe um padrão de recepção de tratados nas Constituições dos Estados Membros da União Europeia? Se positiva a resposta, qual seria esse padrão? Se negativa, qual seria a opção que melhor recepcionaria o ordenamento jurídico relacionado à integração europeia (notadamente os tratados que formam a União Europeia) na ordem interna dos Estados Membros? A relação dos ordenamentos constitucionais internos dos Estados Membros da União Europeia, acrescida de análise de doutrina a respeito do tema, servirá de contraponto prático para verificar se e como ocorre o contato entre estes dois ordenamentos, o interno e o comunitário. A análise constitucional tem como objetivo retratar o direito da integração a partir da perspectiva dos Estados integrados, com o exame dos documentos nacionais. / This dissertation aims to analyze the constitutional context of European integration, based on the Constitutions of the Member States of the European Union. (3) The subject \"Community Law in the Constitutions of the Member States of the European Union can be assessed in two main ways. The first focuses on European law, community law, and on the analysis of normative texts that compose them. (4) It would therefore be necessary to examine in depth the core treaties that build the European Law (in particular, but not only, the Treaties of Rome, Maastricht, Amsterdam, Nice and Lisbon) to only then discuss the possibility of allocating constitutional character to this series of treaties which, addressing diverse and complementary subjects, have created and are creating what is now the European Union. In an attempt to integrate the concept of European Union and Constitutional Law, it was decided to treat the State aspect of the constitutional dimension of the European Union. This dissertation aims to explore whether and how the idea of the European Union is established in the Constitutions of the twenty seven States that comprise it. The dissertation will highlight, as far as possible, the changes experienced by the Constitutions of the Member States which are related with the analyzed articles. This dissertation will present the manner utilized by the Constitutions of the Member States to deal with the inclusion of land within the domestic or European, in cases where there is no explicit mention of Europe, how international treaties are incorporated in domestic law. Finally, there is an attempted to answer the following questions: Is there a pattern of receipt of treaties in the Constitutions of the Member States of the European Union? If there is a positive response, what would this pattern be? If not, what would be the best option to approve the legal system of European integration in the internal order of the Member States? The relation of domestic constitutional law of the Member States of the European Union and the analysis of doctrine on the subject will serve as a practical counterpoint to verify if and how contact occurs between these two types of Law: the internal and the community. The constitutional analysis aims to portray the integration law from the perspective of the member integrated with the national review of the documents 3 It is noteworthy here that analyzes the principles that form the apex of the legal system of every 27 (twenty seven) Member States of the European Union. For States that do not have a unified text called \"Constitution\", the legal equivalent to the fundamental law of the legal system of this state will be analyzed. 4 Community law is not equivalent to European Union law. The EU, as will be seen later, stands on three pillars (economic and monetary union, foreign policy and security policy and judicial and police cooperation in criminal field), but only the rules for the first pillar of EU law stricto sensu, subordinate to the other corresponding to the legal regime governing the various situations. This will be addressed in the early part of the dissertation.

Made available in DSpace on 2016-08-10T10:47:55Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 LARA LIVIA CARDOSO COSTA BRINGEL.pdf: 580750 bytes, checksum: 7fbbc0c25aa9585abf3114f4b0becc5f (MD5) Previous issue date: 2010-10-04 / Mercosul, Southern Common Market, is still considered an incomplete economic bloc, that needs to harmonize their laws, so that it can then achieve a full regional integration. But to achieve, this it is necessary that the tariff and nontariff barriers are eliminated. It takes even these countries macroeconomic policies worked, toward a shared goal, namely the free trade of services, goods, manpower and capital and product markets. This, however, requires the harmonization of standards to be strengthened trade relations and consumption, and also the trust between peoples. Considering this, was chosen as study subject they Harmonization of Standards Consumer Protection within Mercosul. And it was intended, to verify that this walk is the issue of consumerism in Mercosul standards, which form the agreements made so far to the standards of the consumer, are harmonized among member countries. It was concluded that, despite advances, Mercosul remains incomplete. The harmonization of consumerism walk slowly, the barriers to their harmonize is in large part to Brazilian law, which appears as a complete law and can not in any way suffer regression, and is therefore necessary that the other member countries to reassess their laws, equating the Brazilian legislation, so that everyone can stride towards sustainable economic progress. / Mercosul, o mercado comum do sul, é ainda considerado um bloco econômico incompleto, que precisa harmonizar suas legislações, para que possa então alcançar uma integração regional plena. Mas para se chegar a isso, é preciso que as barreiras tarifárias e não tarifárias sejam eliminadas. É preciso ainda que as políticas macroeconômicas desses países sejam trabalhadas, visando um objetivo comum, ou seja, o livre comércio de serviços, de produtos, de mão-de-obra, capitais e produtos. Isso, porém, requer a harmonização de normas com a finalidade de fortalecer as relações comerciais e de consumo, e também a confiança entre os povos. Diante disso, escolheu-se como tema de estudo a Harmonização das Normas de Proteção ao Consumidor no Âmbito do Mercosul. Pretendeu-se, com isso, verificar em que pé se encontra a questão das normas consumeristas no Mercosul, quais acordos foram feitos até o momento para que as normas do consumidor sejam harmonizadas entre os Países-Membros. Concluiuse que, apesar dos avanços, o Mercosul continua incompleto. A harmonização das normas consumeristas caminha lentamente, os entraves para sua harmonização se devem em grande parte à lei brasileira, que figura como uma lei completa e não pode de forma alguma sofrer regressão, sendo portanto necessário que os demais Países-Membros reavaliem suas legislações, equiparando-as à legislação brasileira, para que todos possam caminhar a passos largos no sentido do progresso econômico sustentável.

Submitted by Rosina Valeria Lanzellotti Mattiussi Teixeira (rosina.teixeira@unisantos.br) on 2017-05-23T19:40:24Z No. of bitstreams: 1 Thiago Deiglis de Lima Rufino.pdf: 552557 bytes, checksum: d9a0aa6da6ef1d880e04ff80250708b1 (MD5) / Made available in DSpace on 2017-05-23T19:40:26Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 Thiago Deiglis de Lima Rufino.pdf: 552557 bytes, checksum: d9a0aa6da6ef1d880e04ff80250708b1 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2017-03-31 / Integration right and labor relations in MERCOSUR is a theme that addresses norms related to regionalism process prevenient from the Treaty of Asunción formalization, which created the Common Market of the South. MERCOSUR results of a Latin American states¿ grouping in search of economic protection and a larger market field, with emphasis initially on Brazil, Argentina, Paraguay and Uruguay. Next, Venezuela was included as an integrated country, as well as Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Peru, Ecuador, Guyana and Suriname were included as associate countries. However, factors such as economic protection and market search were not unique in this integration process, but allied to globalization phenomenon spread and diffusion of social rights linked to the human being. As a regionalization process in Latin America, it became part of the economic block. In order to do so, it used negotiations formulated through intergovernmental negotiations, which depended, therefore, on participating States validation in their respective internal systems in order to implement their guidelines. Originally thought to be MERCOSUR as a mechanism for economic expansion, its character of social integration was obliterated, accomplished during its evolution through Ouro Preto Protocol (dated 1994) and the Olivos Protocol (dated 2002), establishing systems and guidelines on social issues, among them, labor. Despite the existence of those search instruments for intrabloc social peace, their lack of effectiveness is evident, due to member countries¿ economic, political and social asymmetries. Therefore, it is aimed to demonstrate that labor negotiations effectiveness will occur with norms harmonization, observing the group¿s asymmetry specificities. / A temática direito da integração no MERCOSUL e das relações laborais aborda as normativas ligadas ao processo de regionalismo advindo da formalização do Tratado de Assunção, que criou o Mercado Comum do Sul. O Mercosul é fruto de uma agrupação de Estados latino-americanos em busca da proteção econômica e maior campo de mercado, com destaque inicialmente para o Brasil, a Argentina, o Paraguai e o Uruguai. Em seguida, foi integrado como membro a Venezuela, e como países associados a Bolívia, o Chile, a Colômbia, o Peru, o Equador, a Guiana e Suriname. Contudo, os fatores proteção econômica e busca de mercado não foram exclusivos neste processo de integração, mas aliados à propagação do fenômeno da globalização e difusão dos direitos sociais ligados à pessoa humana. Como processo de regionalização da América Latina, integralizou-se na condição de bloco econômico. Para tanto, utilizou tratativas formuladas através de negociações de cunho intergovernamental, dependendo, assim, da convalidação dos Estados partícipes nos seus respectivos ordenamentos internos para a efetivação de suas diretrizes. Pensado preliminarmente o MERCOSUL como mecanismo de expansão econômica, foi relegado a segundo plano seu caráter de integração social, o que foi efetivado no transcorrer de sua evolução através do Protocolo de Ouro Preto (datado de 1994) e do Protocolo de Olivos (datado de 2002), instituindo organismos e diretrizes sobre temas de cunho social, entre estes, o laboral. Apesar da existência destes instrumentos de busca da paz social intrabloco, fica evidente sua falta de eficácia, diante das assimetrias econômicas, políticas e sociais dos países-membros. Logo, objetiva-se demonstrar que a eficácia das tratativas de cunho laboral se dará com a harmonização das normas, observando-se as especificidades desta condição de assimetria do grupo.

A presente dissertação tem como objetivo analisar o contexto constitucional da integração Europeia, tendo como base as Constituições dos Estados Membros da União Europeia (UE).(1) O tema O Direito da Integração nas Constituições dos Estados Membros da União Europei pode ser visto por dois caminhos principais. O primeiro deles tem como foco o direito europeu, o direito comunitário, e a análise dos textos normativos que os compõem. (2) Para isso, seria necessário analisar com profundidade os principais tratados que constroem o direito europeu (notadamente, mas não apenas, os Tratados de Roma, Maastricht, Amsterdã, Nice e Lisboa) para em seguida discorrer sobre a possibilidade de atribuição de caráter constitucional a essa série de tratados que, ao abordar temas diversos e simultaneamente complementares, criaram e vêm construindo o que hoje é a União Europeia. Na tentativa de integrar o conceito de União Europeia e o de direito constitucional, optou-se por tratar do aspecto estatal da dimensão constitucional da União Europeia. O foco dessa dissertação é saber de que modo ocorre, ou se ocorre, a previsão da União Europeia nas Constituições dos vinte e sete Estados que a compõem. Serão destacadas, na medida do possível, as modificações experimentadas pelas Constituições dos Estados Membros relacionadas aos artigos analisados. Longe de esgotar o tema, essa dissertação apresentará a maneira como as Constituições dos Estados Membros tratam da inserção do ordenamento comunitário no ordenamento interno ou, nos casos onde não há menção expressa à Europa, de que maneira os tratados internacionais são recepcionados na ordem jurídica interna. Finalmente, tentar-se-á responder às seguintes questões: existe um padrão de recepção de tratados nas Constituições dos Estados Membros da União Europeia? Se positiva a resposta, qual seria esse padrão? Se negativa, qual seria a opção que melhor recepcionaria o ordenamento jurídico relacionado à integração europeia (notadamente os tratados que formam a União Europeia) na ordem interna dos Estados Membros? A relação dos ordenamentos constitucionais internos dos Estados Membros da União Europeia, acrescida de análise de doutrina a respeito do tema, servirá de contraponto prático para verificar se e como ocorre o contato entre estes dois ordenamentos, o interno e o comunitário. A análise constitucional tem como objetivo retratar o direito da integração a partir da perspectiva dos Estados integrados, com o exame dos documentos nacionais. / This dissertation aims to analyze the constitutional context of European integration, based on the Constitutions of the Member States of the European Union. (3) The subject \"Community Law in the Constitutions of the Member States of the European Union can be assessed in two main ways. The first focuses on European law, community law, and on the analysis of normative texts that compose them. (4) It would therefore be necessary to examine in depth the core treaties that build the European Law (in particular, but not only, the Treaties of Rome, Maastricht, Amsterdam, Nice and Lisbon) to only then discuss the possibility of allocating constitutional character to this series of treaties which, addressing diverse and complementary subjects, have created and are creating what is now the European Union. In an attempt to integrate the concept of European Union and Constitutional Law, it was decided to treat the State aspect of the constitutional dimension of the European Union. This dissertation aims to explore whether and how the idea of the European Union is established in the Constitutions of the twenty seven States that comprise it. The dissertation will highlight, as far as possible, the changes experienced by the Constitutions of the Member States which are related with the analyzed articles. This dissertation will present the manner utilized by the Constitutions of the Member States to deal with the inclusion of land within the domestic or European, in cases where there is no explicit mention of Europe, how international treaties are incorporated in domestic law. Finally, there is an attempted to answer the following questions: Is there a pattern of receipt of treaties in the Constitutions of the Member States of the European Union? If there is a positive response, what would this pattern be? If not, what would be the best option to approve the legal system of European integration in the internal order of the Member States? The relation of domestic constitutional law of the Member States of the European Union and the analysis of doctrine on the subject will serve as a practical counterpoint to verify if and how contact occurs between these two types of Law: the internal and the community. The constitutional analysis aims to portray the integration law from the perspective of the member integrated with the national review of the documents 3 It is noteworthy here that analyzes the principles that form the apex of the legal system of every 27 (twenty seven) Member States of the European Union. For States that do not have a unified text called \"Constitution\", the legal equivalent to the fundamental law of the legal system of this state will be analyzed. 4 Community law is not equivalent to European Union law. The EU, as will be seen later, stands on three pillars (economic and monetary union, foreign policy and security policy and judicial and police cooperation in criminal field), but only the rules for the first pillar of EU law stricto sensu, subordinate to the other corresponding to the legal regime governing the various situations. This will be addressed in the early part of the dissertation.

After the Enlargement of the European Union in 2004, around a million Accession State migrants arrived in the United Kingdom, with Polish migrants constituting the largest group. There is a growing body of literature focusing on their migratory patterns, networks, labour market performance, and identity. However, little has been said so far about the Polish migrants' relationship with law in the United Kingdom. This thesis asks: how do the Polish post-2004 EU Enlargement migrants form their relationship with the law, and what are the factors that affect this? It focuses on the intricacies of migrants' choices of `semi-legal' over legal status, subsequent legalization strategies, and the interpretations of legality they result in. Socio-legal integration has so far been viewed solely via state legal frameworks, following the traditional approach of the `law-first' perspective. This thesis argues that it is not the institutional arrangements and legal architecture alone that decide the nature of migrants' semi-legal relationship with law in the host society. A more comprehensive insight into the socio-legal integration of migrants is possible only when we combine in the analysis the interplay between the structural factors of the host country's legal environment, migrants' agency and the culturally derived values, attitudes, behaviour and social expectations towards the law and its enforcement. The thesis therefore makes a case for a `proper' recognition of migrants' legal culture in the study of their socio-legal integration. The thesis concludes that semi-legality, as an initial response to the legal environment is not static, but changing. As a result, migrants' socio-legal integration is extended in time and gradual. Migrants' legality could be discussed at two levels - at the behavioural level and at the level of a value. Changing status between the two poles of legality and illegality brings with it greater appreciation of legality as a value. This research presents a strong argument that the relationship between behaviour and attitudes to law could be meaningfully investigated in an applied domain of the new socio-legal environment.

Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior / The impact of globalization has influenced the national states and also determined their regional economic integration. The concepts that orientate nowadays regional economic integration are far from those which inspired the foundation of national sovereigns. It means that Law as an institution has been suffering so many profound transformations that it requires a revision of the basis on which international public Law, and more recently, the comunitary Law are founded. The present work intends to contribute to the discussion and the systematization of economic integration processes, especially the Mercosul. In this context is the problem of the brazilian fiscal federalism and its chalenges to the future of the regional agreement, particularly the permanence of the ICMS (Circulation Tax about Goods and Services), the resistance of some sectors of the brazilian society to increase the Tributary Reform and also the implantation of the IVA (Value-Added Tax). There is a general consensus that if federal IVA was adopted by Brazil it would provide great advances to the tributary harmonization in Mercosul, for the reason that many national legislations´ principles would be convergent. The progress of the economic integration depends on it. A bibliographic review of economic integration theories - the mainly example is taken from the European Union is followed here by a comparative study of the tributary systems of the countries that belong to Mercosul, especially the Brazilian Tributary System and its influences to the consolidation of the integrationist process. The fiscal harmonization will be a mark of this study. / Os impactos decorrentes da globalização influenciaram os Estados nacionais e os colocaram sob o signo dos processos de integração econômica regionais. Com isso, o direito, como instituição, vem sofrendo profundas transformações, afastando-se cada vez mais dos conceitos clássicos que nortearam a instituição das soberanias nacionais. O mundo contemporâneo exige a releitura das bases que fundaram o direito internacional público e o mais recente direito comunitário. O presente trabalho objetiva contribuir para a discussão e sistematização dos processos de integração econômica, em particular do Mercosul. No entorno do processo de integração econômica, está a intrincada engrenagem do federalismo fiscal brasileiro, com seus desafios para o futuro do bloco regional - sobretudo no tocante à manutenção do ICMS (Imposto sobre circulação de mercadorias e serviços), à resistência de certos setores da sociedade em promover a Reforma Tributária ou a implantação do IVA (Imposto sobre o Valor Agregado). A adoção do IVA federal, pelo Brasil, proporcionaria enormes avanços para a harmonização tributária do Mercosul, uma vez que diversos princípios das legislações nacionais seriam com ele convergentes. O aprofundamento da integração econômica depende, em grande parte, deste avanço. Uma revisão bibliográfica sobre as teorias de integração econômica, tomando como exemplo a experiência européia, precede o estudo comparativo dos sistemas tributários dos países-membros do Mercosul, focando principalmente o Sistema Tributário Brasileiro e a sua influência para a consolidação do processo integracionista. O enfoque na importância da harmonização fiscal orienta a organização deste estudo.

De par le monde, les intérêts des personnes travaillant à l’étranger sont tout à la fois méconnus et contestés. Le but de cette étude est de dégager les lignes de force qui sous-tendent, non sans contradictions ni crise la protection de ces personnes. En s’appuyant à la fois sur le droit (interne et international) camerounais et français, la thèse s’attache à démontrer que, nonobstant leur appartenance à des espaces géographiques différents et quel que soit leur niveau dedéveloppement économique, les Etats assurent un traitement juridique semblable aux migrants qui exercent une activité rémunérée sur leur territoire. La démarche d’ensemble de la prise en compte de la situation juridique des travailleursmigrants est caractérisée par le décalage qui existe entre un renforcement normatif de la protection d’une part et une effectivité limité de celle-ci d’autre part. Dans un premier temps, le renforcement du droit se déduit tout d’abord de ladiversité des règles juridiques applicables aux travailleurs migrants et de la dynamique des interactions entre celles-ci.Ensuite, l’affermissement de la protection résulte dune capacité de jouissance et d’exercice de droits par les travailleurs migrants de plus en plus étendue et d’une mise en balance (verticale ou horizontale) relativement harmonieuse desdroits reconnus. Dans un second temps, cette consolidation normative de la protection des travailleurs migrants peine à s’affirmer dans les faits. Cela tient avant tout au fait que les mécanismes de mise en oeuvre des droits des travailleursmigrants sont relativement insatisfaisants et que les acteurs concernés par cette protection sont inégalement impliqués. Le constat d’une effectivité limitée de la protection des travailleurs migrants découle aussi de la diversité des freins à laréalisation des droits des travailleurs migrants et des réformes à envisager dans l’optique d’une meilleure prise en compte des droits de cette catégorie de personnes. Au total, l’étude constitue un bilan particulièrement actuel des forces et des faiblesses (limites) du droit dans ces deux pays, pour autant que soit concerné la sauvegarde des intérêts de cette catégorie fragile de personnes que sont les travailleurs migrants. Elle permet de réaffirmer l’égalité juridique des individus, face à l’inégalité économique criarde des Etats. Ce qui conduit à conclure que, dans le domaine de la protection de l’humain, tous les Etats sont, àdivers degrés, sur un terrain d’apprentissage. C’est dire si le droit est lui-même un enjeu permanent de la protection de l’Homme en général et du travailleur migrant en particulier. / All over the world, the interests of people working abroad are at once unknown and disputed. The purpose of this study is to identify the lines of force behind, not without contradictions crisis or protect these people. Based on French and Cameroon law ( domestic and international ), the thesis seeks to demonstrate that, despite their belonging to different geographical areas and whatever their level of economic development, states provide legal treatment similar to migrants who are gainfully employed in their territory. The overall approach of taking into account the legal status of migrant workers is characterized by the gap between normative strengthening protection on the one hand and limited effectiveness thereof other. At first, strengthening of the law is deduced firstly from the diversity of legal rules applicable to migrant workers and the dynamics of interactions between them. Second, the strengthening of protection results with a capacity of enjoyment and exercise of rights by migrant workers more scope and a balancing (vertical or horizontal) rather harmonious recognized rights. In a second step, this normative consolidation of protection of migrant workers sentence to assert the facts. This is primarily due to the fact that the mechanisms of implementation of the rights of migrant workers are relatively unsatisfactory and that the actors involved in this protection are unequallyinvolved. The finding of limited effectiveness of the protection of migrant workers also stems from the diversity of obstacles to realizing the rights of migrant workers and to consider reforms in the context of a greater consideration of the rights of this category of people. In short, the study is a particularly current assessment of strengths and weaknesses of the law in both countries, so far as is concerned to safeguard the interests of this vulnerable category of people that are migrant workers. It helps to reaffirm the legal equality of individuals facing the screaming economic inequality states. This leads to the conclusion that in the field of protection of human, all states are, to varying degrees, on a training ground. That is,if the law itself is an ongoing issue for the protection of human rights in general and migrant workers in particular.