Spelling suggestions: "subject:"etheses -- bpolitical science"" "subject:"etheses -- bipolitical science""
171 |
Can Canada still be considered a middle power? Zimbabwe and Canada's declining global roleBothwell, Alice 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--University of Stellenbosch, 2011. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Canada between 1945 and 2010 has been classified as a prominent "middle power." At the same
time its relative standing among nations has been declining and it has less regard in the world than
it once did. Middle power theory seeks to classify those nations who in the wake of the Second
World War were neither great powers nor non- great powers.
The idea of middlepowermanship greatly appealed to Canadians and they undertook initiatives to
separate themselves from the non-great powers. Canada is often seen as the exemplary case for
observing middle power status. Through the post war era and the Cold War Canada was both
economically and politically powerful. By getting involved in a plethora of multi-lateral bodies
such as the United Nations and the Commonwealth while promoting peacekeeping and mediation,
Canada was able to exert its growing influence on the world order. Throughout this time Canada
worked hard to build its reputation as a mediator and specialized in ending quarrels. This is true of
Canada’s involvement in the Commonwealth in the 1960s and 1970s with regard to the Rhodesian
question. On two separate occasions it was the Canadian contingents that prevented the
Commonwealth from dissipating. This further bolstered Canada’s rise to prominence in the world
order.
Over the years, as Canada took on more initiatives resources became very thinly spread. With an
economic slow down and new commitments to national policies (universal healthcare and pensions)
the Canadian budget was rearranged and priorities changed. No longer were there the same
resources available to middle power initiatives or the military. This has greatly impacted Canada’s
ability to participate in international projects.
Recently, Canada’s position in the world has come into question, asking whether or not it truly is
still a middle power. By looking at various traditional middle power elements including the
economy, peacekeeping, official development assistance and involvement in multilateral bodies it
can be seen that Canada’s prominence is waning. Using the case study of Zimbabwean/ Canadian
relations through the 20th and 21st centuries, the decline of Canada’s middle power performance can
be traced. Combining these different themes with hard and soft power theory it is clear to see that
Canada no longer holds the same position of middle power it once did. It also shows that Canadians
are holding onto an image of Canada, which is dated, and it is time to redefine Canada’s position
within the world order. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Tussen 1945 en 2010 is Kanada geklassifiseer as ’n prominente “middelmag.” Terselfdertyd het
Kanada se relatiewe posisie ten opsigte van ander nasies begin afneem en minder aansien in die
wêreld geniet as voorheen. Die middelmag-teorie poog om daardie nasies te klassifiseer wat na die
Tweede Wêreldoorlog nóg grootmagte, nóg kleinmagte was.
Die Kanadese was aangetrokke tot die idee van middelmagskap en hulle het inisiatiewe onderneem
om hulself van ander nie-grootmagte te onderskei. Kanada word dikwels gesien as die toonbeeld
van die middelmag rol. Gedurende die post-oorlog era, asook tydens die Koue Oorlog was Kanada
beide ekonomies en polities invloedryk. Deur betrokke te raak in multi-laterale instellings soos die
Verenigde Nasies en die Statebond, en terselfdertyd vredeskepping en bemiddeling te bevorder, kon
Kanada sy groeiende invloed op die wêreld orde uitoefen. Gedurende hierdie tyd het Kanada hard
gewerk om sy reputasie as bemiddelaar gestand te doen en te spesialiseer in die beëindiging van
dispute. Laasgenoemde word veral waargeneem in Kanada se betrokkenheid in die Statebond met
betrekking tot die Rhodesië-vraagstuk in die 1960s en 1970s. Op twee verskillende geleenthede was
dit die Kanadese invloed wat verhoed het dat die Statebond ontbind. Dit het gesorg dat Kanada se
prestige en prominensie in die wêreld orde toegeneem het.
Oor die jare het Kanada meer inisiatiewe aangegaan en het die hulpbronne verminder. Dit, tesame
met ’n stadige groeiende ekonomie en nuwe nasionale verpligtinge soos universele gesondheidsorg
en pensioenfonds moes die Kanadese begroting herrangskik word en prioriteite moes verander.
Daar was nie meer dieselfde hulpbronne beskikbaar vir middelmag- inisiatiewe of die weermag nie.
Dit het grootliks Kanada se vermoë beïnvloed om aan internasionale inisiatiewe deel te neem.
Onlangs het Kanada se posisie in die wêreld onder die loep gekom, en dit word bevraagteken of
Kanada nog werklik ’n middelmag is. Deur te kyk na verskillende tradisionele middelmagelemente
soos die ekonomie, vredeskepping, amptelike ontwikkelingsbystand en die betrokkenheid
in die multilaterale organisasies, word dit waargeneem dat Kanada se prominensie afneem. Deur
gebruik te maak van die gevallestudie van die Zimbabwe/Kanada-verhoudinge deur die 20ste en
21ste eeu, kan die afname van Kanada se middelmag-funksie waargeneem word. Met die
kombinering van reeds genoemde temas met die teorieë van harde en sagte mag, kan dit duidelik
gesien word dat Kanada nie meer dieselfde posisie van middelmag beklee wat dit eens gehad het
nie. Verder wys dit dat die Kanadese aan ’n beeld van Kanada vasklou wat ouderwets is, en dat dit
tyd is om Kanada se posisie te herdefinieer in die huidige wêreld orde.
|
172 |
Oiling Development? A critical analysis of Norway's petroleum assistance to AngolaMartinsen, Mari 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--University of Stellenbosch, 2011. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: African affairs have traditionally not occupied a central place in Norway’s official foreign policy, and relations with countries in West Africa have been limited. However, in recent years, resource-rich countries such as Angola – Africa’s largest oil producer – have become the focus of Norwegian strategic interests. Private and public investments are increasing rapidly, paralleling a larger focus on aid. Today, Angola is a core country within Norway’s most prominent petroleum-related assistant programme, Oil for Development (OfD). This thesis will aim to contribute, by means of a critical political economy analysis, to a better understanding of Norway’s role in Angola through OfD. Specifically, this study aims to question who and what structures Norway really is aiding in Angola. Such an objective will be achieved by firstly using critical theory to demonstrate Norway’s role as a traditional middle power – through which Norway seeks to export an altruistic perception of a ‘do-good- image’ – is underpinned by a deeper national self-interest. Secondly, the thesis questions the theoretical foundation of OfD, and, thirdly, it attempts to identify whom the OfD programme is aiding. Ultimately, the thesis questions whether Norway is promoting sustainable development in Angola, or whether, instead, it is contributing to maintaining a status quo, from which Norway as a middle power continues to benefit. The study illustrates that Norway, as a middle power, has neither the capacity nor the national self-interest to achieve fundamental change in Angola. Norway’s commitment to the good governance agenda, and the belief in solutions offered by the resource curse thesis, is tackling the symptoms of Angola’s underdevelopment, rather than its root causes. OfD adopts a state-centric approach, which accepts the political economy structures in Angola, and gives limited attention to global structures and civil society. The thesis offers an alternative analysis, which illustrates how OfD is masking a neo-liberal development approach by incorporating Norwegian business interests and development goals in the same programme. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Afrika sake het tradisioneel nie 'n sentrale plek in Noorweë se amptelike buitelandse beleid beklee nie, en verhoudings met die westelike deel van die Afrika-kontinent is beperk. Tydens die afgelope jare het olie-ryk lande, soos Angola, egter die fokus van Noorweegse strategiese belange geword. Angola is vandag 'n kern land binne Noorweë se mees prominente petroleum-verwante hulpverleningsprogram, Oil for Development (OfD). Hierdie tesis het ten doel om, deur middel van 'n kritiese politieke ekonomie ontleding, by te dra tot ’n beter begrip van Noorweë se rol in Angola deur die OfD. Spesifiek bevraagteken hierdie studie aan wie en watter strukture in Angola Noorweë hulp verleen. Dit sal gedoen word deur eerstens gebruik te maak van kritiese teorie om te demonstreer dat Noorweë se rol as 'n tradisionele middelmoondheid – waardeur Noorweë poog om 'n altruïstiese persepsie van die staat uit te dra – onderskryf word deur 'n dieper nasionale selfbelang. Tweedens sal hierdie studie die teoretiese begronding van OfD bevraagteken, en derdens poog om te identifiseer wie deur die OfD program ondersteun word. Laastens sal die tesis bevraagteken of Noorweë volhoubare ontwikkeling in Angola bevorder, en eerder bydra tot die instandhouding van die status quo, waaruit Noorweë as 'n middelmoondheid voordeel trek. Die studie sal illustreer dat Noorweë, as ‘n middelmoondheid, nie die kapasiteit of die nasionale selfbelang het om fundamentele verandering in Angola te weeg te bring nie. Norweë se ondersteuning van die ‘good governance’ agenda, en oplossings wat deur die sogenaamde ‘hulpbronvloek’ tesis aangebied word, spreek die simptome van Angola se onder-ontwikkeldheid aan, eerder as die kernoorsake. OfD funksioneer op grond van ‘n staat-sentriese benadering, wat die politieke ekonomiese strukture in Angola aanvaar, en beperkte aandag aan globale strukture en die burgerlike samelewing gee. Hierdie tesis bied ‘n alternatiewe analise, wat wys hoe OfD eintlik ‘n neoliberale ontwikkelingsbenadering volg wat Noorweegse besigheids- en ontwikkelingsdoelwitte in dieselfde program inkorporeer.
|
173 |
Barack Obama : a new precedent in foreign policy?Coetzee, Andre Francois 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--University of Stellenbosch, 2011. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This thesis aims to measure President Barack Obama’s level of presidential agency in
foreign policy, in order to determine whether he will be able to achieve his ambitious goal of
renewing US leadership in foreign affairs. To do so, this thesis will make use of a two-level
analysis: The primary level of analysis will focus on the office of the president, and the
constitutionally determined formal powers it confers on the president. It will also study the
constraints placed on the president by the powers conferred on other branches of government, as
well as the institutional and societal context in which the president must function. The second
level of analysis will focus on the president as an individual, and the role that a number of
personality traits and informal powers play in presidential agency. The central hypothesis of this
thesis is that while all presidents are exposed to roughly the same set of institutional constraints,
an individual president’s level of agency depends on their utilisation of a number of informal
powers. In order to measure this hypothesis, a five-point framework will be developed by
abstracting from the existing literature on informal powers. This framework will consist of five
criteria believed to be a prerequisite for a high degree of presidential agency: (1) a favourable
disposition to foreign affairs; (2) the ability to provide strong leadership in policy formulation;
(3) a command over Pennsylvania Avenue politics; (4) the utilisation of the role of public
opinion maker; (5) and the utilisation of the role of global statesmen. While Obama will be
shown to do well against the framework, his lack of tangible accomplishments will be shown to
stem from the magnitude of the challenges he faces; the larger foreign policy context in which he
came to office; and the deep-seated distrust of the motives underlying US foreign policy in
certain regions. Furthermore, the time constraints he faces, and the impact of the election cycle,
will be identified as a limit to the pace of implementation and the extent of the changes he is able
to make. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die doel van hierdie tesis is om President Barack Obama se vlak van presidensiële
agentskap in buitelandse beleid te meet om te bepaal of hy sy ambisieuse doelwit om die VSA se
leierskap in buitelandse sake te hernu, sal bereik. ’n Tweevlakkige analise sal vir hierdie doel
aangewend word. Die analise sal op ’n primêre vlak fokus op die president as ampsdraer, en die
formele magte wat deur die grondwet aan hom toegeken word. Dit sal ook die beperkinge wat op
die president geplaas word as gevolg van die magte wat aan die ander takke van die regering
toegeken word, bestudeer. Verder sal die institusionele en maatskaplike konteks waarin die
president moet fuksioneer in ag geneem word. Die tweede vlak van analise sal op die president
as individu fokus, en die rol wat sekere informele magte en persoonlikheidseienskappe in
presidensiële agentskap speel. Die sentrale hipotese van hierdie tesis, is dat alhoewel alle
presidente deur dieselfde institusionele beperkinge geaffekteer word, ’n spesifieke president se
vlak van agentskap afhang van sy gebruik van informele magte. Hierdie hipotese sal gemeet
woord deur ’n vyfpuntraamwerk te ontwikkel wat gebruik maak van die bestaande literatuur op
presidensiële agentskap. Dié raamwerk bestaan uit vyf kriteria wat benodig word om ’n hoë vlak
van agentskap te handhaaf: (1) ’n positiewe gesindheid teenoor buitelandse sake; (2) die vermoë
om sterk leierskap in die beleidsformuleringsproses uit te oefen; (3) meesterskap oor
Pennsyvanie Avenue politiek; (4) die gebruik van die rol van openbare ’n opinie maker; (5) en
die gebruik van die rol van ’n globale staatsman. Die tesis sal wys dat alhoewel Obama
suksesvol is wanneer hy teen die raamwerk gemeet word, sy tekort aan prestasies toegeskryf kan
word aan die omvang van die probleme wat hy moet oplos; die groter buitelandse konteks
waarin hy verkies is; en die wantroue in die VSA se onderliggende motiewe in sekere streke.
Verder sal die tydsbeperkinge op sy presidentskap en die impak van die verkiesingsiklus
geïdentifiseer word as ’n bepreking op die spoed waarteen hy veranderinge kan implementeer.
|
174 |
The impact of the private security industry on peace-building efforts in Africa : an assessment of Executive Outcomes, MPRI and DynCorpHolager, Emma 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--University of Stellenbosch, 2011. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The emergence and rapid growth of the private security industry in the 1990s followed from
the downsizing of the armed forces in the aftermath of the Cold War and the development of
new security threats which increased demand for military manpower and expertise. This has
led to a redefinition of security strategies and the restructuring of armed forces by Western
governments, which has resulted in the elimination of non-core activities from the functions
of many armed forces. Recently it has been argued that the private security industry can
challenge what previously was believed to be a primary responsibility of states, namely to
take on peacebuilding initiatives and support to other peace operations.
This study seeks to assess the impact of the private security industry in peacebuilding efforts
in African conflicts. The study suggests that the private security industry have taken on a
much stronger role in conflicts world wide since the 1990s, and that its activities have
significantly changed. Companies such as MPRI and DynCorp have managed to keep close
contact with their home governments, which arguably has been a crucial factor to their
growing business. Furthermore, the private security industry have sought to distance itself
from the negative connotations associated with mercenaries and the activities of companies
such as Executive Outcomes in the 1990s, by avoiding operations involving elements of direct
combat. This has been illustrated through the extensive case study of the activities of three
private military and security companies: Executive Outcomes, MPRI and DynCorp.
Furthermore, this thesis has confirmed an increased presence of the United States on the
African continent post-9/11, illustrated by the presence of American-based private military
and security companies which arguably are being used as proxies for US foreign policy
purposes.
Furthermore, this study has discussed the various implications the private security industry
has on the traditional notion of the state’s monopoly on the legitimate use of force. This thesis
has argued that the legitimate use to exercise violence is in the process of devolution from
governments to other actors, which the extensive growth of the private security industry
illustrates. Additionally, it has been argued that the privatisation of military and security
services can harm the reliable delivery of essential services in conflict. Furthermore, the
findings of this thesis has highlighted the dilemma that many countries do not want stricter
regulation or elimination of the private security industry for the reason that these companies are viewed as valuable assets in fulfilling foreign policy objectives that for various reasons
cannot be fulfilled by national armies. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die opkoms en vinnige groei van die privaatsekuriteitsbedryf in die 1990s was die gevolg van
die afskaling van gewapende magte in die nasleep van die Koue Oorlog en die ontwikkeling
van nuwe sekuriteitsbedreigings, wat die aanvraag na militêre arbeidskragte en kundigheid
verhoog het. Dit het aanleiding gegee tot ’n herdefiniëring van sekuriteitstrategieë en die
herstrukturering van gewapende magte deur Westerse regerings, met die gevolg dat niekernaktiwiteite
van die funksies van talle gewapende magte uitgesluit is. Daar is onlangs
aangevoer dat die privaatsekuriteitsbedryf aanspraak kan maak op ’n funksie wat voorheen as
die primêre verantwoordelikheid van regerings beskou is, naamlik om vredesinisiatiewe en
steun aan ander vredesverrigtinge te onderneem.
Die doel van hierdie studie was om die impak van die privaatsekuriteitsbedryf in
vredesinisiatiewe in Afrika-konflikte te assesseer. Daar word aan die hand gedoen dat die
privaatsekuriteitsbedryf sedert die 1990’s ’n baie groter rol in wêreldwye konflikte gespeel
het, en dat die aktiwiteite van hierdie bedryf aanmerklik verander het. Maatskappye soos
MPRI en DynCorp was suksesvol daarin om nabye kontak met hul tuisregerings te behou, wat
stellig ’n deurslaggewende faktor in hul groeiende besighede was. Voorts het die
privaatsekuriteitsbedryf gepoog om hom te distansieer van die negatiewe konnotasies wat met
huursoldate en die aktiwiteite van maatskappye soos Executive Outcomes in die 1990’s
geassosieer is deur bedrywighede wat elemente van direkte stryd inhou, te vermy. Hierdie
poging is geïllustreer deur die omvattende gevallestudie van die aktiwiteite van drie privaat
militêre en sekuriteitsmaatskappye: EO, MPRI en DynCorp. Die bevindinge van die studie
bevestig voorts die Verenigde State van Amerika (VSA) se toenemende teenwoordigheid op
die Afrika-vasteland ná 9/11, wat duidelik blyk uit die teenwoordigheid van Amerikaansgebaseerde
privaat militêre en sekuriteitsmaatskappye wat stellig as volmag gebruik word vir
die VSA se buitelandsebeleidsdoelstellings.
Die verskeie implikasies van die privaatsekuriteitsbedryf vir die tradisionele siening van die
regerings se monopolie ten opsigte van die wettige gebruik van magte word ook in die studie
bespreek. Daar word aangevoer dat die wettige gebruik van geweld in die proses van
devolusie is vanaf regerings na ander rolspelers, wat deur die omvattende groei van die
privaatsekuriteitsbedryf bevestig word. Daar word verder ook beweer dat die privatisering van militêre en sekuriteitsdienste die betroubare lewering van noodsaaklike dienste tydens konflik
kan benadeel. Die studie se bevindinge werp ook lig op die dilemma dat talle lande strenger
regulering of uitskakeling van die privaatsekuriteitsbedryf teëstaan omdat hierdie
maatskappye beskou word as waardevolle bates in die bereiking van
buitelandsebeleidsdoelwitte, wat vir verskeie redes nie deur nasionale leërs bereik kan word
nie.
|
175 |
Debt relief for economics or debt relief for the people? : a critical analysis of the heavily indebted poor countries initiativeAbendanon, Lucille 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2003. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The HIPC Initiative offers qualifying heavily indebted poor countries the opportunity
to renege on their debt obligations in return for an emphatic commitment to poverty
reduction and reform. This dissertation assesses the effectiveness of the HIPC
Initiative in light of the fact that one third of the world's population continues to live
on an average of US$1 per day. In evaluating the HIPC Initiative one simple question
is posed: taking into consideration the abject poverty experienced by over a billion
people in the developing world, and the urgency with which it must be addressed, is
the HIPC Initiative extensive enough, deep enough or broad enough to effectively
challenge worldwide poverty?
Using quantitative and qualitative research methods, the dissertation investigates this
question by examining the divergent points of view offered by the World Bank and
IMF on the one hand, and NGOs on the other as they comment on the most hotly
debated issues surrounding the effectiveness of the HIPC Initiative. The analysis leads
us to an evaluation of the following issues: establishing debt sustainability to qualify
for HIPC relief; the issue of conditionality and the use of poverty reduction strategy
papers; funding the HIPC Initiative; the likelihood of HIPCs escaping the debt trap
after HIPC relief; and finally, how the HIPC Initiative is contributing to attaining the
Millennium Development Goals is evaluated.
After probing the stances of the World Bank and IMF, and the contrasting views of
NGOs the conclusions indicate that the HIPC Initiative is neither extensive, deep nor
broad enough to effectively challenge poverty, or to provide indebted poor countries
with a lasting escape from the burden of unsustainable debt. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) Inisiatief bied aan arm lande met 'n
groot skuldlas, wat kwalifiseer vir hulp, die geleentheid om hul skuldverpligtings af te
las in ruil vir 'n definitiewe verbintenis tot armoede-vermindering en -hervorming.
Hierdie verhandeling evalueer die doeltreffendheid van die HIPC Inisiatief teen die
agtergrond van die feit dat een derde van die wêreld se bevolking op 'n gemiddelde
van een Amerikaanse Dollar per dag oorleef. Hierdie evaluering van die HIPC
Inisiatief stel 'n eenvoudige vraag: Is die HIPC Inisiatief voldoende en uitgebreid
genoeg om die uitdaging van wêreldwye armoede aan te spreek indien 'n mens die
uiterste armoede van meer as 'n biljoen mense in ontwikkelende gebiede in ag neem,
sowel as die dringendheid waarmee dit aangespreek moet word?
Deur van kwantitatiewe en kwalitatiewe navorsingsmetodes gebruik te maak,
ondersoek die verhandeling hierdie vraag deur uiteenlopende gesigspunte van die
Wêreldbank en die Internasionale Monitêre Fonds (IMF) aan die een kant, en Nie-
Regerings Orginisasies (NRO's) s'n aan die ander kant, te ondersoek aan die hand van
hul kommentaar op die belangrikste kwessies oor die doeltreffendheid van die HIPC
Inisiatief. Hierdie ontleding lei tot 'n evaluering van die volgende kwessies: bepaling
van lande se potensiaal om met terugbetalings vol te hou ten einde vir hulp deur die
HIPC te kwalifiseer; die kwessie van voorwaardelikheid en die gebruik van armoedeverligtingstrategieë;
befondsing van die HIPC Inisiatief; die moontlikheid dat die
HIPC's die skuldstrikke na toepassing van HIPC-bystand sal ontsnap; en laastens, hoe
die HIPC Inisiatief se bydrae tot die bereiking van die Millenium
Ontwikkelingsdoelwitte geëvalueer word.
Die standpunte van die Wêreld Bank en die IMF sowel as die teengestelde sienings
van die NRO's word ondersoek. Die gevolgtrekking toon dat dat die HIPC Insiatief
nie uitgebreid, diep of breed genoeg is om armoede doeltreffend hok te slaan nie, of
om skuldlastige arm lande te help om finaal van hul skuldlas te ontsnap nie.
|
176 |
Foreign aid and NGO-state relations in South Africa : post-1994 developmentsRammutle, Radithebe 04 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--University of Stellenbosch, 2003. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This study investigates the impact of foreign aid on the relations between Non-
Governmental Organisations (NGOs) and the state in South Africa since 1994. There
are three different ways in which NGOs can interact with the state and public policy:
viz. they can support and help to implement policies, attempt to reform policies, or
oppose them. During apartheid, the nature of NGO-state relations was characterised
by political confrontation and distrust. NGOs primarily served as organisations of
opposition to the state's exclusivist and dehumanising policies. Many NGOs,
however, also provided developmental and social services to communities who were
neglected by the apartheid state.
After the first democratic election in 1994, the role of NGOs underwent a significant
process of change. Various factors contributed to this change. This study, however,
primarily focuses on the role of foreign aid and its effect on NGO activities in South
Africa, post-1994. This study relied on secondary data sources (both qualitative and
quantitative) available in the area of NGO state relations. The study also focused on
two major donor agencies in South Africa: European Union (EU) and United States
Agency for International Development (USAID).
Analysis of data reveals that, since 1994 much of the funding that was previously
directly channeled to civil society now goes to the state, which distributes it to
targetted NGOs. As a result many NOOs have collapsed because of a shortage of
financial resources to sustain their work.
Secondly, since 1994 the rationale and purpose behind international donor policies
has been to advance the New Policy Agenda (NPA), which is aimed at promoting free
market-orientated reforms and the consolidation of liberal democracy. As a result,
foreign aid donors have endorsed the liberal economic policies, which are set out in
the government's macroeconomic strategy, viz. Growth, Employment, and
Redistribution (GEAR). Thus, both government and donors have prioritised NGOs
who are involved in service delivery rather than those that are likely to challenge and
oppose liberal market policies. They have also shown preference to NGOs that are
more concerned with the norms and practices of procedural democracy as opposed to those that are concerned with issues of participatory and social democracy. This has
resulted in constraining the overtly political and advocacy role, which characterised
NGOs during the apartheid era.
International donors, via government disbursement institutions such as the National
Development Agency (NDA), have also constrained the work of NGOs by insisting
on numerous managerial related requirements that have been made conditional for the
receiving of financial support. Many small, informal, rural community based
organisation that lack the required administrative capacity have, as a result, been
facing serious financial crises.
Subsequently, NGO-state relations, since 1994, have become less adversarial and
confrontational. Most NGOs, complement and support the state's social services
delivery programmes and also serve as organisations which help shape the norms and
practices of procedural democracy. The study concludes, that the persistent
inequality, poverty and unemployment which is associated with the GEAR
macroeconomic policy and endorsed by international donor agencies, will lead to the
resurgence of advocacy NGOs. Furthermore, in order to resuscitate their role and to
ensure their vitality as organisations, which promote participatory democracy, it is
essential to focus on strategies, which can effectively challenge the current funding
environment to NGOs. These include, building the administrative capacity of both the
NDA and NGOs, ensuring NDA independence, and ensuring recognition by funding
institutions of the importance of advocacy NGOs in the consolidation of economic
democracy. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Hierdie studie ondersoek die impak van buitelandse hulp op die verhoudinge tussen
Nie-Regeringsorganisasies (NRO'S) en die staat sedert 1994. Daar is drie verskillende
wyses waarop NRO's interaksie kan bewerkstellig met die staat en met openbare
beleid, naamlik, hulle kan help om beleid te implementeer, hulle kan help om beleid te
verander, of hulle kan beleid teenstaan. Tydens apartheid, is die aard van NRO - staat
verhoudings gekenmerk deur konfrontasie en wantroue. Die NRO's het primêr gedien
as organisasies van opposrsie teen die staat se eksklusiwistiese en
onmenslikingsbeleid. Talle NRO's het egter ook ontwikkelings- en sosiale dienste
voorsien aan gemeenskappe wat afgeskeep is deur die apartheidstaat.
Na die eerste demokratiese verkiesing in 1994, het die rol van NRO's 'n beduidende
proses van verandering ondergaan. 'n Verskeidenheid faktore het bygedra tot hierdie
verandering. Hierdie studie fokus egter primêr op die rol van buitelandse hulp en die
uitwerking daarvan op NRO's se aktiwiteite in Suid-Afrika na 1994. Hierdie studie het
staatgemaak op sekondêre bronne (kwalitatief sowel as kwantitatief) in die gebied van
NRO's - staat verhoudinge. Die studie fokus ook op twee belangrike donateur
agentskappe in Suid-Afrika: die Europese Unie (EU) en die Verenigde State
Agentskap vir Internasionale Ontwikkeling (VSAlO).
'n Analise van die data toon aan dat, sedert 1994, heelwat van die befondsing wat
voorheen direk gekanaliseer is aan die openbare gemeenskap, nou na die staat gaan,
wat dit versprei na geteikende NRO's. Gevolglik het talle NRO's ineengestort vanweë
'n tekort aan finansiële bronne om hulle werk vol te hou.
Tweedens, sedert 1994 was dit die rasionaal en doelstelling van internasionale
donateurskapsbeleid om die Nuwe Beleid Agenda (NBA) te bevorder, wat as
doelstelling het die bevordering van vrye mark-georiënteerde hervormings en die
konsolidasie van 'n liberale demokrasie. Gevolglik het buitelandse hulp donateurs
liberale ekonomiese beleidvorming onderskryfwat uiteengesit word in die regering se
makro-ekonomiese strategie, nl. Groei, Werkverskaffing en Herverdeling (GEAR). Dus het sowel die regering as donateurs prioriteit gegee aan NRO's wat betrokke is in
dienslewering, eerder as dié wat geneig is om liberale markbeleid teen te staan. Hulle
het ook voorkeur gegee aan NRO's wat meer besorg is oor die norme en praktyke van
'n prosedurele demokrasie in teenstelling met dié wat besorgd is oor die vraagstukke
van 'n deelnemende en sosiale demokrasie. Dit het die resultaat gehad dat die openlike
politiese en kampvegtersrol wat kenmerkend van die NRO's was gedurende die
apartheidsera, beperk is.
Internasionale donateurs het, Vla regerings-instellings soos die Nasionale
Ontwikkelingsagentskap (NOA), ook die werk van NRO's beperk deur die aandrang
op talle bestuursverwante vereistes wat as voorwaarde gestel is vir die ontvangs van
finansiële ondersteuning. Talle klein, informele landelike gemeenskaps-gebaseerde
organisasies wat die vereiste administratiewe kapasiteit kort, het gevolglik ernstige
finansiële krisisse begin ondervind.
Daaropvolgend, het NRO-staat verhoudinge sedert 1994 minder konfronterend begin
raak. Die meeste NRO's ondersteun die staat se diensleweringsprogramme en dien
ook as organisasies wat help om die norme en praktyke van 'n prosedurale demokrasie
te vorm. Die studie kom tot die gevolgtrekking dat die voortdurende ongelykheid,
armoede en werkloosheid wat geassosieer word met die makro-ekonomiese beleid van
die regering se program vir Groei, Werkskepping en Herverdeling (GEAR) sal lei tot
In nuwe opkoms van kampvegter NRO's. Voorts, ten einde hulle rol te stimuleer en
hulle lewenskragtigheid as organisasies te verseker, kan ons die huidige
befondsingsomgewing van NRO's doeltreffend uitdaag. Dit sluit in die bou van die
administratiewe kapasiteit van beide die NOA en NRO's, die versekering van NOA
onafhanklikheid, en die versekering van die erkenning deur befondsingsinstellings
van die belangrikheid van kampvegter NRO's in die konsolidasie van 'n ekonomiese
demokrasie.
|
177 |
Gendering conflict resolution in the Democratic Republic of the CongoVan Schalkwyk, Gina 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2003. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This research report documents the results of a study that aims at investigating the potential
contribution of a gender perspective towards conflict resolution. In this regard, the
Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) is used as a case in point. The study takes the
form of an exploratory and descriptive study and extensive use is made of both primary and
secondary sources of data.
By arguing that a gender perspective on conflict will elucidate the way in which women are
affected differently by conflict it logically follows that women should be permitted to assume
their rightful positions in attempts at transforming conflict. The application of a gender
perspective furthermore urges a revision of conflict resolution towards conflict management
and transformation as the appropriate ways of bringing an end to war. This implies that the
emphasis is shifted from a search for political solutions towards conflict prevention and early
warning as the most effective ways of pre-empting violent conflict and the breakdown of
peace-processes aimed at resolving violent conflicts. In the search for an appropriate role for
women in conflict management, the study revisits a number of frameworks for the full and
equal participation of women in conflict management at the international, regional and subregional
levels of analysis. These frameworks are then applied to the situation in the DRC
and some practical courses of action are proposed. While the study concludes that there is a
clearly defined need for exposing the gender bias in the analysis and resolution of violent
conflict, it notes that the patriarchal nature of the DRC and the international system will in
many instances hamper progress towards the achievement of a non-patriarchal and nongendered
peaceful social world order. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Hierdie navorsingsverslag dokumenteer die uitkomste van 'n studie wat daarna streef om die
potensiële bydrae van vroue tot konflik resolusie te ondersoek. Tot hierdie end word die
Demokratiese Republiek van die Kongo as 'n gevalstudie gebruik. Die navorsings ontwerp is
eksploratories en beskrywend en daar word ekstensief gebruik gemaak van beide primêre en
sekondêre bronne van data.
Deur aan te voer dat 'n gender perspektief op konflik die wyse waarop vroue verskillend
geraak word deur konflik beklemtoon, volg dit logies hierop dat vroue toegelaat behoort te
word om hul regmatig plek in te neem ten tyde van pogings tot konflik transformasie. Die
toepassing van 'n gender perspektief dwing verder ook 'n hersiening van konflik resolusie en
beskou konflik bestuur en transformasie as die gepaste maniere om oorlog tot 'n einde te
bring. Dit bring mee dat daar 'n verskuiwing van klem plaasvind - vanaf 'n soeke na
politieke oplossings na konflik voorkoming en vroeë/tydige waarskuwing as die mees
effektiewe instrumente om geweldadige konflik en die ineenstorting van vredesprosesse te
voorkom. In die soeke na die gepaste rol vir vroue in konflik bestuur, herondersoek die
studie 'n aantal raamwerke vir die volledige en gelyke deelname van vroue in konflik bestuur
op die internasionale, regionale en sub-regionale vlakke van analise. Hierdie raamwerke
word dan toegepas op die situasie in the DRK, en praktiese riglyne word voorgehou. Hoewel
die studie vind dat daar 'n duidelike gedefinieerde behoefte bestaan om die gender
vooroordeel in die analisie en resolusie van konflik te openbaar, word dit ook aanvaar dat
die patriargale aard van die DRK en die internasionale sisteem in die meeste gevalle ware
vooruitgang in die daarstelling van 'n nie-patriargale, gelykregtige, vreedsame sosiale
wêreldorde sal kniehalter.
|
178 |
Investigating women's participation in protest politics between 1991 and 2001Wildschut, Angelique Colleen 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MPhil)--Stellenbosch University, 2003. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The involvement of women in both conventional and unconventional forms of political
participation in South Africa has over the past 10 years, and often at present, been
experienced as problematic and limited. Exacerbating the problem of limited access and
information, the study of, and literature about, women's participation in unconventional
forms of politics have also been limited. It is the aim of this study to contribute to our
knowledge in this area.
This study investigates women's participation in unconventional politics between 1991
and 2001. This period is specifically important, as it makes possible the examination of
trends in women's political participation before and after the democratic transition in
1994. This makes it possible for us to speculate about the influence of transition on
women's political participation.
I propose and evaluate two mam hypotheses in which I; firstly, expect women's
participation in protest politics to decrease between 1991 and 2001, and secondly, expect
to find women's levels of participation in protest to be consistently lower than that of
their male counterparts. The complex set of variables influencing women's participation
is evaluated according to the socialization and structural approaches, which offer
different assumptions about the reasons for the trends in women's participation.
In conclusion, I offer the main findings of my research, as well as suggesting possible
areas still to be investigated within the field, as deduced from the questions arising out of
my analysis in this project. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die betrokkenheid van vroue in beide konvensionele en onkonvensionele vorme van
politieke deelname in Suid Afrika, was oor die laaste 10 jaar, en is steeds ervaar as
problematies en beperk. Wat die probleem vererger, is die beperkte toegang tot
informasie, die studie van, en literatuur oor, vroue se deelname in onkonvensionele
vorme van politiek. Dit is in die strewe na die oorkoming van hierdie leemtes, dat hierdie
werk aangepak word.
Hierdie werk ondersoek vroue se deelname in onkonvensionele politiek tussen 1991 en
2001. Hierdie periode is spesifiek belangrik, omdat dit die demokratiese transisie na 1994
insluit, en om neigings in vroulike deelname voor en na 1994 te bestudeer. Dit maak dit
moontlik om oor die invloed van die transisie op vroue se politieke deelname te
spekuleer.
Ek stel, en evalueer twee hoof hipoteses waarin ek; eerstens, verwag dat vroue se
deelname in protes politiek sal verminder tussen 1991 en 2001, en tweedens, verwag ek
om te vind dat vroue se vlakke van deelname in protes, deurentyd laer sal wees as die van
mans. Die komplekse stel veranderlikes wat vroue se deelname beinvloed, word geevalueer
in terme van die sosialisering- en strukturele benaderings, wat verskillende
voorstelle oor die motivering van die geobserveerde neigings in vroue se deelname
oplewer.
Ten slotte, bied ek die hoof bevindinge van my navorsing aan, so wel as voorstelle ten
opsigte van moontlike areas vir verder ondersoek binne die veld.
|
179 |
Lobbying disability in South Africa, 1994-2001 : a description of the activities of the disabled people South Africa (DPSA) in the policy-making processTire, Thabo Dennis 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MPhil)--Stellenbosch University, 2003. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This research assignment is a detailed descriptive investigation of the lobbying role
played by the Disabled People South Africa (DPSA) in the post-apartheid era in South
Africa. The period under investigation is 1994-2001.
The focus is on the DPSA as a lobbyist attempting to influence policy in favour of the
disabled people in South Africa. In doing this, the study gives an overview of the three
important concepts in this study, namely policy-making, disability and lobbying. The
three concepts are analysed and looked at particularly from a South Africa perspective.
The study utilises different methods of data collection.
Disabled people have a history of being exposed to discrimination. After 1994 South
Africa had a Constitution that outlawed such a practice against disabled people. South
Africa in its democracy has new policies that are different from the ones that were
governing the country during the apartheid era. The DPSA, as an umbrella body
representing the disabled, now has to play a more effective role regarding the advocating
for its members. Hence this study is conducted during the 1994-2001 period. The study
mainly focuses on what and how the DPSA has tried to influence lobbying policy-making
in favour of the disabled.
The conclusion of the study is that the DPSA has achieved success directly and
indirectly. The DPSA has managed to playa significant role in the improvement of the
lives of disabled people in South Africa. However, it is recommended that the DPSA
should make more efforts in addition to what has been done up to this far. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Hierdie navorsingsopdrag is 'n gedetailleerde beskrywende studie van die rol wat die
werwing van steun deur die Gestremde Mense van Suid Afrika (DPSA) in die postapartheid
era 1994-2001 in Suid-Afrika speel.
Die fokus is op die DPSA as 'n steunwerwer om die beleid te beïnvloed ten gunste van
gestremde mense in Suid-Afrika. Deur dit te doen gee hierdie studie 'n oorsig van drie
belangrike konsepte, naamlik beleidvorming, gestremdheid en steunwerwing. Hierdie
drie konsepte is spesifiek vanuit 'n Suid-Afrikaanse perspektief ontleed. Die studie
gebruik verskillende metodes om data te versamel.
Gestremde mense het 'n geskiedenis van blootstelling aan diskriminasie. Na 1994 het
Suid-Afrika 'n grondwet wat diskriminasie teen gestremde mense onwettig verklaar het.
'n Demokratiese Suid-Afrika het nuwe beleide wat verskillend is van dié wat die land
tydens die apartheid era gehad het. Die DPSA, as 'n sambreelorganisasie,
verteenwoordigend van gestremdes, moes nou 'n meer effektiewe rol speel in die
verdediging van sy lede. Die studie fokus hoofsaaklik op die voordele wat die DPSA
gekry het ten gunste van die gestremdes.
Die gevolgtrekking van die studie is dat die DPSA direkte en indirekte suksesse behaal
het. Die DPSA het dit reggekry om 'n belangrike rol te speel in die verbetering van die
lewe van gestremdes in Suid-Afrika. Daar is nietemin voorgestel dat die DPSA meer
pogings moet aanwend, addisioneel tot dit wat reeds gedoen is.
|
180 |
The World Trade Organisation : international trade, dispute settlement & the environmentGreyling, Minette Ilse 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2003. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The norms governing international trade on the one hand, and sustainable development on the
other, have both different origins and objectives. This is the central problem that will be addressed
in this research assignment, by analysing the structure, functioning and future of the World Trade
Organisation Dispute Settlement Mechanism (DSM). Though there has been a significant shift from
politics to legality, the dispute settlement system is still far from perfect. When looking at recent
environmental trade disputes, the stress placed on the system is revealed. ••
The focus is on the impact of environmental disputes on the nature and functioning of the DSM,
and how these disputes have contributed to the development of international trade law, and the
concept of sustainable development. These will all contribute to a greater understanding of the
interaction of the World Trade Organisation and the multilateral trading system, and the future role
the WTO should play on the agenda for sustainable development. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die norme wat enersyds internasionale handel, en andersyds volhoubare ontwikkeling beheer, het
uiteenlopende oorspronge en doelstellings. Hierdie is die sentrale probleem wat deur hierdie
navorsingsverslag aangespreek word, te wete deur die struktuur, funksionering en toekoms van
die Wereldhandelsorganisasie (WHO) Dispute Settlement Mechanism (DSM) te analiseer. Hierdie
dispuutskikkingstelsel is nog steeds nie volmaak nie, ten spyte daarvan dat daar reeds 'n
betekenisvolle verskuiwing van politiek tot wetlikheid plaasgevind het. As daar na onlangse
omgewingshandelsdispute gekyk word, kom die druk wat op die stelsel geplaas word, duidelik na
vore.
Die fokus word dus met hierdie navorsingsverslag geplaas op die impak wat omgewingsdispute op
die aard en funksionering van die DSM het, en hoe die dispute bygedra het tot die ontwikkeling van
internasional handelswette asook op die konsep van volhoubare ontwikkeling. Hierdie fokus
behoort by te dra tot 'n groter begrip tot die interaksie tussen die Wereldhandelsorganisasie (WHO)
en die multilaterale handelstelsels, asook op die toekomstige rol wat die WHO behoort te speel
met betrekking tot die agenda vir volhoubare ontwikkeling.
|
Page generated in 0.097 seconds