Spelling suggestions: "subject:"etheses -- bpolitical science"" "subject:"etheses -- bipolitical science""
81 |
Namibian democracy: consolidated?Kangas, Lari 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis MA (Political Science))--University of Stellenbosch, 2006. / Namibian independence was much delayed: it took place during the last years of decolonisation in Africa, at the end of the Cold War, and during the final phases of the third wave of democracy.
SWAPO prevailed in the first hotly contested elections. We all thought that the institutions of democracy were in place and that Namibia was going to lead the way for the new wave of consolidated democracies in Africa. Inclusiveness, using the classic terminology from Robert Dahl, was there to a significant degree, a “one-man-one-vote” –system was finally achieved.
|
82 |
Social and natural reality : prospects for a consilient theory of nationalismSwerhun, Bryce 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA (Political Science))--Stellenbosch University, 2008. / Nationalism is quite easy to understand, but somewhat difficult to explain. In
terms of understanding nationalism, we do not need to know anything more
about society and sentiment than what is taken for granted in everyday life.
An individual who ‘drops’ into a foreign culture may know absolutely nothing
about its people’s songs, rituals, amusements and traditions: why some
customs evoke tears, and others, bravado. This person would feel no sense
of collective awe or inspiration when touring historic battlefields and
monuments of an unfamiliar country. Nevertheless, he or she would likely
understand and appreciate that all of these things are steeped in meaning and
identity. These instances of meaning and identity may not be felt, shared or
even fully known, but their role as expressions of nationalism can be readily
appreciated. The global spread of nations entails an array of mutually
unfamiliar national identities, but the actual phenomenon nationalism is rarely
foreign to anyone. From an outsider’s perspective we do not know how
certain expressions are significant to a particular group, but we do understand
that they are expressions of national belonging.
Explaining nationalism is more difficult for the simple reason that experiencing
and recognizing a phenomenon is not sufficient to account for its existence.
Customs and rituals are two suggested properties of nationalism, but what is
the causal relationship between such properties and the end phenomenon
(how does custom actually lead to nationalism, if at all)? The answers to
these questions are still a matter of debate. The situation is only made worse
by the fact that most theories explaining nationalism seem to rest on a tower
of abstractions. For instance, it may seem uncontroversial for some to argue
that nationalism is an outgrowth of ethnic identity. However, this just begs the
question. What is ethnicity? The potential for regress to abstraction is a
major impediment to theory.
This thesis will examine the problem of explanation: the reasons why theories
of nationalism have struggled with explaining nationalism, and a discussion on
how to overcome these difficulties. Specifically, this thesis will show that:
1) The problem of explaining nationalism is due in part to the
‘classical’ problem found in the literature: whether nationalism is
an ‘ancient’ social phenomenon, or a ‘modern’ phenomenon
which can be dated (roughly) to the late eighteenth century.
2) Debates regarding the classical problem are closely affected by
philosophical issues in the social sciences.
3) The incorporation of a consilient methodology (i.e. a research
program that unifies theories of social science with theories of
natural science) can provide a new strategy for future theories of
nationalism and work to solve the classical problem.
|
83 |
Constructing Africa(ns) in international relations theory: bridging a theoretical abyssOswald, Rikus 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA (Political Science))--University of Stellenbosch, 2009. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Africa(ns) are currently marginalised within the discipline of International Relations. This
thesis explores the possibility that employing a constructivist approach could facilitate the
inclusion of Africa as an object of study and Africans as potential agents of IR knowledge
within the discipline by bridging a theoretical abyss.
Two discourses, namely the rationalist and Africanist, are identified. They frame the sides
of the theoretical abyss to which Africa(ns) have been marginalised within IR. These
discourses adhere to the opposing analytical approaches which constitute the Third
Debate, namely rationalism and reflectivism. This thesis proposes two theoretical
reconstructions that can facilitate the bridging of this theoretical abyss. The theoretical
reconstructions are explicated by employing different research stances. The researcher is
situated within the intellectual space afforded by the boundaries of the discipline in order to
propose the first reconstruction. The second theoretical reconstruction is proposed by
problematising the boundaries the discipline of IR.
This study found that constructivism facilitates the process of establishing the middle
ground between rationalism and reflectivism and in so doing could include Africa as an
object of study. It also found that the intervention of constructivism facilitated a necessary
change in the culture of the discipline to create the possibility of extending the notion of
engaged pluralism and re-imagining the discipline as a disciplinary community of
difference. This leads to the opening up of the necessary dialogical space to include
Africans as potential agents of IR knowledge. Constructivism is therefore the mutually
constituting link between the two proposed theoretical reconstructions as they are made
possible by its intervention in the discipline. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Afrika(ne) word huidiglik gemarginaliseer binne die dissipline van Internasionale
Betrekkinge. Hierdie tesis ondersoek die moontlikheid dat die gebruik van ‘n
konstruktiwistiese benadering die insluiting van Afrika as ‘n onderwerp van studie of
Afrikane as potensiële agente van IB kennis deur die oorbrugging van ‘n teoretiese kloof
kan fasiliteer.
Twee diskoerse, naamlik die rasionalistiese and die Afrikanistiese, word geïdentifiseer.
Hierdie diskoerse stel die sye van die teoretiese kloof voor waarin Afrika(ne)
gemarginaliseer word binne IB. Hulle hou verband met die twee opponerende analitiese
benaderings van rasionalisme en reflektiwisme wat die Derde Debate uitmaak. Hierdie
tesis stel twee teoretiese rekonstruksies voor wat die oorbrugging van die teoretiese kloof
kan fasiliteer. Hierdie teoretiese rekonstruksies word ontvou deur verskillende
navorsingsposisies in te neem. Die navorser plaas homself binne die intellektuele spasie
wat deur die grense van die dissipline toegelaat word om sodoende die eerste
rekonstruksie voor te stel. Die tweede rekonstruksie word voorgestel deur die
problematisering van die grense van die dissipline.
Hierdie studie het gevind dat konstruktiwisme die proses van die opstelling van ‘n
middelgrond tussen rasionalisme en reflektiwisme fasiliteer en sodoende Afrika as ‘n
onderwerp van studie kan insluit. Die studie het ook gevind dat die toetrede van
konstruktiwisme die nodige verandering aan die kultuur van die dissipline veroorsaak het
wat die moontlikheid skep dat die begrip van ‘engaged pluralism’ uitgebrei en die
hervoorstelling van die dissipline as a dissiplinêre gemeenskap van diversiteit kan word.
Hierdie hervoorstelling lei tot die skepping van die nodige dialogale spasie om Afrikane as
potensiële agente van IB kennis in te sluit. Konstruktiwisme is dus die onderliggende
skakel wat die twee voorgestelde teoretiese rekonstruksies moontlik maak deur die
benadering se toetrede tot die dissipline.
|
84 |
Political risk analysis and economic reform : investing in the Indian electricity sectorDuncan, Stewart M. 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2003. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The definition of political risk and the methodology of its assessment have changed since
the inception of the discipline midway through the last century. This assignment assesses
the usefulness of a new quantitative technique that uses political constraints and the policy
preferences of political actors to construct a measure of political risk. Integrating the
findings of the resulting Political Constraints Index with an analysis of the political
economy of the Indian Electricity Sector, the assignment demonstrates that, contrary to the
original interpretations of the index, high levels of political constraints and political
competition may propagate a disabling policy regime and be detrimental to the investor,
despite the stated commitment of the incumbent government to policy reform. The
implication of these findings is that, to avoid incorrect interpretation, the Political
Constraint Index should be augmented by a comprehensive qualitative assessment of the
industry in question. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die definisie van politieke risiko en die metodologie om dit te ontleed, het verander sedert
die onstaan van hierdie dissipline gedurende die middel van die laaste eeu. Hierdie opdrag
ontleed die nuttigheid van 'n nuwe kwantitatiewe tegniek wat die politieke beperkings en
beleidsvoorkeure van politieke rolspelers gebruik om 'n maatstaf van politieke risiko te
verskaf. Die opdrag se integrasie van die bevindinge van die resulterende Politieke
Beperkings Indeks met 'n analise van die politieke ekonomie van die Indiese Elektrisiteits
Sektor bewys dat, teenstrydig met oorspronklike interpretasies van die indeks, hoe vlakke
van politieke beperkings en politieke kompetisie 'n deaktiveringsbeleid regime kan kweek
wat nadelig is vir die belegger, ten spyte van die huidige regering se verklaarde
toegewydheid tot beleidshervorming. Die implikasie van hierdie bevindinge is dat, om
foutiewe interpretasie te vermy, die Politieke Beperkings Indeks verbeter moet word deur 'n
omvattende kwalitatiewe ontleding van die verlangde industrie.
|
85 |
The cost of South Africa's 1999 National Elections : too high a price for democracy?Wessels, Ricardo Peter 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2000. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This thesis addresses the financial cost implications incurred during elections, with
special focus on South Africa. The discussion is conducted by way of comparing
South Africa to countries like India, Australia, Israel and Mexico.
Democracy entails more than merely conducting periodic elections that are free and
fair, but it cannot be less. To a large extent free and fair elections are indicative of the
governing authority's commitment to democracy. This commitment however, does
have financial implications. A question that is very rarely addressed relates to the
financial cost implications that accompany this commitment. For a country such as
South Africa with a range of other pressing socio-economic issues, the cost factor
with regard to the voting process is of vital importance.
The South African electoral experience, in comparison to that of other developing
countries, is presently a very costly undertaking at a conservative average cost of
more than US $13.00 per vote. Depending on how the expenses are calculated, this
figure takes on hefty proportions.
To an extent the tardiness on the part of the South African Government in appointing
the Electoral Commission to conduct the 1999 elections and the subsequent conflicts
regarding the budgetary allocations to the Electoral Commission (EC) combined with
poor electoral planning, resulted in the EC having to resort to very expensive
technology in order to ensure that a free and fair election would be conducted on the
date set by the President.
Apart from addressing the above mentioned issues, relating to the cost expenditure
during elections, the assignment also addresses possible ways to reduce these costs
incurred. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Hierdie tesis fokus op die finansiële uitgawes wat tydens verkiesings aangegaan word,
met spesifieke verwysing na Suid-Afrika. Die bespreking geskied aan die hand van 'n
vergelyking met lande soos Indië, Australië, Israel en Mexico.
Demokrasie behels baie meer as net die hou van periodieke vrye en regverdige
verkiesings, maar dit kan ook nie enigiets minder as dit behels nie. Vrye en
regverdige verkiesings is tot 'n groot mate 'n bewys van 'n bepaalde regime se
verbintenis tot die demokrasie. Hierdie verbintenis het egter finansiële implikasies vir
'n land. Die finansiële koste verbonde aan hierdie "verbintenis" is egter selde 'n punt
van akademiese bespreking. Met die aantal sosio-ekonomiese vraagstukke waarmee
die Suid-Afrikaanse regering op die oomblik gekonfronteeer word, is dit van
kardinale belang dat dringende aandag geskenk word aan pogings om die koste-faktor
van die verkiesingsproses so laag as moontlik te hou.
In vergelyking met die gemiddelde koste wat verbonde is aan verkiesings in ander
ontwikkelende lande, was die 1999 Suid-Afrikaanse verkiesing (teen sowat US
$13,00 per kieser) 'n duur onderneming en afhangende van hoe die kostes bereken
word, ontaard hierdie bedrag in 'n aardige een.
Tot 'n groot mate was swak verkiesingsbeplanning die oorsaak dat daar tot duur
tegnologie gewend moes om te verseker dat die verkiesing vry en regverdig verloop,
soos op die datum wat deur die President bepaal is. Die laat aanwysing van die 1999
Verkiesingskommissie en die daaropvolgende konflik oor die verkiesingsbegroting,
het ook bygedra tot die feit dat duur tegnologie ingespan moes word.
Afgesien van bogenoemde aspekte, bespreek die tesis ook moontlike maniere om
toekomstige verkiesings in Suid-Afrika teen 'n laer koste te hou.
|
86 |
Trade union reaction to privatisation : the case of the congress of South African trade unionsWildeman, Russell Andrew 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MPhil)--Stellenbosch University, 2000. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The assignment examines the policy positions of the Congress of South African Trade
Unions (COSATU) on restructuring and privatisation.
The assignment's theoretical point of departure is found in the work of Levitsky and
Way (1998). Levitsky and Way (1998) examines the alliance between a political party
and its labour ally in the context of neo-liberal economic reform. The context is
usually a political party that has come to power with the aid of a powerful trade union
federation. The authors are interested in establishing if the party-union alliance would
be sustained if the political party embarks on drastic economic reforms that have the
potential to undermine trade union federations. The two cases that are investigated are
Poland and Argentina, because in both these cases, a political party has been swept
into power with the aid of a powerful trade union federation. Against the background
of neo-liberal economic reforms, both trade union federations initially supported the
economic reforms. In the medium and long term however, labour defected from the
alliance in Poland, whereas the alliance was sustained in Argentina despite the
enormous costs to workers.
Levitsky and Way (1998) then posit a number of material and institutional factors that
explain both the initial convergence and the later divergence between the two test
cases. The factors that are included in this framework are social linkages, party
strength, leadership overlap, union competition and the degree of autonomy from
either party leadership or the rank-and-file. These factors are hypothesised to explain
the policy positions and behaviour of the trade union federation. It is this theoretical
framework, which will be tested to establish if the framework permits enough
conceptual leverage to explain the past and present policy positions of COSATU on
privatisation. These factors have been given prominence because of its actual bearing
on the status of the alliance relationship. The present study will therefore be using
these factors of the framework, and barring one exception, it will be conceptualised in
the same way.
The second component of the study is to use the South African National Opinion
Leader Survey of 1997/98 to study the actual attitudes and opinions of COSATU
leaders on a range of privatisation issues. The survey is going to be used to determine
if there is any degree of continuity between formal congress resolutions and the
attitudes of COSATU leaders in the survey. This is also an indirect way of verifying
the ideological loyalty of leaders to the official positions of the trade union federation.
The second question returns to the alliance relationship by examining differences, if
any between COSATU and ANC leaders on privatisation related issues.
Factor analysis is used to build two indexes, namely a "privatisation index" and a
"gear index." An interesting finding from the data is the relatively greater policy
cohesion amongst COSATU leaders. These results permit speculations that do not
necessarily indicate an imminent breaking up of the alliance, but rather continued
discussions with possibly various policy compromises by COSATU and the ANC. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die werkstuk ondersoek die beleidsposisie van die Congress of South African Trade
Unions (COSATU) oor herstrukturering en privatisering in Suid Afrika.
Die werkstuk se teoretiese uitgangspunt word in die werk van Levitsky en Way
gevind (1998). Hierdie skrywers ondersoek die alliansie tussen 'n politieke party en sy
arbeidsvennoot in die konteks van neo-liberale ekonomiese hervorming. Die konteks
is 'n politieke party wat aan bewind gekom het met die steun van 'n kragtige vakbondfederasie.
Die skrywers wil vas stel of die party-vakbond-alliansie sal voortgaan
wanneer die politieke party drastiese ekonomiese hervorming aanpak wat die
potensiaal het om vakbond federasies te ondermyn. Twee gevalle, naamlik Pole en
Argentinië word ondersoek. In albei gevalle het die regerende politieke party aan
bewind gekom met die hulp van die vakbond federasie. Teen hierdie agtergrond van
neo-liberale hervorming het albei vakbond federasies in Pole en Argentinië
aanvanklik die proses gesteun. Gedurende hierdie tydperk het vakbonde in Pole
weggebreek van die alliansie, terwyl die alliansie in Argentinië ten spyte van die groot
koste vir die werkers voortgesit was.
Levitsky en Way (1998) verskaf 'n aantal materiële en institusionele faktore wat die
aanvanklike samevloeiing en die latere uiteenvloeiing in hul twee voorbeelde kan
verduidelik. Die faktore wat in die ontleding gebruik word is sosiale verbindinge,
partysterkte, leierskap oorvleueling, vakbond kompetisie en outonomie van of party
leierskap en gewone werkers. Volgens die skrywers se hipotese sal hierdie faktore die
beleidsposisies van die vakbond federasie verklaar. Dit is hierdie teoretiese raamwerk
wat in die studie gebruik word. Daar word gepoog om vas te stel of hierdie raamwerk
genoegsame konseptuele reikwydte het om COSATU se privatiserings beleid te
verduidelik.
Die tweede komponent van die studie is die gebruik van die Suid Afrikaanse
Nasionale Menings Opname van 1997/98. Dit word gebruik om die houdings en die
opinies van COSATU leiers oor n breë spektrum van privatiserings kwessies te
ondersoek. Die doel is om vas te stel of daar enige graad van kontinuïteit tussen
formele kongres resolusies en houdings van COSATU leiers bestaan. Dit is ook 'n
manier om die "ideologiese getrouheid" van COSATU leiers te verifieer. Tweedens
word daar teruggekeer na die alliansie verhouding deur die verskille tussen ANC en
COSATU leiers betreffende privatiserings verwante kwessies te ondersoek.
Faktor ontleding word gebruik om twee indekse te bou, naamlik 'n "Privatiserings
indeks" en 'n "Gear-indeks". Interessante bevindinge wat dui op 'n groter
beleidskohesie by Cosatu-meningsvormers as by ANC-meningsvormers kom na vore.
Na aanleiding van bogenoemde model word daar gespekuleer dat hierdie
meningspatrone nie noodwendig op 'n uiteenval van die alliansie dui nie, maar eerder
op voortgesette gesprekke met verskeie beleidskompromisse by Cosatu sowel as die
ANC-leierskap.
|
87 |
China's rise to superpower status : problems and prospectsHoogbaard, Morne 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2001. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The research assignment examines pertinent factors affecting the political, economic and
social landscape of the development of the People's Republic of China (PRC). Domestic
conditions within the PRC are influencing its foreign policy behaviour in the international
arena. The PRC's internal environment will thus determine the extent of its external
presence. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die werkstuk bestudeer die relevante faktore wat die politieke, ekonomiese en sosiale
landskap ten opsigte van die Republiek van China (PRC) se holistiese ontwikkeling
beïnvloed. Omstandighede binne die Republiek beïnvloed die land se buitelandse
beleidsgedrag in die internasionale arena. Dit sal dus regverdig wees om te sê dat
binnelandse faktore 'n beslissende rol speel ten opsigte van hoe die land homself binne
die globale arena hanteer.
|
88 |
Economic, social and political/institutional assessment of spatial development initiatives (in South Africa)Tessely, Ruth 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2001. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The Spatial Development Initiatives (SDIs) became the Department of Trade and
Industry's (DTI) official policy in 1995/6 to accommodate problems, such as
unemployment and empowerment, through sustainable development. We consequently
pose the question whether the government has realised a strategic fit, i.e. whether the
initial intention with the SDI strategy has consequently been achieved and, if not, what
the main lessons are to fill the strategic gap? This question will be addressed in five
chapters. The first chapter will provide the reader with the necessary background
information on these initiatives. Before concluding (Chapter 6), the following three
chapters will follow the inherent logic of the SDI strategy, i.e. economic investments are
crowded in (Chapter 3) through a facilitating and mediating role of government (Chapter
4) in order to solve employment and empowerment (Chapter 5). Each realm, i.e.
economic- political/institutional-and social, is evaluated on its contribution to the success
of the Spatial Development Initiative.
On the one hand it is difficult to say categorically whether or not there was a strategic fit,
because the strategic aims were not initially written out in measurable detail. If the aim
was to employ and to empower, while strengthening the institutions, we could
qualitatively discern only when institutional capacity building (like in Lubombo) was a
clear aim, that the resulting effect of the SDI strategy was significant.
The employment and empowerment efforts may have been more disappointing than
hoped for. But again this is difficult to discern because it may be too early to observe the
trickle down effects. Neither is it easy to measure the many achievements that were
recorded, and still then, they will probably look very relative because of the immensity of
the problem. In 2001 the South African Government acknowledged that it has failed in its
empowerment programme, while a Presidential Summit was convened in 1998 to search
for employment solutions. Against this background and given that not more effort is
made to measure the results of the efforts to create employment, has to indicate that the
SDIs have not left behind an impression of having performed well in terms of their
strategic aim. On the one hand this was because government strongly tended towards
attracting foreign investment while paying too little attention to the subsequent needs of
SMMEs. Moreover is there a need for an integrated and long-term development plan that
allows rational choices to be made. Nevertheless, the fact that evaluations are
commissioned and that government publicly admits a mistake could be the signs of a
learning organisation, which again is the start of a positive process. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Ruimtelike Ontwikkelings Inisiatiewe (ROI's) het die Departement Handel en Nywerheid
se amptelike beleid in 1995/96 geword om probleme soos werkloosheid en
swartbemagtiging deur middel van volhoubare ontwikkeling aan te spreek. Ons stel
gevolglik die vraag of die regering 'n strategiese plan gehad het waarbinne die ROI
inisiatief gepas het, of dit gewerk het en wat die lesse te leer is? Hierdie kwessie sal in
vyf hoofstukke aangespreek word. Die eerste hoofstuk voorsien die leser van die nodige
agtergrondinligting oor dergelike inisiatiewe. Die samevatting is hoofstuk ses, maar dit
word deur drie ander hoofdstukke voorafgegaan: 'n logiese beoordeling van die
ekonomiese determinante (hoofstuk drie), die fasiliterende rol van die regering (hoofstuk
vier) en die suksesse, al dan nie, van werkskepping en bemagtiging (hoofstuk vyf). Elke
tema word beoordeel in die lig van die vraag of dit bydra to die sukses van ROI's.
Aan die een kant is dit moeilik te verklaar of daar 'n strategiese plan was omdat so 'n
plan nie vooraf uiteengesit was nie. Indien dit die bedoeling was om werkgeleenthede te
skep en om bemagtiging te bevorder, sou mens slegs na enkele inisiatiewe hoef te kyk,
bv die Lubombo Plan. In so 'n geval was die suksesse tog beduidend. In die algemeen
was die werkverskaffings- en bemagtigingsresultate egter teleurstellend. Dit is moontlik
steeds te vroeg om 'n finale oordeel uit te spreek. Op hierdie stadium is dit geen
eenvoudige taak om prestasies in die lig van die groter problematiek te meet nie. Bv in
2001 het die regering bevestig dat bemagtigingsprogramme in die lig van die
presidensiele beraad van 1998, misluk het. Teen hierdie agtergrond word die indruk
geskep dat die ROI's moontlik nie hul strategiese doelwitte bereik het nie. Sedertdien het
die regering daarna gestrewe om buitelandse direkte investering na Suid-Afrika te lok
deur middel van privatisering en klein, mikro en medium ondernemings te vestig. Die
planne was moontlik meer suksesvol. Al hierdie inisiatiewe behoort in 'n enkele
langtermyn ontwikkelingsplan opgeneem te word sodat rasionele keuses gemaak kan
word. Dan sal daar duidelikheid wees oor die rol en plek van ROI's. Dit bestaan nog nie.
Nietemin doen die regering reeds beoordelings van hulle planne met die oog om dit te
hersien en die erkenning dat sekere planne nie hulle mikpunte bereik nie, is tekens
daarvan dat 'n leerproses aan die orde van die dag is wat tog 'n positiewe begin was.
|
89 |
The international political economy of the Cartagena Protocol on biosafetyDu Plessis, Marthinus Johannes 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--University of Stellenbosch, 2001. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The development of the global biotechnology industry largely coincided with the
development of the US biotechnology industry. This resulted in this industry's
oligopolistic and centralised nature where only a few multinational chemical and
pharmaceutical companies control most biotechnology processes and production of
commodities emanating from these processes. The governance of biotechnology
has, until recently, been dominated by state actors who have endeavoured to secure
national interests, including those of large multinational corporations (MNCs) based
within their boundaries.
The technological ability of developed states to exploit and use unevenly distributed
resources to their advantage means that an uneven relationship exists between
these and poor developing countries. This has been highlighted by differences in
public opinion about the role and application of biotechnology in society. While some
opinions favour the use and application of biotechnology to enhance food supplies
and boost production levels and trade, other opinions caution against the possible
hazards that genetically manipulated organisms (GMOs) hold for the environment
and human existence.
The commercialisation of biotechnology has resulted in the exponential growth of
genetically manipulated crops in especially the United States and countries like
Argentina and Canada. These countries produce large surpluses of staple grains
such as corn and soya and try to sell these to countries with food supply problems.
The clash in commercial interests stemming from developed countries' insistence on
the protection of intellectual property rights (IPR) on genetically manipulated (GM)
seeds has caused considerable conflict with poor farmers who will not be able to
sustain their livelihoods if they cannot save seeds for future harvests.
This is one aspect of the problems surrounding the protection of knowledge products
that is exacerbated by the scientific uncertainty pertaining to the risk involved with
biotechnology. While some observers agitate for precaution with the use of GMOs,
others feel that a lack of scientific proof of harm is sufficient grounds for proceeding
with developments in biotechnology. Conversely, there are some that feel that biotechnology is market driven instead of human needs driven, ultimately resulting in
developing countries receiving very little benefit from it.
The Cartagena Protocol on biosafety was drafted to address some of the difficulties
involved with the transboundary movement of GMOs. Although it holds very specific
advantages for developing countries, as a regulatory framework it is limited in its
scope and application. Developing countries are limited in their policy options to
address their need to protect biodiversity and secure their food supply. This means
that considerable challenges and constraints await these countries in utilising global
governance of public goods and building their human and technological capacities. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die ontwikkeling van die globale biotegnologie-industrie het grootliks saamgeval met
die ontwikkeling van die Verenigde State se biotegnologie-industrie. Dit het
aanleiding gegee tot hierdie industrie se oligopolistiese en gesentraliseerde aard
waar slegs enkele multinasionale chemiese en farmaseutiese maatskappye die
meeste biotegnologie prosesse en die vervaardiging van kommoditeite uit daardie
prosesse beheer. Die regering van biotegnologie was tot onlangs oorheers deur
staatsakteurs wie gepoog het om nasionale belange te beskerm, insluitend die
belange van multinasionale korporasies (MNK) wat vanuit hulle grondgebied
funksioneer.
Die tegnologiese vermoë van ontwikkelde state om oneweredig verspreide
hulpbronne tot eie gewin te benut beteken dat 'n ongelyke verhouding bestaan
tussen hierdie en arm ontwikkelende state. Dit word beklemtoon deur verskille in
openbare mening oor die rol en aanwending van biotegnologie in die samelewing.
Terwyl sekere opinies ten gunste van die aanwending van biotegnologie vir die
verbetering van voedselbronne en produksievlakke en handel is, dui ander opinies
op die moontlike gevare wat geneties gemanipuleerde organismes (GMOs) vir die
omgewing en menslike voortbestaan inhou.
Die kommersialisering van biotegnologie het gelei tot die eksponensiële groei van
geneties gemanipuleerde gewasse in veral die Verenigde State en state soos
Argentinië en Kanada. Hierdie state produseer groot hoeveelhede stapelgrane soos
mielies en soja en poog om dit te verkoop aan state met
voedselvoorsieningsprobleme. Die botsing in kommersiële belange wat spruit uit
ontwikkelde state se aandrang op die beskerming van intellektuele eiendomsreg op
geneties gemanipuleerde saad veroorsaak beduidende konflik met arm landbouers
wie nie hulle lewensonderhoud kan verseker as hulle nie saad kan berg vir
toekomstige saaiseisoene nie.
Dit is een aspek van die problematiek rondom die beskerming van kennisprodukte
wat vererger word deur die wetenskaplike onsekerheid wat gepaard gaan met die
risiko's van biotegnologie. Terwyl sekere waarnemers vir waaksaamheid pleit in die gebruik van GMOs, is daar ander wat voel dat 'n gebrek aan wetenskaplike bewyse
van skade genoegsame gronde is vir die voortsetting van ontwikkelings in
biotegnologie. Insgelyks is daar diegene wat meen dat biotegnologie markgedrewe
in plaas van menslike behoefte gedrewe is, wat uiteindelik daartoe lei dat
ontwikkelende state baie min voordeel daaruit trek.
Die Kartagena Protokoloor bioveiligheid is opgestel om van die probleme betrokke
by die oorgrens verskuiwing van GMOs aan te spreek. Hoewel dit spesifieke
voordele vir ontikkelende state inhou is dit as reguleringsraamwerk beperk in omvang
en aanwending. Ontwikkelende state het beperkte beleidsopsies om hulle behoefte
om biodiversiteit te beskerm en voedselvoorsiening te verseker, aan te spreek. Dit
beteken dat beduidende uitdagings en beperkings hierdie state in die benutting van
globale regering van openbare goedere vir die bou van menslike en tegnologiese
kapasiteite in die gesig staar.
|
90 |
First among equals : the impact China's accession, to the WTO is going to have on the developing worldCrichton, Ruth 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--University of Stellenbosch, 2002. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This study explores the impact China's accession to the WTO and growing economic
ascendancy in the multilateral trading system is going to have on the developing
world. The central problem addressed is whether China's accession and growing
stature is going to be a competitive threat to the developing world or will China
emerge as a collaborator to the developing world and assist in redressing the
inequalities of the system.
Three themes emerge and are dealt with in this study. The first addresses China as a
developing nation itself and its overall position in relation to the rest of the developing
world. Then China's growing economic progress and its internal developments are
looked at. Finally China is evaluated as collaborator or competitor to the developing
world.
A descriptive and analytical approach is employed in this study. The complexity and
the interplay between the multiple levels of analysis emerge in this study. In order to
best address the role China is to play, China has to be set in the greater multilateral
context, the regional context and then evaluated in conjunction with the internal
dynamics which are unfolding. These perspectives together are of the utmost
importance in determining the future role China is to play in relation to the developing
world. Whether it will emerge as a collaborator or a competitor to the already
marginalised developing sector of the trading system.
The regional level of analysis is playing an increasingly important role in the current
system as the regional units are proving more effective trading units than sole national
units. Thus this study pays particular attention to the region in a case study focusing
on South East Asia in relation to China. The multilateral level of analysis addressing China's role in relation to the developing
world and the answer to the question of whether China is going to be collaborator or
competitor to the developing world is of particular importance in the current global
context. The developing world is increasingly calling for the inequalities prevalent in
the system to be addressed and China's position in the current context and in relation
to this current issue will play an important role.
Despite the optimism surrounding China and its possible future the internal dynamics
and context cannot be underestimated or neglected. The unfolding domestic
developments that take place at the hands of the current leadership will playa
deciding role in China's future. As China is in a transition and attempting a mix
between a market-based economic system encapsulated in a socialist system it is a
precarious situation that needs the careful attention of the leadership to best manage
China's internal and external developments. The inclusion thus of China's internal
dynamics, therefore cannot be neglected and have been included in this study.
Current trends regarding China emerge and it is possible to make assumptions on the
basis of these trends as to what China's future role entails. This then is looked at as to
the impact these trends are going to have on the various contexts that China finds
itself in and most importantly the impact that it is likely to have on the developing
world. The possibilities of different impacts being played out in different time frames
emerge as the most likely to manifest themselves. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Hierdie studie ondersoek die impak wat China se aansluiting by die WHO, en sy
groeiende ekonomiese mag in die multilaterale handelsisteem, op die ontwikkelende
wêreld het. Die sentrale vraag wat hier aangespreek word, is of China se aansluiting
by die WHO 'n bedreiging inhou vir ontwikkelende ekonomieë en of dié land,
alternatiewelik, sy posisie kan gebruik om laasgenoemde ekonomieë by te staan in hul
stryd teen die ongelykhede van die huidige sisteem.
Drie hooftemas is hier ter sprake. Die eerste handeloor China se status as
ontwikkelende land, en sy algemene posisie vis a vis ander ontwikkelende lande. Die
tweede, fokus op China se ekonomiese en interne ontwikkelings, terwyl die derde
tema meer lig werp op die vraag of China beskou moet word as bondgenoot of
mededinger van die ontwikkelende wêreld.
'n Deskriptiewe en analitiese benadering is VIr die doeleindes van die studie
aangewend. Die kompleksiteit en interaksie tussen verskillende vlakke van analise
kom in die studie na vore. Om China se rol in konteks te plaas, is dit nodig om daarna
te kyk vanuit 'n streeksperspektief en dit in verband te bring met interne
ontwikkelinge binne dié land. Hierdie perspektiewe, tesame, is kardinaal vir 'n beter
begrip van China se toekomstige rol met betrekking to ander ontwikkelende lande.
'n Streeksanalise raak toenemend belangrik in die lig van die feit dat regionale
eenhede algaande meer effektief funksioneer as individuele nasionale state. In hierdie
studie word daar verallig gewerp op Suid-oos Asië, waarvan China deel uitmaak.
Op die multi-laterale vlak van analise is dit ook van belang om vas te stel hoe China
saloptree teenoor ontwikkelende lande na sy toetredede tot die WHO. Die
ontwikkelende wêreld pleit vir die regstel van strukturele ongelykhede, en China kan
moontlik hier 'n deurslaggewende rol speel.
Ten spyte van hoë verwagtinge aangaande China se toekomstige rol, kan die land se
interne konteks en dinamika nie buite rekening gelaat word nie. Ontwikkelinge wat
tans binne China plaasvind sal 'n defnitiewe impak op die land se toekoms hê. China se unieke mengsel van 'n markgerigte ekonomie, wat funksioneer binne 'n breër
sosialistiese opset, sal deeglike beplanning rakende die landse binne en buitelandse
sake van sy leiers verg. Om hierdie rede het die studie ook klem gelê op die interne
politiek dinamiek van China.
Spesifieke tendense rakende China is besig om te ontwikkel, en dit raak algaande
makliker om sekere afleidings aangaande die land se toekomstige rol binne die
internasionale konteks te maak. Hierdie tendense is veral van belang wanneer daar
gekyk word na China se toekomstige verhoudinge met die ontwikkelende wêreld. Dit
wil dus voorkom asof uiteenlopende resultate hulself gedurende verskillende
tydsgrepe sal manifesteer.
|
Page generated in 0.1061 seconds