Made available in DSpace on 2014-06-11T19:22:19Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 0 Previous issue date: 2007-07-30Bitstream added on 2014-06-13T20:08:59Z : No. of bitstreams: 1 bogado_am_me_arafcl.pdf: 959038 bytes, checksum: 81452521bce9f681c5bd203b5c6bd59a (MD5) / Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (CAPES) / A pesquisa consiste em estudar a expressão poética e filosófica existente no romance Lucinde (1799), de Friedrich Schlegel (1772-1829). Crítico e pensador deste período, Schlegel concretiza nesta obra, através da linguagem e da forma, os ideais do Primeiro Romantismo (Frühromantik). Tendo como base o idealismo subjetivo da filosofia de Johann Gottlieb Fichte, ele desenvolve um conceito que chama de poesia progressiva universal. Em Lucinde, Schlegel concebe um romance histórico-crítico no qual o processo de amadurecimento vivido pelo personagem principal (Júlio) - da sua tempestuosa juventude até a sua harmoniosa vida com Lucinda - pode ser visto como uma alegoria do percurso vivido pelo movimento romântico desde o surgimento do Sturm und Drang (fase de ruptura com os preceitos iluministas), passando pelo processo de formação (Bildung), até chegar ao momento presente vivido por Schlegel: a produção de Lucinde e o círculo de Jena, sendo que o texto transita entre o elogio e a crítica desse percurso histórico-literário da Alemanha do século XVIII. A produção dos pensadores do Frühromantik girou em torno principalmente de ensaios filosóficos, da história da literatura e da crítica literária e o romance de Schlegel compreende a infinitude dessas questões. Lucinde está muito distante de ser um romance de entretenimento: trata-se de um projeto romântico. Filosofia, crítica literária e história da literatura em forma de arte. / The reasearch consists in studying the poetic and philosophical expression existing in the novel Lucinde ( 1799 ), by Friedrich Schlegel ( 1772-1829). Critic and thinker from that period, Schlegel renders in this piece , through his language and structure, the ideal of the Early German Romanticism ( Frühromantik ). Based on the subjective idealism from the philosophy of Johann Gottlieb Fichte, Schlegel developes a concept wich he names universal pregressive poetry. In Lucinde, Schlegel conceives a historical-critic novel in wich the process of maturation lived by the protagonist ( Júlio ) - from his tempestuous youth to his harmonious life with Lucinda - can be seen as an allegory of the course traversed by the Romantism since the arising of Sturm und Drang ( a rupture phase with the illuminist principles ), passing from the forming process ( Bildung ), to the present moment lived by Schlegel: the production of Lucinde and the circle of Jena; being the text a transient between the praise and the critique of this historical-literary course of the Germany in the eighteenth century. The production of the Frühromantik's thinker moved around philosophical essays specially, literature history and literary critique; and the Schlegel's novel comprehends the infinities of these issues. Lucinde is quite far away from being an entertainment novel: it's a romantic project. Philosophy, literary critique and literature history turned into art.

Orientador: Wilma Patricia Marzari Dinardo Maas / Banca: Karin Volobuef / Banca: Maria Lídia Lichscheidl Maretti / Resumo: A pesquisa consiste em estudar a expressão poética e filosófica existente no romance Lucinde (1799), de Friedrich Schlegel (1772-1829). Crítico e pensador deste período, Schlegel concretiza nesta obra, através da linguagem e da forma, os ideais do Primeiro Romantismo (Frühromantik). Tendo como base o idealismo subjetivo da filosofia de Johann Gottlieb Fichte, ele desenvolve um conceito que chama de "poesia progressiva universal". Em Lucinde, Schlegel concebe um romance histórico-crítico no qual o processo de amadurecimento vivido pelo personagem principal (Júlio) - da sua tempestuosa juventude até a sua harmoniosa vida com Lucinda - pode ser visto como uma alegoria do percurso vivido pelo movimento romântico desde o surgimento do Sturm und Drang (fase de ruptura com os preceitos iluministas), passando pelo processo de formação (Bildung), até chegar ao momento presente vivido por Schlegel: a produção de Lucinde e o círculo de Jena, sendo que o texto transita entre o elogio e a crítica desse percurso histórico-literário da Alemanha do século XVIII. A produção dos pensadores do Frühromantik girou em torno principalmente de ensaios filosóficos, da história da literatura e da crítica literária e o romance de Schlegel compreende a infinitude dessas questões. Lucinde está muito distante de ser um romance de entretenimento: trata-se de um projeto romântico. Filosofia, crítica literária e história da literatura em forma de arte. / Abstract: The reasearch consists in studying the poetic and philosophical expression existing in the novel Lucinde ( 1799 ), by Friedrich Schlegel ( 1772-1829). Critic and thinker from that period, Schlegel renders in this piece , through his language and structure, the ideal of the Early German Romanticism ( Frühromantik ). Based on the subjective idealism from the philosophy of Johann Gottlieb Fichte, Schlegel developes a concept wich he names "universal pregressive poetry". In Lucinde, Schlegel conceives a historical-critic novel in wich the process of maturation lived by the protagonist ( Júlio ) - from his tempestuous youth to his harmonious life with Lucinda - can be seen as an allegory of the course traversed by the Romantism since the arising of Sturm und Drang ( a rupture phase with the illuminist principles ), passing from the forming process ( Bildung ), to the present moment lived by Schlegel: the production of Lucinde and the circle of Jena; being the text a transient between the praise and the critique of this historical-literary course of the Germany in the eighteenth century. The production of the Frühromantik's thinker moved around philosophical essays specially, literature history and literary critique; and the Schlegel's novel comprehends the infinities of these issues. Lucinde is quite far away from being an entertainment novel: it's a romantic project. Philosophy, literary critique and literature history turned into art. / Mestre

Dorothea Schlegel’s Florentin (1801) is one of the less well known novels of the period commonly referred to as Early German Romanticism. This study attempts to combine both the historical context of the novel and later critical approaches to the ideas of the period. At the same time, this study seeks to avoid the more transcendent approaches that have previously been used in order to attempt to understand Florentin. In order to do so this study makes the expressionless or the gap created by allegorical expression between sign and signified a central theme in order to create a field of tensions and uncertainties. Although many readers of Florentin have noted the sensation of an absence of clarity while reading the novel, the majority of them have put this down to a lack of ability on the part of the author. This study attempts to find a structural explanation for the expressionless in Dorothea Schlegel’s novel while attempting to preserve aspects of its unknowability.

This essay explores the topic of appropriation of nature and the resulting social alienation it imparts on several of the novel’s characters: Frankenstein, Walton, and the Creature. The Creature serves as a personification of both industrialism and urban atomization. His depiction as such follows Marxist critic Warren Montag’s argument that the novel renders the Creature more horrible through the suppression of modernity which makes him the embodiment of industrialism, and Frank Moretti’s claim that the novel favors pastoral, pre-industrial ideals (Montag, Moretti). Frankenstein’s materialist approach to science provides the driving force for this alienation and is informed by both mechanist philosophy (Hogsette) and a desire to remodel nature in accordance with human desire (Mellor). Rather than bringing prosperity, those endeavors alienate Frankenstein from his surrounding in a Marxian line of thought, and Frankenstein himself comes to resemble Bill Hughes’s concept of the negative version of Prometheus who loses himself in his materialist pursuits (Hughes). Drawing upon early German Romantic ideas of reconciliation with nature outlined by Alison Stone, this essay argues that much of the chaos in Frankenstein stems from anthropocentrism that is rooted in Hegelian philosophy and that a healthier solution to this view is proposed by early German Romantic organicism.

A presente dissertação tem como objetivo principal a tradução e o estudo da Charakteristik, caracterização, escrita por Friedrich Schlegel sobre Giovanni Boccaccio, chamada Nachricht von den poetischen Werken des Johannes Boccaccio, Relato sobre as obras poéticas de Giovanni Boccaccio, de 1801, bem como o estabelecimento de sua importância para a teoria da forma narrativa breve denominada Novelle. O estudo preliminar que antecede o trabalho é dividido em duas partes, nas quais buscamos entender a importância da teoria crítica de Friedrich Schlegel, iluminar as peculiaridades da caracterização traduzida, e descrever os principais procedimentos do crítico e filósofo alemão. No estudo também procuramos analisar as teorias sobre a novela do período conhecido como primeiro romantismo alemão, tentando definir a contribuição de Friedrich Schlegel para estas teorias, e esclarecer certos aspectos de sua recepção por parte da crítica literária ocidental. A principal hipótese que formulamos é a de que a caracterização de Schlegel é um exemplo de hermenêutica literária capaz de mesclar a análise filosófica, filológica e poética em uma abordagem histórica. Desta forma, os elementos extrínsecos e intrínsecos da obra literária seriam vistos como um todo orgânico. Esta obra de arte crítica, como Schlegel costumava definir sua Charakteristik, representaria tanto o sensus spiritualis, como o sensus literalis, contemplando, em sua letra e em seu espírito, a tendência [Tendenz] da obra, que seria o resultado da análise crítica progressiva, divinatória e universal do fenômeno literário. / The main purpose of this dissertation is the translation and study of the Charakteristik characterization, written by Friedrich Schlegel about Giovanni Boccaccio, called Nachricht von den poetischen Werken des Johannes Boccaccio, Note on the poetic works of Giovanni Boccaccio, from 1801, as well as to establish its importance for the theory of the short prose narrative called Novelle. The preliminary study prior to the translation has been separated in two parts, in which we aim at understanding the importance of Friedrich Schlegels critical theory, highlight the peculiarities of the translated characterization, and describe the main procedures of the German critic. At the study we also seek to analyze the theories about the novelle from the period known as the early German romanticism, trying to define the contribution of Friedrich Schlegel for these theories, and clarify certain aspects of his reception by the Western literary criticism. The main hypothesis we formulate is that Schlegels characterization is an example of literary hermeneutics, capable of mixing a philosophical, philological and poetic analyze within a historical approach. This way, the intrinsic and extrinsic factors of the literary artwork would be seen as an organic whole. This critical artwork, as Schlegel used to define his Charakteristik, would stand for the sensus spiritualis as well as for the sensus literalis, contemplating, in its letter and spirit, the tendency [Tendenz] of the work, which would be the result of a progressive, divinatory and universal critical analyze of literary phenomenon.

O presente trabalho visa investigar os conceitos de crítica e experiência na obra de Walter Benjamin em torno dos anos de 1920, como resultado dos desdobramentos do Programa de 1918, de modo a pôr em relevo seu entrelaçamento com os conceitos de mito e Iluminismo. Para tanto, este trabalho concentra-se no estudo da dissertação de doutoramento do filósofo acerca do romantismo de Iena, bem como seu ensaio crítico sobre As afinidades eletivas de Goethe. Quanto ao primeiro, mostra-se que o conceito de crítica imanente une-se às perspectivas da filosofia e poesia românticas, o que se deve, em especial, ao messianismo presente veladamente no conceito de reflexão. No segundo, tem-se em vista o problema da crítica e da experiência em nova chave, cujos desdobramentos assinalam as relações entre mito e Iluminismo, o que também inclui uma crítica ao eterno retorno, a concepção mítica do tempo. / The present paper aims to investigate the concepts of critique and experience in the work of Walter Benjamin written in the years around 1920, which was derived from On the program of the coming philosophy written in 1918 and thus to highlight their intertwined relationship with the concepts of myth and Enlightenment. To do so, this paper focuses on Benjamin\'s doctorate thesis, The concept of art criticism in German romanticism, as well as on his critical essay on Goethes Elective Affinities. Regarding the first one, we show that the concept of immanent critique joins the perspectives of romantic philosophy and poetics, which is particularly due to the hidden presence of messianism in the concept of reflection. In the second one, we focus on the problem of critique and experience in a new formulation, whose developments show the relations between myth and Enlightenment, which also includes a critique of the eternal return, the mythical concept of time.

O presente trabalho visa investigar os conceitos de crítica e experiência na obra de Walter Benjamin em torno dos anos de 1920, como resultado dos desdobramentos do Programa de 1918, de modo a pôr em relevo seu entrelaçamento com os conceitos de mito e Iluminismo. Para tanto, este trabalho concentra-se no estudo da dissertação de doutoramento do filósofo acerca do romantismo de Iena, bem como seu ensaio crítico sobre As afinidades eletivas de Goethe. Quanto ao primeiro, mostra-se que o conceito de crítica imanente une-se às perspectivas da filosofia e poesia românticas, o que se deve, em especial, ao messianismo presente veladamente no conceito de reflexão. No segundo, tem-se em vista o problema da crítica e da experiência em nova chave, cujos desdobramentos assinalam as relações entre mito e Iluminismo, o que também inclui uma crítica ao eterno retorno, a concepção mítica do tempo. / The present paper aims to investigate the concepts of critique and experience in the work of Walter Benjamin written in the years around 1920, which was derived from On the program of the coming philosophy written in 1918 and thus to highlight their intertwined relationship with the concepts of myth and Enlightenment. To do so, this paper focuses on Benjamin\'s doctorate thesis, The concept of art criticism in German romanticism, as well as on his critical essay on Goethes Elective Affinities. Regarding the first one, we show that the concept of immanent critique joins the perspectives of romantic philosophy and poetics, which is particularly due to the hidden presence of messianism in the concept of reflection. In the second one, we focus on the problem of critique and experience in a new formulation, whose developments show the relations between myth and Enlightenment, which also includes a critique of the eternal return, the mythical concept of time.

A presente dissertação tem como objetivo principal a tradução e o estudo da Charakteristik, caracterização, escrita por Friedrich Schlegel sobre Giovanni Boccaccio, chamada Nachricht von den poetischen Werken des Johannes Boccaccio, Relato sobre as obras poéticas de Giovanni Boccaccio, de 1801, bem como o estabelecimento de sua importância para a teoria da forma narrativa breve denominada Novelle. O estudo preliminar que antecede o trabalho é dividido em duas partes, nas quais buscamos entender a importância da teoria crítica de Friedrich Schlegel, iluminar as peculiaridades da caracterização traduzida, e descrever os principais procedimentos do crítico e filósofo alemão. No estudo também procuramos analisar as teorias sobre a novela do período conhecido como primeiro romantismo alemão, tentando definir a contribuição de Friedrich Schlegel para estas teorias, e esclarecer certos aspectos de sua recepção por parte da crítica literária ocidental. A principal hipótese que formulamos é a de que a caracterização de Schlegel é um exemplo de hermenêutica literária capaz de mesclar a análise filosófica, filológica e poética em uma abordagem histórica. Desta forma, os elementos extrínsecos e intrínsecos da obra literária seriam vistos como um todo orgânico. Esta obra de arte crítica, como Schlegel costumava definir sua Charakteristik, representaria tanto o sensus spiritualis, como o sensus literalis, contemplando, em sua letra e em seu espírito, a tendência [Tendenz] da obra, que seria o resultado da análise crítica progressiva, divinatória e universal do fenômeno literário. / The main purpose of this dissertation is the translation and study of the Charakteristik characterization, written by Friedrich Schlegel about Giovanni Boccaccio, called Nachricht von den poetischen Werken des Johannes Boccaccio, Note on the poetic works of Giovanni Boccaccio, from 1801, as well as to establish its importance for the theory of the short prose narrative called Novelle. The preliminary study prior to the translation has been separated in two parts, in which we aim at understanding the importance of Friedrich Schlegels critical theory, highlight the peculiarities of the translated characterization, and describe the main procedures of the German critic. At the study we also seek to analyze the theories about the novelle from the period known as the early German romanticism, trying to define the contribution of Friedrich Schlegel for these theories, and clarify certain aspects of his reception by the Western literary criticism. The main hypothesis we formulate is that Schlegels characterization is an example of literary hermeneutics, capable of mixing a philosophical, philological and poetic analyze within a historical approach. This way, the intrinsic and extrinsic factors of the literary artwork would be seen as an organic whole. This critical artwork, as Schlegel used to define his Charakteristik, would stand for the sensus spiritualis as well as for the sensus literalis, contemplating, in its letter and spirit, the tendency [Tendenz] of the work, which would be the result of a progressive, divinatory and universal critical analyze of literary phenomenon.

Die Dissertation untersucht die Entwicklung des Gesamtkunstwerk-Konzeptes und seine Aktualität, Möglichkeit und Notwendigkeit in Bezug auf ein modernes filmisches Gesamtkunstwerk. Ausgegangen wird von der ästhetischen Theorie und Praxis der deutschen Frühromantik, in der das Konzept wurzelt. In einer umfassenden Betrachtung und Analyse der ästhetischen und gesellschaftspolitischen Dimension des Konzeptes in den Schriften und dem Werk Richard Wagners sollen wesentliche Strukturmerkmale erkundet und soll ein Maßstab für ein ‚positives‘ zeit-genössisches Gesamtkunstwerk gebildet werden, das sich von seinem ideologischen Missbrauch befreit. Erforscht wird, inwiefern der Farb- und Tonspielfilm ein geeignetes Kunstmedium für die Anwendung des Konzeptes darstellt und wie sich die Frage seiner gesellschaftspolitischen Dimension in der globalen Epoche übersetzen lässt. / The dissertation explores the evolution of the concept of the Total Work of Art (ʹGesamtkunstwerkʹ) as well as its actuality, feasibility and necessity in the form of a modern cinematic Gesamtkunstwerk. Starting point is the aesthetic theory and praxis of the Early German Romanticism, in which the concept is rooted. An extensive consideration and analysis of the concept in both its aesthetic and socio-political dimension as developed in the writings and works of Richard Wagner aims to define its essential structural features and to set the standard for a ʹpositiveʹ contemporary Gesamtkunstwerk beyond its ideological abuse. Key is the examination of how and to what extend the sound and colour feature film constitutes a legit artistic medium for the application of the concept as well as how its sociopolitical facet translates within the global era.

Dans cette thèse d'histoire de l'art, nous posons un lien inédit entre la philosophie de Johann Gottlieb Fichte (1762-1814) et quelques pratiques artistiques et/ou littéraires issues du premier romantisme allemand : notamment celles de Friedrich Schlegel (1772-1829), de August Wilhelm Schlegel (1767-1845), de Friedrich von Hardenberg (« Novalis », 1772-1801) et de Caspar David Friedrich (1774-1840). Bien que ce lien ait été posé dans l'historiographie traditionnelle, il l'a été en tenant compte soit des contenus particuliers enseignés dans la Wissenschaftslehre de Fichte (théorie du sujet, théorie de la liberté), soit des opinions politiques de cet auteur (républicanisme, égalitarisme, universalisme du droit). Or, le projet romantique tel qu'envisagé par ces praticiens a pour matrice la dynamique pragmatique du message fichtéen, c'est-à-dire la structure aussi bien communicationnelle que pédagogique de ce dernier. Dans cette optique, en prenant pour cadre de référence la recherche actuelle en études fichtéennes, nous démontrons que Fichte est l'auteur d'un dispositif réflexif original dans lequel l'usager d'un système représentationnel donné (en l'occurrence : les présentations scientifiques de la Doctrine de la science) se trouve indexé par le dispositif qu'il anime. Si bien que les fonctions de réception et de production du système --- qui sont du ressort de sa performativité --- s'avèrent parfaitement identiques. Afin de proposer un métalangage adapté aux outils épistémologiques de notre champ disciplinaire (l'histoire de l'art), notre lecture de Fichte Fichte se déploie à partir d'un double cadre méthodologique : la sémiologie des représentations (Louis Marin) et la narratologie (Gérard Genette, Mieke Bal). En fonction de cette méthodologie, nous démontrons que le propre du projet romantique, tel qu'envisagé par ses protagonistes de la première heure (les frères Schlegel, Fr. von Hardenberg) et par son peintre le plus abouti (C.D. Friedrich), est d'avoir déployé le dispositif pragmatique fichtéen dans des pratiques littéraires et plastiques, en vue d'engendrer un nouveau rapport entre l'image et la Bildung (esthétique, politique) du spectateur. Dès lors, la finalité de ce travail est de contribuer aux savoirs sur l'efficacité de l'art dans l'économie spectatorielle de la modernité et d'analyser l'apport de Fichte et des romantiques à la problématique actuelle de l' « agentivité » (agency) des images. / The purpose of this art history dissertation is to shed new light on the relation between the philosophy of Johann Gottlieb Fichte (1762-1814) and the artistic practice of some of early German romanticism's leading figures, namely, Friedrich Schlegel (1772-1829), August Wilhelm Schlegel (1767-1845), Friedrich von Hardenberg (“Novalis,” 1772-1801), and Caspar David Friedrich (1774-1840). Although this link has previously been established in the historiography on German romanticism, I contend that Fichte's importance to the romantic movement does not hinge on the content of his philosophical writings (i.e., the Wissenschaftslehre as a theory of subjectivity or as a theory of freedom), nor on Fichte's political beliefs (republicanism, egalitarianism, the universality of Right). Rather, the driving force behind the romantic project resides in the pragmatic dynamics of the Wissenschaftslehre itself, that is, on its communicational and pedagogical framework. In reference to the work of leading Fichte scholars publishing in the field of the history of philosophy, I argue that Fichte's Wissenschaftslehre consists in an original, self-referential representational system whose putative user is indexed within the very system he or she drives. In the final analysis, the reception of such a system coincides with its production, and both are a function of its performative character. In keeping with the epistemological framework of art history, I propose a reading of Fichte that makes use of two methodological approaches, namely, the semiology of representational systems (Louis Marin) and narratology (Gérard Genette, Mieke Bal). Based on this approach, I contend that the Schlegel brothers', Hardenberg's, and C. D. Friedrich's respective artistic practices make use of the Wissenschaftslehre's pragmatic dynamics in order to rethink the way in which pictorial or textual representations shape their beholders (both aesthetically and politically). Ultimately, this dissertation aims to contribute to current debates on the power of images in the modern context, and to understand Fichte’s and the romantics' heretofore unacknowledged contribution to the theory of the agency of images. / Thèse effectuée en cotutelle avec l'École des hautes études en sciences sociales, Paris. Pour
 respecter
 les
 droits
 d’auteur,
 la
 version
 électronique
 de
 cette
 thèse
 
a 
été 
dépouillée
 de 
ses 
documents 
visuels. 
La
 version 
intégrale
 de
 la 
thèse 
a 
été 
déposée
 au 
Service 
de 
la 
gestion 
des 
documents 
et 
des 
archives
 de
 l'Université
 de 
Montréal.