This thesis consists of three related essays that examine investors' order submission strategies during the pre-opening period on the Malta Stock Exchange. The pre-opening is a period of liquidity formation and price discovery characterised by the absence of trade execution. The three essays collectively examine the information content of the order book in relation to: the intensity of order submissions, the aggressiveness of investors' order placement strategy and the determination of returns generated over the pre-opening period.The first essay empirically investigates if public information concerning the current state of the order book impacts the duration between order arrivals. Utilizing an augmented ACD model, the research reveals that the information which can be inferred from the characteristics of incoming orders has a more significant impact on the intensity of buy order submissions as compared to sell order submissions during the pre-opening period. Furthermore, prospective buyers appear to be more responsive to liquidity provided by the sell side than the reverse. Locked or crossed order submissions tend to increases (decreases) the intensity of order flow on the own (opposite) side of the order book, corroborating Cao et al. (2000) that such order-types contain informative signals about the fundamental value of the asset.The second essay analyses the impact of limit order book information on the aggressiveness observed in the submission, revision and cancellation of limit orders during the market pre-opening period. The empirical results indicate that the aggressiveness of order submissions and forward price revisions react both to the existing and subsequent changes in the execution probability at market opening, driven in part by the depth on either side of the order book. The aggressiveness of order cancellations increases on both sides of the order book when the depth at the top of the ask order book increases. In addition, the results suggest that the order book height and size of the inside spread impacts the aggressiveness of order submissions, revisions and cancellations.The third essay studies the contribution of the pre-opening period to the daily price discovery process and the factors that impact the return generated over this period. The results indicate that approximately one third of daily price discovery occurs in the pre-opening period. In addition, the impact of relative depth and height of the overnight and opening order book are concentrated at the top of the order book. Furthermore, cumulative changes to relative depth attributable to order submissions most significantly impact the opening returns of less actively traded stocks. The results show a strong relationship between opening returns and cumulative changes in the relative height along the order book attributable to order submissions, cancellations and forward and backward price revisions over the pre-opening period.

Cette thèse est composée de deux parties reliées, le premier sur le carnet d'ordre et le deuxième sur les effets de valeur de tick. Dans la première partie, nous présentons notre cadre de modélisation de carnet. Le modèle queue-réactive est d'abord introduit, dans laquelle nous révisons l'approche zéro intelligence traditionnelle en ajoutant dépendance envers l'État de carnet. Une étude empirique montre que ce modèle est très réaliste et reproduit de nombreuses fonctionnalités intéressantes microscopiques de l'actif sous-jacent comme la distribution du carnet de commandes. Nous démontrons également qu'il peut être utilisé comme un simulateur de marché efficace, ce qui permet l'évaluation de la tactique de placement complexes. Nous étendons ensuite le modèle de queue-réactive à un cadre markovien général. Conditions de Ergodicité sont discutés en détail dans ce paramètre. Dans la deuxième partie de cette thèse, nous sommes intéressés à étudier le rôle joué par la valeur de la tique à deux échelles microscopiques et macroscopiques. Tout d'abord, une étude empirique sur les conséquences d'un changement de la valeur de tick est effectuée à l'aide des données du programme pilote de réduction de la taille 2014 tick japonais. Une formule de prédiction pour les effets d'un changement de valeur de tique sur les coûts de transactions est dérivé. Ensuite, un modèle multi-agent est introduit afin d'expliquer les relations entre le volume du marché, la dynamique des prix, spread bid-ask, la valeur de la tique et de l'état du carnet d'ordres d'équilibre. / This thesis is made of two connected parts, the first one about limit order book modeling and the second one about tick value effects. In the first part, we present our framework for Markovian order book modeling. The queue-reactive model is first introduced, in which we revise the traditional zero-intelligence approach by adding state dependency in the order arrival processes. An empirical study shows that this model is very realistic and reproduces many interesting microscopic features of the underlying asset such as the distribution of the order book. We also demonstrate that it can be used as an efficient market simulator, allowing for the assessment of complex placement tactics. We then extend the queue-reactive model to a general Markovian framework for order book modeling. Ergodicity conditions are discussed in details in this setting. Under some rather weak assumptions, we prove the convergence of the order book state towards an invariant distribution and that of the rescaled price process to a standard Brownian motion. In the second part of this thesis, we are interested in studying the role played by the tick value at both microscopic and macroscopic scales. First, an empirical study of the consequences of a tick value change is conducted using data from the 2014 Japanese tick size reduction pilot program. A prediction formula for the effects of a tick value change on the trading costs is derived and successfully tested. Then, an agent-based model is introduced in order to explain the relationships between market volume, price dynamics, bid-ask spread, tick value and the equilibrium order book state.

Le contenu de cette thèse est divisé de la façon suivante. Après un premier chapitre d’introduction, le Chapitre 2 est consacré à introduire aussi simplement que possible certaines des théories qui seront utilisées dans les deux premiers articles. Dans un premier temps, nous discuterons des points importants pour la construction de l’intégrale stochastique par rapport aux semimartingales avec paramètre spatial. Ensuite, nous décrirons les principaux résultats de la théorie de l’évaluation en monde neutre au risque et, finalement, nous donnerons une brève description d’une méthode d’optimisation connue sous le nom de dualité. Les Chapitres 3 et 4 traitent de la modélisation de l’illiquidité et font l’objet de deux articles. Le premier propose un modèle en temps continu pour la structure et le comportement du carnet d’ordres limites. Le comportement du portefeuille d’un investisseur utilisant des ordres de marché est déduit et des conditions permettant d’éliminer les possibilités d’arbitrages sont données. Grâce à la formule d’Itô généralisée il est aussi possible d’écrire la valeur du portefeuille comme une équation différentielle stochastique. Un exemple complet de modèle de marché est présenté de même qu’une méthode de calibrage. Dans le deuxième article, écrit en collaboration avec Bruno Rémillard, nous proposons un modèle similaire mais cette fois-ci en temps discret. La question de tarification des produits dérivés est étudiée et des solutions pour le prix des options européennes de vente et d’achat sont données sous forme explicite. Des conditions spécifiques à ce modèle qui permettent d’éliminer l’arbitrage sont aussi données. Grâce à la méthode duale, nous montrons qu’il est aussi possible d’écrire le prix des options européennes comme un problème d’optimisation d’une espérance sur en ensemble de mesures de probabilité. Le Chapitre 5 contient le troisième article de la thèse et porte sur un sujet différent. Dans cet article, aussi écrit en collaboration avec Bruno Rémillard, nous proposons une méthode de prévision des séries temporelles basée sur les copules multivariées. Afin de mieux comprendre le gain en performance que donne cette méthode, nous étudions à l’aide d’expériences numériques l’effet de la force et la structure de dépendance sur les prévisions. Puisque les copules permettent d’isoler la structure de dépendance et les distributions marginales, nous étudions l’impact de différentes distributions marginales sur la performance des prévisions. Finalement, nous étudions aussi l’effet des erreurs d’estimation sur la performance des prévisions. Dans tous les cas, nous comparons la performance des prévisions en utilisant des prévisions provenant d’une série bivariée et d’une série univariée, ce qui permet d’illustrer l’avantage de cette méthode. Dans un intérêt plus pratique, nous présentons une application complète sur des données financières. / This thesis is structured as follows. After a first chapter of introduction, Chapter 2 exposes as simply as possible different notions that are going to be used in the two first papers. First, we discuss the main steps required to build stochastic integrals for semimartingales with space parameters. Secondly, we describe the main results of risk neutral evaluation theory and, finally, we give a short description of an optimization method known as duality. Chapters 3 and 4 consider the problem of modelling illiquidity, which is covered by two papers. The first one proposes a continuous time model for the structure and the dynamic of the limit order book. The dynamic of a portfolio for an investor using market orders is deduced and conditions to rule out arbitrage are given. With the help of Itô’s generalized formula, it is also possible to write the value of the portfolio as a stochastic differential equation. A complete example of market model along with a calibration method is also given. In the second paper, written in collaboration with Bruno Rémillard, we propose a similar model with discrete time trading. We study the problem of derivatives pricing and give explicit formulas for European option prices. Specific conditions to rule out arbitrage are also provided. Using the dual optimization method, we show that the price of European options can be written as the optimization of an expectation over a set of probability measures. Chapter 5 contained the third paper and studies a different topic. In this paper, also written with Bruno Rémillard, we propose a forecasting method for time series based on multivariate copulas. To provide a better understanding of the proposed method, with the help of numerical experiments, we study the effect of the strength and the structure of the different dependencies on predictions performance. Since copulas allow to isolate the dependence structure and marginal distributions, we study the impact of different marginal distributions on predictions performance. Finally, we also study the effect of estimation errors on the predictions. In all the cases, we compare the performance of predictions by using predictions based on a bivariate series and predictions based on a univariate series, which allows to illustrate the advantage of the proposed method. For practical matters, we provide a complete example of application on financial data.

An den Handelsbörsen der Welt, hat der Anteil unsichtbarer Luidität in den letzten Jahren dramatisch zugenommen. Obwohl dieser Trend zunehmend in den Fokus regulatorischer Debatten und akademischer Dikussionen rückt, sind sich Forscher und die Aufsichtsbehörden über die Implikationen und entsprechende regulatorische Maßnahmen uneins. In der vorliegenden Arbeit, werden die damit verbundenen Fragestellungen in drei separaten Kapiteln theoretisch und empirisch untersucht. Mit Hilfe eines speziellen NASDAQ Datensatzes, werden in Kapitel 1 die Marktfaktoren, die unsichtbaren Liquidität begünstigen sowie den Einfluß, den unsichtbare Liquidät auf Märkte ausübt, empirisch ausgewertet. Wir zeigen, daß die Querschnittsvariation unsichtbarer Liquidität entlang des Aktienuniversums in einem hohen Maße durch sichtbare Markteigenschaften erklärt wird. Wir zeigen, daß unsichtbare Order gegenüber sichtbaren Ordern signifikant stärkere Preisfluktuationen hervorrufen. Unsere Resultate geben Grund zu der Annahme, daß Märkte mit hoher unsichtbarer Liquidät volatiler sind und höheren Marktreibungen ausgesetzt sind. In Kapitel 2 entwickeln wir ein strukturelles Handelsmodell und untersuchen die optimale Handelsstrategie mit unsichtbaren Ordern. In diesem Rahmen leiten wir für verschiedene Marktspezifikationen explizite Charakterisierungen der sogenannten optimalen Exposure-Größe her. Unter anderem zeigen wir, daß der Einsatz unsichtbarer Order Transaktionskosten signifikant reduzieren kann. In Kapitel 3 entwickeln wir ein dynamisches, Gleichgewichtsmodell in einem Limitorderbuchmarkt. Innerhalb dieses theoretischen Rahmens können die empirischen Beobachtungen des ersten un zweiten Kapitels rationalisiert werden. Insbesondere zeigen wir daß große versteckte Order Marktineffizienzen hervorrufen und Preisfluktuationen verstärken, indem sie die Koordination zwischen Angebots- und Nachfrageseite schwächen können. / In recent years, the proliferation of hidden liquidity in financial markets has increased dramatically and shifted to the center regulatory debates and market micro-structure panels. Yet investors, scientists and policy makers are at odds about its implications and the adequate regulatory responses. This thesis addresses these issues in three separate chapters on both empirical and theoretical grounds. Chapter 1 provides an empirical investigation of the determinants and impact of hidden order submissions. We report that the cross-sectional variation of hidden liquidity is well explained by observable market characteristics. Second, our results suggest that the hidden orders generate substantial price reactions. Our results suggests that hidden liquidity increases market volatility and trading frictions. Chapter 2 proposes a structural trading model. We investigate trader’s optimal trading strategies with respect to order-exposure in limit order book markets. The optimal exposure size marks a trade-off between costs and benefits of exposure. Our model provides explicit characterizations of the optimal exposure size for various market specifications. Model parameters and exposure strategies are estimated through high-frequency order book data. Our results suggest that hidden orders can substantially enhance trade performance. Chapter 3 develops a dynamic equilibrium model with a public primary market and an off-exchange trading mechanism. Our theory correctly predicts the key findings of chapter one and two. For instance, we show that large hidden orders cause excess returns and increase market volatility and correctly predict the role of the observable market characteristics in the origination of hidden liquidity.

Im ersten Teil der Dissertation wird ein diskretes stochastisches zustandsabhängiges Modell eines zweiseitigen Limit Orderbuchs als bestehend aus den Zustandsgrößen bester Bidpreis (Geldkurs), bester Askpreis (Briefkurs) und vorhandener Kauf- bzw. Verkaufsdichte definiert. Für eine einfache Skalierung mit zwei Zeitskalen wird ein Grenzwertsatz bewiesen. Die Veränderungen der besten Bid- und Askpreise werden im Sinne des Gesetzes der großen Zahlen skaliert und dies entspricht der langsameren Zeitskala. Das Platzieren bzw. Stornieren der Limitorder findet auf der schnelleren Zeitskala statt. Der Grenzwertsatz besagt, dass die fundamentalen Zustandsgrößen, gegeben Regularitätsbedingungen der einkommenden Order, fast sicher zu einem stetigen Limesmodell konvergieren. Im Limesmodell sind der beste Bidpreis und der beste Askpreis die eindeutigen Lösungen von zwei gekoppelten gewöhnlichen DGLen. Die Kauf- und Verkaufsdichten sind jeweils als eindeutige Lösungen von linearen hyperbolischen PDGLen, die anhand der Erwartungswerte der einkommenden Orderparameter festgelegt sind, gegeben. Die Lösungen sind in geschlossener Form erhältlich. Im zweiten Teil wird ein funktionaler zentraler Grenzwertsatz d.h. ein Invarianzprinzip für ein vereinfachtes Modell eines Limitorderbuches bewiesen. Unter einer natürlichen Skalierung konvergiert der zweidimensionale Preisprozess (Bid- und Askpreis) in Verteilung zu einer Semimartingal reflektierten Brownschen Bewegung in der zugelassenen Preismenge. Gleichzeitig konvergieren die Kauf- und Verkaufsdichten im schwachen Sinn zum Betrag einer zweiparametrischen Brownschen Bewegung. Es wird weiterhin anhand eines Beispiels gezeigt, wie man für das Modell im ersten Teil eine stochastiche PDGL, unter einer starken Stationaritätsannahme für die Orderplatzierungen und -stornierungen, herleiten kann. Im dritten Teil wird ein Mittelungs- bzw. ein Invarianzprinzip für diskrete Banach- bzw. Hilbertraumwertige stochastische Prozesse bewiesen. / In the first part of the thesis, we define a random state-dependent discrete model of a two-sided limit order book in terms of its key quantities best bid [ask] price and the standing buy [sell] volume density. For a simple scaling that introduces a slow time scaling, that is equivalent to the classical law of large numbers, for the bid/ask prices and a faster time scale for the limit volume placements/cancelations, that keeps the expected volume rate over the considered price interval invariant, we prove a limit theorem. The limit theorem states that, given regularity conditions on the random order flow, the key quantities converge in the sense of a strong law of large numbers to a tractable continuous limiting model. The limiting model is such that the best bid and ask price dynamics can be described in terms of two coupled ODE:s, while the dynamics of the relative buy and sell volume density functions are given as the unique solutions of two linear first-order hyperbolic PDE:s with variable coefficients, specified by the expectation of the order flow parameters. In the second part, we prove a functional central limit theorem i.e. an invariance principle for an order book model with block shaped volume densities close to the spread. The weak limit of the two-dimensional price process (best bid and ask price) is given by a semi-martingale reflecting Brownian motion in the set of admissible prices. Simultaneously, the relative buy and sell volume densities close to the spread converge weakly to the modulus of a two-parameter Brownian motion. We also demonstrate an example how to easily derive an SPDE for the relative volume densities in a simple case, when a strong stationarity assumption is made on the limit order placements and cancelations for the model suggested in the first part. In the third and final part of the thesis, we prove an averaging and an invariance principle for discrete processes taking values in Banach and Hilbert spaces, respectively.

Motivated by a zero-intelligence approach, the aim of this thesis is to unify the microscopic (discrete price and volume), mesoscopic (discrete price and continuous volume) and macroscopic (continuous price and volume) frameworks of limit order books, with a view to providing a novel yet analytically tractable description of their behaviour in a high to ultra high-frequency setting. Starting with the canonical microscopic framework, the first part of the thesis examines the limiting behaviour of the order book process when order arrival and cancellation rates are sent to infinity and when volumes are considered to be of infinitesimal size. Mathematically speaking, this amounts to establishing the weak convergence of a discrete-space process to a mesoscopic diffusion limit. This step is initially carried out in a reduced-form context, in other words, by simply looking at the best bid and ask queues, before the procedure is extended to the whole book. This subsequently leads us to the second part of the thesis, which is devoted to the transition between mesoscopic and macroscopic models of limit order books, where the general idea is to send the tick size to zero, or equivalently, to consider infinitely many price levels. The macroscopic limit is then described in terms of reflected SPDEs which typically arise in stochastic interface models. Numerical applications are finally presented, notably via the simulation of the mesocopic and macroscopic limits, which can be used as market simulators for short-term price prediction or optimal execution strategies.

No description available.

Cette thèse aborde différents aspects de la modélisation de la microstructure du marché et des problèmes de Market Making, avec un accent particulier du point de vue du praticien. Le carnet d’ordres, au cœur du marché financier, est un système de files d’attente complexe à haute dimension. Nous souhaitons améliorer la connaissance du LOB pour la communauté de la recherche, proposer de nouvelles idées de modélisation et développer des applications pour les Market Makers. Nous remercions en particuler l’équipe Automated Market Making d’avoir fourni la base de données haute-fréquence de très bonne qualité et une grille de calculs puissante, sans laquelle ces recherches n’auraient pas été possible. Le Chapitre 1 présente la motivation de cette recherche et reprend les principaux résultats des différents travaux. Le Chapitre 2 se concentre entièrement sur le LOB et vise à proposer un nouveau modèle qui reproduit mieux certains faits stylisés. A travers cette recherche, non seulement nous confirmons l’influence des flux d’ordres historiques sur l’arrivée de nouveaux, mais un nouveau modèle est également fourni qui réplique beaucoup mieux la dynamique du LOB, notamment la volatilité réalisée en haute et basse fréquence. Dans le Chapitre 3, l’objectif est d’étudier les stratégies de Market Making dans un contexte plus réaliste. Cette recherche contribueà deux aspects : d’une part le nouveau modèle proposé est plus réaliste mais reste simple à appliquer pour la conception de stratégies, d’autre part la stratégie pratique de Market Making est beaucoup améliorée par rapport à une stratégie naive et est prometteuse pour l’application pratique. La prédiction à haute fréquence avec la méthode d’apprentissage profond est étudiée dans le Chapitre 4. De nombreux résultats de la prédiction en 1- étape et en plusieurs étapes ont retrouvé la non-linéarité, stationarité et universalité de la relation entre les indicateurs microstructure et le changement du prix, ainsi que la limitation de cette approche en pratique. / This thesis addresses different aspects around the market microstructure modelling and market making problems, with a special accent from the practitioner’s viewpoint. The limit order book (LOB), at the heart of financial market, is a complex continuous high-dimensional queueing system. We wish to improve the knowledge of LOB for the research community, propose new modelling ideas and develop concrete applications to the interest of Market Makers. We would like to specifically thank the Automated Market Making team for providing a large high frequency database of very high quality as well as a powerful computational grid, without whom these researches would not have been possible. The first chapter introduces the incentive of this research and resumes the main results of the different works. Chapter 2 fully focuses on the LOB and aims to propose a new model that better reproduces some stylized facts. Through this research, not only do we confirm the influence of historical order flows to the arrival of new ones, but a new model is also provided that captures much better the LOB dynamic, notably the realized volatility in high and low frequency. In chapter 3, the objective is to study Market Making strategies in a more realistic context. This research contributes in two aspects : from one hand the newly proposed model is more realistic but still simple enough to be applied for strategy design, on the other hand the practical Market Making strategy is of large improvement compared to the naive one and is promising for practical use. High-frequency prediction with deep learning method is studied in chapter 4. Many results of the 1-step and multi-step prediction have found the non-linearity, stationarity and universality of the relationship between microstructural indicators and price change, as well as the limitation of this approach in practice.

Market microstructure studies the process of exchanging assets underexplicit trading rules. With algorithmic trading and high-frequencytrading, modern financial markets have seen profound changes in marketmicrostructure in the last 5 to 10 years. As a result, previously establishedmethods in the field of market microstructure becomes oftenfaulty or insufficient. Machine learning and, in particular, reinforcementlearning has become more ubiquitous in both finance and otherfields today with applications in trading and optimal execution. This thesisuses reinforcement learning to understand market microstructureby simulating a stock market based on NASDAQ Nordics and trainingmarket maker agents on this stock market. Simulations are run on both a dealer market and a limit orderbook marketdifferentiating it from previous studies. Using DQN and PPO algorithmson these simulated environments, where stochastic optimal controltheory has been mainly used before. The market maker agents successfullyreproduce stylized facts in historical trade data from each simulation,such as mean reverting prices and absence of linear autocorrelationsin price changes as well as beating random policies employed on thesemarkets with a positive profit & loss of maximum 200%. Other tradingdynamics in real-world markets have also been exhibited via theagents interactions, mainly: bid-ask spread clustering, optimal inventorymanagement, declining spreads and independence of inventory and spreads, indicating that using reinforcement learning with PPO and DQN arerelevant choices when modelling market microstructure. / Marknadens mikrostruktur studerar hur utbytet av finansiella tillgångar sker enligt explicita regler. Algoritmisk och högfrekvenshandel har förändrat moderna finansmarknaders strukturer under de senaste 5 till 10 åren. Detta har även påverkat pålitligheten hos tidigare använda metoder från exempelvis ekonometri för att studera marknadens mikrostruktur. Maskininlärning och Reinforcement Learning har blivit mer populära, med många olika användningsområden både inom finans och andra fält. Inom finansfältet har dessa typer av metoder använts främst inom handel och optimal exekvering av ordrar. I denna uppsats kombineras både Reinforcement Learning och marknadens mikrostruktur, för att simulera en aktiemarknad baserad på NASDAQ i Norden. Där tränas market maker - agenter via Reinforcement Learning med målet att förstå marknadens mikrostruktur som uppstår via agenternas interaktioner. I denna uppsats utvärderas och testas agenterna på en dealer – marknad tillsammans med en limit - orderbok. Vilket särskiljer denna studie tillsammans med de två algoritmerna DQN och PPO från tidigare studier. Främst har stokastisk optimering använts för liknande problem i tidigare studier. Agenterna lyckas framgångsrikt med att återskapa egenskaper hos finansiella tidsserier som återgång till medelvärdet och avsaknad av linjär autokorrelation. Agenterna lyckas också med att vinna över slumpmässiga strategier, med maximal vinst på 200%. Slutgiltigen lyckas även agenterna med att visa annan handelsdynamik som förväntas ske på en verklig marknad. Huvudsakligen: kluster av spreads, optimal hantering av aktielager och en minskning av spreads under simuleringarna. Detta visar att Reinforcement Learning med PPO eller DQN är relevanta val vid modellering av marknadens mikrostruktur.

Das moderne Finanzsystem ist komplex, dynamisch, hochdimensional und oftmals nicht stationär. All diese Faktoren stellen große Herausforderungen beim Messen des zugrundeliegenden Finanzrisikos dar, das speziell für Marktteilnehmer von oberster Priorität ist. Hochdimensionalität, die aus der ansteigenden Vielfalt an Finanzprodukten entsteht, ist ein wichtiges Thema für Ökonometriker. Ein Standardansatz, um mit hoher Dimensionalität umzugehen, ist es, Schlüsselvariablen auszuwählen und kleine Koeffizientenen auf null zu setzen, wie etwa Lasso. In der Finanzmarktanalyse kann eine solche geringe Annahme helfen, die führenden Risikofaktoren aus dem extrem großen Portfolio, das letztendlich das robuste Maß für finanzielles Risiko darstellt, hervorzuheben. In dieser Arbeit nutzen wir penalisierte Verfahren, um die ökonometrischen Maße für das finanzielle Risiko in hoher Dimension zu schätzen, sowohl mit nieder-, als auch hochfrequenten Daten. Mit Fokus auf dem Finanzmarkt, können wir das Risikonetzwerk des ganzen Systems konstruieren, das die Identifizierung individualspezifischen Risikos erlaubt. / Modern financial system is complex, dynamic, high-dimensional and often possibly non-stationary. All these factors pose great challenges in measuring the underlying financial risk, which is of top priority especially for market participants. High-dimensionality, which arises from the increasing variety of the financial products, is an important issue among econometricians. A standard approach dealing with high dimensionality is to select key variables and set small coefficient to zero, such as lasso. In financial market analysis, such sparsity assumption can help highlight the leading risk factors from the extremely large portfolio, which constitutes the robust measure for financial risk in the end. In this paper we use penalized techniques to estimate the econometric measures of financial risk in high dimensional, with both low-frequency and high-frequency data. With focus on financial market, we could construct the risk network of the whole system which allows for identification of individual-specific risk.