Identifying the forces responsible for driving genomic divergence during speciation is a major goal of research in evolutionary biology. Thus, many efforts have focused on disentangling these forces by modeling the evolutionary histories of interacting populations. Here, population genomic datasets and a diffusion approximation method is used to model the demographic scenarios that influence divergence between Heliconius erato and the incipient species Heliconius himera. The models support an isolation-with-migration scenario, with relatively low and heterogeneous rates of introgression between H. himera and H. erato cyrbia. Additionally, the models suggest a history of selection driving divergence and introgression patterns among H. himera and H. erato. Collectively, these results support H. himera’s status as an incipient species within the H. erato radiation and highlight the interplay of selection and demographic history in shaping heterogeneous patterns of genomic divergence between hybridizing species.

Comment la diversification biologique peut-elle avoir lieu malgré les échanges génétiques? Comment les barrières reproductives entre espèces évoluent-elles et fonctionnent-elles? Les changements adaptatifs de certains traits favorisent-ils la diversification et la spéciation? Ces questions ouvertes en biologie évolutive constituent la base de ce projet. Pour y répondre, nous nous sommes intéressés aux papillons du genre néo-tropical Heliconius qui constituent une partie importante des communautés diversifiées de papillons néotropicaux. Les papillons de ce groupe sont immangeables pour les prédateurs, arborent des colorations d’avertissement qui signalent leur toxicité, et miment d’autres papillons toxiques dans leurs communautés locales. Ce genre a connu une radiation adaptative des motifs colorés soumis à la sélection naturelle favorisant le mimétisme de divers signaux locaux, mais ces motifs sont également connus comme signaux intraspécifiques favorisant les appariements homogames. Mes travaux ont permis d’approfondir les connaissances actuelles sur la fonction écologique et la base génétique de la couleur des ailes chez ces papillons, et d’explorer l'importance de la couleur des ailes par rapport aux signaux chimiques au cours des premières étapes de diversification. Dans cette optique, j’ai caractérisé la divergence adaptive entre les taxons à différents stades du continuum de spéciation, par une approche intégrative combinant des données génomiques, phénotypiques, comportementales, chimiques et écologiques. Plus précisément, j’ai étudié le sous-clade de Heliconius appelé sylvaniformes, contenant des espèces de papillons aux motifs tigrés, qui participent à des relations de mimétisme avec de nombreuses autres espèces fortement apparentées ou non. Mes travaux incluent la description comparative de l'architecture génétique des motifs colorés adaptatifs parallèlement chez les espèces H. hecale et H. ismenius, en utilisant des croisements, du génotypage génomique à haut débit, et de la morphométrie des motifs colorés. J’ai également exploré l'importance de la sélection naturelle et sexuelle sur les locus contrôlant ces motifs colorés aux stades précoces de divergence dans ce genre. En particulier, j’ai analysé la structure et le maintien de la zone d’hybridation entre deux races parapatriques de H. hecale montrant des colorations différentes, en combinant la génétique et la génomique des populations, ainsi que l’analyse phénotypique de clines et des tests comportementaux sur le choix de partenaire chez les mâles. Enfin, j’ai effectué des analyses génomiques de la divergence et du flux de gènes en me basant sur des données de re-séquençage de génomes complets afin de rechercher des traces d'introgression entre des espèces co-mimétiques et étroitement apparentées. Ceci a été également couplé à des expériences de préférence et de comportement sexuel, ainsi qu’à des analyses chimiques montrant d'importantes différences dans des composés qui pourraient intervenir dans la reconnaissance spécifique et le maintien des limites entre espèces. Dans l'ensemble, mes travaux montrent que bien que la sélection agissant sur les motifs colorés des ailes ait été centrale dans la diversification du genre Heliconius, l'accumulation d'autres barrières au flux de gènes peut jouer un rôle important dans l’aboutissement du processus de spéciation. / How does biological diversification occur in the face of genetic exchange? How do reproductive barriers evolve and function? What is the role of adaptive traits in promoting diversification and speciation? These open questions in evolutionary biology are at the core of this project. In order to tackle them, we have focused on butterflies in the neo-tropical genus which are an important component of the diverse butterfly communities in the Neo-tropics. Butterflies in the genus Heliconius are unpalatable to predators, use warning colours to advertise their defences, and mimic other defended butterflies in their local communities. The genus has undergone an adaptive radiation in wing colour patterns as a result of natural selection for mimicry, and is also well known for assortative mating based on wing pattern. I have extended the current knowledge about the ecological function and the genetic basis of wing color patterns in these butterflies and explored the importance of wing coloration relative to chemical signaling in the early stages of diversification. To this aim, I have characterised the adaptive divergence between lineages at different stages of the speciation continuum, by integrating genomic, phenotypic, behavioural, chemical and ecological data. More precisely, I have studied the so-called silvaniform sub-clade of Heliconius, known for harbouring species with tiger patterns that participate in mimicry with large groups of other closely and distantly-related species. My work includes the comparative description of the genetic architecture of wing pattern adaptation in two species, H. hecale and H. ismenius, using crosses, genome-wide next-generation genotyping, and advanced morphometrics of colour patterns. I have also explored the importance of natural and sexual selection on wing-patterning loci at early stages of divergence in the genus. In particular, I have analysed the structure and maintenance of a hybrid zone between two distinctly coloured parapatric races of H. hecale by using a combination of population genetics and genomics, coupled to a phenotypic analysis of the clines and to behavioural assays on male-based mate choice. Finally, I have carried out genome-wide analyses of divergence and gene flow with whole genome sequencing data to look for evidence of introgression between coexisting, hybridising co-mimetic species. This was again coupled to experiments on mating preferences and behavior, and yielded evidence for important differences in putative pheromone signals which may mediate species recognition and the maintenance of species boundaries. Overall, my results show that although selection on wing pattern divergence have been central to the diversification of the genus Heliconius, the accumulation of other barriers to gene flow may be important for the speciation process to be completed.

Made available in DSpace on 2014-12-17T14:10:20Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 MariaSMC_DISSERT.pdf: 2542892 bytes, checksum: bb7b11247ce7668feb164d1de842f43d (MD5) Previous issue date: 2010-01-27 / Coordena??o de Aperfei?oamento de Pessoal de N?vel Superior / (The Mark and Recapture Network: a Heliconius case study). The current pace of habitat destruction, especially in tropical landscapes, has increased the need for understanding minimum patch requirements and patch distance as tools for conserving species in forest remnants. Mark recapture and tagging studies have been instrumental in providing parameters for functional models. Because of their popularity, ease of manipulation and well known biology, butterflies have become model in studies of spatial structure. Yet, most studies on butterflies movement have focused on temperate species that live in open habitats, in which forest patches are barrier to movement. This study aimed to view and review data from mark-recapture as a network in two species of butterfly (Heliconius erato and Heliconius melpomene). A work of marking and recapture of the species was carried out in an Atlantic forest reserve located about 20km from the city of Natal (RN). Mark recapture studies were conducted in 3 weekly visits during January-February and July-August in 2007 and 2008. Captures were more common in two sections of the dirt road, with minimal collection in the forest trail. The spatial spread of captures was similar in the two species. Yet, distances between recaptures seem to be greater for Heliconius erato than for Heliconius melpomene. In addition, the erato network is more disconnected, suggesting that this specie has shorter traveling patches. Moving on to the network, both species have similar number of links (N) and unweighed vertices (L). However, melpomene has a weighed network 50% more connections than erato. These network metrics suggest that erato has more compartmentalized network and restricted movement than melpomene. Thus, erato has a larger number of disconnected components, nC, in the network, and a smaller network diameter. The frequency distribution of network connectivity for both species was better explained by a Power-law than by a random, Poissom distribution, showing that the Power-law provides a better fit than the Poisson for both species. Moreover, the Powerlaw erato is much better adjusted than in melpomene, which should be linked to the small movements that erato makes in the network / (A rede de marca??o e recaptura: O caso de borboletas do g?nero Heliconius). O ritmo atual de destrui??o dos habitats, especialmente em paisagens tropicais, tem aumentado a necessidade de se ter algum conhecimento sobre fragmentos e dist?ncia entre fragmentos como requisito m?nimo para a conserva??o das esp?cies em remanescentes de florestas. Os estudos de marca??o e recaptura t?m sido fundamentais no fornecimento de par?metros para modelos funcionais. Devido ? sua popularidade, facilidade de manipula??o e bem conhecida biologia, as borboletas tornaram-se modelos nos estudos da estrutura espacial. No entanto, a maioria dos estudos sobre o movimento de borboletas se concentraram em esp?cies de clima temperado que vivem em ambientes abertos, onde fragmentos florestais formam obst?culos para os movimentos. O presente trabalho teve como objetivo visualizar e reavaliar os dados de marca??o e recaptura como uma rede em duas esp?cies de borboleta (Heliconius erato e Heliconius melpomene). Um trabalho de marca??o e recaptura das esp?cies foi realizado em uma reserva de mata Atl?ntica localizada a cerca de 20 km da cidade de Natal (RN), durante um per?odo de tr?s anos, nos meses mais secos e chuvosos do ano, com tr?s visitas semanais. As capturas foram comuns nas duas partes da estrada de terra, com coleta m?nima na trilha de floresta e a dispers?o espacial das capturas tamb?m foi semelhante nas duas esp?cies. Por?m, as dist?ncias entre as recapturas parecem ser maiores para H. melpomene que para H. erato. Al?m disso, a rede erato ? mais desligada, sugerindo que esta esp?cie precisa viajar caminhos mais curtos. Em rela??o ?s medidas de rede, ambas as esp?cies t?m n?mero similar de conex?es (N) e v?rtices n?o considerando os pesos (L). No entanto, melpomene tem uma rede com liga??es que pesou 50% mais que erato. Essas medidas sugerem que erato tem uma rede mais compartimentada e de dispers?o mais restrita do que melpomene. Assim, erato tem um n?mero maior de componentes desconectados, nC, na rede, e um menor di?metro de rede. A distribui??o de freq??ncia de conectividade de rede para ambas as esp?cies foi mais bem explicada pela lei de pot?ncia do que pela distribui??o de Poisson, mostrando que a lei de pot?ncia prev? um ajuste melhor que o de Poisson para ambas as esp?cies. Al?m disto, a lei de pot?ncia de erato ? bem melhor ajustada do que a de melpomene, que deve estar ligado aos pequenos movimentos que erato faz na rede

Made available in DSpace on 2014-12-17T14:33:03Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 PriscilaAM.pdf: 370438 bytes, checksum: 93995dd721c298f0b6f78207c20d0453 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2009-07-24 / Coordena??o de Aperfei?oamento de Pessoal de N?vel Superior / Extensive studies using molecular markers on butterflies have shown how a highly fragmented landscape may result in the reduction of gene flow among patches of habitat and, consequently, increase genetic differentiation among populations. However, little is known about Heliconius geographical structure and the effects of fragmentation on the connectivity of populations. Furthermore, findings on the effects of the population structure on the dynamics of mimicry evolution in Heliconius butterflies need to be tested in H. erato and H. melpomene specimens found in other locations other than Central and northern South Americas. For the present study, we had two motivations: (1) compare the population structure of H. erato and H. melpomene given the highly fragmented Brazil s Atlantic Forest habitat; and (2) studying population structure of co-mimics could give us insights into the dynamics of mimicry evolution. For this, we analysed the spatial structure and connectivity of eight populations of Heliconius butterflies, in a total of 137 H. erato specimens and 145 H. melpomene specimens, using nine microsatellites loci, 1144 AFLPs markers and 282 mitochondrial DNA sequences. In general, both species exhibited evidence of population subdivision but no isolation by distance indicating some extent of genetic differentiation among populations. Contrary to Kronforst & Gilbert s (2008) Costa Rican Heliconius, H. melpomene exhibited more genetic differentiation than H. erato based on nuclear markers. However, for mitochondrial DNA, H. erato populations showed more genetic differentiation than H. melpomene. Our results corroborate to other studies on Heliconius butterflies concerning the pronounced population subdivision and local genetic drift found in this genus. Nevertheless, the pattern of this differentiation varies significantly from the pattern found in studies conducted in Central America, where H. erato is generally more differentiated and structured than H. melpomene, based on nuclear markers. This different pattern may reflect different evolutionary histories of Heliconius species in Northeastern Brazil s Atlantic Forest / Estudos utilizando marcadores moleculares em borboletas t?m mostrado como uma paisagem altamente fragmentada pode resultar na redu??o do fluxo g?nico entre as manchas de habitat e, conseq?entemente, aumentar a diferencia??o gen?tica entre as popula??es. No entanto, pouco se sabe sobre a estrutura geogr?fica e os efeitos da fragmenta??o sobre a conectividade das popula??es do g?nero Heliconius. Al?m disso, as conclus?es sobre os efeitos da estrutura populacional sobre a din?mica da evolu??o do mimetismo de borboletas do g?nero Heliconius precisam ser testados em esp?cimes de H. erato e H. melpomene encontrados em outros locais, al?m dos da Am?rica Central norte da Am?rica do Sul. Neste estudo, tivemos duas motiva??es: (1) comparar a estrutura populacional de H. erato e H. melpomene dada a elevada fragmenta??o do Mata Atl?ntica Brasileira, e (2) estudar a estrutura populacional de esp?cies co-m?micas poderia nos fornecer insights a respeito da din?mica da evolu??o do mimetismo. Para isso, analisamos a estrutura espacial e conectividade de oito popula??es de Heliconius, em um total de 137 esp?cimes de H. erato e 145 de H. melpomene, utilizando nove loci de microssat?lites, 1144 marcadores AFLPs e 282 sequ?ncias de DNA mitocondrial. Em geral, ambas as esp?cies apresentaram evid?ncias de subdivis?o populacional, mas nenhum isolamento por dist?ncia indicando alguma diferencia??o gen?tica entre as popula??es. Contrariamente ao Heliconius da Costa Rica (Kronforst & Gilbert 2008), H. melpomene exibiu maior diferencia??o gen?tica que H. erato, baseado em marcadores nucleares. No entanto, para DNA mitocondrial, as popula??es de H. erato apresentaram maior diferencia??o gen?tica que H. melpomene. Nossos resultados corroboram com outros estudos sobre Heliconius no tocante ? subdivis?o populacional e deriva g?nica local encontrada neste g?nero. No entanto, o padr?o dessa diferencia??o varia significativamente do padr?o encontrado em estudos realizados na Am?rica Central, onde H. erato ? geralmente mais diferenciado e estruturado. Esse padr?o pode refletir diferentes hist?rias evolutivas de esp?cies de Heliconius na Mata Atl?ntica do Nordeste do Brasil

Made available in DSpace on 2014-12-17T14:33:03Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 LucianaLFL.pdf: 2263314 bytes, checksum: 031f7f356fbeb6a00725098fb2fbe8c6 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2009-08-28 / Coordena??o de Aperfei?oamento de Pessoal de N?vel Superior / Tropical environments often face strong seasonal variations in climate, such as alternate periods of dry and rain, that may often be important influence in the annual X the organisms lives. Here we assess how population dynamics of two butterfly species (Heliconius erato and Heliconius mepomene) respond to environmental and seasonal variations. A mark-release-recapture study carried out in an Atlantic forest reserve, 15 Km from Natal, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil, for 3 years, during the dry and rainy season, with three visits weekly done. Information such as species, wing lenght, site of capture, pollen load and phenotype (number of spots) (in H. erato only) were noted for each capture. Seasonal variation exists in capture rates of the two species, with great capture rates during the rainy season. Despite finding differences in the mean density of individuals of the two species among the different collection areas, this difference was only significant between floodplain and central areas, and no influence of seasonality was observed in the mean density between the areas. Seasonality in wing size was only observed for H. erato, with larger wings during the rainy season. Females carried larger pollen loads than males both species, but species were similar. Only males differed seasonally, with larger pollen loads during the rainy season. The distribution of the number of wing spots did not vary between the dry and rainy seasons, and the number of spots in males and females was similar. Therefore, we conclude that there was a strong influence of seasonal variation in the population dynamic of the two Heliconius species, as well as in several aspects of their biology / Ambientes tropicais, assim como temperados, costumam se deparar com fortes varia??es sazonais em seus regimes clim?ticos, manifestadas atrav?s de per?odos alternados de seca e chuva, que podem ter pronunciada influ?ncia em diversos aspectos da vida dos organismos que neles habitam. O presente estudo teve como objetivo avaliar como a din?mica populacional de duas esp?cies de borboleta (Heliconius erato e Heliconius melpomene) responde ?s varia??es ambientais sazonais por elas enfrentadas. Um trabalho de marca??o e recaptura das esp?cies foi realizado em uma reserva de mata Atl?ntica localizada cerca de 15 km da cidade de Natal (RN), durante um per?odo de tr?s anos, nos meses mais secos e chuvosos do ano, com tr?s visitas semanais. Informa??es como esp?cie, comprimento alar, local de captura, idade, tamanho da carga pol?nica coletada e fen?tipo (n?mero de manchas na por??o ventral das asas anteriores) em H. erato foram obtidas para cada captura. Observou-se varia??o sazonal nas taxas de captura das duas esp?cies, com maior incid?ncia nos per?odos mais chuvosos, e baixa taxa de recaptura, principalmente nos per?odos mais secos. Apesar de encontrada diferen?a na densidade m?dia de indiv?duos das duas esp?cies entre as diferentes ?reas de coleta, esta foi significativa somente entre as ?reas de v?rzea e central, e n?o foi observada influ?ncia da sazonalidade na densidade m?dia entre as ?reas. O efeito da sazonalidade sobre o comprimento alar somente foi observado para H. erato, com indiv?duos coletados nos per?odos de chuva apresentando tamanhos superiores. F?meas coletaram maiores cargas pol?nicas do que machos nas duas esp?cies, mas n?o houve diferen?a quando comparadas as esp?cies entre si. Quando analisada a influ?ncia sazonal na obten??o de p?len, somente os machos apresentaram diverg?ncias entre as esta??es, com indiv?duos capturados nos per?odos mais chuvosos coletando maiores cargas pol?nicas. Quanto ? varia??o fenot?pica em H. erato, a distribui??o do n?mero de manchas n?o variou entre as esta??es seca e chuvosa, assim como n?o houve diferen?a no n?mero de manchas entre machos e f?meas. Podemos ent?o concluir que houve forte influ?ncia da varia??o sazonal na din?mica populacional das duas esp?cies de Heliconius, bem como em v?rios aspectos de sua biologia

A major challenge to evolutionary developmental biology is to understand the how modifications to gene regulatory networks can lead to biological diversity. Heliconius butterfly wing patterns provide an excellent example of this diversity. In particular, the species H. melpomene and H. erato display wide variation in wing pattern across their ranges in Central and South America, but wherever they co-occur, they have converged on remarkably similar wing patterns due to Müllerian mimicry. Linkage analysis of wing pattern genes has shown that in both species, there are three genomic loci that are responsible for most of the pattern variation, and that these loci are homologous. One locus, containing the transcription factor optix, is responsible for red pattern elements. A set of non-coding sequences linked to some of the red pattern elements have been identified. Another locus, containing the gene WntA, has been linked to the shape of the forewing band elements and is responsible for variation in wing pattern development in several species of lepidoptera. A third locus, responsible for yellow pattern elements, contains multiple candidate genes that may affect wing pattern development, including the gene cortex, which is also linked to the industrial melanism phenotype in the moth Biston betularia, as well as the genes domeless and washout, linked to the Bigeye mutant in Bicyclus anynana. I first investigated modifications to regulatory sequence near the transcription factor optix, detecting a module associated with the band pattern element. I also found that for some pattern regulatory modules at optix, the same sequence has independently evolved the same function in H. melpomene and H. erato, in association with non-coding sequences conserved throughout the Lepidoptera. I then investigated gene expression differences in two morphs from either side of a hybrid zone that vary only in the presence or absence of a yellow pattern element, in order to determine a role for candidate genes at the yellow pattern locus. In H. melpomene the gene cortex was upregulated in the larval wing discs of the black morph, whereas in H. erato it was upregulated in the larval wing discs of the yellow morph. In pupal wings, washout was differentially expressed, again in the opposite pattern in the two species, suggesting the same locus is responsible for convergent pattern modification, but by a different mechanism. Finally, I investigated the spatial transcriptomic landscape across the wings of three different heliconiine butterflies. I identified candidate factors for regulating the expression of wing patterning genes, including genes with a conserved expression profile in all three species, and others, including genes in the Wnt pathway, with markedly different profiles in each of the three species. Each of these studies contributes to our understanding of how gene regulatory networks can be modified to create diversity: first, at the level of cis-regulation, second at the level of gene interaction and expression, and lastly at the level of developmental bias and constraint.

No contexto da herbivoria, a interação inseto-planta é um sistema dinâmico. As plantas apresentam características que influenciam a preferência e o desempenho dos herbívoros, como por exemplo, a variação da dureza e espessura do limbo foliar, de forma dependente à espécie e à idade da estrutura considerada. Por sua vez, os insetos podem responder às barreiras das plantas por mecanismos fisiológicos e comportamentais. Há registro de nove espécies de passifloráceas utilizadas por Heliconius erato phyllis (Fabricius, 1775) para o Rio Grande do Sul. As larvas deste herbívoro, entretanto, alimentam-se preferencialmente de Passiflora misera Humbold, Bonplant & Kunth, que confere maior performance, apesar de apresentar menor quantidade de nutrientes que outras hospedeiras utilizadas (ex. Passiflora suberosa Linnaeus). Desta forma, o desempenho associado ao consumo de uma passiflorácea possivelmente relaciona-se, não só ao conteúdo nutricional desta, mas também aos mecanismos morfológicos e comportamentais envolvidos na alimentação. Neste trabalho, verificamos se a dificuldade em acessar o alimento, imposta pela dureza e espessura das folhas das hospedeiras e pelas limitações estruturais das mandíbulas de H. erato phyllis, reflete ou não alterações na utilização da planta, analisando os danos causados a estas e o comportamento das larvas deste herbívoro. Para tanto P. misera, P. suberosa, Passiflora caerulea Linnaeus, Passiflora edulis Sims e Passiflora alata Dryander foram cultivadas, sendo folhas jovens e velhas dessas passifloráceas caracterizadas quanto à dureza e espessura, tanto do limbo como da nervura central. A freqüência dos danos causados à P. misera, P. suberosa, P. caerulea e P. edulis foi avaliada, em relação à idade da folha e ao longo da ontogênese larval. Quantificou-se, também, o índice de microdureza de Vickers das mandíbulas para larvas criadas em P. misera e P. suberosa. Adicionalmente, o tempo relativo aos comportamentos (repousando, alimentando, deslocando, provando e cortando nervura) foi quantificado nas cinco passifloráceas, tanto em folhas jovens quanto nas velhas. Os dados obtidos evidenciaram a existência de variação expressiva em relação à idade da folha, quanto à dureza e espessura para as espécies de passifloráceas utilizadas pelas larvas de H. erato phyllis. O tipo e a freqüência do dano (corte do limbo, raspagem e corte da nervura central) foram influenciados pela variação desses parâmetros físicos, sendo que a raspagem do limbo ocorreu quando larvas de primeiro ínstar foram criadas em folhas velhas. Houve influência ontogenética no incremento de dureza das mandíbulas, porém não foram detectados indícios de que a planta hospedeira influencie no aumento deste parâmetro nessas estruturas. As larvas empregaram grande parte do tempo em repouso, independente da espécie de hospedeira e, na maioria dos casos, dedicaram mais tempo à alimentação em P. misera. Larvas observadas em P. alata dedicaram mais tempo ao repouso e menos tempo à alimentação realizando de uma a duas refeições com pequena duração, a cada seis horas. Esta discrepância no tempo destinado a todos os comportamentos das larvas em P. alata se deve, provavelmente, a fatores químicos inerentes a esta passiflorácea. Lagartas de primeiro ínstar em folhas velhas de P. suberosa e P. caerulea despenderam maior tempo no deslocamento, demonstrando que a procura por um sítio de alimentação favorável é de fundamental importância para esta fase do desenvolvimento, evidenciando assim que a dureza foliar constitui fator limitante para ínstares iniciais, neste heliconíneo. / The plant-insect interaction is a dynamic system. Variation in plant morphological traits such as hardness and thickness of the leaves can influence preference and performance of herbivores, depending upon the species and age of the plant structure taking into. On the other hand, insects can respond to these barriers through physiological and behavioral mechanisms. Nine species of passion vine are used by Heliconius erato phyllis (Fabricius, 1775) in Rio Grande do Sul State. However, their larvae feed preferentially on Passiflora misera Humbold, Bonplant & Kunth, which provide greater performance, despite having a lower amount of nutrients when compared to other host plants (e.g. Passiflora suberosa Linnaeus). Thus, the performance related to consumption of a particular passion vine possibly relates not only to their nutritional value, but also to morphological and behavioral mechanisms involved on feeding by these butterfly larvae. In this study, we investigate whether the difficulty in accessing food, imposed by the hardness and thickness of host leaves when in association to structural limitations on the mandibles of H. erato phyllis larvae, lead in turn to changes in host plant use. We examined the plant hosts damages and also larval behavior of this herbivore on five cultivated passion vine: P. misera, P. suberosa, Passiflora caerulea Linnaeus, Passiflora edulis Sims and Passiflora alata Dryander. Young and old leaves of these passion vine species were characterized in terms of hardness and thickness for the blade and the midrib. The frequency of differences on damage caused to P. misera, P. suberosa, P. caerulea and P. edulis was evaluated in relation to leaf age throughout larval ontogeny. Vickers hardness index was quantified for mandibles dissected from larvae reared on P. misera and P. suberosa. Additionally, the time spent in different behaviors (resting, feeding, walking, tasting and vein cutting) was quantified for the five passion vine, while feeding on both young and old leaves. The data showed the existence of expressive variation in hardness and thickness according to leaf age for the passion vine species used by H. erato phyllis larvae. The type (cutting blade, scraping and vein cutting) and frequency of damages were influenced by the variation of such leaf parameters. Scraping occurred when first instar were reared on old leaves. There was an ontogenetic influence on mandibular hardness, which increases with larval age. However, there was no evidence that the host plant influences the hardness in these structures throughout ontogeny. Independently of the host tanken into account, larvae employed most of the time resting. In several cases, they devoted more time feeding in P. misera. In P. alata, they spent more time resting and less time feeding, having up to only two meals of short duration each, at every six hours. This discrepancy in time is probably due to the presence of deterrent chemicals present in this passion vine. In old leaves of P. suberosa and P. caerulea, first instar larvae spent more time moving, thus showing that the search for an suitable food site is extremely important for this stage of development. Thus, we demonstrate that leaf hardness is a limiting factor for the early larval instars in this heliconian butterfly.

The theory of "genomic islands of speciation" has been extensively debated during the last decade. This thesis not only supports this theory, but provides evidence that challenges previous beliefs on the level of admixture between species. The recently published Heliconius melpomene genome project reported apparent genomic paraphyly of H. pardalinus with regard to H. elevatus (Heliconius Genome Consortium 2012). Here, we investigate this pair of butterfly species more fully, firstly by using whole-genome resequence data, and secondly by analyzing additional geographic populations of both species, as well as outgroup taxa. Using a nuclear whole-genome phylogenetic analysis we also confirm that H. elevatus is paraphyletic. The genome-wide phylogenetic signal in H. pardalinus and H. elevatus does not indicate expected mutual monophyly of each species as it seems strongly distorted by a high level of admixture. However, several regions of the genome remain differentiated and do show the presumably original phylogenetic signal with mutual monophyly of H. pardalinus and H. elevatus. The genomic background is so homogenized that its level of differentiation (FST ~ 0.03) virtually implies panmixia. The pattern of a high level of homogenization across the genome with several regions of differentiation was consistent with a number of other statistics such as absolute divergence Dxy, nucleotide polymorphism π, number of fixed differences and with a sliding window phylogeny. The identified genomic islands of divergence comprise genes responsible for wing-patterning and chemosensation in Heliconius and some of these genes are found to be under positive selection, suggesting possible candidates of speciation.

Neste trabalho procurou-se analisar a coloração das pupas em Heliconius erato phyllis em relação aos componentes genético e ambiental. Um total de 25 proles foi utilizado neste estudo, sendo 17 a partir de cruzamentos feitos em insetário e 8 provenientes de fêmeas já fecundadas trazidas da natureza. A coloração das pupas seguiu um sistema de escores discretos sendo a cor mais clara categorizada como 2 e a mais escura como 5. Para testar o efeito ambiental (na realidade, apenas um componente ambiental, particularmente a sensibilidade da lagarta à um ambiente claro ou à um ambiente escuro), cada prole foi dividida em três tratamentos: controle, preto, e branco, com as lagartas sendo transferidas para estes tratamentos no início do 5º instar. O tratamento controle consistia na criação das larvas em potes translúcidos, com o fundo coberto por papel de cor bege e à temperatura de 25o C + 1o C com iluminação permanente. Os dois outros tratamentos diferiam do anterior por terem todo o revestimento interno dos potes, ora com papel branco, ora com papel preto; nos demais itens, os tratamentos eram idênticos. As lagartas, individualizadas, eram alimentadas diariamente. As pupas desenvolvidas no tratamento preto obtiveram escore 5 ou 4 e as desenvolvidas no tratamento branco não diferiram estatisticamente daquelas do controle. Este caso pode ser visto com um exemplo de modulação fenotípica na qual o grau de melanização da pupa é influenciado por um ambiente preto. Para obter-se maiores informações em relação ao tempo de sensitividade das lagartas ao ambiente preto, elas foram testadas em diferentes tempos de desenvolvimento. Quando elas foram submetidas ao tratamento preto na fase de pré-pupa, estas não mostraram diferenças em relação ao tratamento controle, mas sim quando colocadas sob este tratamento no instar anterior, indicando que o período crítico na indução da melanização ocorre de forma breve no 5º instar. O componente genético foi estudado através dos cruzamentos onde levouse em conta o grau de parentesco (coeficientes de endocruzamento de irmãos inteiros de 0,0; 0,125; 0,25 e 0,375) e a estimativa da herdabilidade (h2) pelos métodos da regressão e da análise da variância. Quatro proles dos cruzamentos foram endocruzadas e assim descartadas das estimativas de herdabilidade. Todavia, elas mostraram uma variância decrescente nos escores das colorações das pupas quando o coeficiente de endocruzamento aumentava, sugerindo uma base genética para a coloração. As estimativas da herdabilidade situaram-se ao redor de 0,30 na regressão da média dos escores da prole sobre a média dos genitores. A regressão da média da prole sobre o escore dos pais (masculinos) forneceu valores de h2 maiores, variando de 0.40 a 0.73. Esta foi negativa e extremamente baixa quando os escores maternos estavam envolvidos. As estimativas pela análise da variância resultaram em um intervalo de 0.48 a 0.55. Um resultado adicional que reforça a idéia de um componente genético, foi obtido a partir do tratamento preto: mesmo quando larvas de 5º instar foram sujeitas ao ambiente preto, com as pupas resultantes sendo escuras, a análise da variância mostrou diferenças significantes entre as proles, o que sugere uma diferença genética entre estas. Assim, mesmo havendo uma forte influência do ambiente preto na indução de pupas pretas, a resposta das proles mostrou variação que deve ser devida à diferenças genéticas. Os resultados encontrados no presente trabalho indicam que o componente genético na melanização da pupa é compatível com o modelo de controle poligênico. / This work analysed the genetic and the environmental influence on the pupal colouration in the butterfly Heliconius erato phyllis. A total of 25 offspring were used in the study, 17 from crosses made in insectary, and 8 from females brought from nature, already inseminated. Pupal colour followed a system of discrete scores, from 2 for the light pupae to 5 for the darkest ones. To test the effect of environmental alteration (actually only one environmental component, namely the caterpillar sensitivity to a light or to a dark environment), each offspring was subjected to three treatments: control, darkness and whiteness, with caterpillars being transferred to these treatments in the beginnings of their 5th instar. The control treatment consisted in rearing caterpillars in translucent pots, with the bottom covered with beige paper and at a temperature of 25o C + 1o C and with permanent illumination. The two other treatments differed from the previous one by having their pots covered internally with white or with black paper; the remaining procedures being similar. Caterpillars, growing individually, received daily abundant food. Pupae from the dark environment originated pupae that scored 5 or sometimes 4; for those in the white environment, there were no differences with the controls. The case can be viewed as an example of phenotypic modulation, in which the degree of melanization of the pupa is influenced by a dark environment. To get more details on the time the caterpillars were sensible to the darkening of environment, they were tested at different age of development. When they were subjected to the dark treatment at the prepupal stage, the score for the pupae did not differ statistically from those of the control treatment. However, when subjected to the dark environment at the 5th instar, the resulting pupae had scores statistically different from the control treatment. This indicates that the critical period for inducing melanization is shortly around the 5th instar. The genetic component was studied through crosses where the degree of relatedness were taken into account (inbreeding coefficients of the sibship being 0.0 for the unrelated, and 0.125, 0.25, and 0.375). Heritability estimates (h2) were done by the methods of regression and analysis of variance. Four offspring from the crosses were inbred and were discarded in the estimates of heritability. However, they showed a decreasing variance in the scores for pupal colour as the inbreeding coefficient increased, suggesting a genetic background for colour. Estimates of heritability were around 0.30 when the score of the offspring were regressed on the midparental value. When regressed on the male parent, h2 was larger, varying from 0.40 to 0.73 and was generally negative and very low when female parent was the regressor. Estimates by the analysis of variance resulted in the interval 0.48 - 0.55. One additional fact comes from the black treatment. Even when fifth instar larvae were subjected to a dark environment, with the resulting pupae being dark, the analysis of variance showed a significant difference among offspring, which suggests genetic differences among the offspring not totally inhibited by the dark treatment. Our results dealing with the genetic component of pupal melanization are compatible with a polygenic control.

No contexto da herbivoria, a interação inseto-planta é um sistema dinâmico. As plantas apresentam características que influenciam a preferência e o desempenho dos herbívoros, como por exemplo, a variação da dureza e espessura do limbo foliar, de forma dependente à espécie e à idade da estrutura considerada. Por sua vez, os insetos podem responder às barreiras das plantas por mecanismos fisiológicos e comportamentais. Há registro de nove espécies de passifloráceas utilizadas por Heliconius erato phyllis (Fabricius, 1775) para o Rio Grande do Sul. As larvas deste herbívoro, entretanto, alimentam-se preferencialmente de Passiflora misera Humbold, Bonplant & Kunth, que confere maior performance, apesar de apresentar menor quantidade de nutrientes que outras hospedeiras utilizadas (ex. Passiflora suberosa Linnaeus). Desta forma, o desempenho associado ao consumo de uma passiflorácea possivelmente relaciona-se, não só ao conteúdo nutricional desta, mas também aos mecanismos morfológicos e comportamentais envolvidos na alimentação. Neste trabalho, verificamos se a dificuldade em acessar o alimento, imposta pela dureza e espessura das folhas das hospedeiras e pelas limitações estruturais das mandíbulas de H. erato phyllis, reflete ou não alterações na utilização da planta, analisando os danos causados a estas e o comportamento das larvas deste herbívoro. Para tanto P. misera, P. suberosa, Passiflora caerulea Linnaeus, Passiflora edulis Sims e Passiflora alata Dryander foram cultivadas, sendo folhas jovens e velhas dessas passifloráceas caracterizadas quanto à dureza e espessura, tanto do limbo como da nervura central. A freqüência dos danos causados à P. misera, P. suberosa, P. caerulea e P. edulis foi avaliada, em relação à idade da folha e ao longo da ontogênese larval. Quantificou-se, também, o índice de microdureza de Vickers das mandíbulas para larvas criadas em P. misera e P. suberosa. Adicionalmente, o tempo relativo aos comportamentos (repousando, alimentando, deslocando, provando e cortando nervura) foi quantificado nas cinco passifloráceas, tanto em folhas jovens quanto nas velhas. Os dados obtidos evidenciaram a existência de variação expressiva em relação à idade da folha, quanto à dureza e espessura para as espécies de passifloráceas utilizadas pelas larvas de H. erato phyllis. O tipo e a freqüência do dano (corte do limbo, raspagem e corte da nervura central) foram influenciados pela variação desses parâmetros físicos, sendo que a raspagem do limbo ocorreu quando larvas de primeiro ínstar foram criadas em folhas velhas. Houve influência ontogenética no incremento de dureza das mandíbulas, porém não foram detectados indícios de que a planta hospedeira influencie no aumento deste parâmetro nessas estruturas. As larvas empregaram grande parte do tempo em repouso, independente da espécie de hospedeira e, na maioria dos casos, dedicaram mais tempo à alimentação em P. misera. Larvas observadas em P. alata dedicaram mais tempo ao repouso e menos tempo à alimentação realizando de uma a duas refeições com pequena duração, a cada seis horas. Esta discrepância no tempo destinado a todos os comportamentos das larvas em P. alata se deve, provavelmente, a fatores químicos inerentes a esta passiflorácea. Lagartas de primeiro ínstar em folhas velhas de P. suberosa e P. caerulea despenderam maior tempo no deslocamento, demonstrando que a procura por um sítio de alimentação favorável é de fundamental importância para esta fase do desenvolvimento, evidenciando assim que a dureza foliar constitui fator limitante para ínstares iniciais, neste heliconíneo. / The plant-insect interaction is a dynamic system. Variation in plant morphological traits such as hardness and thickness of the leaves can influence preference and performance of herbivores, depending upon the species and age of the plant structure taking into. On the other hand, insects can respond to these barriers through physiological and behavioral mechanisms. Nine species of passion vine are used by Heliconius erato phyllis (Fabricius, 1775) in Rio Grande do Sul State. However, their larvae feed preferentially on Passiflora misera Humbold, Bonplant & Kunth, which provide greater performance, despite having a lower amount of nutrients when compared to other host plants (e.g. Passiflora suberosa Linnaeus). Thus, the performance related to consumption of a particular passion vine possibly relates not only to their nutritional value, but also to morphological and behavioral mechanisms involved on feeding by these butterfly larvae. In this study, we investigate whether the difficulty in accessing food, imposed by the hardness and thickness of host leaves when in association to structural limitations on the mandibles of H. erato phyllis larvae, lead in turn to changes in host plant use. We examined the plant hosts damages and also larval behavior of this herbivore on five cultivated passion vine: P. misera, P. suberosa, Passiflora caerulea Linnaeus, Passiflora edulis Sims and Passiflora alata Dryander. Young and old leaves of these passion vine species were characterized in terms of hardness and thickness for the blade and the midrib. The frequency of differences on damage caused to P. misera, P. suberosa, P. caerulea and P. edulis was evaluated in relation to leaf age throughout larval ontogeny. Vickers hardness index was quantified for mandibles dissected from larvae reared on P. misera and P. suberosa. Additionally, the time spent in different behaviors (resting, feeding, walking, tasting and vein cutting) was quantified for the five passion vine, while feeding on both young and old leaves. The data showed the existence of expressive variation in hardness and thickness according to leaf age for the passion vine species used by H. erato phyllis larvae. The type (cutting blade, scraping and vein cutting) and frequency of damages were influenced by the variation of such leaf parameters. Scraping occurred when first instar were reared on old leaves. There was an ontogenetic influence on mandibular hardness, which increases with larval age. However, there was no evidence that the host plant influences the hardness in these structures throughout ontogeny. Independently of the host tanken into account, larvae employed most of the time resting. In several cases, they devoted more time feeding in P. misera. In P. alata, they spent more time resting and less time feeding, having up to only two meals of short duration each, at every six hours. This discrepancy in time is probably due to the presence of deterrent chemicals present in this passion vine. In old leaves of P. suberosa and P. caerulea, first instar larvae spent more time moving, thus showing that the search for an suitable food site is extremely important for this stage of development. Thus, we demonstrate that leaf hardness is a limiting factor for the early larval instars in this heliconian butterfly.