Spelling suggestions: "subject:"dissertations -- bpolitical science"" "subject:"dissertations -- bipolitical science""
21 |
Non-interference as a doctrine in China's Africa policy : the case of DarfurTheron, Annette 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2012. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This study aimed to look at non-interference as a doctrine in China’s Africa Policy. This involved looking at the non-interference principle in general, not only in Beijing’s policies. The non-interference principle as contained in the policies of the African Union, United Nations and in the policies of Western and Asian states were discussed, noting a gradual shift away from strict non-interference towards non-indifference and humanitarian intervention. Beijing’s orthodox understanding of non-interference, on the other hand, is based on respect for the sovereignty of other states and a belief that, unless requested, no state should interfere in the domestic affairs of another state.
The doctrine of non-interference, as understood by Beijing was then applied to the crisis in Darfur. In the case of Darfur, Beijing initially adhered to its understanding of non-interference, in spite of criticism that its behaviour was based solely on China’s own interests. China initially ignored international expectations to intervene in the affairs of Khartoum. In fact, Beijing continued to support Khartoum and abstained from UN Security Council resolutions on the matter. Initially the government in Beijing was not willing to make any adjustments to the non-interference doctrine, as the situation in Darfur did not seem to present any reason for Beijing to disregard its own policies. Yet Beijing gradually shifted in non-interference; seen in its pressure on Khartoum to allow the AU/UN hybrid peacekeeping force. The reasons for the shift are ascribed to various factors ranging from international pressure and even the possible reputational risk.
China managed to balance its economic and political interests in Sudan with its duties and expectations of the Security Council. At the same time, Beijing continued to protect the sovereignty of the Khartoum government by adhering to its beliefs of the right of the state. The subtle shift away from Beijing’s orthodox understanding of non-interference can be seen as China changing its non-interference doctrine to suit its new role in the international community. It can also be seen as China still adhering to the non-interference doctrine, as it places emphasis on avoiding sanctions and still requires permission from the host state for external intervention. Another key element is that it adapted when its interests were at risk. It would seem probable that this trend will continue, resulting rather in Beijing implementing a form of ‘pro-active non-interference’ based on the situation. Such a position would indicate a shift in the doctrine of non-interference based on the situation and pressure, but according to certain core values of Beijing. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die navorser het ondersoek ingestel na die nietussenkomsleerstelling soos dit in China se Afrika-beleid vervat word. Die nietussenkomsbeginsel soos geformuleer in die beleidsdokumente van die Afrika-unie (AU), Verenigde Nasies (VN), en in die beleidsdokumente van die Westerse en Oosterse state is ook ondersoek. Die wegbeweging van die streng toepassing van die nietussenkomsleerstelling na ’n beleid van onverskilligheid en tussenkoms wat gebaseer is op die beskerming van menseregte was ’n geleidelike proses. Beijing se konvensionele begrip van hierdie beginsel was volgehou met die verstand dat soewereiiteit van ander state gerespekteer moet word en state nie moet inmeng by die interne sake van ander state nie, behalwe wanneer dit versoek word. Die klem word in beleidsdokumente eerder gelê op respek, gelykheid, samewerking en wedersydse voordeel.
Die nietussenkomsleerstelling soos dit verstaan word deur Beijing word ondersoek aan die hand van die Dafoer-krisis. Dit toon Beijing het aanvanklik volgehou met die toepassing van die nietussenkomsleerstelling in China se buitelandsse beleid en optrede, ten spyte van die aantuigings dat hierdie gedrag slegs ter wille van eie belang is. Beijing het haar aanvanklik nie aan die internasionale gemeenskap se verwagting om in te gryp by die sake van Khartoum gesteur nie; China het aangehou om Khartoum te ondersteun en van die VN-veiligheidsraad te weerhou rakende hierdie kwessie. Beijing se optrede teenoor Khartoum het met tyd verander. Sjinese verteenwoordigers het druk op Khartoum begin plaas in 2006 om AU/VN-magte in Darfoer toe te laat. Verskeie redes kan aangevoer word hoekom Beijing uiteindelik haar beleid aangepas het. Van hierdie redes sluit in internasionale druk en die moontlikheid vir China om nie meer as gasheerland vir die Olimpiese Spele in 2008 op te tree nie. Dit kom voor of China daarin geslaag het om die land se ekonomiese en politiese belange in Soedan te balanseer met die verwagtinge wat ander lande van China as ’n permanente VN-lid gehad het. Beijing het gepoog om in so ’n mate in te gryp dat Khartoum se soewereiniteit steeds gerespekteer word. Aan die hand van hierdie subtiele veranderinge in China se beleid en optrede, kan die afleiding gemaak word dat Beijing nie die nietussenkomsleerstelling streng toegepas het nie, maar na die Darfoer-krisis eerder neig na ’n proaktiewe toepassing van die nietuseenkomsleerstelling. Byvoorbeeld, Beijing keur steeds nie die instelling van sanksies goed nie en vereis dat soewereinitiet van state gerespekteer word. Dit blyk dat China die buitelandse beleid aangepas het om steeds die land se belange te beskerm en om te voldoen aan die internasionale vereistes. Hierdie meer proaktiewe optrede blyk om net in sekere gevalle toegepas te word. Daar word bevind dat daar ’n aanpassing van die is met betrekking tot die oorspronklike posisie van die nietussenkomsleerstelling. Beijing sal egter voortgaan om getrou te wees aan aspekte van die oorspronklike leerstelling.
|
22 |
Social capital and political participation in South AfricaHagen, Daniel Edward 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2012. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Empirical research on the impact of membership in voluntary associations as a dimension of
social capital on political participation has been conducted in a number of countries in Europe as
well as North America. With the aid of quantitative analysis of survey data, these studies found
that members of voluntary associations were more likely to participate both formally and
informally in their country’s political processes than those who were not members. This was due
to the role played by voluntary associations in the generation of human capital in the form of
self-efficacy and participatory skills or values, as well as bridging social capital in the form of
increased networking and trust. Existing research by Marion Keim, Cora Burnett and others have
indicated that social capital, and particularly the voluntary association of sport, can have a
profound societal impact on South African communities. However, no quantitative study has
been conducted on the relationship between membership in voluntary associations and the level
of formal political participation in the South African context.
Therefore, this study applied the social capital theory as developed in the literature on European
and North American studies to the South African context in order to determine whether there is a
relationship between the variables of membership in voluntary associations, membership in
multiple associations, membership in sports as a voluntary association and the level of formal
political participation. Using quantitative methodology, a cross-section of 2006 World Values
Survey data was analysed. The findings indicated that the social capital theory on political
participation did not apply to the South African context in the same way as to the European or
North American contexts due to explanatory differences in South Africa’s socio-political
climate. Questions were then raised over whether, due to South Africa’s current political culture,
membership in voluntary associations is conducive to encouraging informal channels of
participation. The findings reached had implications for social capital theory by indicating its
uneven application to the South African context. Moreover, the study highlighted the need for a
more context-specific understanding of social capital and its impact upon South Africa’s political
processes. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Empiriese navorsing oor die uitwerking van lidmaatskap aan vrywillige verenigings as 'n dimensie van maatskaplike kapitaal op politieke deelname is in 'n aantal lande in Europa asook
Noord-Amerika uitgevoer. Met behulp van kwantitatiewe analise van opname-data het hierdie
studies bevind dat lede van vrywillige verenigings op beide formele en informele wyse meer
geneig was om aan hulle land se politieke prosesse deel te neem as diegene wat nie lede was nie.
Dit kon toegeskryf word aan die rol wat vrywillige verenigings speel by die ontwikkeling van
menslike kapitaal in die vorm van selfwerksaamheid en deelnemende vaardighede of waardes,
asook tussentydse maatskaplike kapitaal in die vorm van groter netwerkvorming en vertroue.
Bestaande navorsing deur Marion Keim, Cora Burnett en ander het daarop gedui dat
maatskaplike kapitaal, en in die besonder die vrywillige verbintenis van sport, 'n diepgaande
uitwerking op Suid-Afrikaanse gemeenskappe kan hê. Geen kwantitatiewe studie is egter nog
oor die verhouding tussen lidmaatskap aan vrywillige verenigings en die vlak van formele
politieke deelname in die Suid-Afrikaanse opset uitgevoer nie.
Hierdie studie het dus die maatskaplike kapitaalteorie soos in die literatuur oor Europese en
Noord-Amerikaanse studies ontwikkel, op die Suid-Afrikaanse opset toegepas ten einde te
bepaal of daar 'n verhouding tussen die veranderlikes van lidmaatskap aan vrywillige
verenigings, lidmaatskap aan veelvuldige verenigings, lidmaatskap aan sport as 'n vrywillige
verbintenis en die vlak van formele politieke deelname bestaan. Met behulp van kwantitatiewe
metodologie is 'n dwarssnit van data uit die 2006- Wêreldwaardes-peiling geanaliseer. Die
bevindinge het daarop gedui dat die maatskaplike kapitaalteorie ten opsigte van politieke
deelname nie op dieselfde wyse op die Suid-Afrikaanse opset as op die Europese of Noord-
Amerikaanse opsette van toepassing is nie weens verklarende verskille in Suid-Afrika se sosiopolitieke
klimaat. Vrae is toe gevra of lidmaatskap aan vrywillige verenigings weens Suid-Afrika
se huidige politieke kultuur bevorderlik is vir die aanmoediging van informele kanale van
deelname. Die bevindinge wat bereik is, het implikasies gehad vir maatskaplike kapitaalteorie
deur die ongelyke aanwending op die Suid-Afrikaanse opset aan te dui. Daarbenewens het die
studie die behoefte aan ’n meer konteks-spesifieke begrip van maatskaplike kapitaal en die
uitwerking daarvan op Suid-Afrika se politieke prosesse beklemtoon.
|
23 |
Human security as an influence on Japan’s contemporary Africa policy: principles, patterns and implications.Van Wyk, Heste 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis MA (Political Science. International Studies))--University of Stellenbosch, 2007. / The end of the Cold War, marked by the shift from a bipolar to multipolar security order, prompted a significant change in Japan’s relations with Africa. New political and economic challenges, which are accelerated by the process of globalisation, have forced Japan to adjust its foreign policies accordingly- especially in the African context. The primary goal of this study is to analyse how the concept of human security has influenced Japan’s foreign policy towards Africa since 1998. This research question focuses on Official Development Assistance (ODA) and peacekeeping through the United Nations Peacekeeping Operations in Africa. The methodological nature of this study is qualitative. Secondary sources are mainly used. This study makes use of the two contending theoretical perspectives in the security paradigm, namely Neo- Realism and the Human Security Approach.
An important part of the analysis is Japan’s middlepowership and why it has chosen human security as its niche diplomacy in the new security order. The findings of this study suggest that the reasons for this are, firstly that Japan has had to justify its continuing ODA cuts to Africa over the last decade, as well as its pacifist stance on peacekeeping, which sees it refraining from directly intervening in conflict situations. Other key findings of this study are that Japan’s motives for providing ODA to Africa prior to 1989 were mainly economic in nature and that diplomatic relations were limited. What also emerged from this study is that Japan’s most prominent foreign policy goals include a permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council, establishing itself as a prominent global player both in political and economic realms, and securing favourable relations with states whose resources are vital to its expanding economy. Japan’s more recent relations with Africa can also be characterised by its multilateral approach, particularly through organisations such as the United Nations and the African Union. Important initiatives such as the Tokyo International Conference on African Development (TICAD) have also played an important role in promoting African development. However, its future success will depend on coordinating TICAD and The New Partnership for Africa’s Development (NEPAD) policies, with human security as a common goal. The implications of the findings of this study are that Japan will have to formulate a more coherent foreign policy on security, especially towards Africa. Secondly, since Japan is no longer the ODA giant that it used to be, it will have to find new ways of defining its relationship with Africa, particularly in terms of TICAD and the G8. Future research could expand the analysis to an investigation of Japan’s ODA disbursements to all Africa countries. Additional attention should also be given to Japan’s foreign policy in terms of peacebuilding, and how the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) is formulating these policies. Lastly, more research can be conducted on human security in general, and other aspects of it that are promoted through Japan’s foreign policy.
|
24 |
Prospects of an effective African peacekeeping capability : from rhetoric to realityCrichton, Andrew Trevor Mark 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MPhil (Political Science))--University of Stellenbosch, 2009. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This thesis examines the prospects of an effective African peacekeeping capability in light of
the developing peace and security architecture of the relatively new continental body, the
African Union (AU). The primary aim is to determine the nature and severity of those
challenges that currently face the organization’s ambition of realizing this Pan-African
dream. This study is a qualitative analysis that comprises both descriptive and exploratory
aspects.
The thesis begins by discussing the development of peacekeeping in conflict management. It
establishes that peacekeeping emerged as an ad hoc response by the UN to address the
growing issue of inter-state conflict during the Cold War, but has evolved into one of the
primary tools used by the international community to manage complex crises. The advent of
new security threats in the post-Cold War era, spurred on by the dynamic process of
globalization, necessitated that peacekeeping adapt and is commonly perceived in
contemporary discourse as a multidimensional practice. Central to this development was the
shift in focus from international to human security and the recent development of the
Responsibility to Protect doctrine.
The study then goes on to explore the process that has ultimately led to the establishment of
the AU’s proposed peacekeeping capability, the African Standby Force (ASF). With a
dramatic increase in incidences of violent conflict across the globe in the 1990s, the UN’s
limited resources were pushed to the limit, thus paving the way for regional organizations to
play a more important role in ensuring international peace and security. The establishment of
the AU in 2002 was meant to put to bed the inability of its forerunner, the Organization of
African Unity (OAU), which had suffered from limited financial, logistical and structural
competence, while its political and institutional authority was hampered by dissent and the
qualified support of member states. However, as the African Union Mission in the Darfur
region of Sudan (AMIS), highlights, the AU’s peacekeeping capacity is hamstrung by a lack
of political will on the part of African leaders, weak institutional capacity, severe financial
constraints as well as an overly militaristic approach that neglects the essential
multidimensional nature of peacekeeping. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die tesis ondersoek die vooruitsigte van ‘n effektiewe Afrika vrede-bewaringsmag, binne die
konteks van die huidige Afrika Unie (AU) se raamwerk vir vrede en sekuriteit. Die primêre
navorsingsdoel is om vas te stel wat die AU se belangrikste uitdagings is, om die die strewe
na Pan-Afrikanisme te bewerkstellig in die area van vrede-instandhouding op die kontinent.
Eerstens word ‘n oorsig gegee oor die ontwikkeling van vrede-instandhouding binne die
konteks van konflikbestuur. Die afleiding word gemaak dat vrede-instandhouding ontstaan
het as ‘n ad hoc proses binne die Verenigde Nasies ten einde inter-staat konflik tydens die
Koue Oorlog, te besleg. Dit is later binne die internasionale gemeenskap aanvaar as die
primêre strategie vir die oplossing en hantering van internasionale konflik. Na die einde van
die Koue Oorlog, en tesame met die dinamiese proses van globalisering, het vredeinstandhouding
egter verder ontwikkel en ’n multi-dimensionele proses geword. Hierdie
ontwikkeling is hoofsaaklik gekenmerk deur ’n fokus wat wegbeweeg het van tradisionele
soewereiniteits-sekuriteit na menslike sekuriteit. Dit het gepaardgegaan met die gelyktydige
ontwikkeling van die Verantwoordelikheid om te Beskerm doktrine.
Die studie ondersoek verder die prosesse wat bygedra het tot die AU se voorgestelde
vredesmag – die Afrika Bystandsmag (ASF). As gevolg van ’n toename in internasionale
konflik tydens die 1990s is die Verenigde Nasies se vermoeëns tot die uiterste beproef. Dit
het die weg gebaan vir die opkoms van kontinentale en streeks-organisasies om ‘n meer
prominente rol te speel in internasional vrede-instandhouding en sekuriteit. Die stigting van
die AU in 2002, was veronderstel om die finansiële, logistieke en strukturele tekortkominge
van sy voorganger, die Unie vir Afrika Eenheid (OAU) aan te spreek, aangesien
laasgenoemde se politieke en institusionele hoedanigheid ondermyn is deur sy lidlande. Daar
word bevind – met behulp van ’n gevalle-studie analise van die AU se Sending na Soedan
(AMIS) dat die AU se kapasiteit nie na wense is nie, as gevolg van die gebrek aan
samewerking tussen leiers, finansiële tekortkominge en ’n neiging om militaristiese
benadering te volg, ten koste van die multi-dimensionele aspek van vredes-instandhouding.
|
25 |
The role of military companies in African conflictsRoberts, Ruth 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA (Political Science))--University of Stellenbosch, 2007. / Private military companies (PMCs)are increasing becoming involved in modern conflicts providing specialised skills such as combat services, planning, intelligence, training, support and technical assistance. They provide an alternative to weak state governments as Western governments have become increasingly reluctant to commit their troops to be involved in the civil conflicts of the developing world. Supporters of the employment of private forces see them as an effective solution to this combination of need from conflict-ridden weak states and reluctance of Western governments and international organisations to intervene in these conflicts ...
|
26 |
Namibian democracy: consolidated?Kangas, Lari 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis MA (Political Science))--University of Stellenbosch, 2006. / Namibian independence was much delayed: it took place during the last years of decolonisation in Africa, at the end of the Cold War, and during the final phases of the third wave of democracy.
SWAPO prevailed in the first hotly contested elections. We all thought that the institutions of democracy were in place and that Namibia was going to lead the way for the new wave of consolidated democracies in Africa. Inclusiveness, using the classic terminology from Robert Dahl, was there to a significant degree, a “one-man-one-vote” –system was finally achieved.
|
27 |
Constructing Africa(ns) in international relations theory: bridging a theoretical abyssOswald, Rikus 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA (Political Science))--University of Stellenbosch, 2009. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Africa(ns) are currently marginalised within the discipline of International Relations. This
thesis explores the possibility that employing a constructivist approach could facilitate the
inclusion of Africa as an object of study and Africans as potential agents of IR knowledge
within the discipline by bridging a theoretical abyss.
Two discourses, namely the rationalist and Africanist, are identified. They frame the sides
of the theoretical abyss to which Africa(ns) have been marginalised within IR. These
discourses adhere to the opposing analytical approaches which constitute the Third
Debate, namely rationalism and reflectivism. This thesis proposes two theoretical
reconstructions that can facilitate the bridging of this theoretical abyss. The theoretical
reconstructions are explicated by employing different research stances. The researcher is
situated within the intellectual space afforded by the boundaries of the discipline in order to
propose the first reconstruction. The second theoretical reconstruction is proposed by
problematising the boundaries the discipline of IR.
This study found that constructivism facilitates the process of establishing the middle
ground between rationalism and reflectivism and in so doing could include Africa as an
object of study. It also found that the intervention of constructivism facilitated a necessary
change in the culture of the discipline to create the possibility of extending the notion of
engaged pluralism and re-imagining the discipline as a disciplinary community of
difference. This leads to the opening up of the necessary dialogical space to include
Africans as potential agents of IR knowledge. Constructivism is therefore the mutually
constituting link between the two proposed theoretical reconstructions as they are made
possible by its intervention in the discipline. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Afrika(ne) word huidiglik gemarginaliseer binne die dissipline van Internasionale
Betrekkinge. Hierdie tesis ondersoek die moontlikheid dat die gebruik van ‘n
konstruktiwistiese benadering die insluiting van Afrika as ‘n onderwerp van studie of
Afrikane as potensiële agente van IB kennis deur die oorbrugging van ‘n teoretiese kloof
kan fasiliteer.
Twee diskoerse, naamlik die rasionalistiese and die Afrikanistiese, word geïdentifiseer.
Hierdie diskoerse stel die sye van die teoretiese kloof voor waarin Afrika(ne)
gemarginaliseer word binne IB. Hulle hou verband met die twee opponerende analitiese
benaderings van rasionalisme en reflektiwisme wat die Derde Debate uitmaak. Hierdie
tesis stel twee teoretiese rekonstruksies voor wat die oorbrugging van die teoretiese kloof
kan fasiliteer. Hierdie teoretiese rekonstruksies word ontvou deur verskillende
navorsingsposisies in te neem. Die navorser plaas homself binne die intellektuele spasie
wat deur die grense van die dissipline toegelaat word om sodoende die eerste
rekonstruksie voor te stel. Die tweede rekonstruksie word voorgestel deur die
problematisering van die grense van die dissipline.
Hierdie studie het gevind dat konstruktiwisme die proses van die opstelling van ‘n
middelgrond tussen rasionalisme en reflektiwisme fasiliteer en sodoende Afrika as ‘n
onderwerp van studie kan insluit. Die studie het ook gevind dat die toetrede van
konstruktiwisme die nodige verandering aan die kultuur van die dissipline veroorsaak het
wat die moontlikheid skep dat die begrip van ‘engaged pluralism’ uitgebrei en die
hervoorstelling van die dissipline as a dissiplinêre gemeenskap van diversiteit kan word.
Hierdie hervoorstelling lei tot die skepping van die nodige dialogale spasie om Afrikane as
potensiële agente van IB kennis in te sluit. Konstruktiwisme is dus die onderliggende
skakel wat die twee voorgestelde teoretiese rekonstruksies moontlik maak deur die
benadering se toetrede tot die dissipline.
|
28 |
Political risk analysis and economic reform : investing in the Indian electricity sectorDuncan, Stewart M. 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2003. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The definition of political risk and the methodology of its assessment have changed since
the inception of the discipline midway through the last century. This assignment assesses
the usefulness of a new quantitative technique that uses political constraints and the policy
preferences of political actors to construct a measure of political risk. Integrating the
findings of the resulting Political Constraints Index with an analysis of the political
economy of the Indian Electricity Sector, the assignment demonstrates that, contrary to the
original interpretations of the index, high levels of political constraints and political
competition may propagate a disabling policy regime and be detrimental to the investor,
despite the stated commitment of the incumbent government to policy reform. The
implication of these findings is that, to avoid incorrect interpretation, the Political
Constraint Index should be augmented by a comprehensive qualitative assessment of the
industry in question. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die definisie van politieke risiko en die metodologie om dit te ontleed, het verander sedert
die onstaan van hierdie dissipline gedurende die middel van die laaste eeu. Hierdie opdrag
ontleed die nuttigheid van 'n nuwe kwantitatiewe tegniek wat die politieke beperkings en
beleidsvoorkeure van politieke rolspelers gebruik om 'n maatstaf van politieke risiko te
verskaf. Die opdrag se integrasie van die bevindinge van die resulterende Politieke
Beperkings Indeks met 'n analise van die politieke ekonomie van die Indiese Elektrisiteits
Sektor bewys dat, teenstrydig met oorspronklike interpretasies van die indeks, hoe vlakke
van politieke beperkings en politieke kompetisie 'n deaktiveringsbeleid regime kan kweek
wat nadelig is vir die belegger, ten spyte van die huidige regering se verklaarde
toegewydheid tot beleidshervorming. Die implikasie van hierdie bevindinge is dat, om
foutiewe interpretasie te vermy, die Politieke Beperkings Indeks verbeter moet word deur 'n
omvattende kwalitatiewe ontleding van die verlangde industrie.
|
29 |
A golden midway for a divided society? : the South African land reform project and its relationship with the rule of law and transformationGerber, Johannes Abraham 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MPhil)--University of Stellenbosch, 2004. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: South Africa's history led to an unequal distribution in land ownership, which is not
conducive to democratic consolidation. Land refortn is the means to address this
problem. However, land reform, part of the larger process of transformation, is a
potentially dangerous process: it can have negative implications on the rule of law.
The objective of this study is to provide an analysis of the dynamic relationship
between land reform, the rule of law and transformation in South Africa, within the
debate on democratic consolidation.
One can distinguish two paradigms regarding democracy: the liberal paradigm and the
liberationist paradigm. These two paradigms have divergent views on the way land
reform and transformation should be implemented, and what the goal of these two
processes is. The liberal paradigm would seem to be more favourable for democratic
consolidation, while the liberationist paradigm is a breeding ground for populist
transformation.
Furthermore, the negotiated constitutional settlement has left land reform with an
ambiguity. On the one hand the constitution forces the govemment to address land
reform, but on the other hand it firmly entrenches the private property rights by
enforcing the 'willing buyer, willing seller' principle, which makes the process more
costly and time consuming.
The main hypothesis of this study is: Demographic indicators (race, party affiliation
and provincial setting) influence support or rejection of the land reform policies of the
South African govemment. Tbe dependent variable is 'support or rejection of the
government's land reform policies'. Support for the govemment's land reform
policies is indicative of the liberal paradigm and rejection of the govemment's
policies is indicative of the liberationist paradigm.
It is found that the majority of South Africans reject the govemment's land reform
policies. However, strong divisions are evident. Respondents differ along racial,
party affiliation and provincial lines. Thus, the liberationist paradigm dominates, but
the liberal paradigm has a strong presence, creating an ideologically divided society.
This means that the legitimacy of South Africa's land reform project, as well as the
legitimacy of the constitution, is under stress. This does not bode well for democratic
consolidation, as the rule of law is under severe threat. Thus, one can conclude that
land reform is not going to make a positive contribution to the consolidation of South
Africa's democracy, if a substantial financial injection is not found to increase the
efficiency of the process. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Suid-Afrika se geskiedenis het aanleiding gegee tot 'n ongelyke verspreiding van
grondeienaarskap. Dit is nie gunstig vir demokratiese konsolidasie nie.
Grondhervorming IS die mamer waarmee die probleem aangespreek kan word.
Grondhervorming, deel van die groter proses van transformasie, is egter 'n potensieel
gevaarlike proses: dit kan negatiewe implikasies vir regsoewereiniteit hê. Die doel
van hierdie tesis is om 'n analise van die dinamiese wisselwerking tussen
grondhervorming, regsoewereiniteit en transformasie te verskaf, binne die debat oor
demokratiese konsolidasie.
Daar kan aangaande demokrasie tussen twee paradigmas onderskei word: die liberale
paradigma en die bevrydings (liberationist) paradigma. Hierdie twee paradigmas het
teenstrydige perspektiewe oor die manier waarop grondhervorming, sowel as
transformasie, geïmplementeer behoort te word, sowel as wat die doel van hierdie
twee prosesse is. Die liberale paradigma is meer geskik vir demokratiese
konsolidasie, terwyl die bevrydings paradigma 'n teelaarde vir populistiese
transformasie is.
Verder het die onderhandelde grondwetlike skikking grondhervorming in 'n
teenstrydigheid geplaas. Aan die een kant vereis die grondwet dat die regering
grondhervorming moet aanspreek, maar aan die anderkant bied dit 'n ferm
onderskraging van private eiedomsreg deur op die 'gewillige koper, gewillige
verkoper' beginsel aan te dring. Dit maak die grondhervormings proses langer en
duurder.
Die hoof hipotese van die studie is: Demografiese indikatore (ras, partyaffiliasie en
provinsie) beïnvloed ondersteuning of verwerpmg van die regering se
grondhervormingsbeleid. Die afhanklike veranderlike IS 'ondersteuning of
verwerping van die regering se grondhervormingsbeleid '. Ondersteuning van die
regering se grondhervormingsbeleid dui op die liberale paradigma, en die verwerping
daarvan dui op die bevrydings paradigma. Daar word bevind dat die meerderheid Suid-Afrikaners die regenng se
Respondente verskil volgens ras, partyaffiliasie en provinsie. Dus, die bevrydings
paradigma domineer, maar die liberale paradigma het ook 'n sterk teenwoordigheid.
Dit sorg vir 'n ideologies verdeelde samelewing.
Dit beteken dat die legitimiteit van Suid-Afrika se grondhervormings projek, sowel as
die legitimiteit van die grondwet, in gedrang is. Dit is nie 'n goeie teken vir
demokratiese konsolidasie nie, aangesien dit regsoewereiniteit in die gedrang bring.
Daarom kan daar tot die gevolg gekom word dat grondhervorming nie 'n positiewe
bydrae ten opsigte van die konsolidasie van Suid-Afrikaanse demokrasie sal maak nie,
tensy daar 'n beduidende finansiële inspuiting gevind kan word.
|
30 |
Assessing the political and investment risk climate of the PRC : a SAB-Miller case studyLanhove, Tom 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MA)--Stellenbosch University, 2004. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: This research assignment has investigated the overall nature of the
investment climate in the People's Republic of China (PRC).The investment
climate was analysed using a Political Risk Analysis (PRA) framework,
whereby the PRC was scrutinised closely for its most defining socioeconomic
features and, especially, for its most salient political risk factors.
Based on this, the assignment evaluated this climate with specific relevance
to the investment plans of the South African company SAB-Miller.
Since its accession to the World Trade Organisation (WTO)in 2001, the PRC
has intensified its economic restructuring process, a necessary and
inevitable process, in order to comply with the terms of the WTOframework.
This period of adjustment has heightened the anxiety over the strength of
the Chinese economy, and the repercussions and/or opportunities for the
multinational SAB-Miller.To remedy this uncertainty, this assignment has
drawn up an in-depth qualitative scenario, in order to forecast the major
trends of the PRC's short-term socio-political future. The main findings of
the assignment indicate that a 'high-road' scenario is the most likely to
occur in the PRC in the short-term. Clearly, this favourable forecast 1S
dependent on the continuation of the current economic and socio-political
restructuring process in the PRC.
With regards to the main macro-political risks factors, the assignment draws
attention to several critical areas of concern. Firstly, the lack of
legitimatisation from the 'bottom-up' is a worrying feature, especially in light
of the growing economic disparities between citizens and between provinces.
Secondly, the financial and governmental sectors need a thorough
restructuring, according to WTO criteria. Thirdly, the fragmentation of the
market inside the PRe undermines the potential of the PRC government to
diffuse the benefits of economic growth and to absorb the downsides of
globalisation. Micro-specific risk factors for the company SAB-Miller are
focussed predominantly on the speed and the depth of the implementation of
the guidelines of the WTO. Especially with regards to the lowering of intra-provincial trade barriers and the efficacy of the distribution networks. Lastly,
SAB-Miller should eliminate any risk factors, which may originate from
inside the company's behaviour, such as the effects of its adopted labour
policies. Lastly, it should maintain a clear level of transparency in their
associations with governmental institutions. Throughout the assignment,
these risk factors will be investigated and related to the overall political risk
climate and utilised to draw conclusions concerning the potential of the
investment plans of SAB-Miller. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Hierdie werkstuk het die beleggingsklimaat van die Volksrepubliek China
(VRC) ondersoek. Die beleggingssklimaat is ontleed deur gebruik te maak
van 'n model vir Politieke Risiko Analise (PRA), waarby die VRC sorgvuldig
onderwerp is aan 'n ondersoek van sy mees kenmerkende sosio-ekonomiese
faktore en van die belangrikste risiko faktore. Hierop gebaseer, het die
werkstuk ook die beleggingsklimaat ontleed met spesifieke betrekking tot die
beleggingsplanne van die Suid Afrikaanse maatskappy SAB-Miller.
Sedert toetreding tot die Wêreld Handelsorganisasie (WHO) in 2001, het die
VRC sy transformasie proses versnel ten einde te voldoen aan die WHO se
toelatingskriteria. Hierdie tydperk van aanpassing het kommer gewek oor die
Chinese ekonomie asook oor die gevolge daarvan vir die maatskappy SABMiller.
Om hierdie onsekerheid aan te spreek het die werkstuk 'n
kwalitatiewe scenario voorgestel, ten einde die hoofpunte van die VRC se
sosio-ekonomiese kort-termyn toekoms vooruit te skat. Die gevolgtrekking
van hierdie werkstuk toon aan dat 'n 'high-road' scenario die waarskynlikste
is gedurende die kort termyn. Dis ook duidelik dat die gunstige
vooruitskattings afhanklik is van die voortsetting van die huidige sosioekonomiese
transformasie proses van die VRC.
Met betrekking tot die vernaamste makro-politieke risiko faktore het die
werkstuk aandag gegee aan verskeie kommerwekkende aspekte. Eerstens,
die gebrek aan elektorale regmatigheid van die 'grond-af, waarskynlik in die
lig van die toenemende ekonomisiese verskille tussen burgers asook tussen
provinsies. Tweedens, moet die finansiële- en staatssektore grondig
herstruktureer word volgens die WHO riglyne. Derdens, ondermyn die
fragmentasie van die mark van binne China die mag van die VRCse regering
om die voordele van die ekonomiese groei gelykmatig te versprei, asook om
die nadele van Globalisasie te absorbeer. Mikro-spesifieke risiko faktore vir
die SAB-Miller maatskappy het hoofsaaklik gefokus op die spoed en die
diepgang van die implementering van die WHO riglyne. In besonder met
betrekking tot die hoë interprovinsiale handelsbelemmerings en die optimale
effektiwiteit van die verspreidingskakels. Laatstens, moet SAB-Miller enige risiko faktore elimineer wat as gevolg van die maatskappy se eie gedrag kan
onstaan, byvoorbeeld die maatskappy se arbeidsvoorwaardes. SAB-Miller
moet ook 'n duidelike aanspreeklikheidsfunksie daarstel, in hulle
betrekkinge met Chinese staatsinstellings. Deur die hele werkstuk word
hierdie risiko faktore ondersoek en in verband gebring met die algemene
politieke risiko klimaat, en word ook gebruik om gevolgtrekkinge te maak
aangaande die potensiaal van SAB-Millerse beleggingsplanne.
|
Page generated in 0.1654 seconds