Spelling suggestions: "subject:"legitimation"" "subject:"delegitimation""
211 |
Att hålla folket på gott humör : Informationsspridning, krigspropaganda och mobilisering i Sverige 1655-1680 / Keeping the People in a Good Mood : Dissemination of Information, War Propaganda and Mobilisation in Sweden, 1655–1680Forssberg, Anna Maria January 2005 (has links)
Starting around 1500 a period of state formation changed the European map. The scattered medieval principalities were replaced with more centralised and better organised states with permanent armies. Sweden was quite successful in competing with these states and experienced a period of expansion. The means for warfare were drawn, to a large extent, from the peasantry, which meant that a great number of Swedes were sent to the front line and were never to return. This thesis investigates the dissemination of information, war propaganda and mobilisation in Sweden, 1655–1680. This period is interesting since it includes both offensive wars (under the reign of Karl X Gustav), a period of peace (under the regency) and defensive warfare(under Karl XI). A basic assumption has been that information is an important power resource. In the study both the dissemination and the content of the propaganda are examined. The most important sources have been the minutes and correspondence of the kings, the regency and the council of the realm, along with the sources from the diet and the provincial meetings. In particular, the prayer days and thanksgiving days, in both manuscript and printed sources, have been studied. To investigate the actual dissemination of information, the sources in the regional archives of the counties of Uppsala and Kopparberg and the archives of several episcopates have been examined. There existed developed media for the dissemination of information, namely, “the system of information”. Information was disseminated from the pulpits, at the diet and provincial meetings, by county governors and bailiffs, and by printed texts. In this thesis it is shown that the rulers were anxious to explain and justify the wars to the people and that they deliberately used the dissemination of information as a power tool. To keep the people in a good mood was vital for the war effort. War propaganda was spread both in times of war and peace, and its main messages remained the same during Sweden’s Age of Greatness. The main message of the long-term propaganda was that the wars were a divine punishment: it was because of the sinful people that wars broke out. According to the propaganda, the world was populated with evil enemies that were striving to destroy Sweden. The best protection against the enemies (next to God) was a good regent. It was also stated that, in the event of war, it was the duty of the subjects to contribute. The direct propaganda was conducted in four different phases. The first phase was about explaining the outbreak of war, the second phase was about mobilisation, the third phase was about disseminating information in order to uphold the morals and the fourth and last phase was about explaining the peace. The messages of the long-term propaganda had their equivalents in the direct propaganda. These arguments, however, were not always sufficient. The state representatives also highlighted the great perils threatening the country and used a patriotic rhetoric. The war propaganda depoliticised the wars, and made it possible to mobilise great resources from the population in times of war. The frequently used picture of threatening wars contributed to the legitimacy not only of a permanent army and offensive warfare, but also of the power of the king and the social order at large.
|
212 |
Elfenbenstornet under belägring : Legitimering och mobilisering av humaniora i Sverige 1937-1947Östh Gustafsson, Hampus January 2014 (has links)
Recently, there have been intense discussions about the humanities and their role in society. Internationally, as well as in a Swedish context, the humanities have been regarded to be in a state of crisis. However, these discussions usually demonstrate a lack of historical perspectives based on thorough empirical research. The notion of a crisis needs to be historicized. In this study, a case is being examined where the relationship between science and society was renegotiated. In the context of World War II, a discourse has been identified in a borderland between science and politics through an analysis of Swedish journals and anthologies during the time period 1937-1947. Historical actors were then highlighting that the humanities faced several challenges. The study argues that these discussions should be regarded as parts of a renegotiation of the humanities’ social contract. In the context of the war and fundamental societal changes, there occurred a greater pressure than before to mobilize science socially in order to make science appear as a legitimate undertaking. For the humanities, such demands seemed to conflict with their scientific ethos. During the interwar period this ethos was often based on a norm that demanded the drawing of a strict boundary between science and politics. But if they did not mobilize socially, scholars risked getting blamed for being isolated in the so-called ‘ivory tower’. How the humanities could be effectively mobilized in order to satisfy the needs of society while still maintaining their legitimacy in a scientific context emerged as a fundamental problem with no clear solutions. Part of this problem was the exclusion of the humanities from politically hegemonic narratives of society’s development, in contrast to natural and social sciences. Reactions to specific historical experiences and distinct expectations for the future thus seem – at least on a discursive level – to have put the humanities in a state of marginalization as early as the time period examined in this thesis.
|
213 |
Legitimation of violence against women in Colombia: A feminist critical discourse analytic studyLaura Tolton Unknown Date (has links)
This study analyses the legitimation of violence against women in Colombia, using critical discourse analysis to explore attitudes related to violence, gender, and power. Internet forums from the website of the Colombian newspaper El Tiempo provide everyday examples of talk about two incidents of violence against women (VAW), a sexual assault and a wife-beating, both of which triggered a large scale reaction from the Colombian public. Colombia is a unique context to study the normalisation of VAW. This nation has been characterised by high levels of violence over the last sixty years, suffering through evolving stages of armed conflict. Militarisation has been shown to increase the occurrence of VAW (Kelly, 2000), and the normalisation of VAW may intensify as well in militarily violent contexts (Hume, 2004; McWilliams, 1998). Critical discourse analysis offers theory and methodology to examine an aspect of life in terms of social justice and power (Fairclough, 2003; Resende, 2009), denaturalising the discursive practices which help to produce and reproduce power relations between social groups (Fairclough & Wodak, 1997; van Dijk, 1993). This study examines legitimation, a social action realised in discourse, which has the goal of setting and reinforcing a certain social order. The project also explores how legitimation in these forums is tied to Colombian culture and the topic of VAW. Drawing on the methods of van Dijk (1988, 1998, 2001) ,Wood and Kroger (2000), and grounded theory (Corbin & Strauss, 2008), multiple readings of the forums elicited salient themes as well as discursive strategies used to carry out legitimation of VAW. These were analysed in terms of underlying social beliefs prevailing in Colombian society. Dominant themes emerging from analysis of the sexual assault forums include: ‘“real” violence is more important’; ‘this incident was not a big deal’; ‘it’s her fault anyway’; and ‘she should have appreciated it’. These manifest the dominant strategies and structures of contrasts, minimisation, victim blaming, and romanticisation/sexualisation, respectively. Analysis of the wife-beating forums reveals the following themes: ‘this is not related to me’; ‘wife-beating is a private issue’; ‘domestic violence is normal and even important’; ‘it is the victim’s responsibility to change’; and ‘the victim deserves this violence’. Dominant strategies included respectively: distancing explanations and solutions, discourses of privacy, normalising violence, focusing on the victim, and victim blaming. The forum analyses illustrate how legitimation relates to Colombian culture and the topic of VAW. Numerous elements of culture and topic are used to criticise women’s agency and suggest that women ought to be passive and silent. In one culture-related example, the Colombian reiteration of violent events works to silence women’s stories about their experiences of VAW. Another strong element of culture is found in Colombian sayings and proverbs presenting a common knowledge discourse normalising VAW as romantic, sexual and necessary. Discourses used more universally to justify VAW include the idea that women belong in the private sphere and the psychopathologisation of women as attention-seeking and slutty. These elements work together to suggest that women are strong, sexual, and dangerous, needing violence from an authority to keep them uncomplaining and submissive. This work can inform future studies about discourse concerning VAW in Hispanic contexts, sketching in a little-studied disciplinary intersection. As this research participates in the aims of feminist critical discourse analysis, it is hoped that the present study will also be used for critical campaigns aimed at media specialists and educators so that they may create greater awareness and promote change, pointing out and discouraging these discourses legitimating violence against women in Colombia.
|
214 |
Legitimation of violence against women in Colombia: A feminist critical discourse analytic studyLaura Tolton Unknown Date (has links)
This study analyses the legitimation of violence against women in Colombia, using critical discourse analysis to explore attitudes related to violence, gender, and power. Internet forums from the website of the Colombian newspaper El Tiempo provide everyday examples of talk about two incidents of violence against women (VAW), a sexual assault and a wife-beating, both of which triggered a large scale reaction from the Colombian public. Colombia is a unique context to study the normalisation of VAW. This nation has been characterised by high levels of violence over the last sixty years, suffering through evolving stages of armed conflict. Militarisation has been shown to increase the occurrence of VAW (Kelly, 2000), and the normalisation of VAW may intensify as well in militarily violent contexts (Hume, 2004; McWilliams, 1998). Critical discourse analysis offers theory and methodology to examine an aspect of life in terms of social justice and power (Fairclough, 2003; Resende, 2009), denaturalising the discursive practices which help to produce and reproduce power relations between social groups (Fairclough & Wodak, 1997; van Dijk, 1993). This study examines legitimation, a social action realised in discourse, which has the goal of setting and reinforcing a certain social order. The project also explores how legitimation in these forums is tied to Colombian culture and the topic of VAW. Drawing on the methods of van Dijk (1988, 1998, 2001) ,Wood and Kroger (2000), and grounded theory (Corbin & Strauss, 2008), multiple readings of the forums elicited salient themes as well as discursive strategies used to carry out legitimation of VAW. These were analysed in terms of underlying social beliefs prevailing in Colombian society. Dominant themes emerging from analysis of the sexual assault forums include: ‘“real” violence is more important’; ‘this incident was not a big deal’; ‘it’s her fault anyway’; and ‘she should have appreciated it’. These manifest the dominant strategies and structures of contrasts, minimisation, victim blaming, and romanticisation/sexualisation, respectively. Analysis of the wife-beating forums reveals the following themes: ‘this is not related to me’; ‘wife-beating is a private issue’; ‘domestic violence is normal and even important’; ‘it is the victim’s responsibility to change’; and ‘the victim deserves this violence’. Dominant strategies included respectively: distancing explanations and solutions, discourses of privacy, normalising violence, focusing on the victim, and victim blaming. The forum analyses illustrate how legitimation relates to Colombian culture and the topic of VAW. Numerous elements of culture and topic are used to criticise women’s agency and suggest that women ought to be passive and silent. In one culture-related example, the Colombian reiteration of violent events works to silence women’s stories about their experiences of VAW. Another strong element of culture is found in Colombian sayings and proverbs presenting a common knowledge discourse normalising VAW as romantic, sexual and necessary. Discourses used more universally to justify VAW include the idea that women belong in the private sphere and the psychopathologisation of women as attention-seeking and slutty. These elements work together to suggest that women are strong, sexual, and dangerous, needing violence from an authority to keep them uncomplaining and submissive. This work can inform future studies about discourse concerning VAW in Hispanic contexts, sketching in a little-studied disciplinary intersection. As this research participates in the aims of feminist critical discourse analysis, it is hoped that the present study will also be used for critical campaigns aimed at media specialists and educators so that they may create greater awareness and promote change, pointing out and discouraging these discourses legitimating violence against women in Colombia.
|
215 |
Legitimation of violence against women in Colombia: A feminist critical discourse analytic studyLaura Tolton Unknown Date (has links)
This study analyses the legitimation of violence against women in Colombia, using critical discourse analysis to explore attitudes related to violence, gender, and power. Internet forums from the website of the Colombian newspaper El Tiempo provide everyday examples of talk about two incidents of violence against women (VAW), a sexual assault and a wife-beating, both of which triggered a large scale reaction from the Colombian public. Colombia is a unique context to study the normalisation of VAW. This nation has been characterised by high levels of violence over the last sixty years, suffering through evolving stages of armed conflict. Militarisation has been shown to increase the occurrence of VAW (Kelly, 2000), and the normalisation of VAW may intensify as well in militarily violent contexts (Hume, 2004; McWilliams, 1998). Critical discourse analysis offers theory and methodology to examine an aspect of life in terms of social justice and power (Fairclough, 2003; Resende, 2009), denaturalising the discursive practices which help to produce and reproduce power relations between social groups (Fairclough & Wodak, 1997; van Dijk, 1993). This study examines legitimation, a social action realised in discourse, which has the goal of setting and reinforcing a certain social order. The project also explores how legitimation in these forums is tied to Colombian culture and the topic of VAW. Drawing on the methods of van Dijk (1988, 1998, 2001) ,Wood and Kroger (2000), and grounded theory (Corbin & Strauss, 2008), multiple readings of the forums elicited salient themes as well as discursive strategies used to carry out legitimation of VAW. These were analysed in terms of underlying social beliefs prevailing in Colombian society. Dominant themes emerging from analysis of the sexual assault forums include: ‘“real” violence is more important’; ‘this incident was not a big deal’; ‘it’s her fault anyway’; and ‘she should have appreciated it’. These manifest the dominant strategies and structures of contrasts, minimisation, victim blaming, and romanticisation/sexualisation, respectively. Analysis of the wife-beating forums reveals the following themes: ‘this is not related to me’; ‘wife-beating is a private issue’; ‘domestic violence is normal and even important’; ‘it is the victim’s responsibility to change’; and ‘the victim deserves this violence’. Dominant strategies included respectively: distancing explanations and solutions, discourses of privacy, normalising violence, focusing on the victim, and victim blaming. The forum analyses illustrate how legitimation relates to Colombian culture and the topic of VAW. Numerous elements of culture and topic are used to criticise women’s agency and suggest that women ought to be passive and silent. In one culture-related example, the Colombian reiteration of violent events works to silence women’s stories about their experiences of VAW. Another strong element of culture is found in Colombian sayings and proverbs presenting a common knowledge discourse normalising VAW as romantic, sexual and necessary. Discourses used more universally to justify VAW include the idea that women belong in the private sphere and the psychopathologisation of women as attention-seeking and slutty. These elements work together to suggest that women are strong, sexual, and dangerous, needing violence from an authority to keep them uncomplaining and submissive. This work can inform future studies about discourse concerning VAW in Hispanic contexts, sketching in a little-studied disciplinary intersection. As this research participates in the aims of feminist critical discourse analysis, it is hoped that the present study will also be used for critical campaigns aimed at media specialists and educators so that they may create greater awareness and promote change, pointing out and discouraging these discourses legitimating violence against women in Colombia.
|
216 |
Die Beschwerdekammern der europäischen Agenturen /Dammann, Amina. January 2004 (has links) (PDF)
Univ., Diss.--Frankfurt am Main, 2003.
|
217 |
O discurso no ensino em Saúde: processos comunicacionais e mecanismos de legitimação através de recursos audiovisuais / The speech in the health education: communication processes and mechanisms of legitimation through audiovisual resourcesKudeken, Victoria Sayuri Freire dos Santos 30 October 2017 (has links)
Submitted by VICTÓRIA SAYURI FREIRE DOS SANTOS KUDEKEN null (vick-sayuri@hotmail.com) on 2017-12-21T19:53:15Z
No. of bitstreams: 1
Victória Sayuri Freire dos Santos Kudeken.pdf: 1378516 bytes, checksum: 3293e1e5d002f2713b235ff9d94d21f7 (MD5) / Approved for entry into archive by Minervina Teixeira Lopes null (vina_lopes@bauru.unesp.br) on 2017-12-22T11:55:36Z (GMT) No. of bitstreams: 1
kudeken_vsfs_me_bauru.pdf: 1365340 bytes, checksum: 02d88b3d4a2ccadad4928952bc119cac (MD5) / Made available in DSpace on 2017-12-22T11:55:36Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1
kudeken_vsfs_me_bauru.pdf: 1365340 bytes, checksum: 02d88b3d4a2ccadad4928952bc119cac (MD5)
Previous issue date: 2017-10-30 / O presente estudo tem como objetivo compreender quais são alguns dos mecanismos de legitimação discursiva envolvidos nos processos comunicacionais do curso de Gestão da Qualidade e Segurança do paciente, oferecido pelo Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein (HIAE), na modalidade a distância para um público de profissionais da saúde. Desmembrando a análise em três momentos de configuração narrativa com o foco nos processos de legitimação discursiva, pretende-se responder a seguinte questão: quem discursa no ensino de saúde? Na primeira parte, foram analisados os possíveis discursivos do ensino em saúde, sendo estes o modelo de ensino por competências, a hierarquia no discurso médico e os saberes práticos da equipe de enfermagem. A segunda parte visualizou através dos objetos midiáticos e educacionais como os discursos se materializam no formato do curso. Já o terceiro momento, de refiguração narrativa, expõe o cenário comunicacional contemporâneo, como é construído um leitor/aluno modelo para o material educacional e como funcionam os processos de interação na narrativa do curso. / The present study aims to understand which are some of the mechanisms of discursive legitimation involved in the communicational processes of the Quality and Safety Management course, offered by Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein (HIAE), in distance modality for a professional public of health. Dismembering the analysis into three moments of narrative configuration with the focus on the processes of discursive legitimation, it is intended to answer the following question: who speaks in health education? In the first part, the possible discursives of health education were analyzed, being these the model of teaching by competences, the hierarchy in the medical discourse and the practical knowledge of the nursing. The second part visualized through the media and educational objects how the speeches materialize in the format of the course. The third moment, narrative refiguration, exposes the contemporary communication scenario, how a reader/student model is constructed for the educational material and how the interaction processes work in the course narrative.
|
218 |
EXAME NACIONAL DO ENSINO MÉDIO NO BRASIL: DAS INTENCIONALIDADES ÀS FORMAS DE LEGITIMAÇÃO PELAS ESCOLAS NO JOGO DAS CLASSIFICAÇÕES E DESCLASSIFICAÇÕESNascimento, Juvenilto Soares 14 August 2017 (has links)
Submitted by admin tede (tede@pucgoias.edu.br) on 2017-10-25T16:33:37Z
No. of bitstreams: 1
JUVENILTO SOARES NASCIMENTO.pdf: 1497375 bytes, checksum: 4a4137345fa4ed77ae76dc3e1c1275a4 (MD5) / Made available in DSpace on 2017-10-25T16:33:37Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1
JUVENILTO SOARES NASCIMENTO.pdf: 1497375 bytes, checksum: 4a4137345fa4ed77ae76dc3e1c1275a4 (MD5)
Previous issue date: 2017-08-14 / This research investigates the intentions of the National High School Examination
(ENEM) in contrast to both the forms of apprehension of cultural capital and the
provisions of the game of classifications and declassifications by the school social
agents, expressed by the discourses and strategies employed. For this, Bourdieu's
method of praxiological knowledge was chosen, whose theory served as theoretical
reference and support of data analysis. It was opportune, it was decided that the
object of study should be observed in public schools of the same Federal Unit, which
is why three middle schools of the Distrito Federal were selected, belonging to
Administrative Regions whose socioeconomic conditions are different: High School
(CEM) Piloto Plano, CEM Ceilândia and CEM Recanto das Emas. Aiming at a more
effective field research, it was decided to diversify the instruments and strategies of
data collection: direct observation, with the help of the field diary; application of
questionnaires with open and closed questions; and interviews with semi-structured
script. The investigation had a total of 281 respondents from the questionnaires -
directors, teachers and students - among which 28 of these agents were interviewed.
From the theoretical reference, the discussion dealt with the fundamental logic of the
exams, which is to select and exclude; and unveiled some of the mechanisms that
lead students from privileged classes to achieve a better performance in the Exam.
This is because, besides incorporating in an "osmotic" way a favorable habitus in the
school field, they can employ better strategies against the privileged capitals that
they possess. The data collected were analyzed from the following categories: a)
Acquisition of cultural capital; (b) reproduction and processing strategies; c)
Legitimation and its forms; and d) Resistance. It was identified that three particular
forms of legitimation of the Examination stand out: by the discourse, by the policies
with social acceptance that were attached to it and by the "support" to the students.
As for the policies linked to the ENEM, these have allowed some social advances,
while at the same time reinforcing the legitimacy of the inequalities that still continue
to operate by it. In turn, the results point out that contradictorily the school unit most
affected by the rules of the Exam is the one that most legitimizes it. One of the
factors that confirms this is the race issue. This unit, that of CEM Recanto das Emas,
has 78% of blacks among its students, in contrast to 61% of CEM Plano Piloto and
76% of CEM Ceilândia. However, only 47% of its students approve racial quotas,
compared to 65% of CEM Plano Piloto students' approval and 71% of CEM
Ceilândia. Another factor that confirms more legitimacy for the most penalized school
is the teacher evaluation of the ENEM selection form: 75% of the teachers
participating in CEM Recanto das Emas consider it fair, while 50% of the CEM Plano
Piloto teachers and 62, 5% of CEM Ceilândia teachers consider this. On the other
hand, it should be pointed out that, although the school system is one of the State's
reproductive instruments, the existence of discourses and resistance practices in the
schools investigated suggests that it is possible to fight for a school system whose
political-pedagogical orientation is beyond reproduction. / Esta pesquisa investiga as intencionalidades do Exame Nacional do Ensino Médio
(ENEM) em contraste tanto com as formas de apreensão do capital cultural quanto
com as disposições do jogo das classificações e desclassificações, pelos agentes
sociais escolares, expressas pelos discursos e estratégias empregados. Para tal,
elegeu-se o método do conhecimento praxiológico de Bourdieu, cuja teoria serviu
como referencial teórico e suporte de análise dos dados. Por oportuno, optou-se que
o objeto de estudo fosse observado em escolas públicas de uma mesma Unidade da
Federação, razão pela qual foram selecionadas três escolas de ensino médio do
Distrito Federal, pertencentes a Regiões Administrativas cujas condições
socioeconômicas são distintas: o Centro de Ensino Médio (CEM) Plano Piloto, o
CEM Ceilândia e o CEM Recanto das Emas. Visando a uma pesquisa de campo
mais efetiva, decidiu-se pela diversificação dos instrumentos e estratégias de coleta
de dados: observação direta, com o auxílio do diário de campo; aplicação de
questionários com questões abertas e fechadas; e realização de entrevistas com
roteiro semiestruturado. A investigação contou com o total de 281 respondentes dos
questionários – diretores, professores e estudantes –, dentre os quais 28 desses
agentes foram entrevistados. A partir do referencial teórico, a discussão tratou da
lógica fundamental dos exames, que é selecionar e excluir; e desvelou alguns dos
mecanismos que levam os estudantes oriundos de classes privilegiadas a
alcançarem um melhor rendimento no Exame. Isso porque, além de incorporarem de
maneira “osmótica” um habitus favorável no campo escolar, podem empregar
melhores estratégias face aos capitais privilegiados que possuem. Efetuou-se a
análise dos dados coletados a partir das seguintes categorias: a) Aquisição do
capital cultural; b) Estratégias de reprodução e de transformação; c) Legitimação e
suas formas; e d) Resistência. Identificou-se que se destacam três formas
particulares de legitimação do Exame: pelo discurso, pelas políticas com aceitação
social que se lhe atrelaram e pelo “suporte” aos estudantes. Quanto às políticas
atreladas ao ENEM, essas permitiram alguns avanços sociais, ao mesmo tempo em
que reforçaram a legitimação das desigualdades que ainda continuam operadas por
ele. Por sua vez, os resultados apontam que contraditoriamente a unidade escolar
mais prejudicada pelas regras do Exame é a que mais o legitima. Um dos fatores
que confirma isso é a questão racial. Essa unidade, a do CEM Recanto das Emas,
apresenta entre os seus estudantes o índice de 78% de negros, em contraste com
61% do CEM Plano Piloto e 76% do CEM Ceilândia. No entanto, apenas 47% de
seus estudantes aprovam as cotas raciais, frente aos 65% de aprovação dos
estudantes do CEM Plano Piloto e 71% do CEM Ceilândia. Outro fator que confirma
maior legitimação pela escola mais penalizada é a avaliação docente da forma de
seleção do ENEM: 75% dos professores participantes do CEM Recanto das Emas a
consideram justa, ao passo em que 50% dos professores do CEM Plano Piloto e
62,5% dos professores do CEM Ceilândia assim a consideram. Por outro lado,
destaca-se que, embora o sistema escolar seja um dos instrumentos de reprodução
do Estado, a existência de discursos e práticas de resistência nas escolas
investigadas aponta ser possível sim lutar por um sistema escolar cuja orientação
político-pedagógica seja para além da reprodução.
|
219 |
Processus sociaux de légitimation et pratiques organisationnelles des filiales de firmes multinationales : l'étude des banques étrangères en Inde / Social processes of legitimation and organizational practices of MNE subsidiaries : a study of foreign banks in IndiaCaussat, Paul 22 May 2018 (has links)
L'objectif de cette thèse est d'étudier le rôle des processus sociaux de légitimation sous-jacents au développement local des filiales de firmes multinationales (FMN) dans des environnements lointains du siège. Notre thèse explore la façon dont les filiales tentent de modérer les pressions simultanées issues de leur environnement d'accueil et de leur environnement organisationnel. À partir d'un cadre théorique institutionnaliste fondé sur une littérature pluridisciplinaire. nous étudions la nature des processus de légitimation de huit filiales de banques étrangères en Inde un contexte caractérisé par une forte «Liability of Foreignness» (i.e. LOF : handicap du fait d'être étranger). Nous identifions ensuite les pratiques organisationnelles mobilisées afin de réduire les tensions entre le «central» et le «local». Nos résultats suggèrent que les stratégies de légitimation des filiales -passives (isomorphisme, transfert), réactive (lobbying politique) et proactive (rhétorique)- varient avec le degré d'exposition à la LOF et l'intensité des pressions internes: certaines filiales recherchent un « ancrage local» prononcé tandis que d'autres filiales utilisent plutôt «l'ancrage mondial» en s'appuyant sur la légitimité du siège. Dans un second temps, la thèse développe une estimation de la performance organisationnelle d'une filiale de FMN, en lien avec son processus de légitimation dans l'environnement d'accueil. Les résultats suggèrent qu’un niveau« d'ancrage local» élevé est associé positivement à la performance externe de la filiale et négativement à sa performance interne, ce qui conduit la filiale et le siège à opérer des arbitrages entre performance externe et interne. / The aim of this thesis is to study the role of social processes of legitimation underlying MNE subsidiaries' loci development in distant environments from the headquarters. Our thesis explores how subsidiaries attempt to mitigat simultaneous pressures from both their host and their organizational environments. Using an institutionalist theoretical framework based on a multidisciplinary literature, we investigate the nature of the legitimation processes for eight subsidiaries of foreign banks in India, a context characterized by a strong «Liability of Foreignness» (i.e. LOF). We the identify the organisational practices mobilised in order to decrease the «central/local» tensions. Our results suggest that subsidiaries' legitimation strategies -passive (isomorphism, transference), reactive (political lobbying) and proactive (rhetoric)- vary along with their degree of exposure to the LOF and according to the intensity of internal pressures the face: certain subsidiaries seek a deeper “local anchoring” while other subsidiaries rely more on a “world anchoring” benefitting from the headquarters' legitimacy. In a second development, this thesis sketches an estimate of the organisational performance of an MNE subsidiary in relation to its legitimation process in the host environment. Our results suggest that a higher level of local anchoring' is associated positively with a subsidiary's external performance and negatively with its internal performance. This leads the subsidiary and the headquarters to arbitrage between external and internal performance.
|
220 |
Trois études sur la mesure de la performance des entreprises en matière de développement durable : pouvoir disciplinaire et légitimation / Three studies on the corporate sustainability performance measurement : disciplinary power and legitimationChelli, Mohamed 06 May 2013 (has links)
L’objectif de cette thèse est d’étudier, sous un angle sociologique, la nouvelle pratique de mesure de la performance des entreprises en matière de développement durable. Cette pratique émergente constitue un espace social où s’articulent divers jeux de pouvoir, de confrontation et de résistance de nombre d’acteurs engagés dans le domaine du développement durable. Le premier article présume que l’analyse du discours, socialement construit et constitué, entourant les mesures produites et diffusées (souvent très médiatisées), joue un rôle fondamental dans la compréhension de ladite pratique. En particulier, le discours transmis par les organismes de mesure de la performance socio-environnementale des entreprises, aussi bien dans leurs sites web que dans leurs documents publics, se trouve à promouvoir une idéologie du chiffre qui sous-tend l’exercice d’un certain pouvoir de type disciplinaire sur les entreprises évaluées. En dépit de toutes les ambiguïtés et les incertitudes méthodologiques associées à la pratique de la mesure socio-environnementale, les organismes de mesure s’efforcent de développer et de transmettre un discours, relativement réducteur, pour légitimer leur revendication d’expertise en la matière. Le deuxième article de cette thèse fait état des stratégies de légitimation déployées par les organismes de mesure ainsi que leurs effets disciplinaires sur les entreprises évaluées et les parties prenantes. Il s’agit, dans les faits, du pouvoir disciplinaire et de normalisation de l’idéologie des chiffres qui peut induire certains effets d’autodiscipline dans le champ du développement durable en général. Une telle autodiscipline s’observe également dans le monde universitaire lorsque les gardes-frontières des organisations font pression sur les chercheurs à renoncer à la publication de leurs recherches. Prenant la forme d’une étude méthodologique, le troisième article de la thèse cherche à susciter une réflexion sur les entraves que peut poser le pouvoir des gardiens des organisations, notamment lorsque celui prend la forme de menaces de poursuites judiciaires, sur l’indépendance et la liberté des chercheurs et des universités auxquelles ils se rattachent. / The objective of this dissertation is to examine, under a sociological lens, the new practice of the corporate sustainability performance measurement. This emerging practice seems to be a social space where are structured various games of power, confrontation and resistance of many actors involved in the field of sustainable development. The first paper assumes that discourse analysis, socially constructed and constituted, surrounding measurements produced and disclosed (often highly popularized through the media), plays a fundamental role in the understanding of the practice of corporate sustainability performance measurement. In particular, the discourse transmitted by the sustainability ratings and rankings agencies (SRRA), both on their websites and in their public documents, tends to promote an ideology of numbers that exerts disciplinary power over companies appraised. Despite all the ambiguities and methodological uncertainties associated with the practice of socio-environmental performance measurement, SRRA strive to develop and transmit discourse, quite reductive, to legitimize their claim to expertise in the field. The second paper of this dissertation outlines the legitimation strategies deployed by SRRA and the disciplinary impacts of these strategies on companies scrutinized and stakeholders. Actually, it is the disciplinary power and the normalization power of the ideology of numbers which can induce some effects of self-discipline in the field of sustainable development in general. Such self-discipline is also observed in the academic world when corporate gate-keepers put pressure on researchers to abandon the publication of their research. As a methodological study, the third paper of the dissertation seeks to stimulate reflection on the impediments that the power of the corporate gate-keepers can pose on the independence and the freedom of the researchers and the universities to which they are attached, especially in the case of threats of lawsuits.
|
Page generated in 0.1386 seconds