This thesis deals with the institute of summary preliminary proceedings in the context of past and current legislation and also the reasons that led to its introduction into law. The paper also outlines the objectives of summary proceedings and the use of the institute for other criminal laws. In this work there are also defined summary preliminary proceedings within individual forms of pre-trial proceedings. In some cases, the work compares the above mentioned institute of summary preliminary proceedings with foreign legislation. This study also defines the essence of summary preliminary proceedings and acts carried out in it. At the same time the author tries to define the legal conditions for holding summary preliminary proceedings, further the course of summary preliminary proceedings. The paper also describes the course of summary preliminary proceedings, from the record of initiation of criminal proceedings, to notification about suspicion, further deals with the question of proving evidence in summary proceedings. The paper also discusses in detail the specific entities acting in summary preliminary proceedings. In the description of these entities an analysis of their rights and obligations is simultaneously carried out. Furthermore, the paper describes the various ways of ending summary preliminary...

This thesis deals with education of socially handicapped people in the Czech Republic and in Slovakia. It presents approaches and supporting disposals in both countries. The attention is devoted to actual situation in education of socially handicapped children at various degrees of schools. It describes affirmative actions, such as preliminary classes, education assistants in the Czech Republic or zero grades, education assistants and daylong education system in Slovakia. The thesis also sums up several projects focused on socially handicapped, one project focused on Roma children support realized in the Czech republic, three projects focused on education of socially handicapped, their parents' and educators' support, realized in middle Slovakia in years 2011-2015. KEYWORDS education, social handicap, Roma people, affirmative action, preliminary class, education assistant, daylong education system

This thesis provides a means to estimate the physical and performance characteristics of a preliminary cruise ship design. The techniques utilized to estimate these characteristics are showcased in the user-friendly interface known as the Cruise Ship Analysis Tool (CSAT). Using the CSAT, the implications that design feature decisions in the preliminary design stage have on a cruise ship’s profitability is analyzed. Then, the most profitable design feature assemblage among a finite number of varying design feature combinations is estimated and compared among cruise ship designs with different passenger carrying capacities. Profitability is analyzed using the measure of merit (MOM) known as net present value (NPV). If a preliminary cruise ship design has a positive NPV at a reliable rate of return and ship operating life, the design is considered to be a profitable investment if implemented. The greater the NPV, the more profitable the investment is considered to be.

La conception de systèmes mécaniques, de par son aspect pluridisciplinaire et technologique, fait intervenir et interagir différentes personnes qui travaillent et prennent des décisions ensemble, et, participent ensemble à l’élaboration du produit. Elles travaillent de manière collaborative cependant elles ne se connaissent pas obligatoirement, ne se situent pas forcément géographiquement sur un site commun, n’ont peut-être pas la même culture et n’appartiennent pas systématiquement à la même entreprise. La conception préliminaire représente les premières phases du cycle de conception ou le produit est en cours de définition. Le nombre d’incertitudes sur les paramètres et les informations produit sont très importantes. Il y a un manque de connaissances important à cette étape du processus de conception qui doit être considéré afin d’améliorer et d’aider les prises de décisions dans les phases amonts. C’est ce manque de connaissances que je me propose de qualifier et caractériser en apportant une réponse à la question résultante: comment prendre en compte le manque de connaissances pour prendre des décisions durant la conception préliminaire collaborative ? Pour se faire, nous proposons un méta-modèle de connaissances permettant de structurer les informations du produit et les connaissances en intégrant la maturité du produit. Cette maturité est définie par une métrique et permet d’identifier le niveau de connaissances des concepteurs sur le produit et d’orienter la prise de décision grâce à l’utilisation d’une approche mixte, à la fois qualitative et quantitative. Enfin, nous évaluerons la capacité de ce méta-modèle à générer différent modèles produit, puis sa pertinence avec l’implémentation sur un cas industriel. / The design of mechanical systems, due to their multi-disciplinary and technological aspects, involves different people who, together, work and make decisions and jointly participate in the development of the product. They work in a collaborative manner; however, they may have different strategies, geographical positions, cultures and do not know the other members of the team. Preliminary design represents the early stages of the design cycle or product definition. A number of uncertainties regarding the parameters and product information are very important. There is an important lack of knowledge at this stage of the design process that must be managed or filled in order to improve and support the decision making in the early phases. It is this lack of knowledge that I propose to qualify and characterise, providing an answer to the question: how does one to take into account the lack of knowledge in decision making during the preliminary design collaboration? To do so, we propose a meta-model for structuring product information and knowledge by integrating product maturity. A metric allows this maturity to be defined, to identify the level of knowledge of the product designers and to guide the decision making, thanks to the use of a qualitative and quantitative approach. Finally, we evaluate the ability of the meta-model to generate the different models produced and its relevance to the implementation in an industrial case.

O presente trabalho tem como objetivo desenvolver processos analíticos e programas computacionais para avaliação da estabilidade global e pré-dimensionamento de pórticos planos em concreto pré-moldado com base na garantia da estabilidade global. Em relação à avaliação da estabilidade global, são propostas duas expressões. A primeira está relacionada à expressão do limite do parâmetro de estabilidade aplicada a pórticos planos em concreto pré-moldado. A segunda expressão tem o objetivo determinar o deslocamento horizontal de topo de pórticos planos em concreto pré-moldado de um pavimento. A expressão do limite alternativo do parâmetro de estabilidade é deduzida a partir dos valores obtidos da relação entre o deslocamento horizontal médio e de topo de 1320 pórticos. A expressão é função do fator de restrição da ligação, contemplando, dessa forma, os efeitos causados pela semirrígidez das ligações no comportamento da estabilidade global desse sistema estrutural. A equação de determinação do deslocamento horizontal de topo de pórticos planos em concreto pré-moldado de um pavimento é deduzida com base no método dos deslocamentos. Em relação ao pré-dimensionamento de pórticos planos em concreto pré-moldado, são propostos processos analíticos para o pré-dimensionamento dos pilares de pórticos de um pavimento com ligação semirrígida e de pórticos de múltiplos pavimentos com ligações rígidas e articuladas. Os processos analíticos são constituídos pela expressão da rigidez equivalente de estabilidade de pórticos, desenvolvida através das equações do parâmetro de estabilidade e do seu limite alternativo. O trabalho ainda apresenta o Programa de Avaliação da Estabilidade Global e Pré-dimensionamento de Pórticos Planos em Concreto Pré-moldado, denominado PRE-MOLDIM. O programa é constituído por quatro módulos. O primeiro módulo realiza a avaliação da estabilidade global e verificação da deslocabilidade lateral de pórticos planos em concreto pré-moldado. O segundo módulo tem o objetivo de definir as dimensões mínimas dos pilares em função da garantia da estabilidade global e do deslocamento lateral admissível. O terceiro módulo define o valor da rigidez das ligações necessário para que sejam atendidos os quesitos de estabilidade global e deslocamento lateral admissível. O quarto módulo realiza o dimensionamento da armadura de continuidade de uma típica ligação viga-pilar em concreto pré-moldado. O dimensionamento da armadura de continuidade é realizado em função da garantia da estabilidade global e do deslocamento lateral admissível de pórticos planos em concreto pré-moldado. A aplicação dos processos analíticos e programas computacionais em exemplos comprovaram, de forma satisfatória, o desempenho de suas funções. Os valores obtidos pela expressão alternativa do limite do parâmetro de estabilidade são compatíveis com o limite do coeficiente \'gama\'z. Os valores do deslocamento de topo de pórticos de um pavimento com ligações semirrígidas, obtidos pelo processo analítico, são próximos dos valores obtidos pela simulação numérica. Os pilares pré-dimensionados pelos processos analíticos conseguem garantir de forma satisfatória estabilidade global dos pórticos planos em concreto pré-moldado. / The present work aims to develop analytical processes and computer programs for the evaluation of global stability and preliminary design of plane frames in precast concrete based on ensuring global stability. Regarding the evaluation of global stability, two analytical expressions are proposed. The first is related to the expression of the limit of the stability parameter applied to plane frames in precast concrete. The second expression has the objective to determine the horizontal displacement of the top of plane frames in precast concrete for a floor. The expression of the alternative stability limit of the parameter is deduced from the values obtained from the relationship between the average and the top horizontal displacement of 1320 frames. The expression is a function of the limiting factor of the connection, thus contemplating the effects caused by the semi-rigidity of the connection on the global stability behavior of this structural system. The equation for determining the horizontal displacement of the top of plane frames in precast concrete pavement is obtained based on the displacement method. Regarding the preliminary design of plane frames in precast concrete, analytical procedures are proposed for the preliminary design of column of an one store frame with semi-rigid connection and a multiple store frames with rigid and articulated connections. The analytical processes are constituted by the expression of equivalent stiffness of frame stability, developed through the equations of the stability parameter and its alternative limit. The work also presents the Program of Global Stability Evaluation and Preliminary Design of Plane Frames in Precast Concrete, called PRE-MOLDIM. The program consists of four modules. The first module performs the evaluation of global stability and verification of lateral plane frames displaceability in precast concrete. The second module aims to set minimum dimensions for the pillars due to guarantee the global stability and check the allowable lateral displacement. The third module defines the value of the connections stiffness so the matter of global stability and allowable lateral displacement are satisfied. The fourth module performs the design of continuity armor of a typical beam-column connection in precast concrete. The design armour continuity is made on the basis of ensuring the global stability and lateral displacement allowable plane frames in precast concrete. The application of analytical processes and computer programs in examples proved satisfactorily, the performance of its functions. The values obtained by the alternative expression of the limit of stability parameter are compatible with the limit of the coefficient \'gama\'z. The offset values top venting a pavement with semi-rigid connections, obtained by the analytical process, are close to the values obtained by numerical simulation. The preliminary designed pillars by analytical processes can ensure a satisfactory global stability of the plane frames in precast concrete.

Cette recherche porte sur le développement d'une méthode d'estimation de la qualité environnementale afin d'assister l'éco-conception. Nous avons nommé cette méthode Éco-Profil. Nous nous sommes attachés plus singulièrement à développer un outil adapté aux particularités de la conception architecturale, l'objectif étant de favoriser une (re)mise en question environnementale le plus tôt possible dans le processus de conception. Après avoir exploré différentes approches et outils d'assistance environnementale, nous avons identifié les limites qui expliquent, en partie, les difficultés de ces outils à être intégrés dans la conception architecturale. Certaines phases de conception semblent ne bénéficier que de peu d'assistance, notamment les étapes préliminaires. Pourtant nous savons qu'elles sont essentielles à l'intégration des enjeux environnementaux. Nous proposons une méthode pour assister l'ensemble de la conception architecturale en réponse aux limites identifiées. Une approche estimative par référentiel est mise en place. Elle comporte la particularité d'être globale, qualitative, contextualisé et progressive et possède une instrumentation visuelle analysable. C'est notamment ces caractéristiques qui permettent l'utilisation de la méthode lors des phases de conception en proposant au concepteur le ou les profils environnementaux de son projet. Le développement d'une application prototype nous a conduits à une expérimentation d'Éco-profil. Différents tests ont largement confirmé les hypothèses formulées et la pertinence de la méthode proposée / This research concerns the development of a method to estimate the environmental quality to assist eco-design in architecture. We named this method « Éco-Profil ». We focused more particularly to develop o toot adapted the specificities of architectural design, the aim is to promote environmental challenge as early as possible in the design process. After exploring various approaches and tools for environmental assistance, we have identified some limitations that explain, in part, the difficulties of integration in architectural design. Some phases of design seem appear to get that bit of assistance, including the preliminary stages. Yet they appear to be essential to the integration of environmental issues. We propose a method to assist the overall architectural design in response to the identified limitations. A assessment method per referential is set up, which has the distinction of being comprehensive, qualitative, contextualized and progressive and which has a analysable visual instrumentation. This is particularly this features that allow the use of the method in the design phases and thus provide environmental profiles to the designer. The development of visual tools and an application led us to experiment « Éco-Profil ». These tests have largely confirmed the assumptions made and the relevance of the proposed method

A avaliação de impactos ambientais (AIA) se tornou uma ferramenta amplamente utilizada para análise da viabilidade ambiental de novos empreendimentos e conseqüente subsídio à tomada de decisão nos procedimentos de licenciamento ambiental. Neste sentido, a Secretaria do Meio Ambiente do Estado de São Paulo editou a Resolução SMA nº 42/94, instituindo o relatório ambiental preliminar (RAP) como instrumento de licenciamento ambiental simplificado. Este instrumento foi criado com a intenção de agilizar a tramitação do licenciamento das atividades modificadoras do meio ambiente, incluindo algumas das previstas no artigo 2º da Resolução CONAMA nº 01/86 e, ao mesmo tempo, garantir que os objetivos de prevenção e preservação ambiental sejam assegurados. Como forma de analisar a utilização deste instrumento no licenciamento ambiental de sistemas de distribuição de gás no Estado de São Paulo foram elaboradas três diferentes listas de checagem cujos indicadores buscam, respectivamente, aferir quanto ao atendimento dos requisitos legais, identificar a ocorrência de falhas na elaboração de estudos de avaliação de impacto ambiental e analisar a conformidade de estudos de impacto ambiental com as melhores práticas nacionais e internacionais de AIA. Estes indicadores foram aplicados aos RAPs de sistemas de distribuição de gás elaborados nos anos de 2006 e 2007, num total de dois estudos de caso, o RAP do Sistema de Distribuição de Gás Lins/Marília e o RAP do Sistema de Distribuição de Gás Bauru/Agudos/Pederneiras. Os resultados obtidos demonstram que para ambos os casos analisados: (i) o RAP elaborado não atende adequadamente os requisitos legais definidos pela Secretaria de Meio Ambiente do Estado de São Paulo; (ii) o número de falhas identificadas nos estudos é bastante significativo, com falhas ocorrendo em 83,5% das questões analisadas para o RAP do Gasoduto Lins/Marília e em 89,5% para o RAP do Gasoduto Bauru/Agudos/Pederneiras; (iii) salvo questões pontuais, os estudos de caso analisados estão muito aquém das melhores práticas nacionais e internacionais de AIA, com 76% de resultados insatisfatórios para o RAP do Gasoduto Lins/Marília e 83,5% para o RAP do Gasoduto Bauru/Agudos/Pederneiras. Os resultados obtidos demonstraram que o RAP é um estudo bastante precário para dar subsídio ao licenciamento. É possível identificar uma série de questões de grande relevância para uma adequada tomada de decisão quanto à viabilidade ambiental de empreendimentos que não são exigidas para a efetivação do licenciamento ambiental intermediado por RAP. Desta forma, fica explicita a necessidade de uma revisão do sistema de licenciamento ambiental paulista, como forma de induzir estudos mais bem elaborados e com conteúdo mais abrangente, em consonância com as melhores práticas de AIA adotadas em todo o mundo. / The environmental impact assessment (EIA) become a tool widely used to analysis the environmental suitability of new activities and subsidy the decision making process for the expedition of environmental licensing. In this case, the Secretariat of the Environment from the State of São Paulo edited the resolution number 42/94 instituting the preliminary environmental report (PER), like an simplified instrument of environmental licensing. This instrument was created with the intention of accelerate the transaction of the environmental licensing process for activities with potential to modify the environment, including the foreseen ones in the article 2° of the CONAMA Resolution number 01/86 and, at the same time, to guaranty that the goals of the environmental prevention and preservation are assured. As form to analyze the use of this instrument in the environmental licensing of natural gas pipeline in the State of São Paulo, three different checklists had been elaborated to survey, respectively, the attendance of the legal requirements, to identify the occurrence of the nonconformities in the elaboration of studies of environmental impact assessment and analyze the conformity of environmental impact assessment studies with national and the international best practices in EIA. These elaborated indicators had been applied to the RAPs in the years of 2006 and 2007, in a total of two case studies, the PER of Lins/Marília Gas Line and the PER of Bauru/Agudos/Pederneiras Gas Line. The gotten results demonstrate that for both the analyzed cases: (I) the elaborated PER do not achieve adequately the legal requirements of the Secretariat of Environment of the State of São Paulo; (II) the number of imperfections identified in the studies are very significant, with imperfections occurring in 83,5% of the analyzed questions for the PER of the Lins/Marília Gas Pipeline and in 89,5% for the PER of the Bauru/Agudos/Pederneiras Gas Pipeline; (III) the case studies analyzed are very far from the national and international EIA best practices, with 76% of unsatisfactory results for the PER of Lins/Marília Gas Pipeline and 83.5% for the PER of Bauru/Agudos/Pederneiras Gas Pipeline. The gotten results had demonstrated that the PER is a very precarious instrument of licensing. Is possible to identify series of questions from a great relevance for the decision making process who are not effectively achieved. In such a way, it is explicit the necessity of a revision of the São Paulos environmental licensing system, as a way for more accordance with EIA best practices.

Made available in DSpace on 2016-04-26T20:24:10Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 Rodrigo Ramos.pdf: 1460017 bytes, checksum: ba0722d39d125b403671868fa24bae0a (MD5) Previous issue date: 2016-02-16 / The current study aims at analyzing the institute of provisional injuction of evidence, in the way it is set and ruled in the new Brazilian Civil Procedure Code (CPC), covering concepts, hypotheses of its incidence and legal discipline. The provisional injunction of evidence is a technique that aims to the isonomic redistribution of time in the process, giving enforceability, regardless of urgency, to the main or side effects of the final injuction, prior to the beginning of its natural effectiveness. In the course of this research, will be approached the fundamental procedural institutes related to the topic, the general aspects of the provisional injunction, the constitutional basis of the measures and its functional profile, analyzing the burden of time in the process and the possibility of redistribution through the anticipation technique. Shall be searched the concept of evidence and injuction of evidence, and be examined the four hypotheses set out in article 311 of the new CPC, as well as those set out in special procedures. Finally, the various aspects related to their discipline will be analyzed, beginning by those who apply the guidelines relating to the provisional injunction of urgency and ending with those in which the discipline is in some modified because of the absence of urgency. From the analysis of these aspects, it aims to draw up a general framework concerning provisional injuction of evidence, positioning it opposite to other theoretical categories of civil procedural and outlining the practical aspects of its application / O objetivo do presente trabalho é analisar o instituto da tutela provisória de evidência, na forma como está previsto e disciplinado no novo Código de Processo Civil brasileiro (CPC), abrangendo conceituação, hipóteses de cabimento e regime jurídico. A tutela antecipada de evidência é técnica que visa a redistribuição isonômica do tempo no processo, conferindo executividade, independentemente do requisito da urgência, aos efeitos principais ou secundários da tutela final, em momento anterior ao do início de sua eficácia natural. No decorrer do trabalho, serão abordados os institutos processuais fundamentais relacionados ao tema, os aspectos gerais da tutela antecipada, o fundamento constitucional da medida e seu perfil funcional, analisando-se o ônus do tempo no processo e a possibilidade de sua redistribuição, por meio da técnica da antecipação. Buscar-se-á a fixação do conceito de evidência e de tutela de evidência e se examinarão as quatro hipóteses de cabimento previstas no art. 311 do novo CPC, bem como as estabelecidas nos procedimentos especiais. Por fim, serão analisados os diversos aspectos relacionados à sua disciplina, iniciando-se por aqueles em que aplicáveis as regras gerais relacionadas à antecipação de tutela e encerrando-se com aqueles em que a disciplina é, de alguma forma, modificada em razão da ausência de urgência. A partir da análise dos aspectos referidos, pretende-se a elaboração de um quadro-geral a respeito da tutela provisória de evidência, posicionando-a em face das demais categorias teóricas do processo civil e delineando-se os aspectos práticos principais

Submitted by PPG Direito (ppgdir@pucrs.br) on 2018-06-25T15:39:42Z No. of bitstreams: 1 MARINA_DAMASCENO_DIS.pdf: 1287729 bytes, checksum: d08b6177aa2b3735020a5895f295cda2 (MD5) / Approved for entry into archive by Sheila Dias (sheila.dias@pucrs.br) on 2018-06-29T17:04:41Z (GMT) No. of bitstreams: 1 MARINA_DAMASCENO_DIS.pdf: 1287729 bytes, checksum: d08b6177aa2b3735020a5895f295cda2 (MD5) / Made available in DSpace on 2018-06-29T17:11:41Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 MARINA_DAMASCENO_DIS.pdf: 1287729 bytes, checksum: d08b6177aa2b3735020a5895f295cda2 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2018-02-27 / Conselho Nacional de Pesquisa e Desenvolvimento Cient?fico e Tecnol?gico - CNPq / The present dissertation aims to analyze the jurisdictional policies that assist in the construction of a consensus culture. In order to do so, it critically investigates the propositions used in the preliminary hearing of conciliation or mediation brought by the Civil Procedure Code of 2015 (CPC/15). From a deductive approach method, starting from the ideas related to the transformation occurred in the society and, consequently, going through the consolidation of new forms to regulate litigation ? adequate methods of conflicts resolution ? concluding with the analysis of the preliminary hearing that aims the reach of consensus, foreseen in article 334 of the CPC/15. It can be concluded that a culture of consensus is not achieved by imposing a legal device, but through policies that effectively encourage its application, which cannot be restricted solely to the Judiciary. Therefore, the preliminary hearing, in essence, is beneficial to the realization of a jurisdictional policy, once it allows a consensual dialogue before a statement of defense is offered. If critically considered the models exposed by the legislator, there is a distortion in its arguments, which in article 334 prioritize the reduction of numbers through a legal imposition, thereby becoming indifferent or even harmful its application, as it ends up being considered only a mere procedural step. / A presente disserta??o tem por objeto a an?lise das pol?ticas jurisdicionais que auxiliam na constru??o de uma cultura do consenso. Para tanto, investiga criticamente as proposi??es utilizadas na audi?ncia preliminar de concilia??o ou media??o trazida pelo C?digo de Processo Civil de 2015 (CPC/15). A partir de um m?todo dedutivo de abordagem, partindo das ideias relativas ? transforma??o na sociedade e, consequentemente, ? consolida??o de novas formas de regula??o de lit?gios ? meios adequados de resolu??o de conflitos ? at? a an?lise da audi?ncia preliminar com vistas ao consenso, prevista no artigo 334 do CPC/15. Conclui-se que uma cultura voltada ao consenso n?o se concretiza com a imposi??o de um dispositivo legal, mas por meio de pol?ticas que efetivamente incentivem sua aplica??o, as quais n?o podem estar restritas unicamente ao Poder Judici?rio. Diante disso, por mais que referida audi?ncia, em sua ess?ncia, mostre-se ben?fica ? concretiza??o de uma pol?tica jurisdicional, uma vez que possibilita um di?logo consensual antes do oferecimento da contesta??o. Se considerados criticamente os moldes expostos pelo legislador, h? uma distor??o em seus fundamentos, os quais, no artigo 334, priorizam a diminui??o de n?meros por meio de uma imposi??o legal, tornando-se, desse modo, sua aplica??o indiferente ou at? mesmo prejudicial, na medida em que acaba por transform?-la, muitas vezes, em mera etapa processual.

A medida cautelar e a antecipação de tutela são espécies do mesmo gênero de tutela jurisdicional. A doutrina diverge quanto à diferença dos dois institutos. Ambas exercem a mesma função de garantir a efetividade da tutela jurisdicional. Projeto do novo Código de Processo Civil disciplina conjuntamente as atuais medidas cautelares e a antecipação de tutela. Elas são essenciais para a tutela jurisdicional do direito ao meio ambiente ecologicamente equilibrado porque o dano ambiental frequentemente é irreparável ou de difícil reparação. A Constituição Federal de 1988 garantiu a autonomia do direito ambiental no direito brasileiro, que tem princípios e regras próprios. O princípio da precaução tem especial relevância no direito ambiental porque visa mitigar ou eliminar o risco de dano, ainda que não haja certeza científica. O princípio da precaução é aplicado por diversos institutos do direito administrativo, como o licenciamento ambiental. Se a proteção do meio ambiente pelo Poder Executivo e pelo Poder Legislativo não for suficiente, é cabível tutela jurisdicional. As ações coletivas e as ações de controle concentrado de constitucionalidade são adequadas para a proteção do meio ambiente. A tutela de urgência, que pode ser concedida nas referidas ações, é um dos instrumentos para garantir a efetividade do princípio da precaução para a proteção do meio ambiente, pois pode evitar o dano ambiental no curso do processo judicial. / The preliminary injunction and the provisional injunction are species of the same genus to judicial review. The doctrine diverges as the difference between the two institutes. Both perform the same function of ensuring the effectiveness of the remedy. Design of the new Code of Civil Procedure jointly governs the current preliminary injunction and provisional injunction. They are essential to judicial protection of the right to an ecologically balanced environment because environmental damage is often irreparable or difficult to repair. The Federal Constitution of 1988 guaranteed the autonomy of environmental law in Brazilian law which has own rules and principle. Precautionary principle has particular relevance in environmental law because it seeks to mitigate or eliminate the risk of damage, although there is no scientific certainty. Precautionary principle is applied by various institutes of administrative law, such as environmental licensing. If the protection of the environment by the Executive Branch and the Legislative Branch is not sufficient, it is appropriate jurisdictional tutelage. The class actions and actions for declaration of constitutionality and unconstitutionality are suitable for protecting the environment. The preliminary injunction, which may be granted in such actions, is one of the instruments to ensure the effectiveness of the precautionary principle to protect the environment because it can avoid environmental damage during the judicial proceedings.