À la lecture d’ouvrages philosophiques anciens, nous sommes souvent surpris par la virulence des critiques adressées à l’écriture, dans la mesure où ces critiques nous parviennent au moyen de textes écrits. N’est-il pas paradoxal de tout à la fois rejeter et utiliser une même technologie ? Ou est-ce que les pratiques de l’oralité et de l’écriture des philosophes grecs, telles que ceux-ci les décrivent dans leurs ouvrages, peuvent être cohérentes avec leurs critiques ? Notre thèse visait, d’une part, à répondre à ce questionnement en confrontant les pratiques des philosophes anciens aux critiques qu’ils adressent à l’écriture, par le biais d’une étude systématique des discours sur la lecture et l’écriture dans des textes anciens d’auteurs et d’époques variés, et notamment des textes qui n’ont pas l’écriture pour objet. D’autre part, comme les travaux déjà publiés sur ce thème tentaient le plus souvent de trouver le point de rupture entre la tradition orale et la tradition écrite (cf. Havelock 1963, Lentz 1989), nous avons voulu inscrire notre objet d’étude dans une plus longue durée, ce qui nous a permis de constater qu’une rupture radicale entre les philosophes de tradition orale et ceux appartenant à la tradition écrite n’avait pas eu lieu, et que l’on observait plutôt une continuité des critiques et des pratiques de l’oralité et de l’écriture depuis l’époque classique jusqu’à l’Antiquité tardive. Malgré le développement de nouveaux supports matériels pour l’écriture, l’émergence d’une religion du livre, et la mise à l’écrit des poèmes homériques, la tradition philosophique grecque témoigne d’un usage circonspect de l’écriture et du refus de rejeter définitivement l’oralité. / When we read ancient philosophical works, often we are surprised to find that the Greek philosophers strongly criticize literacy, as we are still confronted with a written text. Is it not paradoxical to reject a technology while still using it? Or is the philosophers’ practice of literacy, as described in their works, consistent with their criticism? Is the philosophers’ practice of literacy, as described in their works, consistent with their criticism of it? This thesis aims to answer these questions, firstly, by comparing the ancient philosophers’ criticism of literacy to their practice of it, through the study of what various authors from various periods say about reading and writing. On the other hand, since earlier works on this topic have proposed that the classical period witnessed a sudden and, to a certain extent, definitive turn to literacy, and have tried to locate this turn in time, I have examined the situation in a broader perspective, over a longer period of time. The results show that, if we consider how philosophers criticize literacy and how they describe themselves in their own discourses, literacy patterns tended to remain similar until late Antiquity; and that, in spite of Aristotle's new use of literacy, the criticism we find in Plato lingers on. As a result, what we usually call the transition from an oral tradition to a written tradition could be better viewed as a cultural continuity. In spite of the commitment to writing recording of the Homeric poems, of the emerging of a book-centered religion, and notwithstanding an evident use of literacy, the ancient philosophical tradition testifies to a refusal, both theoretical and practical, of throwing away orality.

Le présent mémoire se penche sur la dramaturgie que mettent en scène le Banquet et le Phédon de Platon. Dans le cas du premier dialogue, une étude de l'épilogue et du discours d'Alcibiade, assortie de parallèles ponctuels dans la République et la Lettre VII, permet de déceler un exemple de la rétention d'information platonicienne, telle que comprise sous l'égide des écoles platoniciennes de Tübingen et de Milan, de même qu'une attestation de l'existence de doctrines non-écrites qualitativement supérieures à celles que renferment les dialogues. L'épilogue du Banquet fait ensuite, à la lumière des conclusions susmentionnées, l'objet d'une interprétation qui distingue trois niveaux de lecture des dialogues platoniciens : l'extériorité, l'intériorité et l'oralité philosophique, symbolisées respectivement par le poète comique Aristophane, le poète tragique Agathon et le poète philosophique Socrate. Il va de soi que ce dernier renvoie sémantiquement au philosophe par excellence, titre que Platon endosse volontiers. L'essai exégétique touchant le Phédon se concentre pour sa part sur la dernière volonté de Socrate. Celle-ci survient au dénouement de la partie la plus « dramaturgique » du dialogue, c'est-à-dire après les discours proprement philosophiques sur l'immortalité de l'âme. En ciblant ces moments, de même que l'introduction, nous distinguons l'adjonction des tons tragique et comique, illustrant par là un procédé inhabituel dont le but, ultimement, est de soustraire le dialogue au registre tragique afin d'éviter la propagation d'émotions contraires à la philosophie. En exploitant l'oxymore comique-tragique sur un plan mimétique, nous montrerons que la dernière volonté de Socrate véhicule un dessein parénétique. / The present work has as its main focus Plato's dramaturgy in the Symposium and the Phaedo. The former studies both Alcibiades' speech and the epilogue whilst paralleling some of their elements with relevant passages from the Republic and the Seventh Letter. In doing so, it reveals an instance of Socratic withholding of information - as understood by the platonic school of Tübingen and Milan - and sheds light upon the existence of a set of unwritten doctrines philosophically higher than the ones contained in the dialogues. On the basis of these conclusions, I come to discern a hermeneutics in the epilogue according to which there are three hierarchical levels of comprehension to Plato's dialogues: exteriority, interiority of and oral philosophy - said three levels being symbolised by the comic poet Aristophanes, the tragic poet Agathon and the philosopher Socrates. The exegetic essay on the Phaedo revolves around Socrates' last will, which comes at the end of a ''dramatic'' sequence exceeding the bounds of the discursive philosophy that seeks to prove the immortality of the soul during the major part of the dialogue. By aiming at this sequence as well as at the introduction, one comes to see that comedy carries the mandate of counterbalancing tragedy in order to overcome the philosophically reprehensible emotions it fosters. Whilst contrasting tragedy and comedy, Socrates' last words fulfill, on a mimetic level, a paraenetic design, insofar as they invite the Athenian reader, indeed every reader, to philosophically overcome common places in regards to death.

Depuis le début du vingtième siècle, une poésie écrite fait entendre dans l’ensemble des Amériques la voix des personnes d’origine africaine ; ce phénomène est distinctement moderne, dans la mesure où une telle voix était jusqu’alors impensable dans un champ littéraire conçu selon des termes peu conciliables avec l’idée d’une perspective propre à un groupe social ou ethnique. De la « Harlem Renaissance » des années 1920 au « negrismo » cubain, du « Teatro Experimental do Negro » brésilien au « Black Arts Movement » nord-américain ou au « Caribbean Artists Movement » caribéen, nombreux ont été les moments de manifestation de cette quête d’une voix noire en poésie. L’appropriation par les poètes de pratiques orales, en particulier, a joué un rôle moteur dans l’émergence de cette communauté de discours poétique transnationale. L’objectif de ce travail est d’interroger les apports méthodologiques de la littérature comparée dans l’éclaircissement des enjeux proprement littéraires de cette poésie moderne des « Amériques noires ». / From the early Twentieth Century on, a written poetry has been carrying in the entire Americas the voice of people of African descent; this phenomenon is distinctively modern, as far as such a voice had until then been unconceivable within a literary field conceived in terms that were hardly compatible with the very idea of a perspective proper to one particular social or ethnic group. From the “Harlem Renaissance” of the 1920s to the Cuban “negrismo”, from the Brazilian “Teatro Experimental do Negro” to the “Black Arts Movement” or the “Caribbean Artists Movement”, there have been numerous manifestations of this quest of a Black poetic voice. The poets’ appropriation of oral practices, in particular, played a dynamic role in the appearance of this transnational poetic community of discourse.. The aim of this work is to question the methodological benefits of comparative literature in the clarification of what is at stake literarily speaking in this modern poetry of the “Black Americas”.

O presente trabalho se propõe a buscar identificar se existe relação entre a recorribilidade das decisões interlocutórias e a efetividade da tutela jurisdicional, de modo a compreender se as alterações legislativas a que vem sendo submetido o regime de agravo serão eficazes para resolver o problema da excessiva duração do processo. Para tanto, analisa-se o papel dos recursos no sistema processual, a necessidade do recurso de agravo, a relação entre o agravo e a preclusão de questões, o princípio da oralidade (que tem como subprincípio a irrecorribilidade em separado das decisões interlocutórias), e conceitos básicos sobre a efetividade. Ao final, procura-se responder ao questionamento a partir da análise comparativa das disciplinas do agravo a partir do Código de Processo Civil de 1939. / The present work aims to identify if there is a connection between interlocutory orders appealability and judicial effectiveness, in order to understand whether legislative modification to which the discipline of the appeal (agravo) has undergone will be able to solve the problem of the processs excessive duration. To that purpose, the role of the appeal against interlocutory orders (agravo) will be analysed, as well as its necessity and the connection between such remedy and issue preclusion, the orality principle (and its sub principle, the unnapeallability of interlocutory orders), and basic concepts about effectiveness. At the end, it the primary question is answered by also comparing the discipline of the appeal against interlocutory orders since the Code of Civil Procedure, 1939.

Este trabalho propõe-se a examinar as duas versões francesas de Grande Sertão: Veredas, separadas por um intervalo de quase trinta anos, e verificar como elas procuram recuperar a poética roseana. Para tanto, discute-se, com o auxílio dos críticos de sua obra e do próprio Guimarães Rosa em sua correspondência com seus tradutores, em que consiste essa língua especial que é o português-brasileiro-mineiro-guimarãesroseano, em que falado e escrito, realidade e ficção, prosa e poesia, sujeito e objeto são indissociáveis. A impossibilidade de submeter a escrita de Rosa a essas categorias estanques levou-nos a eleger o ritmo, tal como elaborado por Henri Meschonnic, como o conceito que poderia nos guiar nas análises das traduções do romance de Rosa. Desvendando o sujeito como ponto crucial do ritmo, Meschonnic recoloca todo escrito literário e toda tradução em sua história, fazendo-nos entender que os conceitos de poética que os regem são ligados às representações que certa época tem de literatura. A partir das críticas de imprensa, procuramos então reconhecer o universo literário peculiar que acolheu cada uma das versões de Grande Sertão: Veredas na França, para finalmente observar como cada tradução é manifestação da leitura historicizada da obra. / This work intends to examine the two French translations of Grande Sertão: Veredas, one coming out almost thirty years after the other, and to find out how they strive to restore Rosean poetry. Counting on Rosas critics and Rosa himself through correspondence with his translators, this research discusses what that special language, the Rosean-Mineiro-Brazilian-Portuguese consists of, a language in which spoken and written, fiction and reality, prose and poetry, subject and object are inseparable. The impossibility of subordinating Rosas writings to such fixed categories led us to select rhythm, as accounted by Henri Meschonnic, as the concept which could guide us in the analysis of Rosas novels translations. Disclosing subject as a crucial point of rhythm, Meschonnic places all writings and all translations back into their history, allowing us to understand that concepts of the poetic which rule them are connected to each historical times own representations of literature. From the press critiques, we seek to identify the particular literary universe that welcomed each of Grande Sertão: Veredas translations in France in order to finally point out that each of them is an expression of a historicized reading of the novel.

Considerando a importância de tornar a educação e a prática docente mais próximas à realidade do educando e da sociedade contemporânea e considerando ainda a relevância que as novas tecnologias de informação e os recursos midiáticos podem somar ao processo educativo, essa pesquisa investigou as contribuições da utilização do software Movie Maker para a construção de narrativas digitais. À luz do embasamento teórico, realizamos uma análise das produções dos educandos com o intuito de averiguar os avanços obtidos, resultados e entraves da metodologia aplicada. Esta investigação foi baseada numa lógica seqüencial de construção do conceito, desenvolvida dentro da teoria sócio-construtivista. Foram utilizadas a diversidade dos recursos midiáticos e das novas tecnologias de informação para despertar a curiosidade e a reflexão e para que através do contato com o novo, surgisse o conflito cognitivo, a fim de que o aluno adquirisse saberes que o habilitasse a explicar um processo, formular um conceito, chegando a um nível de conhecimento maior. Avaliamos os recursos midiáticos como importantes ferramentas de contextualização e renovação de conteúdos didáticos, bem como poderosos meios de motivação e sedução discente para o aprender a aprender.(ASSMANN, 2002). Trata-se de uma pesquisa realizada com alunos do ciclo fundamental II e EJA de escolas públicas, sendo que o material analisado, foi coletado no laboratório de informática e sala de aula. Para obtenção dos dados da pesquisa, fui simultaneamente educadora e pesquisadora. Os dados obtidos durante o processo de investigação permite avaliar que efetivamente houve a contribuição, especifica do software Movie Maker, como ferramenta procedimental para a melhoria da produção oral e escrita do gênero narrativo pelos alunos envolvidos. Além disso, o processo investigativo reforçou a certeza de que a mediação do professor é fundamental para a construção do conhecimento formal. / Considering the importance of making the education and the teaching practice nearer to the reality of the pupil and of the contemporary society and considering still the relevance what new technologies of information and media resources can add up to the educative process, this research investigated the results of the use of Movie Maker software for the construction of digital narratives. By the light of the theoretical foundation, we carry out an analysis of the pupils productions with the intention of checking the obtained advancements, results and obstacles of the hard-working methodology. This investigation was based on a construction of the concept sequential logic, developed inside the social-constructivist theory. It was used media resources and information new technologies diversity to wake curiosity and reflection so that, through the contact with the new, the cognitive conflict appeared, and so that, from then on, the pupil acquired knowledge that would enable him to explain a process, to formulate a concept, reaching so a level of better knowledge (DIJK, 1992). We considered media resources as important tools of context and renovation of educational contents, as well as mighty ways of motivation and learning seduction for learning to learn (ASSMANN, 2002). A research carried out with pupils of the Basic II Cycle of public schools, being that most of the analysed material were collected in the computer science laboratory and in the classroom, that´s what this is all about. For getting the research data, I was simultaneously an educator and investigator. The data obtained during the process of investigation allow us to evaluate that there effectively was specific contribution of Movie Maker software, like procedure tool for the improvement of oral and written production of narrative type for the involved pupils. Besides, we can think that the teacher´s mediation is basic for the construction of formal knowledge.

Este trabalho tem como objeto de estudo as obras de João Guimarães Rosa Sarapalha, Corpo fechado e A terceira margem do rio e de Juan Rulfo Luvina e Pedro Páramo. Partindo destes materiais literários analisamos as categorias da transculturação, as relações entre escrita e poder e as implicações das teorias de Ángel Rama para a análise cultural da América Latina. Fundamentam este estudo as teorias críticas desenvolvidas por Roberto González Echevarría, Alberto Moreiras, Antonio Cornejo Polar e Jacques Derrida. Desta forma, o trabalho passa pela discussão de temas como a influência, a mediação e a representação do discurso antropológico na literatura, o debate entre a oralidade e a escrita e o papel paradoxal da literatura na América Latina. / This study aims at studying the works Sarapalha, Corpo fechado and A terceira margem do rio by João Guimarães Rosa and Luvina and Pedro Páramo, by Juan Rulfo. With this literary material as basis, the dissertation analyzes the category of transculturation, the relation between writing and power and the implications of Ángel Rama\'s theories for Latin America cultural analysis. The foundations of this study are the critical theories developed by Roberto González Echevarría, Alberto Moreiras, Antonio Cornejo Polar and Jacques Derrida. Hence, the work deals with the discussion of issues such as the influence, mediation and representation of anthropology in literature, as well as with the debate between orality and writing and the paradoxical role of literature in Latin America.

Este trabalho tem como foco a análise da função da oralidade e do registro coloquial em treze contos do ciclo El Laberinto mágico, do escritor espanhol Max Aub, que se ocupam da vida nos campos de concentração franceses criados ao final da Guerra Civil Espanhola para internar a massa de vencidos que então cruzou os Pirineus. O corpus é composto pelos seguintes textos: Vernet, 1940, Una historia cualquiera, Historia de Vidal, Los creyentes, Un traidor, Manuel el de la Font, El limpiabotas del Padre Eterno, Yo no invento nada, Ruptura, El cementerio de Djelfa, Manuscrito cuervo: historia de Jacobo, Playa en invierno e Ese olor. A análise pauta-se no exame dos seguintes elementos: léxico, sintaxe, formas de tratamento, registros de fala, presença de frases feitas, uso de provérbios e nível sociocultural e lingüístico do narrador e dos personagens. / This paper focuses on the analysis of the function of orality and the colloquial register observed in thirteen short stories written by the Spanish writer Max Aub, in the cycle El Laberinto mágico. These short stories are about life in the concentration camps the French created in France at the end of the Spanish Civil War in order to hold the defeated and broken men and women that crossed the Pyrenees and then became inmates of such camps. The corpus encompasses the following stories: Vernet, 1940, Una historia cualquiera, Historia de Vidal, Los creyentes, Un traidor, Manuel el de la Font, El limpiabotas del Padre Eterno, Yo no invento nada, Ruptura, El cementerio de Djelfa, Manuscrito cuervo: historia de Jacobo, Playa en invierno and Ese olor. The analysis is based on the study of the following elements: lexicon, syntax, forms of address, records of spoken language, occurrence of idioms, use of proverbs, as well as the socio-cultural and linguistic level of the narrator and the characters.

Esta dissertação tem o objetivo de responder à seguinte questão: é possível abordar a música negra nas escolas, ao som do tambor africano, de modo a promover a aceitação e valorização deste instrumento e, consequentemente, da cultura afro-brasileira? Com a intenção de refletir e encontrar caminhos para iluminar essa questão, realizou-se um trabalho de campo na Escola de Aplicação da Faculdade de Educação da USP e na Escola Municipal Saturnino Pereira, ambas situadas no município de São Paulo, durante três anos, com turmas de 9º, 7º, 6º e 8º anos, respectivamente. Por meio de uma proposta de docência compartilhada com os professores dessas turmas, foram realizadas intervenções conjuntas em sala de aula, como forma de suscitar, especialmente entre os jovens afrodescendentes, um olhar crítico à toda forma de estigmatização do tambor e da sonoridade de matriz africana que dele emana. Em busca de novas práticas educacionais e analisando detalhadamente o cotidiano escolar, ao introduzir práticas e saberes dos afrodescendentes, promoveram-se rupturas de campo em duas dimensões do universo escolar: a) nos rituais e práticas de ensino em sala de aula; b) no imaginário da cultura escolar, envolvendo professores e alunos, a propósito do tambor. Os estudos realizados apontam que o tambor ocupa um lugar central, nos rituais de religiões de matriz africana, opondo-se aos instrumentos eurocêntricos e consagrados pelo mainstream, e que talvez, por isso mesmo, seja considerado inferior, do mesmo modo como toda a cultura proveniente da África. Dessa maneira, verifica-se uma série de estereótipos relacionados à cultura afro-brasileira, presentes nas atitudes de alguns docentes e alunos em face do instrumento, que tem dificultado a valorização, por parte dos estudantes afrodescendentes, de sua própria cultura. A fundamentação teórica que orientou tais reflexões baseou-se, principalmente, nas obras de Munanga (2005), Caputo (2012), Leite (2008), Gilroy (2001), Herrmann (2001) e Schafer (2011), além de outros autores, cujos escritos colaboraram para a fundamentação desta pesquisa. / This paper aims to answer the following question: is it possible to approach black music at schools, with the sound of African drums, in order to promote acceptance and appreciation of that instrument and consequently of Afro-Brazilian culture? With the purpose of reflecting on that question and shedding light on it, fieldwork was done at the Escola de Aplicação institute at the University of São Paulos School of Education and at the Escola Municipal Saturnino Pereira elementary school, both located in the city of São Paulo, involving, for three years, students from the 6th to the 9th grades in the Brazilian school system. Through a shared teaching project involving the teachers of those classes, concerted in-class efforts were carried out to promote critical thinking, especially among Afro-Brazilian students, about the many ways in which the drum is stigmatized along with the African sound character that it has. In search of new teaching practices and in performing an in-depth analysis of the day-to-day at the schools, the introduction of new practices and knowledge promoted a field disruption in two scopes of the school realm: the in-class teaching rituals and practices; b) the image that the school culture, including teachers and students, holds about the drum. The studies show that the drum plays a key role in the religious rituals of African origin, as opposed to Eurocentric instruments celebrated in mainstream culture, and that for that very reason, the drum is held as inferior, to the same extent that African culture as a whole is. Many stereotypes about Afro-Brazilian culture emerge from that perception, as observed in the attitude toward the instrument by part of both the students and the teaching staff. This has an impact on how Afro-Brazilian students view their own culture. The theoretical basis for our reflections drew mainly on the works by Munanga (2005), Caputo (2012), Leite (2008), Gilroy (2001), Hermann (2001) and Schafer (2011), as well as various other authors, whose theories helped provided the grounds for this study.

Made available in DSpace on 2016-04-28T18:23:02Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 Juliana Munhoz dos Santos.pdf: 1264768 bytes, checksum: fe046c330e1e41cf4589fb18ccfaaca1 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2015-03-02 / Secretaria da Educação do Estado de São Paulo / This research aims to investigate what the senses and meanings that the English public school teacher attributes to the oral modality at the Public School and how teachers evaluate a complementary oral material with oral activities. This study was conducted from the perspective of Critical Applied Linguistics, based on Moita Lopes (2006). It is based on socio-cultural-historical theory (VYGOTSKY, [1934] 2013) and in oral concepts discussed by Marcuschi (2008); Savignon (1997) and Byrne (1976). The methodology used is the critical-interpretive (MOITA LOPES, 1994; 1996); and the data were collected through an online questionnaire, a reflective conversation on the material created by the researcher and a reflective conversation about orality in English classes. For analysis and discussion of the results, it was used the thematic content category by Bronckart ([1997] 1999), evidenced by lexical choices of the participants, about the orality and about the complementary material as well. The results can guide a more specific work about the oral modality in English language classes at the public schools, enabling the transformation of practices in the classroom / Esta pesquisa tem como tema o ensino de Língua Inglesa na escola pública estadual e objetiva investigar quais os sentido-e-significados que o professor de inglês de escola pública atribui à modalidade oral e como os professores avaliam uma proposta de complementação dos cadernos com atividades orais. Este estudo foi realizado dentro da perspectiva da Linguística Aplicada Crítica, com base em Moita Lopes (2006), e apoia-se na teoria sócio-histórico-cultural (VYGOTSKY, [1934] 2013 e seus colaboradores) e nos conceitos de oralidade discutidos por (Marcuschi (2008); Savignon(1997); Byrne(1976) e Paiva (2009). A metodologia de pesquisa utilizada é a crítico-interpretativista (Moita Lopes, 1994;1996; e os dados foram coletado por meio de um questionário online, uma conversa reflexiva sobre o material criado pela pesquisadora e uma outra conversa reflexiva sobre a oralidade nas aulas de Língua Inglesa. Para análise e discussão dos resultados foi utilizada a categoria de conteúdo temático (BRONCKART, [1997] 1999), evidenciada pelas escolhas lexicais dos participantes, tendo como eixos de interpretação de análise os sentidos-e-significados atribuídos pelos professores participantes tanto para a oralidade quanto sobre o material criado. Os resultados obtidos podem nortear um trabalho mais especifico a respeito da modalidade oral nas aulas de Língua Inglesa da rede pública, possibilitando a transformação de práticas em sala de aula