91 |
Eutanazie z hlediska etiky a teologie / Euthanasia from the points of view of theology and ethicsBARTKOVÁ, Štěpánka January 2010 (has links)
Abstract Euthanasia from the points of view of theology and ethics Key words: euthanasia, suffering, death, dying, dignity, human rights, doctor, patient, palliative medicine, hospice care, assisted suicide, religious motivation, followers, objectors of euthanasia In my thesis I am covering the topic of ?qeuthanasia??. The main objective of this paper is to introduce the reader to the problem of euthanasia from the points of view of theology and ethics. This thesis consists of theoretical and practical parts. The theoretical part further consists of eleven chapters. In the first chapter, the types of euthanasia ares discussed (active, passive, prenatal, and assisted suicide). In the second chapter, the history of euthanasia is discussed in a great detail. The third chapter mainly concentrates on euthanasia in the world. The fourth chapter is about the criteria of death. In the fifth chapter, I address the questions of euthanasia and death in recent years. The sixth chapter is about the relationship between a doctor and a patient. The seventh chapter covers palliative medicine and the eighth chapter further expands on this subject with the topic of hospice care. In the ninth chapter, I pursue the point of religious motivational impact. The tenth and eleventh chapters are dedicated to the followers and objectors of euthanasia. The practical part concentrates on exploratory research. I have chosen sociological research using the methods of discussion. Here are three interviews with experts, who interact with dying individuals on a daily basis. These questioned specialists are believers and therefore the discourses are anonymous. The objective of these discussions was to uncover how professional in different facilities view the issues of euthanasia. This objective was sucessfully achieved.
|
92 |
Les médecins et les patients face à la fin de vie : entre devoir thérapeutique et volonté de choisir sa mort / The doctors ans the patients in front of the end of life : enter therapeutic duty and will to choose its deathCammellini, Céline 05 June 2015 (has links)
Au cours du dernier siècle, les circonstances de la mort ont changé. La plupart des décès surviennent maintenant à des âges élevés. Ils ont principalement lieu en institution et sont souvent précédés d’une longue maladie chronique accompagnée de souffrances et d’angoisses qui ne peuvent être soulagées. Ces mêmes sentiments se retrouvent aussi chez les personnes accidentées de la vie. C’est pourquoi, désormais, les patients privilégient la qualité de la mort à la prolongation de la vie dans la souffrance. Ainsi, de plus en plus fréquemment, le corps médical est confronté à des demandes d’euthanasie ou de suicide assisté de la part des souffrants. C’est dans ce contexte qu’il est intéressant de s’interroger sur la législation française en matière de fin de vie et sur la place donnée tant aux professionnels de santé, qu’aux patients. Si la loi Leonetti du 22 avril 2005 a constitué une avancée considérable en la matière, elle ne répond malheureusement pas à l’ensemble des situations existantes et demeure actuellement insuffisante face aux requêtes constantes des personnes souffrantes et de la majorité de la population française. En témoigne la récente affaire Vincent Lambert dans laquelle, l’équipe médicale confrontée à des avis discordants au sein de la famille proche du patient et à l’absence de volonté exprimée de celui-ci, a été amenée à prendre une décision collégiale sur la poursuite ou non du traitement délivré à ce patient tétraplégique en état de conscience minimale, qui semble-t-il ne voulait plus survivre. S’en sont suivies plusieurs mêlées judiciaires qui ont permis de relancer le débat sur l’évolution de la législation en matière de fin de vie / During the last century, the circumstances of the death changed. Most of the deaths arise now at high ages even very high. They mainly take place in institution and are often preceded by a long chronic disease accompanied with sufferings and with fears which cannot be relieved. The same feelings also find themselves at the more or less young people, damaged by the life.That is why, from now on, the patients favor the quality of the death to the extra time of the life in the suffering. So, more and more frequently, the medical profession is confronted with requests of euthanasia or suicide assisted on behalf of the suffering.It is in this context that it is interesting to wonder on the French legislation regarding the end of life and on the place given as long to the healthcare professionals, and the patients.If the Leonetti’s law of April 22nd, 2005 constituted a considerable advance on the subject, she does not unfortunately answer all the existing situations and currently not sufficient in front of constant requests of the suffering people and the majority of the French population. The recent affair Vincent Lambert shows it in which, the medical team confronted with clashing notices within the family close to the patient and in the absence of will expressed by this one, was brought to make a collective decision on the pursuit or not of the treatment delivered to this patient tetraplegic in state of minimal consciousness, who it seems did not want to survive any more. Followed itself several judicial scrums which allowed to boost the debate on the evolution of the legislation regarding the end of life
|
93 |
Of Stewardship, Suffering and the “Slippery Slope”: A Vattimian Analysis of the Sanctity of Life Ethos in Canada (1972–2005)Chambers, Stuart January 2011 (has links)
This dissertation examines from a Vattimian perspective the challenge that euthanasia and assisted suicide posed to the sanctity of life ethos in Canada from 1972–2005. Gianni Vattimo’s central themes—metaphysics (absolute values), “event of being” (lived experiences that call absolute values into question), and passive-reactive nihilism (the use of “masks” or “disguises” to prevent the dissolution of metaphysics)—are pivotal to understanding the way religious and secular beliefs are interwoven within ethical, medical, legal and political discourses in Canada. Vattimo’s philosophico-ethical approach was specifically chosen because as a theoretical tool, it helps to illuminate the presence, weakening, and resilience of metaphysics in discourses surrounding an intentionally hastened death.
To demonstrate how Vattimo’s major themes apply empirically to the research, a social constructionist approach was adopted in the form of a discourse analysis. Particular emphasis was placed on an examination of the three most important cases of death and dying in Canada, namely, Nancy B., Sue Rodriguez and Robert Latimer. The bulk of the evidence suggests that when these “events of being” challenged the sanctity doctrine as the ultimate foundation for life-terminating decisions, ethical, medical, legal and political discourses converged to promote three normative positions or authorizing discourses used in the tradition of Christian ethics: (1) stewardship—the view that since life is a “loan from God,” sacred, and of infinite worth, death cannot be intentionally hastened (“nature must take its course”); (2) value in prolonged suffering—the view that since suffering possesses transcendent meaning or purpose, its prolongation is justified in individual circumstances; and (3) the “slippery slope”—the view that any weakening of the sanctity of life ethos inevitably harms or threatens the community.
Generally speaking, religious and secular advocates of the sanctity of life ethos reacted similarly in cases involving an intentionally hastened death. In other words, both the religious and the secular embraced metaphysics (absolute values), condoned and rationalized the prolongation of suffering, and relied on the “slippery slope” as a “mask” to maintain the sanctity of human life as first principle. The research strongly suggests that Canada is still significantly indebted to Christian notions when it comes to discussions surrounding the decriminalization of euthanasia and assisted suicide.
|
94 |
Svårt sjuka cancerpatienters intresse för aktiv dödshjälpNilsson, Nicholas January 2006 (has links)
Syftet med studien var att undersöka intresset för aktiv dödshjälp hos patienter som lider av en långt framskriden cancer samt vilka faktorer som påverkar dem i detta ställningstagande. I en litteraturstudie har relevant litteratur insamlats, analyserats och tolkats. Utifrån bevisen från sammanlagt fem kvalitativa studier har nya slutsatser dragits. Resultaten pekar på att det finns ett intresse för aktiv dödshjälp bland svårt sjuka cancerpatienter men att detta i hög grad är framtidsorienterat. Faktorer som påverkar intresset är uppfattningen om att vara en börda för andra, rädsla för framtiden, lidande, den demoraliserande inverkan som cancern har på individen samt religion och etik. / The aim of this study was to examine the personal interest in receiving a physician hastened death among terminally ill cancer patients and the factors that are associated with such a consideration. A review of literature has been conducted on relevant articles. The evidence from a total of five qualitative studies formed the basis upon which new conclusions have been reached. The results suggest that an interest is prevalent among terminally ill cancer patients for receiving a physician hastened death. However, this is in most cases future orientated. Factors that influence patients in this consideration are the perception of being a burden to others, fear of the future, suffering, the demoralising effect that cancer has on the individual as well as religion and ethics.
|
95 |
Dödshjälp för psykiskt lidande : Går det att moraliskt rättfärdiga dödshjälp för psykiskt lidande individer? / Euthanasia for psychological suffering : Is it possible to morally justify euthanasia for psychologically suffering individuals?Liedholm, Tilde January 2023 (has links)
Whether mentally ill individuals have the right to receive euthanasia is a controversial issue and today it looks different in different countries regarding how legislation relates to this. In this essay I will present philosophical arguments for and against euthanasia for individuals suffering psychologically. Based on the philosophical arguments, I will examine how and when a psychologically suffering individual can be morally entitled to euthanasia in a modern society. In this essay I will suggest that, based on the arguments, there are cases where it is morally justified within a modern society to perform euthanasia on a psychologically suffering individual who autonomously requests to end their suffering. / Huruvida psykiskt lidande individer har rätt till att få dödshjälp är en kontroversiell fråga och idag ser det olika ut i olika länder gällande hur lagstiftningar förhåller sig till detta. I den här uppsatsen kommer jag att presentera filosofiska argument för och emot dödshjälp för individer som lider psykiskt. Jag kommer utifrån dessa filosofiska argument att undersöka hur och när en psykiskt lidande individ kan vara moraliskt berättigad till dödshjälp i ett modernt samhälle. I uppsatsen kommer jag att driva tesen att det, utifrån argumenten, finns fall där det är moraliskt rättfärdigat inom ett modernt samhälle att utföra dödshjälp på en psykiskt lidande individ som autonomt begär att få sitt lidande avslutat.
|
96 |
Vad patienten vill och vad patienten får : En litteraturöversikt om dödshjälp / What the patient wants and what the patient gets : A literature review about EuthanasiaStenberg, Anna, Sundström, Elisabeth January 2017 (has links)
Background: In 1997 it became legal for patients with a terminal illness to receive assistance to end their lives in Oregon, USA. The same legislative change came into force in the Netherlands in 2002. These changes have not occurred in Sweden, however a debate is ongoing in terms of the option to legalise active and physician assisted suicide and the ethical and moral aspects of this issue. Aim: The aim is to identify factors leading to patients with a diagnosis of cancer or ALS requesting assistance to end their lives. Method: A literature review and analysis was carried out, in combination with an overview of 11 ethically audited scientific articles. Results: The conclusion was divided into four main themes; depression and burden without a sub theme, pain with sub themes suffering and fatigue, existential values with sub theme hope and hopelessness and finally quality of life with the sub theme strength. Discussion: There is an evident interest in the discussion about legalising assisted suicide in Sweden, amongst patients as well as medical professionals. The patient's desire may be overridden as the subject is tabooed, thereby reducing patient autonomy and the patient´s right to self-determination. Patients' attitude towards death assistance has been discussed on the basis of theories of Helga Kuhse, Katie Eriksson and ICN's ethical code. / Bakgrund: År 1997 blev det lagligt för en patient med obotlig sjukdom att få hjälp att avsluta sitt liv i delstaten Oregon i USA. I Nederländerna blev detta ett lagligt alternativ 2002. I Sverige är detta inte lagligt men det pågår en debatt om legaliseringen av aktiv och läkarassisterad dödshjälp ur ett etiskt och moraliskt perspektiv. Syfte: Syftet är att identifiera faktorer till varför patienter med cancer eller ALS ber om dödshjälp. Metod: En litteraturöversikt gjordes med en analys och en sammanställning av 11 etiskt granskade vetenskapliga artiklar. Resultat: Resultatet delades in i fyra huvudteman där tre teman hade underteman. Det första huvudtemat depression och börda hade inget undertema. Det andra huvudtemat smärta har följande underteman: lidande och fatigue. Det tredje huvudtemat existentiella värderingar har undertemat: hopp och hopplöshet och slutligen det fjärde huvudtemat livskvalitet har styrka som undertema. Diskussion: Ett intresse angående en legalisering av dödshjälp finns i Sverige hos både patienter och vårdpersonal. Patientens önskan kan bli åsidosatt då ämnet är tabubelagt och genom detta kan patientens autonomi och rätten till hens självbestämmande sänkas. Patienternas inställning till dödshjälp har diskuterats utifrån teorier av Helga Kuhse, Katie Eriksson och ICN´s etiska kod.
|
97 |
Administrer les demandes de mort : comparaison de l'aide médicale à mourir (Québec) et de l'assistance au suicide (Canton de Vaud)Blouin, Samuel 02 1900 (has links)
Thèse réalisée en cotutelle avec l'Université de Lausanne / Cette thèse porte sur l’administration des demandes de mort à partir de deux modalités controversées, l’aide médicale à mourir au Québec (Canada) et l’assistance au suicide dans le canton de Vaud (Suisse). Au Québec, l’assistance à mourir est un service public médical, tandis que dans le canton de Vaud, elle est un acte privé toléré par l’État et mis en œuvre par des associations. Selon la façon dont la question de l’assistance à mourir est posée dans les deux contextes, différentes réponses y sont apportées qui reflètent des formes variées de concernement pour cette pratique. Je suggère que ces deux régimes contrastés d’assistance à mourir peuvent être compris dans un même mouvement analytique, malgré les différences qui les séparent. Suivant une perspective comparative et ethnographique, cette thèse explore les façons dont sont mises en œuvre les quatre conditions de possibilité de l’assistance à mourir que j’identifie, et ce à plusieurs échelles, des débats publics aux expériences immédiates des personnes directement concernées. L’enquête repose sur quatre années de recherche, croisant des entretiens, des observations, une revue de presse, ainsi que des analyses de sources documentaires.
Cette thèse arrive au constat que les régimes québécois et vaudois d’assistance à mourir se rejoignent autour de maximes morales pratiques employées par les personnes concernées. Ces maximes, qui se matérialisent dans des paroles quotidiennes et des dispositifs institutionnels, encadrent le trouble suscité par l’assistance à mourir et répondent aux quatre conditions de possibilité identifiées. Cette éthique en actes balise l’espace étroit que les personnes concernées doivent naviguer pour rendre l’assistance à mourir possible. J’examine finalement ce qui guette les protagonistes, ainsi que la société, lorsque ces conditions ne sont pas réunies. Plus généralement, la comparaison de l’administration des demandes de mort dans ces deux régimes contrastés ouvre sur une interrogation des frontières de la médecine, du droit et de la vie. L’analyse des conditions de possibilité et des contours du trouble contribue également aux réflexions sur la mise en œuvre des droits, dont celui à la liberté de conscience. / This thesis is about the administration of death requests from two controversial modalities, medical aid in dying in Quebec (Canada) and assisted suicide in the canton of Vaud (Switzerland). In Quebec, assistance in dying is a public medical service, while in the canton of Vaud it is a private act tolerated by the state and implemented by associations. According to how the assistance to dying question is raised in both contexts, different answers are given which reflect different forms of concern for this practice. I suggest that these two contrasting regimes of assistance in dying can be understood in the same analytical movement despite their differences. From a comparative and ethnographic perspective, this thesis explores how the four conditions that enable the possibility of assistance in dying that I identify are put into practice at different scales, from public debates to the experiences of people who are directly involved. The research is based on four years of investigation relying on interviews, observations, a press review, and analyses of documentary sources. This thesis concludes that the assistance in dying regimes of Quebec and Vaud have practical moral maxims used by the people involved in common. These maxims, which emerge in everyday words and institutional arrangements, frame the trouble that arises from the confrontation with assistance in dying and meet the four enabling conditions identified. This ethics in action circumscribes the narrow space that the people involved must navigate to make assistance in dying possible. Finally, I examine what awaits the actors, as well as the society, when these conditions are not met. More generally, comparing the administration of death requests in these two contrasting regimes leads to questioning the boundaries of medicine, law and life itself. Analyzing these enabling conditions and the bounds of the trouble contributes to the reflections on the implementation of rights, including the right to freedom of conscience.
|
98 |
De l'invention du mourant à la figure de l'agonie. Recherche sur l'ultime épiphanie de la personne incarnée / From the invention of the dying, to the figure of agony : research on the final epiphany of the incarnated personTranchant, Blandine 11 January 2017 (has links)
A l’heure où la prise en charge médicale s’avère de plus en plus nécessaire pour accompagner la fin de vie, il nous apparait que sa place est de plus en plus importante et de moins en moins questionnée. Or, réduire la fin de vie à la question du mourant et de sa prise en charge est pour le moins problématique. L’arrêt d’hydratation et d’alimentation, les différentes formes de sédation, l’euthanasie, le suicide assisté, les soins palliatifs résument-ils à eux seuls ce que l’on peut dire de la fin de vie ? Peut-elle se résumer uniquement à une question d’ordre médical ? N’est-elle pas avant tout une question d’ordre existentiel où, à l’heure de notre déclin, nous sommes confrontés à l’agonie ? Souffrance et finitude se trouvent au cœur de notre interrogation et nous poussent à nous confronter au pâtir de la vie, nous dévoilant ainsi comme être de chair. Grâce à la philosophie henryenne, l’agonie va peu à peu se dévoiler comme une occasion ultime de révélation de soi à soi en tant que soi. Face à l’aporie du mal qui frappe, nous découvrons les hommes capables toujours d’y faire face par un effort de repersonnalisation. C’est cet effort nécessaire qui va se dévoiler tant dans le champ métaphysique, que dans le champ éthique, et que dans le champ politique. C’est ce même effort qui amène l’homme à prendre ses responsabilités et à répondre aux questions existentielles. La subjectivité de chacun se doit alors de devenir le centre de l’institution soignante. L’agonie devient possibilité de repenser la place de la personne au sein du système hospitalier : place de la personne soignante, de la personne soignée, de ceux qui accompagnent, tout en développant une éthique de l’accompagnement qui doit ensuite se décliner dans une politique. Car si, métaphysiquement, vivre son agonie ne peut se justifier que par l’Amour, éthiquement, il nous faut construire une nouvelle poétique de l’action faisant place à la fraternité issue de la chair, à l’imagination de l’homme pour répondre à l’appel d’autrui et de la vie, et à la subsidiarité, afin que chacun soit respecté dans son agir et sa conscience. Politiquement, cela nous ouvre alors à un système hospitalier respectueux de chaque « Je Peux » qui se déploie en son sein. Le respect du consentement du patient reste ainsi la pierre angulaire du système hospitalier ; mais il ne peut se construire que dans une alliance avec les soignants. / In the context of today’s world, medical care is becoming increasingly necessary to assist patients at the end of life. It appears that this care is taking on more and more importance and is subject to fewer and fewer questions. is less and less questioned. However, confining the end of life to the state of dying and its medical support is problematic. Can the end of life be resumed as stopping hydration and artificial feeding, sedation in its different forms, euthanasia, assisted suicide, and palliative care? Can it be summed up as a simple medical question? Isn’t the end of life, first and foremost, linked to an existential question in which, at the time of our decline, we come face to face with agony? Finiteness and suffering are at the heart of our questioning as we confront life’s hardships, revealing the mystery of the flesh. With the help of Michel Henry’s philosophy, agony will gradually reveal itself as an ultimate opportunity for self-revelation. Faced with the paradox of evil, we find Man capable of coping with an effort of re-personification. This necessary effort will unfold in the metaphysical, ethical and political fields. This same effort allows Man to take responsibility for himself and to contemplate existential questions. The subjectivity of each person must become the center of the healthcare institution. Agony becomes the possibility to rethink the place of the individual person within the hospital system: the care giver, the care receiver and those supporting them, all while developing an ethical personal assistance which must then translated into policies. Because even if metaphysically, living out agony cannot be otherwise justified but by Love, ethically we must build a new way of operating. We must leave room for fraternity as a consequence of being of the flesh, to imagination in order to respond to our fellow man and our life’s calling, and to subsidiarity so that everyone is respected in his actions and consciousness. Politically, it opens up the possibility of a hospital system respectful of each "I Can" which is echoed within its walls. Respect for the patient's consent remains the cornerstone of the hospital system but can only be built with an alliance with caregivers.
|
Page generated in 0.4058 seconds