本論文以兩篇結論對立的社論為個案，藉由形式語義學設計出將論說性篇章刻畫成一階謂詞邏輯符號的論述分析程序，使自然語言中對真實宣稱或正當宣稱的爭論還原成真值語義和論證形式有效性的判斷，從而具體地挽救被歧見所破壞的溝通行動。設計過程初擬了處理語篇命題結構、複合語句成分、回指關係、量號轄域歧義、因果語句、隱性前提推論、和引述結構的實用方案。 / By the means of formal semantics, this thesis used two opposite editorials as cases to design a discourse analysis procedure which translates expository-argumentative texts into formulae of first-order predicate logic. The procedure reduces disputes in natual language about truth or rightness claims into judgements on truth values and validities of argument forms, thus the communicative actions disabled by quarrels can be practically redempted. The designing drafted feasible treatments for propositional structures of discourses, compound sentential constituents, anaphoras, quantifier scope ambiguities, cause-and-effect statements, inferences for absent premises, and quotation structures.

This study is a contribution to the limited knowledge of how different types of media content (about Muslims and extremism) posted and shared on Facebook might influence corresponding user comments. Through analyzing the discourse of user comments this study aims to identify how comments might reflect certain characteristics of Islamophobia, and to which themes in Facebook posts commentators relate to the most. The linguistic analysis is guided by the use of critical discourse analysis. For the purpose of this study, three different types of articles/video and the corresponding comments are analyzed. Two of the articles/video that I will analyze are from unreliable media sources, and one of the articles is from a credible media source. The linguistic analysis showed that the majority of commentators expressed that they believe the claims made in the articles/video about Muslims and extremism are true. The discourse analysis further showed, the majority of articles/video and the majority of the analyzed corresponding comments reflected the [in the study] defined characteristics of Islamophobia. My findings confirmed similar studies done in the past.

Made available in DSpace on 2016-04-27T14:32:19Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 Amalia Neide Covic.pdf: 5801132 bytes, checksum: ad3db4327b5c15aacdf03a7e55765991 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2008-09-30 / Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior / This study contributes with the knowledge construction related to the learning to teach in an hospital context that have differences from the traditional classroom. These assumptions need to be made: (i) When scholar quotidian actions are enunciated there exists docent learning; (ii)The enunciations of the scholar quotidian actions, when seem as cultural artifacts, can be investigated; and (iii) the docent space of practices is considered a strategy of learning. This research focus in this question: What are the possibilities that the practical enunciations made by intern teachers in an hospital environment promote the docent learning? The search to answer this question is sustained by studies with strong qualitative methodology, oriented in the investigation of the meanings construction in a space which the communicative action takes the place of the experiment. The data for this study comes from the modular discursive analysis and from the study of the Habermas Theory of Communicative Action. The enunciations used in this research comes from a group of eight teachers and eight intern teachers of the IOP-GRAACC-UNIFESP from june 2005 to july 2006. It´s possible to observe that, in the enunciations of the actions used in this study, the group: creates new meanings to the implicit docent knowledge related to the institutional space of Health and Education; there are tendencies of traditional curriculum adaption to the hospital reality; investigation spaces are created in the process; there are arguments for consensus when spaces are open for differences and mobilization of the action; the properties appears as the environment adaptabilities are created; specific curriculum are constructed for the patient-students in oncology treatment; signifies the position of the Hospital School sphere of actions; create a relation of inclusion in the hospital space; investigates the practice with autonomy construction of the docent; space construction for docents; and mobilize knowledges linked to solidarity / O estudo pretende contribuir com a construção do conhecimento acerca da aprendizagem da docência em contextos externos às salas de aulas tradicionais, mais especificamente no ambiente hospitalar. Para tal, partiu-se dos pressupostos: (i) Existe aprendizagem da docência ao se enunciarem ações escolares cotidianas, (ii) As enunciações de ações escolares cotidianas, quando percebidas como um artefato cultural, são passíveis de serem investigadas e (iii) O espaço de práticas situadas da docência é considerado uma estratégia de aprendizagem da docência. A pesquisa tem como orientação de investigação a pergunta: Quais as possibilidades das enunciações de práticas cotidianas realizadas por professores estagiários em um ambiente hospitalar promoverem a construção da aprendizagem da docência ?. A busca de respostas se deu pelo viés dos estudos predominantemente qualitativos, com orientação para a investigação de construção de significados em um espaço em que a ação comunicativa assume o lugar do experimento. Assim a produção de dados se dá com apoio da análise discursiva modular e dos estudos da Teoria da Ação Comunicativa habermasiana. Procuramos, nas enunciações de um grupo de oito professoras e professores estagiários do IOP-GRAACC-UNIFESP, indícios dos processos reflexivos da ação docente. As observações se deram de junho de 2005 até junho de 2006. Foi possível observar que, ao enunciar suas ações, o grupo ressignifica conhecimentos implícitos da docência quanto ao espaço institucional da Saúde e da Educação e: indicam tendências de adaptação dos currículos tradicionais para a realidade hospitalar; criam espaços de investigação do meio; fornecem argumentos para a busca de consenso ao abrirem espaço para diferenciação e mobilização da ação; antecipam as propriedades e criam adaptabilidade ao meio; constroem currículos específicos para os alunos pacientes em tratamento oncológico; significam a posição da esfera da Escola Hospitalar, entre as demais esferas de atividade do espaço hospitalar; estabelecem uma relação de pertencimento ao espaço hospitalar; investigam intersubjetivamente a própria prática com construção de autonomia do espaço da docência, constroem espaços para docência e mobilizam saberes ligados à solidariedade

Cette recherche s’intéresse à la Formation Professionnelle Continue des adultes. Elle questionne la portée de la dynamique qui se crée pendant qu’ils apprennent et se perfectionnent à l’occasion de stages de courte durée. Notre recherche a été réalisée auprès de 24 professionnels du secteur sanitaire et médico-social qui ont suivi au moins un stage entre les années 2008 et 2011. Nous les avons rencontrés dans le cadre d’un entretien semi-directif dont le guide a été élaboré à partir d’un modèle permettant de considérer l’attitude et le comportement en référence au Soi (Hamel et al., 1999). A partir d’un cadre épistémologique socioconstructiviste, l’analyse a contribué à relever non seulement, nombre d’idées forces corroborant la nécessité des stages comme espaces d’acquisition de compétences, mais aussi certaines indiquant des « transformations silencieuses » (Jullien, 2009) intervenant sur la « croissance de la vie adulte » (Bédard, 1987). Nous avons tenté de modéliser en quoi la FPC participe potentiellement de la construction identitaire du sujet. / This research focuses in training adults. We question the impact of the dynamics developed while they learn together. Our research was conducted with 24 people who followed at least one internship between 2008s and 2011. We met the participants within the framework of a semi-directive interview. This technique was developed from a model which consider attitude and behavior in respect to the Self (Hamel, et al., 1999). The analysis made in a socioconstructivist epistemological frame, has contributed to underline a number of ideas which supports the necessity of the internships as a space for the acquisition of skills, and other ideas which indicate that " silent transformations " (Jullien, 2009) can occur on the " growth of adult life " (Bédard, 1987) also thanks to the internships. The diverse elements of our research allowed us to show that the training potentially contributes to the construction of identity of the subject.

This thesis empirically examines how lobby groups and activists respond to innovative forms of public participation. The study centres on processes that foster a particular kind of deliberative governance including citizens’ juries, consensus conferences and planning cells. These deliberative designs bring together a panel of randomly selected lay citizens to deliberate on a specific policy issue for a few days, with the aim of providing decision makers with a set of recommendations. While policy makers worldwide are attracted to these novel participatory processes, little consideration has been given to how well they work alongside more adversarial and interest-based politics. This doctoral research project examines this interface by studying what these processes mean to different kinds of policy actors such as corporations, advocacy groups, government agencies, experts and professionals. These entities are collectively referred to in this thesis as ‘interest organisations’ because in some way they are seeking a specific policy outcome from the state – even government-based groups.¶ The empirical research in this thesis is based on comparative case studies of four deliberative design projects in Australia and Germany. The Australian cases include a citizens’ jury on waste management legislation and a consensus conference on gene technology in the food chain. The German case studies include a planning cells project on consumer protection in Bavaria, and a national consensus conference on genetic diagnostics. Together the cases capture a diversity of complex and contested policy issues facing post-industrialised societies. In each case study, I examine how relevant interest organisations responded to the deliberative forum, and then interpret these responses in view of the context and features of the case.¶ The picture emerging from the in-depth case studies is that interest organisations respond to deliberative designs in a variety of ways. Some choose to participate actively, others passively decline, and a few resort to strategic tactics to undermine citizens’ deliberations. The empirical research reveals that though responses are variable, most interest organisations are challenged by several features of the deliberative design model including: 1) that deliberators are citizens with no knowledge or association with the issue; 2) that experts and interest representatives are required to present their arguments before a citizens’ panel; and 3) that policy discussions occur under deliberative conditions which can expose the illegitimate use of power.¶ Despite these challenges, the paradox is that many interest organisations do decide to engage in lay citizen deliberations. The empirical research indicates that groups and experts value deliberative designs if they present an opportunity for public relations, customer feedback, or advocacy. Moreover, the research finds that when policy actors intensively engage with ‘ordinary’ citizens, their technocratic and elite ideas about public participation can shift in a more inclusive and deliberative direction.¶ The thesis finds that, on the whole, weaker interest organisations are more willing to engage with lay citizens than stronger organisations because they welcome the chance to influence public debate and decision makers. It appears that powerful groups will only engage in a deliberative forum under certain policy conditions, for example, when the dominant policy paradigm is unstable and contested, when public discussion on the issue is emerging, when policy networks are interdependent and heterogeneous, and when the broader social and political system supports public accountability, consensus and deliberation. Given that these kinds of policy conditions do not always exist, I conclude that tensions between interest organisations and deliberative governance will be common. In order to create more cooperative and productive interfaces, I recommend that interest organisations be better supported and integrated into citizens’ deliberations, and that steps be taken to safeguard forums from strategic attempts to undermine their legitimacy.¶ The thesis also sends out three key messages to democratic theorists. First, the empirical research shows that different kinds of groups and actors in civil society vary in their willingness and capacity to participate to public deliberation. Second, the deliberative design model demonstrates that partisan actors, such as interest organisations, will engage in public deliberation when they can participate as strategic deliberators. In this role partisans are not expected to relinquish their agendas, but present them as testimonies before a group of deliberators. Third, the empirical research in this thesis should bring home to theorists that deliberative forums are closely linked to the discursive context within which they operate.

為了更進一步地了解「公共性問題」﹐本文將「公共性」的探究嵌入歷史脈絡之中﹐概略地從古希臘談到十八世紀的歐洲。在「公共性」的考源過程中﹐我們可以發現﹐「公共性」與「啟蒙」､「超越性」的理念一直有著相當密切的關連。透過這段歷史的考源﹐我們可以更進一步地掌握「公共性」的本質與內含於其中的啟蒙潛能。 　　其次﹐為了理解現代「公共性」所展現出的弔詭面貌﹐本文將試圖挖掘潛藏在「公共性」之下的社會變遷﹐也就是所謂的「現代性」(modernity)的發展歷程。從西元十五世紀開始﹐「現代」(modern)的序幕開始揭起﹐一個嶄新的時代於是降生。在這段歷史時期之中﹐我們可以觀察到它的獨特形貌﹐這些獨特的政治､經濟､社會與文化的形構就是所謂的「現代性」。一般說來﹐「現代性」的形構包括了資本主義的興起､民族國家的出現､神話世界觀的解除魔咒､社會運作邏輯的理性化､人類主體性的揚昇等等。值得注意的是﹐「現代性」的發展是一種從西方蔓延到全球的過程﹐「現代性」的發展逐漸成為西方文化的「全球化」(globalization)﹐所以有人直接稱呼「現代化」就是「西化」。在「現代性」的發展之下﹐我們可以發現「公共性」此一範疇的爆炸性擴張。此外﹐我們也可以抽繹出「現代性」的內在邏輯─人類主體性的確立與社會的理性化。由於這兩套現代性邏輯的過度擴張造成了「公共性」的弔詭面貌─「公共性的暴力」與「缺乏回應能力的公眾」。 　　關於「公共性」的弔詭面貌與扭曲發展的解決方案﹐哈伯瑪斯的理論建構是一套值得加以討論的典範。他試圖從相互主體性與溝通理性的重建上﹐尋求一個合理性的公共生活的出路。最後﹐本文的結論將會做一個總結性的批評與討論。

During the last decades Recognition of Prior Learning (RPL) has become a more frequently used method to recognise adult’s prior learning. This thesis analyses a process of RPL in health care, where health care assistants are assessed against subjects in the upper-secondary health care program. Prior research on RPL is to a high degree non-theoretical and focus is primarily on policy level research. This thesis adds to the field by progressing a critical social theory perspective on RPL. In the thesis the RPL process is analysed through Jürgen Habermas’ theory of communicative action and Axel Honneth’s Recognition theory. General questions posed are: What are the power issues in the RPL process? What implications does the tension between the lifeworld of work and the system of education have? What consequences does mutual understanding and communication have for the outcome of the RPL process? What part does recognition play for the participants? The results disclose the power relations that emerge in the relationship between participants and teachers. A caring ideology is developed and problematized. Further, the importance of mutual understanding between participant and teachers in the assessment of prior learning is discussed focusing on the consequences a lack of mutual understanding could have for the outcome in such assessments. On a macro level the analysis demonstrates the tension between the participants prior learning and the educational systems demand for formalising prior learning. In addition, analyses of a more developmental character that intends to show the potential for critical learning, change and recognition are progressed. The results suggest that communicative action can be used to develop RPL into processes focusing on critical learning and change. Recognition of traits and abilities could also enhance individual’s positive relations with the self. Such recognition could develop self-confidence and thus RPL could encourage learning and cultivate continuing self-realisation through work. / Validering har under de senaste decennierna blivit en alltmer använd metod för att erkänna vuxnas tidigare lärande. Denna avhandling analyserar en valideringsprocess inom omvårdnadssektorn för vårdbiträden med mångårig erfarenhet. Vårdbiträdena valideras mot ämnen inom omvårdnadsprogrammets karaktärsämnen. Tidigare forskning om validering är i hög grad icke-teoretisk och mycket fokus har legat på policynivå. Denna avhandling bidrar till forskningsfältet genom att problematisera validering utifrån ett kritiskt samhällsteoretiskt perspektiv. I avhandlingen analyseras valideringsprocessen utifrån Jürgen Habermas teori om det kommunikativa handlandet och Axel Honneths erkännandeteori. Exempel på mer generella frågor som ställs är: Vilka är maktfaktorerna i valideringsprocessen? Är handlingarna i processen koordinerade mot gemensam förståelse? Hur ser förhållandet mellan system och livsvärld ut? Vilken roll spelar erkännandet i validering för deltagarna? Resultatet synliggör de maktförhållanden som uppstår mellan deltagare och lärare i bedömningsprocessen. En omvårdande ideologi lyfts fram och problematiseras. Därtill diskuteras betydelsen av gemensam förståelse mellan deltagare och lärare vid bedömning, samt vilka konsekvenser brist på gemensam förståelse kan få. På ett makroplan åskådliggör analysen spänningen mellan deltagarnas erfarenheter och utbildningssystemets krav på formalisering. Vidare genomförs mer utvecklingsfokuserade analyser som vill visa på möjligheterna för kritiskt lärande och förändring i validering. Resultatet demonstrerar också, bland annat, betydelsen av att bli erkänd för sina förmågor och hur detta kan utveckla individens självuppskattning och främja lärande. I studien föreslås det att kommunikativt handlande kan utgöra en norm för hur validering kan utvecklas mot mer kritiskt lärande och positiv förändring. Men också att erkännande av tidigare förmågor kan gynna individens positiva relation till sig själv, hur detta främjar lärande, självuppskattning och hur validering därmed kan utgöra en grund för ett vidare självförverkligande genom arbete.

Met die oog daarop om 'n basisteorie vir familiepastoraat te ontwerp, word verskeie basisteoretiese konsepte geidentifiseer en bespreek. Dit is veral die relasionele definiering van families - eerder as die tradisionele biologiese definiering - wat van fundamentele belang vir basisteoretiese besinning is. Hierdie 'ekologiese' verstaan van families, sluit familiesisteme van alle vorms in en hou rekening met huidige sosiologiese realiteite sowel as bepaalde teologiese perspektiewe. In aansluiting by die relasionele definiering van families, het familiepastoraat 'n verhoudingsfokus en werk dit met 'n multidimensionele perspektief wat op al die dinamiese verhoudingsprosesse en -fases binne familiesisteme gerig is. In verbondenheid met die gemeente, benader familiepastoraat families as ekologiese geloofsisteme en funksioneer dit in die lig van die evangelie asook doelbewus binne koninkrykskonteks. In die slothoofstuk word al die sentrale basisteoretiese konsepte geintegreer tot 'n teoretiese geheel. Die basisteorie vir familiepastoraat, wat hier ontwerp word, kan kemagtig soos volg geformuleer word: Familiepastoraat is gesprekmatige verhoudingsorg van die ekologiese familie en dit geskied binne koninkrykskonteks. / For the purpose of developing a basic theory for family pastoral work, several basic theoretical concepts are identified and discussed. The defining of families in terms of relations - rather than the traditional biological defining - is of fundamental importance for basic theoretical reflection. This 'ecological' understanding of families includes families of all shapes and forms, whilst it also reflects sociological realities and it takes into account certain theological perspectives. The aim of family pastoral work is synchronised with the relational defining of families and focus, therefore, on the multiple dynamic relational processes and phases within family systems. For this manifold relational focus, family pastoral work operates with a multidimensional perspective. The basic theory developed for family pastoral work, can be formulated as follows: Family pastoral work is dialogical care of the relationships of ecological families and it operates within context of the Kingdom. / Philosophy, Practical and Systematic Theology / M.Th. (Practical theology)

A presente tese propõe um modelo de injusto penal rigorosamente dualista, assimentendido aquele que, ao lado do desvalor da ação, exija sempre e necessariamente a efetivaocorrência de um desvalor do resultado, consistente na afetação, danosa ou perigosa, da esferade existência de terceiros. A hipótese que conduz a investigação é a de que, mesmo diante dosmovimentos expansionistas do poder punitivo hoje verificados, é possível defender a viabilidade de tal concepção de injusto penal. Para a demonstração dessa hipótese, parte-se domodelo dual de sociedade proposto por Jürgen Habermas, que tem na teoria do agircomunicativo a chave para a proteção do mundo da vida frente aos influxos colonizatóriosprovenientes dos sistemas econômico e político administrativo. A partir desse marco teórico,propõe-se uma releitura de alguns dos conceitos fundamentais da teoria do delito, de modo aconferir-lhes interpretação compatível com a concepção dualista rigorosa de injusto adotada.Por fim, para verificar a plausibilidade da hipótese colocada, tais conceitos fundamentais sãopostos à prova diante de situações teóricas tradicionalmente classificadas como de difícilconciliação com uma concepção de injusto baseada na necessária ocorrência de desvalor doresultado, como é o caso dos crimes de perigo abstrato e dos crimes tentados. / The thesis you have in hands proposes a concept of crime in which wrongdoing and harmfulness must be always combined and considered together as elements of a criminal offense in order to demonstrate the real affectation of third parties. The main hypothesis is that even facing an expansionist tendency toward incarceration and overcriminalization it is still possible to defend the viability of such a concept of crime. With the purpose of demonstrate this hypothesis, the Habermas's dualistic society model and his theory of communicative action are taken as a point of departure and based on them we intend to review some of the elements that compose the concept of criminal offense. Finally, the thesis will be challenged against controversial existing rulings (such as victimless crimes) to verify if their reasoning are compatible with such a dualistic concept of crime, which deny the possibility of existing criminal offenses without harm to others.

Made available in DSpace on 2014-12-17T14:36:33Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 AdrianoMC_TESE.pdf: 7364454 bytes, checksum: 49a57ea72913799104a87daad0a21e44 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2013-04-18 / The thesis investigated how social networks online that allows anonymous postings can be used by teachers and students to promote the meeting between the sexual education and the needs and expectations of young people face a crosscutting theme, remarkably a taboo. It needs teaching strategies more efficient than those traditionally defended. With this experience, found in a short course about sexuality and health, we sought to go beyond the use of social networks for social entertainment, showing they can be an field that favors the process of teaching and learning. The research was based on the convergence of the communication concepts from Paulo Frere and another from J?rgen Habermas, as well as the philosophical concepts of utopia, ideology and dialectic are interrelated not only among themselves, but also inside an education field. Methodologically in this thesis, we adopted the category of qualitative research; the method is a combination of case study with action research. The technique was the use of questionnaires, data collection was in attendance and the types of data were primary. Finally, we present, then, the idea the communication is not in the middle, but in the trusty relationship established between the interlocutors. In this way, we can think when a student has met their need to be able answer his questions about sex with their teacher through an online social network that allows anonymity and through which the student knows who responds is their teacher, but the teacher can not distinguish the identity of his students, this dialogic relationship serves to get claims of the validity that are characterized as potential communicative action / Esta tese investigou como as redes sociais on-line que permitem postagens an?nimas podem ser utilizadas por professores e alunos para a promo??o da Educa??o Sexual atender ?s necessidades e ?s expectativas dos jovens diante de um tema transversal notavelmente considerado tabu, exigindo estrat?gias pedag?gicas mais eficientes do que aquelas tradicionalmente oferecidas. Com essa experi?ncia, realizada em um minicurso sobre sexualidade e sa?de, buscou-se ir al?m da utiliza??o das redes sociais para o entretenimento social, mostrando que elas podem ser um ambiente que favorece o processo de ensino-aprendizagem. A pesquisa foi fundamentada na converg?ncia dos conceitos de comunica??o para Paulo Freire e J?rgen Habermas, bem como nos conceitos filos?ficos de utopia, ideologia e dial?tica que se inter-relacionam n?o s? entre si, mas tamb?m com o pr?prio campo da educa??o. Metodologicamente, nesta tese, foi adotada a categoria da pesquisa qualitativa. O m?todo ? uma combina??o de estudo de caso com pesquisa-a??o. A t?cnica foi a aplica??o de question?rios; a coleta de dados foi presencial e os tipos de dados foram prim?rios. Por fim, apresenta-se, ent?o, a concep??o de que a comunica??o n?o est? no meio, mas na rela??o de confian?a estabelecida entre os interlocutores. Dessa forma, ? poss?vel afirmar que quando um aluno tem sua necessidade atendida ao conseguir esclarecer suas d?vidas sobre sexo com seu professor atrav?s de uma rede social on-line que permita anonimato e atrav?s da qual o aluno sabe que quem responde ? o seu professor, mas o professor n?o consegue distinguir a identidade de seu aluno, essa rela??o dial?gica atende a pretens?es de validez que a caracterizam como a??o comunicativa em potencial